The challenge with flash sync at very high shutter speeds with GS is that the 'shutter' is sampling a potentially very small/short portion of the full flash output. And many strobes with high power output, have fairly long flash duration at full power. A hypothetical 1000 W/s strobe at full power might have around 1/250 flash duration, which is sufficient for conventional mechanical shutter use, but with GS, say if you wanted to shoot at 1/1000, you'd only be sampling 1/4 of the strobe's output (assuming linear power output, which it isn't in reality). 1/2000 shutter speed would be 1/8 of the strobe output, etc. At that point you're only sampling around 125 W/s. In this case it's still about 2x the output of an on-camera flash and still definitely useable when you can position the strobe and modifier relatively close to the subject. I'm routinely doing head & shoulder portraits with a 100cm octabox and getting f/8 at ISO 200 around 100 W/s. But as the shutter speed gets shorter, usable light from the strobe's full power output decreases accordingly. Some strobes shorten flash duration as power output is decreased. Using the example here, setting the strobe to 1/4 power might hypothetically decrease flash duration to around 1/1000, which would better mesh with the camera's 1/1000 shutter speed. While this wouldn't give you more usable light than leaving the strobe at full power, it would allow for faster recycling time, use less battery power per exposure, etc.
The reality remains that using a very high GS speed will still only use a fraction of the strobe's full output. Another challenge is that strobe output is not linear. There is a moment of peak light output followed by a longer 'tail' as output trails off (though with IGBT controlled strobes, the tail is 'cut'). As shutter speeds shorten, it becomes more and more important to correctly time the moment the shutter is open with peak light output. Therefore the camera should have some option to allow the photographer to fine tune shutter and flash synchronization to better align the moment of exposure with the strobe's peak output.
This capability already exists for conventional shutter cameras in the form of 'hypersync' or 'hi-sync' (not to be confused with high speed sync - HSS). But the difference with conventional shutters at 1/1000 vs. GS at 1/1000 is that the mechanical shutter opening still takes around 1/250 to travel across the frame, whereas GS samples the full image at 1/1000. This means with mechanical shutters, if flash duration is shorter than 1/250, you get uneven exposure across the frame. This is why hypersync relies on long strobe duration - so that there is consistent strobe output for the full time the shutter opening travels across the frame.
With GS it's reading the entire frame at the actual shutter speed and would be usable with shorter flash duration strobes, but it will be necessary to be able to correctly synchronize the timing of the shutter and the strobe to fully take advantage of this.
Pixelpuffin wrote:
Spray & Pray
Was never so apt
This has been a derogatory remark for ages. 6fps with film eventually peaking around 10fps. Then 14-16fps with the fastest DSLRs. Now with recent mirrorless it has been in the 20-40fps range. So inevitably fps rates will increase and yes, we're effectively shooting short video bursts.
Lately I've been shooting some sports with the R6II at ~40fps and it's interesting to see that with fast action, there is still considerable variation between frames. So as someone commented earlier, at these 20-40fps rates, there's still no guarantee of actually getting 'ball on bat' but 120fps improves this by 3-6 times.
With my 'old' 1DX cameras, the shutter release had a very definite, hairpin-like release point. With it I was frequently able to successfully time single shots of peak action moments. With the R6II and other mirrorless cameras I have used, it hasn't been as easy. The slight delay of the EVF combined with a different shutter release button 'feel' has made this much more difficult for me to fine-tune. As a result, if the situation allows, I will fall back to 40fps bursts instead and when possible start the bursts earlier.
The tradeoff is that yes, there are many more images to go through. But when browsing thumbnails, it is still pretty quick and easy to home in on the peak moment.
As with any new feature, higher frame rates will provide benefits and have downsides, which the photographer will have to manage accordingly.