fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Lighter gear options?

  
 
TGPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Lighter gear options?
Colin, so sorry to hear this. Your images are something I always look up to.

I looked into lighter gear for hiking and travel wildlife. I don't really have any unique perspectives or anything too different to add. I looked into:

Sony a6XXX and 100-400, or 70-350. Decided against it, just not motivating to go back to a mechanical shutter or slow eshutter.

Nikon with light weight pf lenses, but heavier cameras. Didn't want a second system and the weight savings once you add a heavier camera back isn't worth it to me. If I was starting from scratch with one system I would consider it more seriously.

OM-1 and the 300 or 150-400. This was most intriguing to me. The IQ looks good enough to me in most cases. The other benefit is they are probably more weather resistant. I believe it is the only system which is IP rated for water and splashes. This may matter more as your condition changes. I think it is overpriced compared to ff and didn't want a second system.

I decided to just lug my A1 and 200-600 or 600 around instead of any of the alternatives. I know I am lucky to be able to do so.
Nov 27, 2023 at 07:47 PM
SpecFoto
Online
Details
p.3 #2Lighter gear options?
Colin F wrote:
tsdevine wroteIt sounds like you almost need to work on getting used to a tripod/gimbal setup. As you mention, even if there was a lighter ILC solution, as the disease progresses you might end up in the same situation as now.
Yes, after reading of the considerable step backwards in AF, tracking, ISO, resolution etc, I'm starting to think along that line...




The OM-1 is not a "considerable step backwards in AF", as it is a stacked BSI sensor with AI subject recognition that can shoot at 50FPS with AF and no blackout, or 120FPS with AF only on the first shot of the burst. Plus it has Pro Capture which allows for capturing numerous shots before you fully press the shutter and hold them in the buffer. This is the same new "hot" feature that is now on the 24MP A9III, and I have been using this feature since 2015 with Olympus cameras. The other great feature is the IBIS and the Lens IS which sync together to improve stabilization on longer lenses. You will be able to shoot this setup handheld at least a couple of stops slower ss than you now can, which makes up for the ISO differences.

Mirrorless Comparisons has an ongoing series on BIF and testing of all camera and lenses, see link below. They rate the A1 as the best overall at 98%. They rate the OM-1 as the best M4/3 camera and at 89%. So no camera is as good as the A1 for BIF, but the OM-1 is close.

https://mirrorlesscomparison.com/best/mirrorless-cameras-for-birds-in-flight/

I shoot both OM and Sony systems and each has its strength and weaknesses. For your situation the OM-1 and an Olympus 300mm f4 IS lens would be a considerable weight and size saving over your A1 and 600mm f4, but giving you the same reach, and see below where I added the weights of each setup for you. Together these can be purchased new for about $4,700.










Edited on Nov 28, 2023 at 10:00 AM · View previous versions
Nov 28, 2023 at 08:26 AM
Colin F
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Lighter gear options?
SpecFoto wrote:
For your situation the OM-1 and an Olympus 300mm f4 IS lens would be a considerable weight and size saving over your A1 and 600mm f4, giving you the same reach.


Thanks for this. Reach is one thing, but aperture is another, and one thing I'm not clear on: I keep reading the claim of f/4.5 through the entire focal range on the 150-400, but isn't it actually f/9 equivalence to FF?

Nov 28, 2023 at 09:29 AM
SpecFoto
Online
Details
p.3 #4Lighter gear options?
Colin F wrote:
SpecFoto wroteFor your situation the OM-1 and an Olympus 300mm f4 IS lens would be a considerable weight and size saving over your A1 and 600mm f4, giving you the same reach.
Thanks for this. Reach is one thing, but aperture is another, and one thing I'm not clear on: I keep reading the claim of f/4.5 through the entire focal range on the 150-400, but isn't it actually f/9 equivalence to FF?



This is made confusing by some who maybe don't understand it as well or others who want to discredit any sensor less than FF. Aperture is aperture and at f4.5 you will have the same shutter speed and ISO camera settings for the the M4/3 OM-1, APS-C Sony A6700 (which I own), or FF A1. But the DOF is increased by half more on the A6700 and double with the OM-1, vs the A1. So this is why some say the lens is F9, which is wrong, it is an f4.5 for aperture. To me, this is actually an advantage in many situations, such as where I want more than 1 eye in focus on closeup portraits, or more of background in focus on scenic travel photos or in Macro photos. But for closeups of birds with busy backgrounds, it may not be quite as smooth in some cases. You will never notice any difference with a clear blue or cloudy sky background I suggest you go the Micro 4/3 forum on FM and look at the BIF photos with the 300 f4 and 150-450 f4.5, I think you will be pleasantly surprised.
Nov 28, 2023 at 09:50 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Lighter gear options?
Colin F wrote:
SpecFoto wroteFor your situation the OM-1 and an Olympus 300mm f4 IS lens would be a considerable weight and size saving over your A1 and 600mm f4, giving you the same reach.
Thanks for this. Reach is one thing, but aperture is another, and one thing I'm not clear on: I keep reading the claim of f/4.5 through the entire focal range on the 150-400, but isn't it actually f/9 equivalence to FF?



It's a little more complicated than that. The depth of field at f4.5 is the same as it would be for any 400mm lens on a full frame camera; the crop sensor changes the angle of view, but does not change the DOF. You get the same subject magnification that you would achieve with an 800mm lens, but you still have the DOF of a 400mm lens. However, because you would typically be farther from your subject (to get the same composition) with the shorter lens on a m4/3 camera, you have greater DOF - which may be roughly equivalent to f9 on a FF 800mm at one specific subject distance. The Sony 70-350mm f4.5-6.3 zoom would also be an f9 "FF equivalent" but with a bit less reach.

In actual practice, the added DOF from using a shorter focal length and cropping the view often helps at really close distances, but can be a hindrance in isolating the subject at longer distances if you can't control how close you are to the background or foreground elements. Because the m4/3 gear is more portable and much more hand-holdable, it can be easier to work you composition to help deal with the greater DOF.

I'm not saying that m4/3 is the best solution to your situation, but it is definitely an option worth considering. Check out some of the work that Petr Bambousek does with the OM cameras - his images put most full-frame shooters to shame.

Edited on Nov 28, 2023 at 10:34 AM · View previous versions
Nov 28, 2023 at 10:18 AM
Ross Martin
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Lighter gear options?
molson wrote:
Colin F wrote
SpecFoto wroteFor your situation the OM-1 and an Olympus 300mm f4 IS lens would be a considerable weight and size saving over your A1 and 600mm f4, giving you the same reach.
Thanks for this. Reach is one thing, but aperture is another, and one thing I'm not clear on: I keep reading the claim of f/4.5 through the entire focal range on the 150-400, but isn't it actually f/9 equivalence to FF?
It's a little more complicated than that. The depth of field at f4.5 is the same as it would be for any 400mm lens on a full frame camera; the crop sensor changes the angle of view, but does not change the DOF. You get the same subject magnification that you would achieve with an 800mm lens, but you still have the DOF of a 400mm lens. However, because you would typically be farther from your subject (to get the same composition) with the shorter lens on a m4/3 camera, you have greater DOF - which may be roughly equivalent
...Show more →


Thanks for the link. Stunning images, he’s an artist.

Nov 28, 2023 at 10:32 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Lighter gear options?
I'm more of a landscape photographer than a birder, so I moved on from the OM-1 primarily due to its lower dynamic range and the lack of a tilting rear screen (it has one of those annoyingly ubiquitous "selfie" screens) but for general birds and wildlife use a small kit consisting of an OM-1, 12-100mm f4, and 150-400mm f4.5 TC lens would cover a lot of situations with great image quality and unmatched image stabilization.

Here's a smattering of images I shot with the OM 150-400 f4.5: https://www.flickr.com/photos/193226160@N06/albums/72177720298241041
Nov 28, 2023 at 10:40 AM
berimbolo
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #8Lighter gear options?
Galleries of two friends of mine who are OM1 ambassadors:

https://www.instagram.com/arthurlefo/

https://www.instagram.com/brookelittlebear/

One more thing to note for OM1: They have raw pre-capture. Probably increasingly useful if your reaction time is expected to worsen.
Nov 28, 2023 at 10:44 AM
GOVA
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Lighter gear options?
OP. Do consider Olympus. It is very capable and much lighter than any Sony combo. I used to have an EM5 and loved it.

Also, consider the Sony RX-10 IV. I really wish for MK5 of it but that's another story.
Nov 28, 2023 at 02:00 PM
Geekapoo
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Lighter gear options?
Given that the RX10IV was released in 2018 and that Sony's made so many improvements to their AF, an RX10V should be an incredible bridge zoom camera if/when Sony starts selling us one.

GOVA wrote:
OP. Do consider Olympus. It is very capable and much lighter than any Sony combo. I used to have an EM5 and loved it.

Also, consider the Sony RX-10 IV. I really wish for MK5 of it but that's another story.

Nov 28, 2023 at 02:37 PM
Colin F
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Lighter gear options?
Thanks for all the input so far.

Here’s a couple of questions regarding the OM-1 controls, and how I shoot (Manual + Auto ISO – non-negotiable).

AF: I have always assigned one (left) rear button as a broader “zone” for BIF, and another (right) as a single point for static birds. How do I achieve this with the OM-1? Can the AEL button be one, and the AF-ON button be the other?

On my A1, I have the rear/upper dial assigned as the all-important shutter speed, and the front dial assigned as Aperture. Can the OM-1 be set the same?

Exposure Comp: I’m constantly adjusting my EC when shooting, so need it readily available. What can I assign EC to with the OM-1? If the only way to adjust EC on the OM-1 is some clunky, clumsy way, then I’d likely assign EC to the front wheel if possible, and lose the Aperture setting, as I would likely be shooting wide open all the time anyways.
Nov 28, 2023 at 03:00 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Lighter gear options?
Hey, Colin. First off, I am sorry to read about your health issues. Keep up the good fight.

As impressive as I find the OM-1, and it does has some great features, I don't know that the weight savings is as fantastic a deal as it appears in some of the previous comparisons. Your a1 can do 21MP in APSC mode with roughly equal dynamic range to the OM-1 in mechanical shutter, and a bit better in e-shutter. So the OM-1+300 = a1+600 is only accurate if you ignore the 30 extra MPs the a1 gives you. You'd really only need a 400 on the a1, and that would give you a crop-to-zoom 400-600.

If I were in your position, I'd start out renting the 100-400GM, with the idea of using crop-to-zoom at the long end, and see if that weight savings over the 200-600 was enough. If that works, then I'd look at switching out the 600GM with the 300GM.
Nov 28, 2023 at 03:36 PM
SpecFoto
Online
Details
p.3 #13Lighter gear options?
Colin F wrote:
Thanks for all the input so far.

Here’s a couple of questions regarding the OM-1 controls, and how I shoot (Manual + Auto ISO – non-negotiable).

AF: I have always assigned one (left) rear button as a broader “zone” for BIF, and another (right) as a single point for static birds. How do I achieve this with the OM-1? Can the AEL button be one, and the AF-ON button be the other?

On my A1, I have the rear/upper dial assigned as the all-important shutter speed, and the front dial assigned as Aperture. Can the OM-1 be set the same?

Exposure Comp: I’m
...Show more →

Colin, the OM-1 is Highly Customizable, even more so than my Sony A7RIV. Just about every button or switch can be set to almost any feature you want. To answer your specific questions:

AF: The OM-1 actually has a better solution than 2 separate buttons and I find their solution to dual AF setups easier. There is a 2 position sliding FN lever around the AEL button that I have set to AF-C zone for position 1 and AF center point for position 2, just for the reason you mentioned. It is easy to slide the switch with your thumb while looking through the EVF. But yes you could use both the AEL and AF-On button for this too. You could also program this and set it in 2 of the 4 Custom Settings on the Mode dial.

The OM-1 has a front and rear dial and you can set Aperture to one and SS to the other. And you can adjust to dial to have it turn the way you want, i.e faster ss can be set to left or right.

There is a dedicated button for E/C and ISO. You hold the E/C button on the top with your shutter finger and slide the rear dial with your thumb to increase or decrease the E/C, so this can be done in the viewfinder. For the ISO button, as it is on the rear thumb rest you use your right thumb to press the button once and then use the Rear Control pad to increase/decrease ISO, then hit the OK button in the center of the pad to set.

One nice feature the OM-1 has, but Sony doesn't, is the lens release is on the left non-grip side at the front. So where the Sony lens release is there are 2 easy to reach buttons to adjust items quickly without taking your eye out of the EVF. I use this to set Eye Detect ON and Off, but again it is programmable to almost any function you want.

And the EVF is excellent, the same as my A7RIV at 5.76 Million dots.

Edit: Below is a link to the OM-1 Quick Start Guide with easy to see graphics, which goes over the basic control buttons, dials, custom modes and AF.

https://my.omsystem.com/consumer/special/test_wow/OM-1_QuickGuide_EN.pdf?icid=tw-internal-content_page_landscape-link-download_om1_guide_en



Edited on Nov 29, 2023 at 08:11 AM · View previous versions
Nov 28, 2023 at 05:26 PM
Colin F
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Lighter gear options?
^^^ Thanks, very helpful.
Nov 28, 2023 at 06:56 PM
aCuria
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Lighter gear options?
SpecFoto wrote:
Colin F wrote
tsdevine wroteIt sounds like you almost need to work on getting used to a tripod/gimbal setup. As you mention, even if there was a lighter ILC solution, as the disease progresses you might end up in the same situation as now.
Yes, after reading of the considerable step backwards in AF, tracking, ISO, resolution etc, I'm starting to think along that line...
The OM-1 is not a "considerable step backwards in AF", as it is a stacked BSI sensor with AI subject recognition that can shoot at 50FPS with AF and no blackout, or 120FPS with AF only on the first shot of the burst. Plus it has Pro Capture which allows for capturing numerous shots before you fully press the shutter and hold them in the buffer. This is the same new "hot" feature that is now on the 24MP A9III, and I have been using this feature since 2015 with Olympus cameras. The other great feature is the IBIS and
...Show more →

This is not equivalent though, the 300/4 on M43 sensor will have the DOF of 600/8 on FF

It is closer to compare the A1 + 300/2.8 + M43 crop (12.5MP) to the OM1 + 300/4 (20MP)

There is a MP gap but it’s similar to going from a 50MP A1 to ~32MP camera (A7iv?) this isn’t that big a hit

The 300GM is one stop faster, the lower iso means more detail in the file and this may be enough to overcome any MP gap

The MP count can also be increased with a 1.4x or 2x
Nov 28, 2023 at 07:22 PM
Robin Smith
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Lighter gear options?
The Sony 300mm GM costs $6000 and I don’t think is available yet (?), the OM 300 is $2700 and is available secondhand. So the Sony still does not have the equivalent field of view. You can also add TCs to the OM. The equivalent dof is a red herring IMO. Is the depth of field for a 300mm at f4 “bad”? It’s not as shallow, but hardly a catastrophe. Many times more dof for a given light gathering capability is a positive.
Nov 28, 2023 at 09:59 PM
berimbolo
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #17Lighter gear options?
The 300GM likely won't be in people's hands for quite some time. I have read there is more demand than expected for that lens. Having something in hand sooner that has a few compromises compared to the 300GM may result in greater expected enjoyment than waiting until spring/summer for a 300GM.
Nov 29, 2023 at 08:36 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Lighter gear options?
With some of the comments about "equivalence", it's sure easy to tell the armchair photographers from the people who actually take the gear out and make images with it...




Too Much Depth of Field?

  E-M1X    OLYMPUS M.300mm F4.0 lens    300mm    f/4.0    1/125s    1250 ISO    0.0 EV  

Nov 29, 2023 at 09:26 AM
aCuria
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Lighter gear options?
Robin Smith wrote:
The Sony 300mm GM costs $6000 and I don’t think is available yet (?), the OM 300 is $2700 and is available secondhand. So the Sony still does not have the equivalent field of view. You can also add TCs to the OM. The equivalent dof is a red herring IMO. Is the depth of field for a 300mm at f4 “bad”? It’s not as shallow, but hardly a catastrophe. Many times more dof for a given light gathering capability is a positive.


The DOF isn’t “bad” but you compared a 600/8 equivalent to a 600/4 which seemed odd to me.

Regarding FOV the Sony 300/2.8 has an identical field of view after cropping to the same M43 sensor size

Using the 300/2.8 GM lens this way also makes far easier to track the bird in frame, since you can see so much more in the viewfinder. Even with the 2-6 I can’t shoot at 600mm all the time because of difficulty tracking songbirds

With the GM you would have the option of punching out to get a wider fov for large birds, while the 300/4 on a M43 camera is only a 600/8 equivalent and cannot do anything wider

The GM is also one stop brighter, but that stop does come with a 200g weight penalty and a higher cost

While you can put a 2x on the 300/4 which yields a 600/8, note that f/8 on M43 is diffraction limited to ~”13.46MP” even for an optically perfect lens.

On the other hand, running a 2x on the 300/2.8 yields a 600/5.6 and that’s diffraction limited to 27.47 MP on a M43 sized sensor, so this setup is more sensor limited not lens limited

Anyway I completely agree that getting a copy of the 300 GM lens is the biggest problem for the OP should he go this route, but on the other hand he doesn’t have to sell as much gear which does take time.

On the other hand the lightest MILC kit is probably the Canon 600/11 and R8 (1346g) which is considerably lighter than the OM1 and 300/4 (1869g)


Edited on Nov 29, 2023 at 12:28 PM · View previous versions
Nov 29, 2023 at 11:46 AM
aCuria
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Lighter gear options?
molson wrote:
With some of the comments about "equivalence", it's sure easy to tell the armchair photographers from the people who actually take the gear out and make images with it...


A somewhat unnecessary jab; I've shared wildlife photos in this forum you can look up
Nov 29, 2023 at 12:07 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister