fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)

  
 
jaygould
Offline

p.1 #1RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
I received a brand new Sigma 40mm f1.4 DG HSM Art lens a couple of days ago. I was curious of its supposed optical excellence and unmatched sharpness. Not only that, but the rendering was supposed to be something extraordinary. Anyhow, I have tested it head to head against the new nifty fifty, and have been surprised at the results.

Personally, I cannot tell them apart when it comes to sharpness. And when it comes to rendering, I actually think the Canon's cheap prime is a notch above. It just renders slightly more beautiful images in my opinion, with a bit more "3D pop" (perhaps it has to do with higher contrast).

Now the question is, did I receive a faulty lens? Or does MTF charts and crispness while shooting brick walls not matter?

Some images:







Sigma 40mm f1.4 DG HSM - f4 - ISO 100 - 1/3200s







Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM - f5 - ISO 100 - 1/2000s







Sigma 40mm f1.4 DG HSM - f8 - ISO 100 - 4s







Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM - f8 - ISO 100 - 4s

Feb 26, 2023 at 12:11 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.1 #2RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Well there’s one big problem with these comparisons and that’s the fact you shot two different focal length lenses from the same distance. As such, you’re getting more magnification with the 50mm and thus more detail.

You need to move back from the subject by 20% to frame the subject similarly and get a more apples to apples comparison.
Feb 26, 2023 at 01:01 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #3RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Like your setup, on the 1st images especially. Looks pretty cool, bit of a look to it. Especially for a lens comparison

I haven't used these two, but I'm still using the 50/1.8 II. I was actually very happy the last time I took it out. For that matter, my mid to late 60's 50/2 I got off ebay for ~$20 is excellent, by 5.6-8, although I haven't tested ff corners. You might look at Philip reeve test of the old minolta vs 55 Sony.

Back on film, 1.8 lenses generally sharper than 1.4, by 5.6-8 or so. I'd guess the Sigma tops out by 2.8-4.
Feb 26, 2023 at 01:14 PM
Gochugogi
Offline
Details
p.1 #4RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
I can't comment on the Sigma, but I bought the RF 50 1.8 STM last year and it's a darn good lens, especially for the price. I compared it to my EF 50 1.8 STM and, while in the same ball park, the RF version was a little better: slightly sharper in the periphery and less coma in night images. Since the the RF 50 1.8 STM is pretty dad burn good, the Sigma can only obvious whip it in terms of bokeh. Any improvements in sharpness would be tiny.
Feb 26, 2023 at 02:16 PM
Cinstance
Offline
Details
p.1 #5RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
At f4 and beyond, I doubt that you will be able to see any difference in sharpness between the two lenses.

If you really want to see the difference, frame the shots the same like what Jman13 suggested, and shoot both wide open.
Feb 26, 2023 at 02:27 PM
jedibrain
Offline
Details
p.1 #6RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
agree with Cinstance....shoot them wide open and alter the distance to get the same framing.

-Brian
Feb 26, 2023 at 08:37 PM
comotionfilms
Offline
Details
p.1 #7RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
For sharpness test, I’d shoot them both at 1.8. For rendering, I’d shoot them at the f stop you are most likely to use them at (or just wide open). Try to frame it where you’ll have a background that creates some bokeh balls as well, since that’s often a good place to see some differences. At f4, you aren’t seeing what makes these lenses so different. As mentioned by others, try to get the framing more closely aligned. I’m actually interested in seeing the result, so good luck.
Feb 26, 2023 at 10:01 PM
jaygould
Offline
Details
p.1 #8RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Thanks for the suggestions, everyone. I will do some new shots tomorrow and post the results.
Feb 26, 2023 at 11:45 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #9RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Wouldn't expect to see much difference like this, generally you want to post 100% crop, and look at 100% on your monitor to see the difference.
Feb 27, 2023 at 12:14 AM
msadat
Offline
Details
p.1 #10RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
what camera r u using
Feb 27, 2023 at 10:22 AM
milesformoment
Offline
Details
p.1 #11RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
As with the previous comments, you won't see much difference in IQ without zooming in. When you zoom in there will be a significant difference with more the further from the center you look. Beyond sharpness is how much better the sigma is for contrast and control of aberrations.
Feb 27, 2023 at 10:25 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.1 #12RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Cinstance wrote:
At f4 and beyond, I doubt that you will be able to see any difference in sharpness between the two lenses.

If you really want to see the difference, frame the shots the same like what Jman13 suggested, and shoot both wide open.


I also agree. I would add, shoot both wide open, at f/2 and f/2.8. Once you get to f/4 and smaller the differences will become minor.

Also, I guess you didn't get the 'bokeh testing memo' but you need to use backlit foliage/vegetation as the background to induce all sorts of bokeh balls from the complex organic structure. OOF twigs and branches are also good for checking 'busy' and double-edged rendering.

Feb 27, 2023 at 11:59 AM
jedibrain
Offline
Details
p.1 #13RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Christmas lights also make a good bokeh ball test. There is a youtuber famously using them in all his tests.

-Brian
Feb 27, 2023 at 12:02 PM
jaygould
Offline
Details
p.1 #14RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Some more pictures here. I am not able to get the same exact angle and FOV by moving the camera, though. I guess it's just the nature of having different focal lengths. They are relatively similar here though and the subjects are about the same size.

The reason I didn't post any shots wide open before is because I personally almost never shoot wide open. Very rarely do I shoot faster than f4. But included f1.8 and f2.8 comparison here.

When pixelpeeping 300%, I can now see a slight improvement in sharpness on the Sigma. However when you look at the overall picture, I can't tell. Perhaps I need a higher resolution sensor to really see the difference. These are shot with an R6 (20mp).





Sigma 40mm f1.4 DG HSM - f1.8







Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM - f1.8

Feb 27, 2023 at 03:08 PM
jaygould
Offline
Details
p.1 #15RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Continued.





Sigma 40mm f1.4 DG HSM - f2.8







Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM - f2.8







Sigma 40mm f1.4 DG HSM - f11







Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM - f11

Feb 27, 2023 at 03:12 PM
milesformoment
Offline
Details
p.1 #16RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Should've led with that lol! Yeah, I doubt there is much difference in decent lighting on a 20mpx camera. Definitely no need for the 40 at that point.
Feb 27, 2023 at 03:41 PM
comotionfilms
Offline
Details
p.1 #17RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
Honestly, no reason to spend the big bucks on the sigma if you are mostly shooting a f4. At f4, most any modern lens will be sharp. The blurred trees do look better with the sigma in your 1.8 shot, but at f4 or f8, it’s all sharp anyways.
Feb 27, 2023 at 07:14 PM
jaygould
Offline
Details
p.1 #18RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
comotionfilms wrote:
Honestly, no reason to spend the big bucks on the sigma if you are mostly shooting a f4. At f4, most any modern lens will be sharp. The blurred trees do look better with the sigma in your 1.8 shot, but at f4 or f8, it’s all sharp anyways.


Yeah, and I honestly don't think the Sigma is better. The difference in sharpness is negligible (although a bit more noticeable wide open), but the pictures look a little bit different. I do still think I see more "3D pop" in the Canon lens. The Sigma is more clinical. Both will have their place for different purposes.

I can't send the Sigma back at this point, but it's fine. This experiment has taught me that glass doesn't actually matter (for most of my shooting and purposes). So it will likely save me a lot of money down the line. Will get more of Canon's cheaper lenses.

Edited on Feb 27, 2023 at 11:29 PM · View previous versions
Feb 27, 2023 at 11:18 PM
jaygould
Offline
Details
p.1 #19RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
rscheffler wrote:
Cinstance wroteAt f4 and beyond, I doubt that you will be able to see any difference in sharpness between the two lenses.

If you really want to see the difference, frame the shots the same like what Jman13 suggested, and shoot both wide open.
I also agree. I would add, shoot both wide open, at f/2 and f/2.8. Once you get to f/4 and smaller the differences will become minor.

Also, I guess you didn't get the 'bokeh testing memo' but you need to use backlit foliage/vegetation as the background to induce all sorts of bokeh balls from the complex organic structure. OOF twigs and branches are also good for checking 'busy' and double-edged rendering.



I will try a bokeh comparison as well!

Edited on Feb 27, 2023 at 11:37 PM · View previous versions
Feb 27, 2023 at 11:26 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.1 #20RF 50mm f1.8 STM vs Sigma 40mm f1.4 Art HSM (Comparison pictures)
comotionfilms wrote:
The blurred trees do look better with the sigma in your 1.8 shot, but at f4 or f8, it’s all sharp anyways.


This agrees with the MTFs of each lens.

The Sigma:



The Canon:

https://cweb.canon.jp/eos/rf/lineup/rf50-f18/image/spec/spec-mtf.png

The sagittal and tangential lines in the Sigma's graph track together which results in its smoother background blur. In the Canon's MTF the lines diverge off-axis. IIRC this is an indicator of astigmatism and results in a more nervous rendering in this area of the image, which can be seen in the OOF trees above the brick wall.

If you just want good sharpness in the plane of focus, then the RF will be good across most of the frame by f/4. But if you care about wider open blur quality outside the plane of focus, the Sigma will be better. There's also the question of what the focus transition quality looks like. I'd guess off-axis the RF is more nervous because the sagittal and tangential planes probably have best sharpness in different areas, resulting in nervous astigmatic blur quality.
Feb 27, 2023 at 11:35 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister