fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021African safari talk...recommendations?

  
 
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.9 #1African safari talk...recommendations?
Primus wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Primus wrote
artsupreme wrote
Primus wroteKicheche Camps.....

We stayed only two nights at the Kicheche Valley camp in the Naboisho conservancy. This is a huge place. We had massive rains the day we arrived and everything had turned into a river. Difficult to walk in the camp and drive anywhere. Yet, things were easier the next morning and we had one of the best leopard experiences ever with a one year old male leopard snatching the kill from the mother, then dropping it from the tree, being chased by jackals and almost getting nabbed by hyenas. There were possibly just 2-3 other cars with us.

Also saw lots of cheetahs there, no elephants. Lion pride encountering a buffalo but no hunt.

Kicheche Mara in the Mara North......

Very big conservancy, almost half of the mara triangle itself. Great elephant sighting with a one week old baby, a huge tusker in masth, lots of cheetahs, one with originally seven, just a single baby now. Lot of birds (I love birds), one mating pair of lions, very close sighting of the male and female. No leopard here though - nobody saw one in the five days we were there.

One day a large lioness walked right up to our tent and past it, in broad daylight, just as the wife was going to walk to the main tent for tea before the afternoon game drive. We were in the last tent in the row. Scary moments.

Overall the experience in the conservancies is well worth the money you pay for.

As for gear, I realize this is a Canon forum (ex-Canon user myself), but I am now a Sony user. Most of my pictures were taken with a 400 2.8 prime on an a1 body, about half again with a 70-200 2.8 MkII on another a1. The 400 lens is absolutely superb. I never needed to use any TCs, just used the APS-C option a few times. The 70-200 is also a fantastic lens, much better than Mk1.

Happy to answer any questions. Will post some pictures later, too many to process right now.
Great information Primus! Can’t wait to see some of your photos. You are one of the few I’ve seen post who’s happy with a max focal length of 400mm. Most people I have talked to said they wish they had a.600mm + extender with them. Sounds like they are getting a lot of rain? I wonder if this is the end of the drought conditions that one of the other members was discussing?
Yes, I found the 400 to be quite adequate. In the past I have taken the big 600 f4 and the 200-600 lens with me, even then i found I was mostly under 400mm in focal length. This time I used the 2X TC just once to see how the images looked at a place where the flamingos were quite far. I did not like the effect. In low light, hand holding a lens that becomes 800mm is difficult for me.

The 400 2.8 wide open is a super sharp lens, with an incredible bokeh in addition. I can hand hold it easily and of course the images do improve on a bean bag.

I did not miss the 600 at all. My friend with the 600 had to keep going back to his 100-400 as there was often too much lens. I too had to switch to the shorter (70-200) lens quite often especially shooting elephants and the big cats. Only when there was a small bird to photograph did I miss the 600 but even then, with 50Mpx to play with, it was not a problem.

A lot depends upon what you want to do with your images in the end. Unlikely that I am going to blow up a small bird into a poster print, even if I do, these days software is so good that PS can do it for you.

As for rains, it seems that for the past 3 years, rains have come 6-8 weeks earlier in East Africa, maybe it is a pattern that marks the effects of climate change, I don't know. However, it is a nuisance for the drivers and guides and often for us photographers as well, although a boon for the animals and sometimes do make for beautiful backgrounds. So it is a mixed blessing.
Hmmmm, you got me thinking now...maybe I'll bring a 400 2.8 with 2x TC instead of the 600/4. Did you find you were able to fill the frame with your 400 often to avoid cropping? Everyone else seems to be wanting the 600/4 out there, but maybe you were able to get closer to the animals.
There is a lot of variability in how close the animals come to you. I also feel that the frame-filling images sometimes leave one feeling there is something missing. A bit of the environment I think adds to the story. Also, at times there is not enough room around the subject as it is.

During my recent trip, rarely did I feel I needed more reach, having too much lens can be a handicap sometimes. Here are a few random images from my trip, did not have time to select much, took too many as it is...

The Serval is at
...Show more →

Okay, thanks for the feedback. I think you convinced me to bring the 400 2.8. Your cheetah shot is amazing and I hope to come home with something similar. Great work!
Feb 21, 2022 at 07:04 PM
evertdoorn
Offline
Details
p.9 #2African safari talk...recommendations?
still contemplating trading in my 500 EF for a 400 RF . Also because it's a bit lighter and balances nicer. On the other hand, in the Mara the 500mm served me well too.

Next trip for me is in August; jaguars in the Pantanal. Then, in jan/feb next year I'm working on organizing a photographer trip hosted by me and a collegue in the Mara. We're going to do national reserve to keep the cost acceptable, but after that week I'll probably spend another week with my wife in Kenya. Possibly Lentorre for a few days and then contemplating the rest at Porini Lion Camp in the OMC.
Feb 22, 2022 at 12:43 AM
robert_in_ca
Offline
Details
p.9 #3African safari talk...recommendations?
I would seriously recommend going with the RF 400mm and bring both the 1.4x and 2.0x TC - especially if you’re shooting with the R5, or an R3/R6 for lowlight/high ISO situations.

I am currently in transit (waiting in AMS) back to LA after an 11 day safari in Tanzania. Unlike my TZ trip in July - during the dry season in the north near the Mara River, I could easily get away with 400-500mm or less whereas during the green season (where water is more abundant) I was shooting on avg at 700-800mm out.

evertdoorn wrote:
still contemplating trading in my 500 EF for a 400 RF . Also because it's a bit lighter and balances nicer. On the other hand, in the Mara the 500mm served me well too.

Next trip for me is in August; jaguars in the Pantanal. Then, in jan/feb next year I'm working on organizing a photographer trip hosted by me and a collegue in the Mara. We're going to do national reserve to keep the cost acceptable, but after that week I'll probably spend another week with my wife in Kenya. Possibly Lentorre for a few days and then contemplating
...Show more →
Feb 22, 2022 at 01:16 AM
Primus
Offline
Details
p.9 #4African safari talk...recommendations?
robert_in_ca wrote:
I would seriously recommend going with the RF 400mm and bring both the 1.4x and 2.0x TC - especially if you’re shooting with the R5, or an R3/R6 for lowlight/high ISO situations.

I am currently in transit (waiting in AMS) back to LA after an 11 day safari in Tanzania. Unlike my TZ trip in July - during the dry season in the north near the Mara River, I could easily get away with 400-500mm or less whereas during the green season (where water is more abundant) I was shooting on avg at 700-800mm out.

evertdoorn wrotestill contemplating trading in my 500 EF for a 400 RF . Also because it's a bit lighter and balances nicer. On the other hand, in the Mara the 500mm served me well too.

Next trip for me is in August; jaguars in the Pantanal. Then, in jan/feb next year I'm working on organizing a photographer trip hosted by me and a collegue in the Mara. We're going to do national reserve to keep the cost acceptable, but after that week I'll probably spend another week with my wife in Kenya. Possibly Lentorre for a few days and then contemplating the rest at Porini Lion Camp in the OMC.


I think it is a good idea to bring the TCs with a 400 lens, you never know. In places like the Crater there is no way to get closer to the animal without a long lens and sometimes the rhinos are just too far away. Elsewhere when off-roading is permitted you may not need great reach.

I had taken my 600 f4 last time we were in Kenya and found I was not using it much because a lot of the time the reach was too much. I had to fall back on the 200-600 but in low light that lens is not useful. So upon my return I traded the 600 for the 400. If you have a high resolution sensor you can of course also just use the APS-C function and still have 20MPx of data. That is not a bad idea either.
Feb 22, 2022 at 05:39 AM
Primus
Offline
Details
p.9 #5African safari talk...recommendations?
artsupreme wrote:
Primus wrote
artsupreme wrote
Primus wrote
artsupreme wrote
Primus wroteKicheche Camps.....

We stayed only two nights at the Kicheche Valley camp in the Naboisho conservancy. This is a huge place. We had massive rains the day we arrived and everything had turned into a river. Difficult to walk in the camp and drive anywhere. Yet, things were easier the next morning and we had one of the best leopard experiences ever with a one year old male leopard snatching the kill from the mother, then dropping it from the tree, being chased by jackals and almost getting nabbed by hyenas. There were possibly just 2-3 other cars with us.

Also saw lots of cheetahs there, no elephants. Lion pride encountering a buffalo but no hunt.

Kicheche Mara in the Mara North......

Very big conservancy, almost half of the mara triangle itself. Great elephant sighting with a one week old baby, a huge tusker in masth, lots of cheetahs, one with originally seven, just a single baby now. Lot of birds (I love birds), one mating pair of lions, very close sighting of the male and female. No leopard here though - nobody saw one in the five days we were there.

One day a large lioness walked right up to our tent and past it, in broad daylight, just as the wife was going to walk to the main tent for tea before the afternoon game drive. We were in the last tent in the row. Scary moments.

Overall the experience in the conservancies is well worth the money you pay for.

As for gear, I realize this is a Canon forum (ex-Canon user myself), but I am now a Sony user. Most of my pictures were taken with a 400 2.8 prime on an a1 body, about half again with a 70-200 2.8 MkII on another a1. The 400 lens is absolutely superb. I never needed to use any TCs, just used the APS-C option a few times. The 70-200 is also a fantastic lens, much better than Mk1.

Happy to answer any questions. Will post some pictures later, too many to process right now.
Great information Primus! Can’t wait to see some of your photos. You are one of the few I’ve seen post who’s happy with a max focal length of 400mm. Most people I have talked to said they wish they had a.600mm + extender with them. Sounds like they are getting a lot of rain? I wonder if this is the end of the drought conditions that one of the other members was discussing?
Yes, I found the 400 to be quite adequate. In the past I have taken the big 600 f4 and the 200-600 lens with me, even then i found I was mostly under 400mm in focal length. This time I used the 2X TC just once to see how the images looked at a place where the flamingos were quite far. I did not like the effect. In low light, hand holding a lens that becomes 800mm is difficult for me.

The 400 2.8 wide open is a super sharp lens, with an incredible bokeh in addition. I can hand hold it easily and of course the images do improve on a bean bag.

I did not miss the 600 at all. My friend with the 600 had to keep going back to his 100-400 as there was often too much lens. I too had to switch to the shorter (70-200) lens quite often especially shooting elephants and the big cats. Only when there was a small bird to photograph did I miss the 600 but even then, with 50Mpx to play with, it was not a problem.

A lot depends upon what you want to do with your images in the end. Unlikely that I am going to blow up a small bird into a poster print, even if I do, these days software is so good that PS can do it for you.

As for rains, it seems that for the past 3 years, rains have come 6-8 weeks earlier in East Africa, maybe it is a pattern that marks the effects of climate change, I don't know. However, it is a nuisance for the drivers and guides and often for us photographers as well, although a boon for the animals and sometimes do make for beautiful backgrounds. So it is a mixed blessing.
Hmmmm, you got me thinking now...maybe I'll bring a 400 2.8 with 2x TC instead of the 600/4. Did you find you were able to fill the frame with your 400 often to avoid cropping? Everyone else seems to be wanting the 600/4 out there, but maybe you were able to get closer to the animals.
There is a lot of variability in how close the animals come to you. I also feel that the frame-filling images sometimes leave one feeling there is something missing. A bit of the environment I think adds to the story. Also, at times there is not enough room around the subject as it is.

During my recent trip, rarely did I feel I needed more reach, having too much lens can be a handicap sometimes. Here are a few random images from my trip, did not have time to select much, took too many as it is...

The Serval is at 200mm, I did some adjustments mainly exposure and slight vignetting. I also shot it at 400 mm, but it came very close to our vehicle as you can see here.

The rest of the images are all at 400mm, f2.8, wide open. No adjustments done at all, no sharpening, no color balance, straight OOC. Note the African Pygmy Kingfisher is super sharp. I could not have taken the flight shot if it was much bigger in the frame, as it is it almost flew out of it. However, I did find some other birds did not let us get as close and I did wish I had more reach then, but overall was very satisfied with just 400mm

All of these are completely uncropped, at full 50 Mpx. Lots of room left for further repositioning and printing large if needed.
Okay, thanks for the feedback. I think you convinced me to bring the 400 2.8. Your cheetah shot is amazing and I hope to come home with something similar. Great work!


Thanks Brett. I took a ton of pictures of this pair. I think the critical factor is whether you can go off road or not. We had permits to do this in the Mara reserve and of course in the conservancies you are allowed to any way.
Feb 22, 2022 at 05:40 AM
Alan Kefauver
Offline
Details
p.9 #6African safari talk...recommendations?
As I said before, I am going in June to Botswana and Madikwe in SA. Definitely taking the RF100-500 with 1.4ex, RF70-200, and RF24-70. On the fence about the RF15-35. Thoughts?
Feb 22, 2022 at 07:05 AM
jpegram
Offline
Details
p.9 #7African safari talk...recommendations?
Alan Kefauver wrote:
As I said before, I am going in June to Botswana and Madikwe in SA. Definitely taking the RF100-500 with 1.4ex, RF70-200, and RF24-70. On the fence about the RF15-35. Thoughts?


I'd think that depends on your bag. If you don't have it, you'll want it on the trip for one or two occasions then not be able to, but you have the 24-70, so....that seems like it would do for close shots and the ranges that lens allows.

Realistically, you have all the ranges covered within reason.
Feb 22, 2022 at 07:23 AM
Primus
Offline
Details
p.9 #8African safari talk...recommendations?
Alan Kefauver wrote:
As I said before, I am going in June to Botswana and Madikwe in SA. Definitely taking the RF100-500 with 1.4ex, RF70-200, and RF24-70. On the fence about the RF15-35. Thoughts?


I never thought I would do this, but on this trip I actually took a lot of shots and videos with my iPhone 12. It serves as a great ultra-wide camera and it is readily available, no need to change lenses. I always wear a photo vest in the field and it is always sitting in the top pocket. The resolution is truly remarkable. The videos are pretty darned good and I never felt the need to use my regular camera for video work.

I am gradually coming to believe that we tend to take way too much gear on these trips. Yes, one does need backup so an extra body (or two) is a must, but one does not need to cover every mm of lens from 12-600. Gaps are OK, that is what cropping and other modes are for. I think for my next trip I will be even more frugal.

Feb 22, 2022 at 10:03 AM
MattAxel
Offline
Details
p.9 #9African safari talk...recommendations?
Alan Kefauver wrote:
As I said before, I am going in June to Botswana and Madikwe in SA. Definitely taking the RF100-500 with 1.4ex, RF70-200, and RF24-70. On the fence about the RF15-35. Thoughts?


You'll be down here in the heart of Milky Way season, and the night skies in Botswana are amazing! So if you're into Astro/Milky Way landscape photography then you'll definitely want that RF15-35 with you. If not then the RF24-70 should be adequate to cover the wider angles.
Feb 23, 2022 at 12:59 AM
seaninsa
Offline
Details
p.9 #10African safari talk...recommendations?


Thanks Brett. I took a ton of pictures of this pair. I think the critical factor is whether you can go off road or not. We had permits to do this in the Mara reserve and of course in the conservancies you are allowed to any way.

Did you pay $300 a week for this permit? Some years you can get it and others for some reason you can't. This year for my trip to the Mara I will be trying to get it. A lot of the times I have never seem to need it. Nice thing with my guide he is very well connected haha. Helps when you have 40 siblings.
Feb 23, 2022 at 06:45 PM
evertdoorn
Offline
Details
p.9 #11African safari talk...recommendations?
well, officially there is no off-roading at all in the Mara reserve I believe.

So what happens is, most of the times guides try it anyway if there's no rangers around. If they are, all the cars flock back to the road. Although just a slight sign of a rough path can also be a road. If there is any payment I believe it's off the books, directly into the pocket of some dude.

The whole place needs a long term plan and much stricter management for sure. Still love the place but I am worried about the future there. Too many camps, too much pressure on wildlife at times (in particular during high season)
Feb 24, 2022 at 03:21 AM
seaninsa
Offline
Details
p.9 #12African safari talk...recommendations?
evertdoorn wrote:
well, officially there is no off-roading at all in the Mara reserve I believe.

So what happens is, most of the times guides try it anyway if there's no rangers around. If they are, all the cars flock back to the road. Although just a slight sign of a rough path can also be a road. If there is any payment I believe it's off the books, directly into the pocket of some dude.

The whole place needs a long term plan and much stricter management for sure. Still love the place but I am worried about the future there.
...Show more →

Wrong. You can buy a pass for off-roading. It is $300 a week. It will say DO NOT FOLLOW FILM CREW. When you say the place needs much stricter management, have you been to the Triangle? There is a different person that manages the Mara Triangle from the National Park. In the Triangle, they are very strict. You cannot go off roading at all.

I have personally seen where the rangers have fined people. The times I have been off-roading there either there was no rangers around or my guide knows the rangers. My guide is very well connected in the Masai community. There used to be the Cheetah Project. The guide I use his brother was one of the top dogs in it and another guide at our camp one of his sisters was married to someone in the Project.

When it comes to payment there are two ways of doing it. The normal fine is about 10,000KS. What you do is tell them you need a receipt. They will then say only the supervisor has the receipt book and will then lower it down to 5000KS. Then it is off the books per say and is Tusker money for them.
Feb 24, 2022 at 07:36 PM
mczuman
Offline
Details
p.9 #13African safari talk...recommendations?
On nearly all of my thirty-ish wildlife trips to Africa I've taken something like a 24-70mm, a 70-200mm, and a 200-400mm (or something similar...now a 200-600mm Sony). I'd estimate that 70% of my shots have been with the 200-400mm reach, 25% with the 70-200mm, and only 5% with the short stuff.
I think that it's possible that if I were a better photographer I'd shoot wider, but for me the best magic is when an animal and you share the same moment in time, and close-ups, particularly with eye contact, do that for me.
I only shot a handful of images with my 24-70mm in Kenya this past October, and some of them were special cases like this aerial of eland crossing the Sand River at the edge of the Mara. But I'd be frustrated beyond belief if I didn't have the reach to get shots like the others here.






Eland Crossing the Sand River







Lion with Wildebeest







Botswana Wild Dog







SA Cape Buffalo







Black Rhino Charge

Feb 24, 2022 at 11:29 PM
Alan Kefauver
Offline
Details
p.9 #14African safari talk...recommendations?
Awesome photos. I hope I can do as well.
Feb 25, 2022 at 08:23 AM
Hathaway
Offline
Details
p.9 #15African safari talk...recommendations?
If it were me, I would skip the 70-200mm. Too much overlap with 24-70 and 100-500. If you will always have the 1.4x on the 100-500mm then it might make sense. Less weight and less fiddling with lenses in the field with risk of dust, missed shots, etc.

Bob
Feb 25, 2022 at 09:02 AM
mczuman
Offline
Details
p.9 #16African safari talk...recommendations?
Hathaway wrote:
If it were me, I would skip the 70-200mm. Too much overlap with 24-70 and 100-500. If you will always have the 1.4x on the 100-500mm then it might make sense. Less weight and less fiddling with lenses in the field with risk of dust, missed shots, etc.

Bob


I don't disagree with Bob. The 70-200mm focal length tends to be a bit short for subject-intensive shooting, and the lens certainly takes up valuable space.
The 70-200mm is a bit of an "emergency" lens for me in Africa. The key is that I have the f/2.8, while the 200-600mm is f/5.6-6.3. Safaris offer an incredible amount of crepuscular opportunity, and having the 70-200's speed combined with a higher ISO has allowed me to get shots that I would have not bothered with if I only had a slower lens.





Morning Lioness

Feb 25, 2022 at 10:04 AM
seaninsa
Offline
Details
p.9 #17African safari talk...recommendations?
I use my 70-200 quite a bit in Kenya. I would say I use it about the same as i do my long lens. I have had a lot of close up encounters especially with Marsh Pride lions. Tuskers are perfect to take with the 70-200. Again I am in the Marsh area quite a bit as the camp I use is in the Marsh area.
Feb 25, 2022 at 04:57 PM
evertdoorn
Offline
Details
p.9 #18African safari talk...recommendations?
Governors? Have to say I used the 70-200 more than I expected. Nice thing about the RF version is the small size when stored and light weight
Feb 26, 2022 at 04:59 AM
seaninsa
Offline
Details
p.9 #19African safari talk...recommendations?
evertdoorn wrote:
Governors? Have to say I used the 70-200 more than I expected. Nice thing about the RF version is the small size when stored and light weight


I stay at Sentinel Mara. They are around from what is called Sentinel Corner. It is a tented camp along the Mara River.
Feb 26, 2022 at 11:11 AM
mholdef
Offline
Details
p.9 #20African safari talk...recommendations?
Hi !

I've been on 5 safaris so far (Tanzania, South Africa, Namibia and Botswana twice), and I've been to luxury lodges and mobile camping including Wilderness, &Beyond... All are great, but I think my preference goes for mobile camp, with a great guide, cook and camp attendant and my own tent. This is essentially basic plus from a lodging standpoint, but this allows me to go more often (and keep the wife happy !). I'm going back to Botswana in April with the same guide I went with last time and can't recommend more:

http://www.tonymobilesafaris.org/

This time, I am going to the Kalahari and Okavango for 11 days.

2. Two body FF camera setup: Nikon Z9, Z7II, along with 70-200 S w/ 1.4TC, and 500/5.6 PF. I am also bring along my 24-120/4 S (98% of shots will be done with the telephotos)
3. Not sure, but these make alot of noise and probably a no for wildlife
4. 1 extra for Z9 and 2 extra for Z7 II
5. just bring a few pairs of shorts, 2 pants, a bunch of shirts for day (can wear twice), underwear and socks, and something warm, along with something to cover neck / dust, plus a hat. Good walking shoes. Sunglasses, binoculars. Headlamp, some good books (or Kindle)
6. Inoculations: DT Polio, Yellow fever, Malaria if wet season
7. Tony above
8. My 11trip with Tony is less than $4000, excluding intl trip, drinks beyond water and tips ($10/day)

If interested in going with Tony, happy to discuss offline.

Mark
Feb 26, 2022 at 12:00 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister