fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue

  
 
sbanom
Offline

p.1 #1Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
Hello all. Hoping to receive some assistance with my Z7 + 100-400 Z lens...thank you in advance for reading through my lengthy post.



In this video I describe an issue I'm having with my Nikon Z 7 (Z7) + the Nikon Z 100-400 lens.

- Both videos are shot at 400MM, handheld while sitting on the couch, with AF area mode of Single-point AF, AF-C (continuous auto focus). Each picture was taken seconds apart, making sure I was as perfect as possible to be focused on what I wanted.
- The first half of this video shows me taking pictures with VR NORMAL mode, focusing on the Q in XQD
- The second half of this video shows me taking pictures in VR SPORT mode, focusing on the lower boxed USB

As you can see, the VR NORMAL mode (focusing on the Q) is NOT taking a picture of what I'm focused on - it's bouncing around. I am 100% locked on the Q in the camera body before I click the shutter. This happens in camera live view after I'm done taking the shot too - and I 100% have to recompose every time I take a shot.

In VR SPORT mode, you can see that I'm pretty well locked on each time, and I do not need to recompose in camera either - the focus point is pretty much staying put.

Per a recommendation of my cousin, I tried to redo this test with my 85MM Z lens. It was perfectly fine in VR NORMAL mode.

I also tested it with silent shooting, to see if the shutter was causing an issue. Still had the same problem.

I also just did a test of this in AF-S mode with the 100-400. The results SEEMED to be better than AF-C mode in VR NORMAL (it was still bouncing), but still not nearly as good as in SPORT mode.

Is this a lens issue? Body compatibility issue? This becomes an issue when shooting birds that are far away from me, and trying to manually lock on to the eye (or head, if even further). More than 80% of the time, I'm missing focus because the focus point is "moving" as it takes the shot. It's a bit harder trying to stay still in SPORT mode, so I'd really like to be able to use NORMAL mode. I'd LOVE for someone to be able to test this on a Z 7 + the 100-400, and even different bodies as well - with EXACT situations. Single Point AF, AF-C, Normal VR mode VS Sport mode. I'd also be up for the same test with different bodies, which may rule out a body compatibility issue.

Thank you all for your time!
Apr 10, 2022 at 10:17 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
Bump. How am I the only one seeing this issue? I've went to the store I use and tested this with a Z6ii w/the 100-400, and also another VR lens (the 24-200?) and still had the same issue. This is definitely a Nikon issue - am I the only one that shoots in single point AF?
Apr 14, 2022 at 02:55 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #3Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
If you're seeing this issue on multiple lenses, you might have a defective IBIS unit in your Z7. I've not seen behavior like this on my Z7ii and 100-400.

Is your Z7 fully updated?

I use single point AF with AF-S and AF-C all the time.
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:06 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
Hey there. Check my last post please - this was tested on a Z6ii at the store, and same issue. Also with a different VR lens and same issue. It seems to be an Nikon software issue, not a hardware issue.

If you do a test with AF-C and single point AF like I did in the Youtube video, do you have a box that's not locked on what you focused on?
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:24 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #5Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
sbanom wrote:
Hey there. Check my last post please - this was tested on a Z6ii at the store, and same issue. Also with a different VR lens and same issue. It seems to be an Nikon software issue, not a hardware issue.

If you do a test with AF-C and single point AF like I did in the Youtube video, do you have a box that's not locked on what you focused on?


I don't have time to do specific testing, but if you are concerned about the display of the AF box on the playback photo, I've learned to not care about those...usually wildly inaccurate. I know what I'm trying to focus on, and would only be concerned if the actual pics were out of focus.

I honestly can't tell if your photos are in or out of focus based on your YT video.

I also don't EVER use sport mode, so I'd have definitely noticed if my lens was having focusing issues. In general I've found that AF-S is more reliable than AF-C in single point and is my preferred combo for shooting most still things.
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:29 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
It's normal. Nikon's own literature tells you this is what to expect when using Normal vs Sport VR. Normal VR is intended more for landscapes and static subjects where you are taking occasional single shots. Sport mode prioritizes a smooth viewfinder experience and is specifically designed to be less "jerky" (Nikon uses that exact word) when shooting bursts or rapidly. Your video actually shows this difference quite nicely.

If it makes you feel any better I have seen much worse AF point 'jerking' than your video shows when I forget to put my Z9 + 200-500 combo in sport mode. The AF point movement in your video is not very severe at all IMHO.
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:34 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #7Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
CanadaMark wrote:
It's normal. Nikon's own literature tells you this is what to expect when using Normal vs Sport VR. Normal VR is intended more for landscapes and static subjects where you are taking occasional single shots. Sport mode prioritizes a smooth viewfinder experience and is specifically designed to be less "jerky" (Nikon uses that exact word) when shooting bursts or rapidly. Your video actually shows this difference quite nicely.

If it makes you feel any better I have seen much worse AF point 'jerking' than your video shows when I forget to put my Z9 + 200-500 combo in sport mode. The
...Show more →

I always understood sport to be analogous to Canon OIS Mode 2, i.e. for panning optimization. Not true?
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:38 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
@RoamingScott - I am seeing some shots out of focus, thus my concern. Pretty messed up that, if true, the AF box is wildly inaccurate. That's just poor software and programming on Nikon's part - and IMO, unacceptable for the money we spend on our equipment. I appreciate you letting me know this, however. And yes, I did see that AF-S seemed more stable, for whatever reason. Hard to shoot a moving bird in AF-S though . Thanks for your feedback with this issue - much appreciated

@CamadaMark - I wasn't recording the viewfinder. That was me scrolling through pictures that were already taken. Based on your / Nikon's description of Normal mode, I'd expect it to be fine with static subjects - like a card reader . And, glad to know that it's still happening on the Z9 - at least I'm not the only one. Thank you also for your feedback - definitely appreciated
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:40 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
RoamingScott wrote:
CanadaMark wroteIt's normal. Nikon's own literature tells you this is what to expect when using Normal vs Sport VR. Normal VR is intended more for landscapes and static subjects where you are taking occasional single shots. Sport mode prioritizes a smooth viewfinder experience and is specifically designed to be less "jerky" (Nikon uses that exact word) when shooting bursts or rapidly. Your video actually shows this difference quite nicely.

If it makes you feel any better I have seen much worse AF point 'jerking' than your video shows when I forget to put my Z9 + 200-500 combo in sport mode. The AF point movement in your video is not very severe at all IMHO.
I always understood sport to be analogous to Canon OIS Mode 2, i.e. for panning optimization. Not true?


You want to be using Sport mode for panning, so you are still correct. Lenses that have "Sport" mode will detect that you are panning, and only apply VR to the axis perpendicular to the direction of your pan. The idea is to make your viewfinder as stable as possible for panning & shooting bursts so you can track the subject better.
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:44 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
sbanom wrote:
@RoamingScott@ - I am seeing some shots out of focus, thus my concern. Pretty messed up that, if true, the AF box is wildly inaccurate. That's just poor software and programming on Nikon's part - and IMO, unacceptable for the money we spend on our equipment. I appreciate you letting me know this, however. And yes, I did see that AF-S seemed more stable, for whatever reason. Hard to shoot a moving bird in AF-S though . Thanks for your feedback with this issue - much appreciated

@CamadaMark - I wasn't recording the viewfinder. That was me scrolling through pictures that
...Show more →

You are always going to see some AF point movement when using VR. It shouldn't be causing you to miss too many shots though.

If you are out shooting bursts, make sure you are in Sport mode. If you are shooting something stationary like a landscape, use Normal mode and give the camera several seconds to stabilize completely before pressing the shutter. You will always see some motion because there is a floating lens group in the lens that is constantly trying to counter your hand movements. The only way to get your AF-S point to never move between shots while shooting is to put it on a tripod and turn VR off.
Apr 14, 2022 at 03:48 PM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
sbanom wrote:
As you can see, the VR NORMAL mode (focusing on the Q) is NOT taking a picture of what I'm focused on - it's bouncing around. I am 100% locked on the Q in the camera body before I click the shutter. This happens in camera live view after I'm done taking the shot too - and I 100% have to recompose every time I take a shot.



this is actually normal, with the "jerking" is more apparent with longer lenses. I just saw a YT video recently which shows a good comparison between the two modes but alas i couldn't find it.
Apr 14, 2022 at 06:26 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
CanadaMark wrote:
sbanom wrote@RoamingScott@@@ - I am seeing some shots out of focus, thus my concern. Pretty messed up that, if true, the AF box is wildly inaccurate. That's just poor software and programming on Nikon's part - and IMO, unacceptable for the money we spend on our equipment. I appreciate you letting me know this, however. And yes, I did see that AF-S seemed more stable, for whatever reason. Hard to shoot a moving bird in AF-S though . Thanks for your feedback with this issue - much appreciated

@CamadaMark - I wasn't recording the viewfinder. That was me scrolling through pictures that were already taken. Based on your / Nikon's description of Normal mode, I'd expect it to be fine with static subjects - like a card reader . And, glad to know that it's still happening on the Z9 - at least I'm not the only one. Thank you also for your feedback - definitely appreciated
You are always going to see some AF point movement when using VR. It shouldn't be causing you to miss too many shots though.

If you are out shooting bursts, make sure you are in Sport mode. If you are shooting something stationary like a landscape, use Normal mode and give the camera several seconds to stabilize completely before pressing the shutter. You will always see some motion because there is a floating lens group in the lens that is constantly trying to counter your hand movements. The only way to get your AF-S point to never move between shots while
...Show more →

Hey Mark. My main issue isn't the AF point moving while taking the shots - I can stop and recompose perfectly for those. I was told by Nikon (in a Nikon Canada Youtube Q/A) that it's the sensor "recentering" itself after every shot. My problem / concern is that the AF box should be perfectly locked on to what I took a picture of "when reviewing the photos" - not in live view. Eg - the YouTube video I posted was when reviewing pictures, not taking them. It really bothers me that Scott noted above that the AF box when reviewing photos is widely inaccurate - it really should not be and Nikon should fix that...I don't see why they wouldn't. It's perfectly fine when using a lens that does not have VR built in (AKA just using IBIS). But when using IBIS + a VR lens, it's like the two can't talk to each other properly...

Again, thanks for chiming in
Apr 15, 2022 at 06:50 AM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
Hey there. Yeah the jerking seems to be normal when TAKING the pictures, but I don't think I should see any jerking when REVIEWING the pictures, if I was locked on when taking the shot...
Apr 15, 2022 at 06:51 AM
James Farrell
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
sbanom wrote:
CanadaMark wrote
sbanom wrote@RoamingScott@@@@ - I am seeing some shots out of focus, thus my concern. Pretty messed up that, if true, the AF box is wildly inaccurate. That's just poor software and programming on Nikon's part - and IMO, unacceptable for the money we spend on our equipment. I appreciate you letting me know this, however. And yes, I did see that AF-S seemed more stable, for whatever reason. Hard to shoot a moving bird in AF-S though . Thanks for your feedback with this issue - much appreciated

@CamadaMark - I wasn't recording the viewfinder. That was me scrolling through pictures that were already taken. Based on your / Nikon's description of Normal mode, I'd expect it to be fine with static subjects - like a card reader . And, glad to know that it's still happening on the Z9 - at least I'm not the only one. Thank you also for your feedback - definitely appreciated
You are always going to see some AF point movement when using VR. It shouldn't be causing you to miss too many shots though.

If you are out shooting bursts, make sure you are in Sport mode. If you are shooting something stationary like a landscape, use Normal mode and give the camera several seconds to stabilize completely before pressing the shutter. You will always see some motion because there is a floating lens group in the lens that is constantly trying to counter your hand movements. The only way to get your AF-S point to never move between shots while shooting is to put it on a tripod and turn VR off.
Hey Mark. My main issue isn't the AF point moving while taking the shots - I can stop and recompose perfectly for those. I was told by Nikon (in a Nikon Canada Youtube Q/A) that it's the sensor "recentering" itself after every shot. My problem / concern is that the AF box should be perfectly locked on to what I took a picture of "when reviewing the photos" - not in live view. Eg - the YouTube video I posted was when reviewing pictures, not taking them. It really bothers me that Scott noted above that the AF box when
...Show more →

Sbanom: Keep this simple; use Sport VR and you will get better results. No need to make this more complicated.

Apr 15, 2022 at 07:58 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
James Farrell wrote:
sbanom wrote
CanadaMark wrote
sbanom wrote@RoamingScott@@@@@ - I am seeing some shots out of focus, thus my concern. Pretty messed up that, if true, the AF box is wildly inaccurate. That's just poor software and programming on Nikon's part - and IMO, unacceptable for the money we spend on our equipment. I appreciate you letting me know this, however. And yes, I did see that AF-S seemed more stable, for whatever reason. Hard to shoot a moving bird in AF-S though . Thanks for your feedback with this issue - much appreciated

@CamadaMark - I wasn't recording the viewfinder. That was me scrolling through pictures that were already taken. Based on your / Nikon's description of Normal mode, I'd expect it to be fine with static subjects - like a card reader . And, glad to know that it's still happening on the Z9 - at least I'm not the only one. Thank you also for your feedback - definitely appreciated
You are always going to see some AF point movement when using VR. It shouldn't be causing you to miss too many shots though.

If you are out shooting bursts, make sure you are in Sport mode. If you are shooting something stationary like a landscape, use Normal mode and give the camera several seconds to stabilize completely before pressing the shutter. You will always see some motion because there is a floating lens group in the lens that is constantly trying to counter your hand movements. The only way to get your AF-S point to never move between shots while shooting is to put it on a tripod and turn VR off.
Hey Mark. My main issue isn't the AF point moving while taking the shots - I can stop and recompose perfectly for those. I was told by Nikon (in a Nikon Canada Youtube Q/A) that it's the sensor "recentering" itself after every shot. My problem / concern is that the AF box should be perfectly locked on to what I took a picture of "when reviewing the photos" - not in live view. Eg - the YouTube video I posted was when reviewing pictures, not taking them. It really bothers me that Scott noted above that the AF box when reviewing photos is widely inaccurate - it really should not be and Nikon should fix that...I don't see why they wouldn't. It's perfectly fine when using a lens that does not have VR built in (AKA just using IBIS). But when using IBIS + a VR lens, it's like the two can't talk to each other properly...

Again, thanks for chiming in
Sbanom: Keep this simple; use Sport VR and you will get better results. No need to make this more complicated.



I mean no offense, but this really isn't about keeping it simple. It's about spending upwards of $5-6k on a body/lens setup, and having it not function properly. If I do as much research as I do, and spend this much money as a hobbyist/travel photographer, then I expect the manufacturer to release a product that functions properly. As much as most on this group seem to just "deal" with the issues with VR/IBIS communication, this is unacceptable to me.

I will continue to take this up with Nikon Support, from multiple angles, and see how far I can get to have this issue/bug resolved
Apr 15, 2022 at 09:56 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #16Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
I’d use the lens in the real world and see if the performance is still indicative of an issue. Again, I’m using the hell out of the 100-400 and with a 1.4x tc half the time and am not having systemic issues in Normal VR mode. No one else in the 100-400 thread is either.
Apr 15, 2022 at 10:02 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
RoamingScott wrote:
I’d use the lens in the real world and see if the performance is still indicative of an issue. Again, I’m using the hell out of the 100-400 and with a 1.4x tc half the time and am not having systemic issues in Normal VR mode. No one else in the 100-400 thread is either.


Oh for sure, Scott - I definitely will be . I'll provide some feedback as well once I get a chance to get out
Apr 15, 2022 at 10:04 PM
pe1125
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
I think I'm just reiterating what many others are saying, but this is completely normal NORMAL (sic) behavior with Nikon's implementation of VR. I'm pretty sure I learned this from Thom Hogan articles or books, but at the instant you trigger the shutter, in NORMAL mode the VR elements are recentered to (1) give the VR maximum range to continue stabilizing and (2) to have the optical elements in the optimum positions for image quality. This causes the image to jump. It happens with every Nikon I've owned and every lens with VR, but it shows up most at telephoto lengths because they're harder to hold steady. It is NOT a Z9 or 100-400 issue for sure.

What I can't tell you, and what I would love to know, is whether the camera updates the focus after the lens recenters. Since the focus point is likely to have jumped off the subject, that could be a problem. I have a ton of blurry 80-400 G photos with VR on where I have suspected that, but I've never been able to devise a definitive test to confirm what is really going on. So on that lens, I follow other's recommendations and turn VR off if I'm shooting at high enough shutter speeds.
Apr 17, 2022 at 11:28 AM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
It is normal behaviour and as they are saying, it is just the IBIS recentering the sensor.
Apr 17, 2022 at 05:16 PM
sbanom
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Nikon Z 100-400mm - VR (Vibration Reduction) + Focus Issue
pe1125 wrote:
I think I'm just reiterating what many others are saying, but this is completely normal NORMAL (sic) behavior with Nikon's implementation of VR. I'm pretty sure I learned this from Thom Hogan articles or books, but at the instant you trigger the shutter, in NORMAL mode the VR elements are recentered to (1) give the VR maximum range to continue stabilizing and (2) to have the optical elements in the optimum positions for image quality. This causes the image to jump. It happens with every Nikon I've owned and every lens with VR, but it shows up most at telephoto
...Show more →

This right here:
"Since the focus point is likely to have jumped off the subject, that could be a problem. I have a ton of blurry 80-400 G photos with VR on where I have suspected that, but I've never been able to devise a definitive test to confirm what is really going on."

This is 100% what I'd like to get to the bottom of too. IMO the focus point should not be jumping in a way that could cause anyone to lose focus. I'll keep everyone posted once I get to a resolution...or a closing...with Nikon...
Apr 17, 2022 at 07:29 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister