p.1 #9Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
jedibrain wrote:
Something to do with the specific glass thickness and material of the glass stack in front of the sensor, if I had to guess.
Brian
You're right about the sensor stack, but I thought the R6 and R5 have a much thinner sensor stack, compared to the slightly older R and RP cameras. And I think it's strange that the R6 is mentioned and not the R5 (I've read that they have the same sensor stack thickness). It would be a huge bummer if this lens caused color shift on the periphery of an image when using it with an R6.
p.1 #10Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
I think the edge color shading is very dependent on pixel well depth and microlens design. It's possible the R5 has a better, more optimized microlens array than the R6, and perhaps somewhat different pixel architecture, though it's still FSI IIRC. My understanding is a finer pixel pitch should be more susceptible to edge color shifts, but it seems the R5 is less prone to this problem. I have the R6II and unfortunately it does exhibit magenta edge shading with a number of adapted rangefinder lenses. Last year I tested many of my rangefinder lenses on the R5 and don't recall it being a noticeable problem.
p.1 #11Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
What does everyone think will be the likely next RF lenses from voigtlander in 2024? It seems their lineup is a bit inconsistent across their Sony, Nikon, and Fuji line of manual lenses.
I'd love to see a 35mm 1.4, but it seems Voigtlander may have discontinued the FE lenses?
p.1 #13Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
Maybe there is too much competition and not enough sales on Sony FE mount from Sony and other manufacturers like Sigma, Samyang, etc so CV didn't even release their 50mm f1 version for Sony.
I used CV 21mm 3.5 M on R5 with no problem. CV 15mm M should be similar. Usually fast lenses and APO lenses needs the native mount for a couple stop enhancements compared to M mount...
Not in English and no subtitles, but a review on R6 II:
p.1 #14Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
Lukepi00 wrote:
What does everyone think will be the likely next RF lenses from voigtlander in 2024? It seems their lineup is a bit inconsistent across their Sony, Nikon, and Fuji line of manual lenses.
I'd love to see a 35mm 1.4, but it seems Voigtlander may have discontinued the FE lenses?
Cosina has discontinued 5 lenses for Sony FE up to now (12/5.6, 21/3.5, 35/1.2 SE, 40/1.2 SE, 50/1.2 SE). The original 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 remain in production and overall they still have 10 lenses for Sony FE in production. They always announce on their Japanese website when any lens reaches end of production (i.e. gets discontinued).
35/1.4 for Sony FE has not been discontinued and it's recently been the #1 best-selling CV lens for FE in Japan as it's compact, has attractive focal length and it's only about 50% of the cost of 40/1.2 (original version) in Japan.
It is a bit mystery to me why they discontinued the 3 SE lenses in E-mount though as those were among their better selling lenses (especially 40/1.2 SE) and they were selling better than the original 40/1.2 & 50/1.2 when both options (original & SE) were available at the same time.
p.1 #15Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
This is an information-poor industry, friends. The honourable exception is Leica, for which we see a good number of videos from Peter Karbe et al, and lots of interaction. The others? It's just 'buy our stuff' and watch our YT shills.
As to range parity by Cosina, let's just say that 21st century Carl Zeiss AG never produced a lens in ZE that did not have a ZF equivalent, that was the European way of doing business. It was the right thing to do then and it's the right thing to do now, when we have but one high end manual lens maker left. Sure, there are the cheapies.
But I wish for a maker like Rodenstock or Schneider to enter the fray, because these CV decision makers are a major disappointment with their 'guess what's next?' schtick. And that is what a monopoly buys you - eff you ability, even to your buyers...
p.1 #16Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
philip_pj wrote:
let's just say that 21st century Carl Zeiss AG never produced a lens in ZE that did not have a ZF equivalent, that was the European way of doing business. It was the right thing to do then and it's the right thing to do now, when we have but one high end manual lens maker left. Sure, there are the cheapies.
True for all the ZEs but going the other direction the ZF 25/2.8 was never produced in a ZE mount nor the special production of ZF-IR trio of 25/2.8, 50/1.4 and 85/1.4.
As I have been selling sold off most of my Nikon mount lenses along with Nikon mount bodies those 4 I kept.
p.1 #17Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
In defense of Cosina, nearly everything they have released 90mm and wider has been in M mount, which is adaptable (ignoring major considerations of sensor stack compatibility) to other mirrorless systems.
I suspect the real answer for their recent mishmash of lens mount offerings probably isn't that simple. My own speculation is that Cosina, a smaller company with limited resources, is somewhat opportunistic, jumping to niches where it sees current opportunities and leaving areas where there is product saturation and mature lens systems. This would explain early interest in m43, which more recently seems to have fallen to the side, as well as Sony. Currently Cosina's focus, other than M mount, seems to be more on Fuji, Nikon and now also Canon. Sony FE is potentially a good example of where there was early opportunity for 3rd parties to address the needs/wants of more discerning, less budget sensitive photographers until Sony got it's act together and was able to produce a really attractive set of native lens options. In this respect I kind of feel that Sony's 'open lens standard' was a shorter term ploy to establish their system with the help of third party brands until they could dominate it with their own offerings. It's possible that Cosina now sees limited opportunities in the FE system due to the overwhelming user preference for autofocus lenses. My impression from the Sony board here is that many who were happy to adapt or use manual focus lenses on Sony early, have since switched to AF options. The losers here would seem to be Zeiss's Loxia line (made by Cosina?) and Voigtlander (Cosina again) due to pressure both from AF options across all price ranges and recent newcomers offering manual focus options in the lower price points. Canon would seem to be a major opportunity for Cosina given Canon's massive restriction of third party RF lens options. For Cosina to receive Canon's blessings would seem to be a significant advantage (though there is already manual focus competition in this space at lower price points from various Chinese brands, which is true for all mirrorless systems).
None of this is anything new from Cosina. They seem to discontinue lenses for reasons only known to them, then maybe re-release some of those as updated versions 5-10 years later. They also don't seem bothered by having multiple products of a given focal length, also in various finishes (eg 6 SKUs of the 50/1.5), while gaps exist elsewhere in their lineup.
p.1 #18Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
I just picked up a Voigtlander RF 50mm 1.0 for my R6 Mark II and I really like it. I have several Canon RF lenses and love what they do, but the Voigtlander is so different and interesting that I'd absolutely consider more of them in different focal lengths.
I'm not an experienced photographer though, and I'm still very much in a learning mode. I have to admit that I don't understand why they have come out with a full frame compatible lens that is seemingly so close the the 50mm 1.0?
Am I missing something obvious/important or is this new lens intended for a specific niche? I had initially thought that it was intended for APS-C cameras, but apparently it is meant for full frame as well.
Would this new 40mm 1.2 offer enough of a practical difference from the 50mm 1.0 to warrant consideration or should I wait for something more "different" from Voigtlander like a 24mm or 35mm in the RF mount?
p.1 #19Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
XMGAU wrote:
I just picked up a Voigtlander RF 50mm 1.0 for my R6 Mark II and I really like it. I have several Canon RF lenses and love what they do, but the Voigtlander is so different and interesting that I'd absolutely consider more of them in different focal lengths.
I'm not an experienced photographer though, and I'm still very much in a learning mode. I have to admit that I don't understand why they have come out with a full frame compatible lens that is seemingly so close the the 50mm 1.0?
Am I missing something obvious/important or is this new lens intended for a specific niche? I had initially thought that it was intended for APS-C cameras, but apparently it is meant for full frame as well.
Would this new 40mm 1.2 offer enough of a practical difference from the 50mm 1.0 to warrant consideration or should I wait for something more "different" from Voigtlander like a 24mm or 35mm in the RF mount? ...Show more →
Perspective is a pretty personal thing. I have the Sigma Art 50mm and canon 40mm pancake. To me, the 40mm compares closer to 35mm than 50 ( Yay math!). I don't find myself looking for 40mm at all when doing people. And doing Walk around I want wider than 50, though 24mm is my preference over35/40mm.
So I suppose what I'm saying is, you might not know u til if you try whether you like 40mm or not. But for some it would not be out of place next to a 50mm.
p.1 #20Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 40/1.2 Canon RF version announced today
XMGAU wrote:
I just picked up a Voigtlander RF 50mm 1.0 for my R6 Mark II and I really like it. I have several Canon RF lenses and love what they do, but the Voigtlander is so different and interesting that I'd absolutely consider more of them in different focal lengths.
I'm not an experienced photographer though, and I'm still very much in a learning mode. I have to admit that I don't understand why they have come out with a full frame compatible lens that is seemingly so close the the 50mm 1.0?
Am I missing something obvious/important or is this new lens intended for a specific niche? I had initially thought that it was intended for APS-C cameras, but apparently it is meant for full frame as well.
Would this new 40mm 1.2 offer enough of a practical difference from the 50mm 1.0 to warrant consideration or should I wait for something more "different" from Voigtlander like a 24mm or 35mm in the RF mount? ...Show more →
There is one thing about Cosina (the company that makes Voigtlander lenses) - they often make what don't seem to be clear-cut logical decisions. They seem to do whatever they please, in terms of lens releases and specifications of those releases. Some models they make available for multiple mounts, while others may only be available for one or two mounts. If you look at their full range of lens models across all mounts, there are some focal lengths with a lot of overlapping products. But as Brian suggested, 40mm is still fairly different from 50mm and there can be arguments made for owning both.
I believe in the Japanese market the Voigtlander 40/1.2 is very popular and they've already released it in the Nikon Z mount, in addition to Sony FE (and Leica M), so probably not too difficult to port it over to Canon RF. And it's at a much different (lower) price point than the 50/1.0.
These two lenses are also technically quite different when used wide open. The 50/1.0 is Cosina's 'halo' lens, so to say, and is aimed to be sharp from wide open, whereas the 40/1.2 is less perfect with a bit more 'glow' (spherical aberration) and 'character' wide open. The 50/1.0 was released first in Leica M mount and it arguably outperforms Leica's own $13k 50/0.95. Cosina put a fair number of optical tweaks into the design, including aspherical element surfaces (including a large diameter ground aspherical surface = $$$), special glass type and a floating element focusing system to retain optimum sharpness and contrast across the full focusing range. It was also their objective to keep the lens as compact as possible (it's shorter than Leica's 50/0.95), a feature that matters for many Leica M system users. I can only guess they released it as their first RF lens to also make a statement for that system.
It's probable that Cosina will release a lineup of lenses in RF mount similar to what they're offering for Nikon Z. But probably depends also on what Canon authorizes them to release in RF mount.