p.4 #1What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote: rob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?
Here is a link to an interesting Sigma blog article that discusses the design of this lens, the choices made by the design team. and why it is an unusual and especially good-rendering lens.
I am not sure it has been a commercial success for Sigma. It may be widely not understood and underappreciated, perhaps because of the 2.8 max ap. Many people overvalue a large max ap in comparison to other attributes of a lens.
p.4 #2What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote: lensfan wroterob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?Here is a link to an interesting Sigma blog article that discusses the design of this lens, the choices made by the design team. and why it is an unusual and especially good-rendering lens.
I am not sure it has been a commercial success for Sigma. It may be widely not understood and underappreciated, perhaps because of the 2.8 max ap. Many people overvalue a large max ap in comparison to other attributes of a lens.
"The only reason why standard lenses had to have high apertures in the first place during the single-lens reflex age was to provide a bright image with shallow field of depth in the viewfinder."
Yeah sure. Available film ISO or intentional shallow DOF in the final image were never a factor. It was all about focusing. So here comes Sigma and fixes it, once for all, with outstanding AF performance:
p.4 #3What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote: lensfan wroterob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?Here is a link to an interesting Sigma blog article that discusses the design of this lens, the choices made by the design team. and why it is an unusual and especially good-rendering lens.
I am not sure it has been a commercial success for Sigma. It may be widely not understood and underappreciated, perhaps because of the 2.8 max ap. Many people overvalue a large max ap in comparison to other attributes of a lens.
BTW, I and others originally had some difficulties with AF-C and eye-AF autofocus with this lens. Those problems have been largely resolved, as many have experienced and reported. Here is an example of both the rendering, the handling of volumes of light, and of the eye-AF under AF-C of the Sigma i Series 45mm f2.8. Also note that it gets the eyeball and not the eyelashes, even though the eyeball is partly covered by eyelashes:
p.4 #4What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
chiron wrote: chiron wrotelensfan wroterob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?Here is a link to an interesting Sigma blog article that discusses the design of this lens, the choices made by the design team. and why it is an unusual and especially good-rendering lens.
I am not sure it has been a commercial success for Sigma. It may be widely not understood and underappreciated, perhaps because of the 2.8 max ap. Many people overvalue a large max ap in comparison to other attributes of a lens.
https://www.sigma-sein.com/en/ohsone/45mm-f2-8-dg-dn-contemporary/BTW, I and others originally had some difficulties with AF-C and eye-AF autofocus with this lens. Those problems have been largely resolved, as many have experienced and reported. Here is an example of both the rendering and of the eye-AF under AF-C of the Sigma i Series 45mm f2.8. Note that it gets the eyeball and not the eyelashes:
Hi Chiron, how and when were the issues resolved? I see the last firmware was back in March '21 and I don't recall AF being much better with an A7RIV and that firmware installed. I've sold off the lens but I'd buy back in a heartbeat if AF was improved!
p.4 #5What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
darrellc wrote: chiron wrotechiron wrotelensfan wroterob_ww wroteAnd a shout out for the Sigma 45/2.8. Don't understand why this lens is not in everyone's bag and it is a steal at the moment.I'm late for the party - what would be the selling points of this lens, optically?Here is a link to an interesting Sigma blog article that discusses the design of this lens, the choices made by the design team. and why it is an unusual and especially good-rendering lens.
I am not sure it has been a commercial success for Sigma. It may be widely not understood and underappreciated, perhaps because of the 2.8 max ap. Many people overvalue a large max ap in comparison to other attributes of a lens.
https://www.sigma-sein.com/en/ohsone/45mm-f2-8-dg-dn-contemporary/BTW, I and others originally had some difficulties with AF-C and eye-AF autofocus with this lens. Those problems have been largely resolved, as many have experienced and reported. Here is an example of both the rendering and of the eye-AF under AF-C of the Sigma i Series 45mm f2.8. Note that it gets the eyeball and not the eyelashes:Hi Chiron, how and when were the issues resolved? I see the last firmware was back in March '21 and I don't recall AF being much better with an A7RIV and that firmware installed. I've sold off the lens but I'd buy back in a heartbeat if AF was improved!
That's a very good question, Darrell. It may be that I stopped shooting it with an A7rIII and A7III and was shooting with an A1, A9, and A7C, all of which have excellent AF that surpasses those III-series cameras. I can't speak to the A7RIV, but I would think that keeping your shutter speeds up might help with that camera and any lens on it under eye-af, as I'm sure you know. But I think that some of the people who report occasional problems with the lens are using A7RIV bodies. I think Sigma lenses often are a notch behind Sony lenses with their AF, but I have found the 45/2.8 and the other Sigma i Series, most of which I now own, fully acceptable for candid shots of children and people when used with those three cameras. The i Series 45/2.8 is almost always mounted on one of my cameras. It also may be that I have learned to work with the lens better, for example by keeping my speed up. Also, I may shoot at max ap less often, as that has become less interesting to me. But it is one of my 3 or 4 favorite lenses, probably my top choice. In the last year, I haven't travelled without it. I am debating it or the Batis 40 for my next trip. If my suitcase isn't heavy, I may take both.
p.4 #6What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
The build quality of the 45 2.8 as well as other I series just feels right too. Mounted it feels solid and small. I have the 45 and 65 and enjoy using both. They are dramatically different even though they are similar focal lengths, and both equally good. Not sure if they sell, but Sigma did the E mount and the Leica/Pany mount a favor.
p.4 #8What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Ok-ok, guys. Just ordered Sigma 2/45 from Adorama (its 230$ only). Will accompany my CV 1.2/40. I may regret it as I'm not a fan of lenses soft wide open and I already got several of those.
p.4 #9What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote:
Ok-ok, guys. Just ordered Sigma 2/45 from Adorama (its 230$ only). Will accompany my CV 1.2/40. I may regret it as I'm not a fan of lenses soft wide open and I already got several of those.
I bet you'll like it a lot. And it is so inexpensive right now that I get the urge to buy a second one, which would be about as silly as one can get.
I can't quickly find a pic wide open, but her is one a stop down at 4.0:
p.4 #12What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
For travel I have chosen the Sigma I series f2 lenses, @ 24, 35 and 65mm. All 3 use 62mm filters (58 to 62mm step-up ring on 35mm) for making using filters easy. The aperture ring, excellent rendering and light weight for an all metal build with solid construction is what drew me to them, they are similar to Voigtlandrs MF lenses I have/had.
BTW I had the 24 f1.4 GM, sold it, and have the 35mm f1.4 GM and I don't feel like I am giving up much. These 3 are smaller, lighter weight and have similar output, so photos taken with this trio are more uniformly balanced in contrast and color. Currently use my Batis 135mm f2.8 as a 4th lens, but would love it if Sigma made a 105 f2 to 2.5 or 135 f2.8 I series with a 62mm filter size, I would be all over that.
p.4 #13What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
SpecFoto wrote:
BTW I had the 24 f1.4 GM, sold it, and have the 35mm f1.4 GM and I don't feel like I am giving up much. These 3 are smaller, lighter weight and have similar output, so photos taken with this trio are more uniformly balanced in contrast and color. Currently use my Batis 135mm f2.8 as a 4th lens, but would love it if Sigma made a 105 f2 to 2.5 or 135 f2.8 I series with a 62mm filter size, I would be all over that.
Why did you sell GM24?
GM35 is so good - I feel you still give up quite a bit. My main issue with 35mm is that it is always too narrow and always too wide at the same time. With GM35 at least there is large amount of croppability available given its resolving power.
Are long primes good for travel? Are not they heavy and non-versatile? I have not given it a proper technical comparison but, for example, CV 2/50 APO gives me enough resolution at infinity that I don't feel like my Batis 85 has additional value here.
Ordered myself second Loxia. This time it is 2.8/21. Will only be able to test it at NY city landscapes in the near future... Still, it is almost as heavy as GM24. It can replace GM24 while hiking for a change, but for vacation and travel - GM24 can give so much more.
p.4 #14What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote: SpecFoto wroteBTW I had the 24 f1.4 GM, sold it, and have the 35mm f1.4 GM and I don't feel like I am giving up much. These 3 are smaller, lighter weight and have similar output, so photos taken with this trio are more uniformly balanced in contrast and color. Currently use my Batis 135mm f2.8 as a 4th lens, but would love it if Sigma made a 105 f2 to 2.5 or 135 f2.8 I series with a 62mm filter size, I would be all over that.Why did you sell GM24?
GM35 is so good - I feel you still give up quite a bit. My main issue with 35mm is that it is always too narrow and always too wide at the same time. With GM35 at least there is large amount of croppability available given its resolving power.
Are long primes good for travel? Are not they heavy and non-versatile? I have not given it a proper technical comparison but, for example, CV 2/50 APO gives me enough resolution at infinity that I don't feel like my Batis 85 has additional value here.....
My kit before I got the 3 Sigmas was the 24GM, 35GM, Batis 85 and Batis 135, with the 100-400 GM. Very nice with great performance and rendering throughout. But by far the 24GM was the least used, it just did not click for me; I felt it was a bit bland for such a high price and the rendering was a bit structured, more so than the 35GM. So I sold it and got the 20 f1.8 G, for me a better lens. Still have the 20G and the other 4 lenses.
The 3 Sigmas are specifically for travel, being smaller, lighter and WR (somewhat). I also have the 21mm f3.5 Voigtlander that I can use when I want wider than the Sigma 24 and it is a lot smaller than the 20 f1.8G. Even at 61MP I am very happy with the 3 Sigmas, they have very good output.
Far as long primes for travel I love my Batis 135mm, and with my Olympus M4.3 gear the 75 f1.8 (150mmFF) and 40-150 f2.8 (80-300mmFF) zoom. Love the compression. Here is a photo taken on my trip to Thailand this summer with my Olympus EM1.3 and the 40-150 f2.8 at 46mm (92mmFF). The girl in the photo is about 100 meters away but the buildings in the background on the mid and left side are about 2 KM away... it is a very sharp lens and was my most used on this 2 month trip during the monsoon season. I took my Olympus gear specifically because of it's weather resistance during this rainy season, it is far better than Sony in this regard.
E-M1MarkIIIOLYMPUS M.40-150mm F2.8 lens46mmf/8.01/800s200 ISO0.0 EV
p.4 #15What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
I know this forum is pro-GAS, but the Sigma 45 being so cheap right now is making it difficult to resist. I have a handful of native normal lenses, the 35 1.8, the CV 40, and the 50 APO. The iffy AF performance on my R3 might be a deal breaker, but I'm wondering how the rendering differs from those lenses?
p.4 #16What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
boblombardi wrote:
I know this forum is pro-GAS, but the Sigma 45 being so cheap right now is making it difficult to resist. I have a handful of native normal lenses, the 35 1.8, the CV 40, and the 50 APO. The iffy AF performance on my R3 might be a deal breaker, but I'm wondering how the rendering differs from those lenses?
Yes the low price, $229 at Adorama, got to me. I ordered the Sigma 45 f2.8 today. Even if I don't use it as often as my 3 Sigma's f2 lenses, how can you go wrong for such a small amount?
p.4 #17What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
7Artisans F5.6 28mm.
I was in the mall in Shanghai yesterday and got to compare these two (7Artisans & TT Artisan - different companies) f5.6 lenses so I'm going to throw this lens in here (and in another thread) because for travel it's a cracking, tiny (131g) lens. Built for LM mount it's easily adaptable (esp. if you're already using a LM to E adapter). Around $300 (nice for me I can get it for £200 here).
Incredibly sharp corner to corner (there are other YT reviews showing this) with very nice contrast and very low CA it's a classic street, travel, landscape and architecture lens. Though the f5.6 may put some people off. But since we're talking travel lenses ...
This is NOT the very similar (but even better looking) TTArtisan f5.6.
p.4 #18What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
boblombardi wrote:
I know this forum is pro-GAS, but the Sigma 45 being so cheap right now is making it difficult to resist. I have a handful of native normal lenses, the 35 1.8, the CV 40, and the 50 APO. The iffy AF performance on my R3 might be a deal breaker, but I'm wondering how the rendering differs from those lenses?
I do think the 45/2.8 would add something to your concentration in near-normal lenses. It would be closest to your CV 40/1.2 in rendering, but with autofocus but without the wide aperture. Depending on what you most shoot with the lens, the AF on the III series might be completely fine--I had problems when I tried to do eye-af on moving children, a difficult task and I may have exacerbated the issue by using too slow shutter speeds in those situations, thus getting eyeball movement and head movement. The 45/2.8 would add a very different rendering than your 35/1.8 and 50 APO. The 50 is very corrected, while the 45 has some deliberate under-correction which yields a different type of image. the 35/1.8, to me, has a good sharp documentary look to it and again the 45 would yield a different result.
p.4 #19What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
lensfan wrote:
Ok-ok, guys. Just ordered Sigma 2/45 from Adorama (its 230$ only). Will accompany my CV 1.2/40. I may regret it as I'm not a fan of lenses soft wide open and I already got several of those.
I would order 6. It is the magic number that allows one to pick a perfectly centered copy, using the Fred Miranda centering test.
p.4 #20What are the best-rendering AF lenses for travel? Primes & Zooms
Frogfish wrote:
7Artisans F5.6 28mm.
I was in the mall in Shanghai yesterday and got to compare these two (7Artisans & TT Artisan - different companies) f5.6 lenses so I'm going to throw this lens in here (and in another thread) because for travel it's a cracking, tiny (131g) lens. Built for LM mount it's easily adaptable (esp. if you're already using a LM to E adapter). Around $300 (nice for me I can get it for £200 here).
Incredibly sharp corner to corner (there are other YT reviews showing this) with very nice contrast and very low CA it's a classic street, travel, landscape and architecture lens. Though the f5.6 may put some people off. But since we're talking travel lenses ...
This is NOT the very similar (but even better looking) TTArtisan f5.6.