fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Sony A9III Shutter

  
 
Tony5787
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Sony A9III Shutter
rscheffler wrote:
Tony5787 wroteUnless Canon’s like a generation ahead with their global shutter sensors, I’d rather see them stick with a stacked sensor for the R1. It’s apparent in the samples that are coming out from the a9 III that low light is not its strong suit.
Adobe Denoise, DxO, Topaz, etc. to the rescue?

Apparently there was a time long ago when CMOS was inferior to CCD... I'm guessing we're at a similar point now with GS vs. stacked.


Those programs can only do so much, if there’s significant noise none of them can bring a photo back. The only times I’ve experienced that though that I can think of was with the R5 a half hour after dusk shooting screech owls with basically no ambient light lol So who knows, maybe with increased noise from GS it won’t matter, and worst case I just hang on to my R3 and use that in low light.
Nov 08, 2023 at 08:39 PM
Pixelpuffin
Online
Details
p.2 #2Sony A9III Shutter
Spray & Pray
Was never so apt

If nothing else it will make users even more lazy - note I deliberately left “ photographers” out.

I think the tech is amazing yes, but it’s similar to the reliance on fast food, most don’t posses the knowledge to cook these days (including me)

In 2007 I used to predict the shutter lag on my Sony T30 compact. Got loads of ball on bat shots of my then young son, got my partners hair blown by the passing of a huge eagle at a bird sanctuary, prefocused and caught both her expression and hair and the eagle flying past. Fluke shot?? Maybe. But I actually did set out to get that shot. I can still recall the kick it gave me when I realised I’d caught “that” moment.
The thought of having to trawl through 120 frames or worse 240 if you played safe and held the button for a couple of seconds.

Clever stuff I agree, but we are basically heading towards videography and just selecting our favourite still.

I suppose as it becomes more main stream the current gear resale prices will take a hit = bargains .
Nov 08, 2023 at 11:48 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Sony A9III Shutter
rscheffler wrote:
Apparently there was a time long ago when CMOS was inferior to CCD... I'm guessing we're at a similar point now with GS vs. stacked.


The CCD to CMOS transition came to my mind too, but I think this is different. Global shutter sensors and rolling shutter sensors are based on the same fundamental technology and production platforms and will coexist in a way that CCD and CMOS couldn't. Any improvements that will make GS sensors better, will also make RS sensors even more better in other areas.

The A9III with GS is a bold move from Sony, as it turns out to be more of a niche camera than anything else in its class. I would say it borders to experimental.
Nov 09, 2023 at 02:07 AM
Choderboy
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Sony A9III Shutter
Have pity on us mere mortals that can only dream of having you amazing skill and talent.
We all worship you.

Pixelpuffin wrote:
Spray & Pray
Was never so apt

If nothing else it will make users even more lazy - note I deliberately left “ photographers” out.

I think the tech is amazing yes, but it’s similar to the reliance on fast food, most don’t posses the knowledge to cook these days (including me)

In 2007 I used to predict the shutter lag on my Sony T30 compact. Got loads of ball on bat shots of my then young son, got my partners hair blown by the passing of a huge eagle at a bird sanctuary, prefocused and caught both her expression and hair
...Show more →

Nov 09, 2023 at 04:03 AM
Rudy Pohl
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Sony A9III Shutter
If you're a sports photographer, especially a pro, and you need images of perfectly round baseballs coming off a straight swinging bat then it looks like salvation has just arrived in the A9III. For the rest of us, maybe not so much.

Edited on Nov 09, 2023 at 07:24 AM · View previous versions
Nov 09, 2023 at 04:36 AM
Tony5787
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Sony A9III Shutter
Pixelpuffin wrote:
Spray & Pray
Was never so apt

If nothing else it will make users even more lazy - note I deliberately left “ photographers” out.

I think the tech is amazing yes, but it’s similar to the reliance on fast food, most don’t posses the knowledge to cook these days (including me)

In 2007 I used to predict the shutter lag on my Sony T30 compact. Got loads of ball on bat shots of my then young son, got my partners hair blown by the passing of a huge eagle at a bird sanctuary, prefocused and caught both her expression and hair
...Show more →

Try shooting something like Barn Swallows in flight catching gnats and you’ll see why that speed is necessary. Over the past two years of shooting tens of thousands of images of them with the R3 at 30fps I still haven’t managed to get the shot I’m looking for. There are certain things where the decisive moment requires more speed, for everything else you can just not use that speed.
Nov 09, 2023 at 05:45 AM
dugaut
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Sony A9III Shutter
melcat wrote:
It looks like I “dodged a bullet” by getting the R3, which I did mainly because the α9 II was so old and I could not wait for its successor.

The idea was that I would have a single body that could do the high frame rate wildlife stuff and the low-ISO landscape stuff. The α9 III is apparently not that body, and the α1 is even older and less-maintained by Sony (notice the largest cheer at the release presentation was for new firmware for that, not the new camera and lens).

The benefits of the global shutter for sports shooting are
...Show more →

I think you summarized a lot of opinion on wildlife vs sports photography being quite different. I hear pundits on either side of that divide quite often. Higher megapixel vs extreme agility. I almost want to say the a9iii is a niche camera, but I haven't heard a lot yet about the unlimited flash sync speed capable with this camera. I wonder if that is also a niche requirement. Sounds good, but most people have figured out how to work around slow sync speeds.

Nov 09, 2023 at 07:43 AM
jedibrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Sony A9III Shutter
dugaut wrote:
melcat wroteIt looks like I “dodged a bullet” by getting the R3, which I did mainly because the α9 II was so old and I could not wait for its successor.

The idea was that I would have a single body that could do the high frame rate wildlife stuff and the low-ISO landscape stuff. The α9 III is apparently not that body, and the α1 is even older and less-maintained by Sony (notice the largest cheer at the release presentation was for new firmware for that, not the new camera and lens).

The benefits of the global shutter for sports shooting are clear. On the other hand the fast shutter in the R3 is sufficient for wildlife, and the animals do not pose in front of LED billboards. It seems to me that, with global shutter technology as it is in the α9 III, sports and wildlife cameras should be different things. People here will also claim the wildlife camera needs more pixels, which the sports one doesn’t.
I think you summarized a lot of opinion on wildlife vs sports photography being quite different. I hear pundits on either side of that divide quite often. Higher megapixel vs extreme agility. I almost want to say the a9iii is a niche camera, but I haven't heard a lot yet about the unlimited flash sync speed capable with this camera. I wonder if that is also a niche requirement. Sounds good, but most people have figured out how to work around slow sync speeds.



Every flash shot ever taken was taken at a slower sync speed than that. Let that sink in a moment. The advantage it will bring is to allow some new types of shots to be made. How many will that be? No one knows. People will experiment and find out. I guess full flash lighting under the noon sun may be possible, as you can go to 1/80,000 to kill the sun and not need super powerful strobes to over power it. But the bottom line is the upgrades are incremental, even though the technology on release day seems revolutionary. BSI sensors were supposed to kill FSI sensors. They did not. So all we can do is wait and see what happens here. ISO performance is a bummer, if it holds true to what's been reported early.

Brian
Nov 09, 2023 at 08:10 AM
rscheffler
Online
Details
p.2 #9Sony A9III Shutter
The challenge with flash sync at very high shutter speeds with GS is that the 'shutter' is sampling a potentially very small/short portion of the full flash output. And many strobes with high power output, have fairly long flash duration at full power. A hypothetical 1000 W/s strobe at full power might have around 1/250 flash duration, which is sufficient for conventional mechanical shutter use, but with GS, say if you wanted to shoot at 1/1000, you'd only be sampling 1/4 of the strobe's output (assuming linear power output, which it isn't in reality). 1/2000 shutter speed would be 1/8 of the strobe output, etc. At that point you're only sampling around 125 W/s. In this case it's still about 2x the output of an on-camera flash and still definitely useable when you can position the strobe and modifier relatively close to the subject. I'm routinely doing head & shoulder portraits with a 100cm octabox and getting f/8 at ISO 200 around 100 W/s. But as the shutter speed gets shorter, usable light from the strobe's full power output decreases accordingly. Some strobes shorten flash duration as power output is decreased. Using the example here, setting the strobe to 1/4 power might hypothetically decrease flash duration to around 1/1000, which would better mesh with the camera's 1/1000 shutter speed. While this wouldn't give you more usable light than leaving the strobe at full power, it would allow for faster recycling time, use less battery power per exposure, etc.

The reality remains that using a very high GS speed will still only use a fraction of the strobe's full output. Another challenge is that strobe output is not linear. There is a moment of peak light output followed by a longer 'tail' as output trails off (though with IGBT controlled strobes, the tail is 'cut'). As shutter speeds shorten, it becomes more and more important to correctly time the moment the shutter is open with peak light output. Therefore the camera should have some option to allow the photographer to fine tune shutter and flash synchronization to better align the moment of exposure with the strobe's peak output.

This capability already exists for conventional shutter cameras in the form of 'hypersync' or 'hi-sync' (not to be confused with high speed sync - HSS). But the difference with conventional shutters at 1/1000 vs. GS at 1/1000 is that the mechanical shutter opening still takes around 1/250 to travel across the frame, whereas GS samples the full image at 1/1000. This means with mechanical shutters, if flash duration is shorter than 1/250, you get uneven exposure across the frame. This is why hypersync relies on long strobe duration - so that there is consistent strobe output for the full time the shutter opening travels across the frame.

With GS it's reading the entire frame at the actual shutter speed and would be usable with shorter flash duration strobes, but it will be necessary to be able to correctly synchronize the timing of the shutter and the strobe to fully take advantage of this.


Pixelpuffin wrote:
Spray & Pray
Was never so apt


This has been a derogatory remark for ages. 6fps with film eventually peaking around 10fps. Then 14-16fps with the fastest DSLRs. Now with recent mirrorless it has been in the 20-40fps range. So inevitably fps rates will increase and yes, we're effectively shooting short video bursts.

Lately I've been shooting some sports with the R6II at ~40fps and it's interesting to see that with fast action, there is still considerable variation between frames. So as someone commented earlier, at these 20-40fps rates, there's still no guarantee of actually getting 'ball on bat' but 120fps improves this by 3-6 times.

With my 'old' 1DX cameras, the shutter release had a very definite, hairpin-like release point. With it I was frequently able to successfully time single shots of peak action moments. With the R6II and other mirrorless cameras I have used, it hasn't been as easy. The slight delay of the EVF combined with a different shutter release button 'feel' has made this much more difficult for me to fine-tune. As a result, if the situation allows, I will fall back to 40fps bursts instead and when possible start the bursts earlier.

The tradeoff is that yes, there are many more images to go through. But when browsing thumbnails, it is still pretty quick and easy to home in on the peak moment.

As with any new feature, higher frame rates will provide benefits and have downsides, which the photographer will have to manage accordingly.
Nov 09, 2023 at 08:39 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #10Sony A9III Shutter
High flash sync speeds aren't really anything new. You just used the short flash duration, and even the 380EX on a 5D had faster ss, granted high speed sync eats a lot of power. Saw a photo of a wasp with the wings frozen, in a magazine back in the film days they used 1/10,000 sec just on vivitar 283 on lowest power or something like that

Not sure of the advantages of global shutter , people have mentioned it on here for a long time, but I don't really use high frame rates at this time. I do use high iso though, a lot, if there's some disadvantage there.

Curious if the R1 has a global shutter. Sony seems to be announcing February releases in an effort to blunt any Canon announcement so there might be something else in the offing. but really the 24-105/2.8 is pretty amazing already, a lens I don't think I ever thought I'd see
Nov 09, 2023 at 10:14 AM
artsupreme
Online
Details
p.2 #11Sony A9III Shutter
Rudy Pohl wrote:
I've been an avid wildlife photography enthusiast going on 15 years. I added videos to the mix a couple of years ago. I have known quite few people with the same passion and pursuit and in all that time I can't remember a single person whose images got noticeably better because they bought a better camera.

Fieldcraft, time spent in the field, patience and determination, shot creativity, understanding natural lighting, processing skills, dedication to excellence and a willingness to learn and improve; these are the things that make good photographs and good photographers, not the features on a camera.

If you're
...Show more →

It could be said that images do not get noticeably better with new gear in a lot of situations, but there are plenty of situations where new gear does improve your images and also makes certain images possible to capture. This applies mostly to fast action and high ISO. Of course someone could capture a similar low ISO shot with an old 5D as an R3, but you have to be really lucky to nail that one split second in time for that one keeper frame. Newer cameras like the R3 with 120fps bursts make the shot super easy to get, and it opens doors to capturing shots that were very difficult to get in the past. Higher ISO capabilities in newer cameras does make your images better. Try to shoot an old 5D at ISO 25,600 and compare with the latest bodies.

As for the baseball on bat, you are not trying to get a perfectly round ball coming off the bat. You are trying to nail the shot when the ball on the bat is being squished like an orange and has dust come out of it. Yes, this is possible to capture with any camera in one frame, but it's very unlikely. And, if you do actually want a perfectly round ball, then yes it's possible now with newer bodies to avoid rolling shutter. The new Sony will likely be able to shoot golf swings with golf balls being mashed on the face of clubs with no distortion or blur. This has never been possible with older bodies. There are a million other examples of where 120fps and more will open up more doors. Like bullets exiting barrels, bullets penetrating glass, etc. It will all come into consumer bodies eventually. As for 120fps, it's very useful in all all sports and fast action to capture certain shots that were very difficult or nearly impossible to get with older bodies. Yes, this body is made specifically for sports/action photographers and is not for everyone. But with Sony having a much broader lineup offering it makes more sense they would make a camera like this. If this were Canon's R3, the bashing would be more expected considering they currently have a limited lineup with holes in it.
Nov 09, 2023 at 11:37 AM
Rudy Pohl
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Sony A9III Shutter
artsupreme wrote:
Rudy Pohl wroteI've been an avid wildlife photography enthusiast going on 15 years. I added videos to the mix a couple of years ago. I have known quite few people with the same passion and pursuit and in all that time I can't remember a single person whose images got noticeably better because they bought a better camera.

Fieldcraft, time spent in the field, patience and determination, shot creativity, understanding natural lighting, processing skills, dedication to excellence and a willingness to learn and improve; these are the things that make good photographs and good photographers, not the features on a camera.

If you're a sports photographer, especially a pro, and you need images of perfectly round baseballs coming off a straight swinging bat then it looks like your salvation has just arrived in the A9III. For the rest of us, not so much.
It could be said that images do not get noticeably better with new gear in a lot of situations, but there are plenty of situations where new gear does improve your images and also makes certain images possible to capture. This applies mostly to fast action and high ISO. Of course someone could capture a similar low ISO shot with an old 5D as an R3, but you have to be really lucky to nail that one split second in time for that one keeper frame. Newer cameras like the R3 with 120fps bursts make the shot super easy to
...Show more →

I agree with all that you've written which is why after some sober second thought this morning I edited and removed most my original post. I regret having written it and I'm a bit disappointed that you chose to make it public and respond to that part of it since it no longer was my point of view. Regarding shooting baseballs, not being a sports shooter I'm not versed in the finer points of what makes the ideal shot. No big deal.

Anyways, all I am saying is that for those who need/want such a camera and can afford it, this technical breakthrough is amazing. Kudos to Sony. At the same time, if someone took pretty ho-hum pictures before the A9III then this new camera probably won't make much difference in their output.

Nov 09, 2023 at 12:08 PM
artsupreme
Online
Details
p.2 #13Sony A9III Shutter
Rudy Pohl wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Rudy Pohl wroteI've been an avid wildlife photography enthusiast going on 15 years. I added videos to the mix a couple of years ago. I have known quite few people with the same passion and pursuit and in all that time I can't remember a single person whose images got noticeably better because they bought a better camera.

Fieldcraft, time spent in the field, patience and determination, shot creativity, understanding natural lighting, processing skills, dedication to excellence and a willingness to learn and improve; these are the things that make good photographs and good photographers, not the features on a camera.

If you're a sports photographer, especially a pro, and you need images of perfectly round baseballs coming off a straight swinging bat then it looks like your salvation has just arrived in the A9III. For the rest of us, not so much.
It could be said that images do not get noticeably better with new gear in a lot of situations, but there are plenty of situations where new gear does improve your images and also makes certain images possible to capture. This applies mostly to fast action and high ISO. Of course someone could capture a similar low ISO shot with an old 5D as an R3, but you have to be really lucky to nail that one split second in time for that one keeper frame. Newer cameras like the R3 with 120fps bursts make the shot super easy to get, and it opens doors to capturing shots that were very difficult to get in the past. Higher ISO capabilities in newer cameras does make your images better. Try to shoot an old 5D at ISO 25,600 and compare with the latest bodies.

As for the baseball on bat, you are not trying to get a perfectly round ball coming off the bat. You are trying to nail the shot when the ball on the bat is being squished like an orange and has dust come out of it. Yes, this is possible to capture with any camera in one frame, but it's very unlikely. And, if you do actually want a perfectly round ball, then yes it's possible now with newer bodies to avoid rolling shutter. The new Sony will likely be able to shoot golf swings with golf balls being mashed on the face of clubs with no distortion or blur. This has never been possible with older bodies. There are a million other examples of where 120fps and more will open up more doors. Like bullets exiting barrels, bullets penetrating glass, etc. It will all come into consumer bodies eventually. As for 120fps, it's very useful in all all sports and fast action to capture certain shots that were very difficult or nearly impossible to get with older bodies. Yes, this body is made specifically for sports/action photographers and is not for everyone. But with Sony having a much broader lineup offering it makes more sense they would make a camera like this. If this were Canon's R3, the bashing would be more expected considering they currently have a limited lineup with holes in it.
I agree with all that you've written which is why after some sober second thought this morning I edited and removed most my original post. I regret having written it and I'm a bit disappointed that you chose to make it public and respond to that part of it since it no longer was my point of view. Regarding shooting baseballs, not being a sports shooter I'm not versed in the finer points of what makes the ideal shot. No big deal.

Anyways, all I am saying is that for those who need/want such a camera and can afford
...Show more →

Unfortunately I don't think there's a way to delete your post here. Unless you edit it before someone else responds, it will always be there. I'm in between conference calls and your unedited post was there when I went to respond to it. Even now after you have edited it, anyone can click on your edited link and it shows your original post. I don't think it's a problem though, you have edited it and mentioned the change in message above.
Nov 09, 2023 at 12:22 PM
Rudy Pohl
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Sony A9III Shutter
artsupreme wrote:
Rudy Pohl wrote
artsupreme wrote
Rudy Pohl wroteI've been an avid wildlife photography enthusiast going on 15 years. I added videos to the mix a couple of years ago. I have known quite few people with the same passion and pursuit and in all that time I can't remember a single person whose images got noticeably better because they bought a better camera.

Fieldcraft, time spent in the field, patience and determination, shot creativity, understanding natural lighting, processing skills, dedication to excellence and a willingness to learn and improve; these are the things that make good photographs and good photographers, not the features on a camera.

If you're a sports photographer, especially a pro, and you need images of perfectly round baseballs coming off a straight swinging bat then it looks like your salvation has just arrived in the A9III. For the rest of us, not so much.
It could be said that images do not get noticeably better with new gear in a lot of situations, but there are plenty of situations where new gear does improve your images and also makes certain images possible to capture. This applies mostly to fast action and high ISO. Of course someone could capture a similar low ISO shot with an old 5D as an R3, but you have to be really lucky to nail that one split second in time for that one keeper frame. Newer cameras like the R3 with 120fps bursts make the shot super easy to get, and it opens doors to capturing shots that were very difficult to get in the past. Higher ISO capabilities in newer cameras does make your images better. Try to shoot an old 5D at ISO 25,600 and compare with the latest bodies.

As for the baseball on bat, you are not trying to get a perfectly round ball coming off the bat. You are trying to nail the shot when the ball on the bat is being squished like an orange and has dust come out of it. Yes, this is possible to capture with any camera in one frame, but it's very unlikely. And, if you do actually want a perfectly round ball, then yes it's possible now with newer bodies to avoid rolling shutter. The new Sony will likely be able to shoot golf swings with golf balls being mashed on the face of clubs with no distortion or blur. This has never been possible with older bodies. There are a million other examples of where 120fps and more will open up more doors. Like bullets exiting barrels, bullets penetrating glass, etc. It will all come into consumer bodies eventually. As for 120fps, it's very useful in all all sports and fast action to capture certain shots that were very difficult or nearly impossible to get with older bodies. Yes, this body is made specifically for sports/action photographers and is not for everyone. But with Sony having a much broader lineup offering it makes more sense they would make a camera like this. If this were Canon's R3, the bashing would be more expected considering they currently have a limited lineup with holes in it.
I agree with all that you've written which is why after some sober second thought this morning I edited and removed most my original post. I regret having written it and I'm a bit disappointed that you chose to make it public and respond to that part of it since it no longer was my point of view. Regarding shooting baseballs, not being a sports shooter I'm not versed in the finer points of what makes the ideal shot. No big deal.

Anyways, all I am saying is that for those who need/want such a camera and can afford it, this technical breakthrough is amazing. Kudos to Sony. At the same time, if someone took pretty ho-hum pictures before the A9III then this new camera probably won't make much difference in their output.
Unfortunately I don't think there's a way to delete your post here. Unless you edit it before someone else responds, it will always be there. I'm in between conference calls and your unedited post was there when I went to respond to it. Even now after you have edited it, anyone can click on your edited link and it shows your original post. I don't think it's a problem though, you have edited it and mentioned the change in message above.


No worries. That'll teach me for posting an opinion before my second cup of coffee in the morning. I thought I learned that lesson years ago.... guess not.
Nov 09, 2023 at 12:48 PM
jedibrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Sony A9III Shutter
Rudy Pohl wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Rudy Pohl wrote
artsupreme wrote
Rudy Pohl wroteI've been an avid wildlife photography enthusiast going on 15 years. I added videos to the mix a couple of years ago. I have known quite few people with the same passion and pursuit and in all that time I can't remember a single person whose images got noticeably better because they bought a better camera.

Fieldcraft, time spent in the field, patience and determination, shot creativity, understanding natural lighting, processing skills, dedication to excellence and a willingness to learn and improve; these are the things that make good photographs and good photographers, not the features on a camera.

If you're a sports photographer, especially a pro, and you need images of perfectly round baseballs coming off a straight swinging bat then it looks like your salvation has just arrived in the A9III. For the rest of us, not so much.
It could be said that images do not get noticeably better with new gear in a lot of situations, but there are plenty of situations where new gear does improve your images and also makes certain images possible to capture. This applies mostly to fast action and high ISO. Of course someone could capture a similar low ISO shot with an old 5D as an R3, but you have to be really lucky to nail that one split second in time for that one keeper frame. Newer cameras like the R3 with 120fps bursts make the shot super easy to get, and it opens doors to capturing shots that were very difficult to get in the past. Higher ISO capabilities in newer cameras does make your images better. Try to shoot an old 5D at ISO 25,600 and compare with the latest bodies.

As for the baseball on bat, you are not trying to get a perfectly round ball coming off the bat. You are trying to nail the shot when the ball on the bat is being squished like an orange and has dust come out of it. Yes, this is possible to capture with any camera in one frame, but it's very unlikely. And, if you do actually want a perfectly round ball, then yes it's possible now with newer bodies to avoid rolling shutter. The new Sony will likely be able to shoot golf swings with golf balls being mashed on the face of clubs with no distortion or blur. This has never been possible with older bodies. There are a million other examples of where 120fps and more will open up more doors. Like bullets exiting barrels, bullets penetrating glass, etc. It will all come into consumer bodies eventually. As for 120fps, it's very useful in all all sports and fast action to capture certain shots that were very difficult or nearly impossible to get with older bodies. Yes, this body is made specifically for sports/action photographers and is not for everyone. But with Sony having a much broader lineup offering it makes more sense they would make a camera like this. If this were Canon's R3, the bashing would be more expected considering they currently have a limited lineup with holes in it.
I agree with all that you've written which is why after some sober second thought this morning I edited and removed most my original post. I regret having written it and I'm a bit disappointed that you chose to make it public and respond to that part of it since it no longer was my point of view. Regarding shooting baseballs, not being a sports shooter I'm not versed in the finer points of what makes the ideal shot. No big deal.

Anyways, all I am saying is that for those who need/want such a camera and can afford it, this technical breakthrough is amazing. Kudos to Sony. At the same time, if someone took pretty ho-hum pictures before the A9III then this new camera probably won't make much difference in their output.
Unfortunately I don't think there's a way to delete your post here. Unless you edit it before someone else responds, it will always be there. I'm in between conference calls and your unedited post was there when I went to respond to it. Even now after you have edited it, anyone can click on your edited link and it shows your original post. I don't think it's a problem though, you have edited it and mentioned the change in message above.
No worries. That'll teach me for posting an opinion before my second cup of coffee in the morning. I thought I learned that lesson years ago.... guess not.


No sweat. We're all just talking about gear here. Nothing anyone should lose sleep over.

Nov 09, 2023 at 01:28 PM
Rudy Pohl
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Sony A9III Shutter
jedibrain wrote:
Rudy Pohl wrote
artsupreme wrote
Rudy Pohl wrote
artsupreme wrote
Rudy Pohl wroteI've been an avid wildlife photography enthusiast going on 15 years. I added videos to the mix a couple of years ago. I have known quite few people with the same passion and pursuit and in all that time I can't remember a single person whose images got noticeably better because they bought a better camera.

Fieldcraft, time spent in the field, patience and determination, shot creativity, understanding natural lighting, processing skills, dedication to excellence and a willingness to learn and improve; these are the things that make good photographs and good photographers, not the features on a camera.

If you're a sports photographer, especially a pro, and you need images of perfectly round baseballs coming off a straight swinging bat then it looks like your salvation has just arrived in the A9III. For the rest of us, not so much.
It could be said that images do not get noticeably better with new gear in a lot of situations, but there are plenty of situations where new gear does improve your images and also makes certain images possible to capture. This applies mostly to fast action and high ISO. Of course someone could capture a similar low ISO shot with an old 5D as an R3, but you have to be really lucky to nail that one split second in time for that one keeper frame. Newer cameras like the R3 with 120fps bursts make the shot super easy to get, and it opens doors to capturing shots that were very difficult to get in the past. Higher ISO capabilities in newer cameras does make your images better. Try to shoot an old 5D at ISO 25,600 and compare with the latest bodies.

As for the baseball on bat, you are not trying to get a perfectly round ball coming off the bat. You are trying to nail the shot when the ball on the bat is being squished like an orange and has dust come out of it. Yes, this is possible to capture with any camera in one frame, but it's very unlikely. And, if you do actually want a perfectly round ball, then yes it's possible now with newer bodies to avoid rolling shutter. The new Sony will likely be able to shoot golf swings with golf balls being mashed on the face of clubs with no distortion or blur. This has never been possible with older bodies. There are a million other examples of where 120fps and more will open up more doors. Like bullets exiting barrels, bullets penetrating glass, etc. It will all come into consumer bodies eventually. As for 120fps, it's very useful in all all sports and fast action to capture certain shots that were very difficult or nearly impossible to get with older bodies. Yes, this body is made specifically for sports/action photographers and is not for everyone. But with Sony having a much broader lineup offering it makes more sense they would make a camera like this. If this were Canon's R3, the bashing would be more expected considering they currently have a limited lineup with holes in it.
I agree with all that you've written which is why after some sober second thought this morning I edited and removed most my original post. I regret having written it and I'm a bit disappointed that you chose to make it public and respond to that part of it since it no longer was my point of view. Regarding shooting baseballs, not being a sports shooter I'm not versed in the finer points of what makes the ideal shot. No big deal.

Anyways, all I am saying is that for those who need/want such a camera and can afford it, this technical breakthrough is amazing. Kudos to Sony. At the same time, if someone took pretty ho-hum pictures before the A9III then this new camera probably won't make much difference in their output.
Unfortunately I don't think there's a way to delete your post here. Unless you edit it before someone else responds, it will always be there. I'm in between conference calls and your unedited post was there when I went to respond to it. Even now after you have edited it, anyone can click on your edited link and it shows your original post. I don't think it's a problem though, you have edited it and mentioned the change in message above.
No worries. That'll teach me for posting an opinion before my second cup of coffee in the morning. I thought I learned that lesson years ago.... guess not.
No sweat. We're all just talking about gear here. Nothing anyone should lose sleep over.



Thanks, not planning on losing any sleep.

Today I watched several videos on the new A9III regarding it's promised stills and video capabilities. It looks like a stunning camera coming up.
Nov 09, 2023 at 07:57 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Sony A9III Shutter
If R1 has global shutter than it almost with certainty won't be a high-MP camera.
I think R3Mk2 will have global shutter around 24MP and R1 will go more towards the higher MP, fast scanning sensor like Z9 and A1.

If R1 has 24MP global shutter then where does that leave the R3 line and what competes with the A1/Z9? I would see no point in the R3 line unless it is marketed as a cheaper entry point to a professional sports camera. The R5II would have to take the place of the high MP, stacked sensor and that would likely mean a significant price increase...at least to Z8 levels but knowing Canon more likely Z9 levels (probably not to A1 levels).

R3 was priced at $6K on release...same as A9III....R3II with 24MP GS can stay at $6K. R1 will be $7K and A1II likely will be $7K and won't have GS either. R5II won't be stacked sensor.

Nikon boys will continue to have the bragging rights for less expensive highMP stacked sensor and best wildlife lenses. Unfortunately they will still be stuck with a severe lack of controls and control options and a cruddy EVF that is only superior in smooth shooting but terrible in all other ways.
Nov 10, 2023 at 04:49 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Sony A9III Shutter
arbitrage wrote:
If R1 has global shutter than it almost with certainty won't be a high-MP camera.
I think R3Mk2 will have global shutter around 24MP and R1 will go more towards the higher MP, fast scanning sensor like Z9 and A1.

If R1 has 24MP global shutter then where does that leave the R3 line and what competes with the A1/Z9? I would see no point in the R3 line unless it is marketed as a cheaper entry point to a professional sports camera. The R5II would have to take the place of the high MP, stacked sensor and that would likely mean
...Show more →

Well we know that Canon is going to introduce a revolutionary new sensor as noted in a recent article. So it looks like there is a very good chance the R1 might be a 24mp.
It ain't going to be your father's type of sensor for sure.

It's suppose to be some super efficient sensor that will allow Canon to develop global shutter sensors with an extremely high dynamic range sensor 32EV dynamic range. And possibly a quad-pixel array (all-directional AF) which would put all known AF systems to shame from any manufacture. That's astonishing if they can pull it off and it would certainly make Sony's A9III even more embarrassing in every way. I suspect Sony is going to regret rushing the A9III to market half baked with it's pathetic IQ just so they could claim the spot to the first global shutter to the masses. Canon has had global shutters for years, just not for mainstream consumer products.

https://www.canonrumors.com/canon-to-speak-at-iedm-about-new-sensor-development/

I think the R3 will be the one and only of it's kind and will slowly disappear after the R1 is released. But who knows, maybe they'll find a slot for it in the line-up like you suggest. Just seems like the high end body line-up would be getting a little cramped to me though.

Nov 10, 2023 at 08:36 AM
Tony5787
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Sony A9III Shutter
At this point I can’t see the R1 not being 45MP+, it’s pretty evident that the R3 was intended to be the R1 and then Canon renamed it after seeing the a1 and Z9. There’s nothing in Canon’s lineup to compete with those bodies, if they made people wait all this time for an R1 and it’s the same resolution as the R3 they’re going to see a TON of people jumping ship. It’s also evident that Sony sees a place in their lineup for an R3-like body so I don’t think the R3 will be a one-off.
Nov 10, 2023 at 11:39 AM
Cnyphotoguy
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Sony A9III Shutter
scottiet wrote:
IMO Canon R1 needs to have a global shutter. Having shot sports against led ad panels, it was a nightmare with banding. I will buy the camera for that reason alone. Can’t imagine the Olympics won’t have the same situation.


Pretty sure the R3's high frequency anti flicker is able to handle that too - https://cam.start.canon/ky/C010/manual/html/UG-03_Shooting-1_0110.html
Nov 10, 2023 at 05:17 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister