lukemeup wrote: RoamingScott wroteJust realized today this lens won't have OIS/VR. That's a major bummer...I've gotten some killer shots handheld with the Sony 24-105 because of the OIS.Why does it matter? You get 5 axis stabilization from IBIS in Nikon Z bodies. I think with Sony you get just 3 axis when the lens doesn't have built in stabilization?
R4 has 5 axis. I think you might be conflating axis and how many effective stops of stabilization you gain with IBIS vs IBIS + OIS.
One of the examples posted earlier in the thread was at 1/10th second. I'm comfortable handholding Sony at 1/2 second, which is 5 times slower. I'll take all the help I can get...not sure why it would be weird to wonder why Nikon doesn't put OIS in this lens when the Canikon variants both have OIS.
Yeah I told you not to shoot wide area for a reason and that's it right there. Camera doesn't think for itself well. The wider box is basically what I'm in a lot of the time or just Dynamic, really depends on what's going on. I have the AF settings menu mapped to the record button for the exact reason of switching it in and out as fast as possible. I basically memorized the number of clicks needed to go back and forth. Wide's...basically pants. I have landed in that mode accidentally a few times, but it's not what I use when I'm shooting events for a reason. RoamingScott wrote:
A few thoughts after my first day with the camera...
(caveat: i only have 50/85 primes, which are lenses not typical for me, so my normal shooting/use cases have to wait a bit)
Things I immediately like:
- The front Fn1 and Fn2 buttons. Most of the functions that I put on a custom button on Sony required using my shutter finger. Nikon's method allows me to do some neat things, like put Spot Metering on Fn1 and AE Hold on AF-ON, allowing me to use 3 different fingers to quickly spot meter, grab the exposure I'm happy with, and quickly compose after, all without shuffling my hand around. Very, very cool!
- Top screen. I had missed this from my Fuji X-H1 days, much prefer this part of the camera to be used for a screen vs exposure dial.
- Menus. Very easy to understand and find what I'm looking for. Also very straightforward to reprogram the buttons.
- EVF (actual viewing). Although worse quality than the Sony, I can see more of it without feeling like I'm cramming my eyeball into it. I shot the R3 long enough to be comfortable with this resolution/refresh rate.
- NEF files. Colors are much easier to play with in post than Sony, in that they need far less massaging. The starting point is much closer to the endpoint.
- Some really cool quality of life features, like switching eyes easily when using EyeAF, or how the camera can remember AF points by orientation (that is DOPE).
- Shutter is very nicely dampened and is nice and quiet (I only shoot mechanical shutter)
- Firmware updates via SD card, much cleaner/easier implementation than Sony's tethered method.
- I like that you can punch into the frame with the + button in AF-C mode (even though it disables AF-C after first focus acquisition. Sony doesn't support this at all, so something is better than nothing.
Things I immediately dislike:
- Dpad instead of scrolling wheel. Sony has the much better implementation here, and it makes things like zooming into a photo or zipping through the photo library much faster.
- Buttons all feel squishy. This reminds me a lot of my Fujis...not a single button has satisfyingly firm feedback.
- Everything that tightens or loosens turns the "wrong" way. Why on earth do the backcaps of Nikon lenses turn the wrong way?! WHY?!
- Battery life is disappointing (but that was expected). Sony will spoil you here.
- AF-C in auto-area (wide) mode. I'll have to continue to play with this, but EyeAF stinks so far, and once you focus on something in area, the camera REALLY doesn't like letting go of it. You'd think the cam would weight the center of the frame more heavily in area, but quite often it's grabbing on to something in the edge of the frame (foreground/background) and refuses to let go of it as I try to recompose and force it to shift focus. Again...Sony leads the industry, and even the R4 will spoil you. It's like the camera can read your mind 90% of the time.
- No dedicated AE-L button. This feels like a big oversight, and I don't like that I had to repurpose a button to pull this off.
If you have any feedback or if you see me doing something obviously wrong, much appreciated. My main feeling is that the Nikon in general feels like it was made by people that understand photography and the needs of a photographer better than Sony....Show more →
It doesn't because there is little benefit for shorter focal lengths. You get up to 5 stops with Nikon's body stabilization.
Personally I prefer a tripod for longer exposures but here's an example at 0.3 sec - https://flic.kr/p/2mztUQu - you can probably get 0.5 sec depending on technique.
RoamingScott wrote:
I’ve seen a few YouTubers suggest this but…why? The plus button does this in both shooting and playback modes. I’m probably missing something.
I just find it easier to reach a function button when my eye is to the viewfinder while photographing symphony orchestra events. It’s less of an issue for landscape photography.
Fair play, just making sure I wasn’t misunderstanding!
Shotokan wrote: RoamingScott wroteI’ve seen a few YouTubers suggest this but…why? The plus button does this in both shooting and playback modes. I’m probably missing something.I just find it easier to reach a function button when my eye is to the viewfinder while photographing symphony orchestra events. It’s less of an issue for landscape photography.
saaketham wrote:
Looks are so subjective though. I do agree that some of the Nikon z lenses are bigger than they should be.
Not sure why the 70-200 z is longer than the non Z version, when Sony's is shorter and lighter than v1.
I don't have much gear - trying my best not to be a lens hoarder, but here're some z lenses and the 35 GM.
Missing my 200-600 which has the lens coat on.
I like both Nikon and Sony lenses .. but the Nikon z's seem to get dust on the body faster for some reason.
I think its because Nikon has done well to eliminate focus breathing on their Z lenses. This is typically why they're a bit longer than the competition.
So are the F mount lenses more susceptible to focus breathing? I don't shoot video (except on my cell), so I don't notice this, but I understand how it affects videographers.
Considering that these were never made to be used for video in the first place yes. saaketham wrote:
So are the F mount lenses more susceptible to focus breathing? I don't shoot video (except on my cell), so I don't notice this, but I understand how it affects videographers.
This is definitely where Z mount beats E mount. Sony had to basically implement a digital crop that only works on specific lenses to work around their focus breathing, meanwhile Nikon reduced it in hardware and catches flack for it (because you just can't please some people). ArizonaImage wrote: saaketham wroteLooks are so subjective though. I do agree that some of the Nikon z lenses are bigger than they should be.
Not sure why the 70-200 z is longer than the non Z version, when Sony's is shorter and lighter than v1.
I don't have much gear - trying my best not to be a lens hoarder, but here're some z lenses and the 35 GM.
Missing my 200-600 which has the lens coat on.
I like both Nikon and Sony lenses .. but the Nikon z's seem to get dust on the body faster for some reason.I think its because Nikon has done well to eliminate focus breathing on their lenses. This is typically why they're a bit longer than the competition.
- Ability to use the manual focus ring while in any AF mode, with automatic focus peaking when doing so. This is a super handy feature and I'm shocked more cameras don't do this. Even more impressed that you can combine this functionality with the zoom feature, to achieve very fast critical focus with a combination of AF and MF.
- The boot up speed. It's almost like the camera is merely in sleep mode vs being turned off. Feels like dark magic compared to Sony, which boots slower than a 10 year old macbook.
I think even the A1 has sluggish boot up speeds. I do not know why it takes forever for the AF point to reappear after you go from screen to EVF, but this is what Sony wanted and seem content with. The RIII having a screen that appears at the bottom getting rid of the AF point was actually the main reason why I got rid of the RIII. I'm actually surprised Sony never bothered to bring over the UI from the A7III via firmware after the A7III came out, but Sony's gonna Sony. RoamingScott wrote:
A few more things I've found that I really like:
- Ability to use the manual focus ring while in any AF mode, with automatic focus peaking when doing so. This is a super handy feature and I'm shocked more cameras don't do this. Even more impressed that you can combine this functionality with the zoom feature, to achieve very fast critical focus with a combination of AF and MF.
- The boot up speed. It's almost like the camera is merely in sleep mode vs being turned off. Feels like dark magic compared to Sony, which boots slower than a 10 year old macbook....Show more →
Theodoric wrote:
Can you compare AF performance in AF-C and single point?
Caveat: the only similar lenses I have right now are the 85/1.8 on Z and 90/2.8 macro on FE.
I did this AF-C test at 2.8 on both, with both set to highlight meter.
Nikon failed to acquire the background in both dynamic and single point, and had this odd glitchy behavior in dynamic:
Sony paused a bit after losing the initial focus point but quickly found the background every time.
In a broader sense, I use wide mode (area equivalent on Nikon) all the time, with great results on Sony. The camera is sticky and can easily pick out obvious subjects. Nikon's area mode is one step above non-functional compared to Sony. I can see no use case so far where I'd pick area vs a single point.
If you can manage to keep the very small single point box, or slightly bigger dynamic box on the subject on Nikon, it seems to hold its own. I'd like to see more options on Nikon, like Sony's "center" or "zone", or at least be able to change the size of the single point box, like Sony's 3 flexible spot size options.
Single point seems roughly about the same (the lens will play a large role here) on these 2 lenses, with less focus breathing/settling on Nikon. The Nikon seems more sure of itself in AF-S than Sony, which is no surprise...Sony's AF-S mode is a no-go zone for many shooters because of its unreliability.
It really does feel like you're trading one mode for the other between these two bodies.
JadedWriter wrote:
I think even the A1 has sluggish boot up speeds. I do not know why it takes forever for the AF point to reappear after you go from screen to EVF, but this is what Sony wanted and seem content with. The RIII having a screen that appears at the bottom getting rid of the AF point was actually the main reason why I got rid of the RIII. I'm actually surprised Sony never bothered to bring over the UI from the A7III via firmware after the A7III came out, but Sony's gonna Sony. RoamingScott wroteA few more things I've found that I really like:
- Ability to use the manual focus ring while in any AF mode, with automatic focus peaking when doing so. This is a super handy feature and I'm shocked more cameras don't do this. Even more impressed that you can combine this functionality with the zoom feature, to achieve very fast critical focus with a combination of AF and MF.
- The boot up speed. It's almost like the camera is merely in sleep mode vs being turned off. Feels like dark magic compared to Sony, which boots slower than a 10 year old macbook.
No,my a1 boots from full off in under 1 second. Faster than I can get it from my side to my eye.
Ok, so Sony basically finally fixed that problem and you have to spend basically 7 grand (I'm including tax) to get a Sony badged camera that boots up as fast as most Nikon cameras. I hope this is also fixed in the A7IV because it really took Sony too long to address this. 1bwana1 wrote: JadedWriter wroteI think even the A1 has sluggish boot up speeds. I do not know why it takes forever for the AF point to reappear after you go from screen to EVF, but this is what Sony wanted and seem content with. The RIII having a screen that appears at the bottom getting rid of the AF point was actually the main reason why I got rid of the RIII. I'm actually surprised Sony never bothered to bring over the UI from the A7III via firmware after the A7III came out, but Sony's gonna Sony. RoamingScott wroteA few more things I've found that I really like:
- Ability to use the manual focus ring while in any AF mode, with automatic focus peaking when doing so. This is a super handy feature and I'm shocked more cameras don't do this. Even more impressed that you can combine this functionality with the zoom feature, to achieve very fast critical focus with a combination of AF and MF.
- The boot up speed. It's almost like the camera is merely in sleep mode vs being turned off. Feels like dark magic compared to Sony, which boots slower than a 10 year old macbook.No,my a1 boots from full off in under 1 second. Faster than I can get it from my side to my eye.
RoamingScott wrote:
Nikon failed to acquire the background in both dynamic and single point, and had this odd glitchy behavior in dynamic:
Thank you.
I'm not an expert on AF area modes, but could the can still have been under one of the focus points, thereby preventing the camera from switching to the background?
Also, isn't there some kind of setting that determines the time a subject can leave the dynamic area before the camera will try to find focus on something else? Something like smooth and eratic, or so. Could that have an effect?
Could you try with just plain old single point?
One more thing, did you release and re-press the shutter or AF-On after moving the camera to the background, or were you AF-ing continuously?
Theodoric wrote: RoamingScott wroteNikon failed to acquire the background in both dynamic and single point, and had this odd glitchy behavior in dynamic:
Thank you.
I'm not an expert on AF area modes, but could the can still have been under one of the focus points, thereby preventing the camera from switching to the background?
Also, isn't there some kind of setting that determines the time a subject can leave the dynamic area before the camera will try to find focus on something else? Something like smooth and eratic, or so. Could that have an effect?
Could you try with just plain old single point?
One more thing, did you release and re-press the shutter or AF-On after moving the camera to the background, or were you AF-ing continuously?
I tried it with a regular single point as well and got the same behavior, minus the flickering AF box. I was AFing the whole time in both clips. If Nikon understood that a green focus acquisition box in AF-C is important, you'd be able to tell
Sony looks a bit sharper given the megapixel difference, but I think it held its own at a pretty long distance for a small target at 2.8. I think Sony AF-C ironically looks the weakest of the bunch. Sony is also exhibiting some nasty aberration near the can tab/rim.
Did you go into the menu and set the camera to focus priority in AF-C and AF-S yet. Granted it's never going to be perfect, but it'll still give you some sort of idea if it's got something in focus. They fixed it in the Z9 so hopefully it's something FW can carry over. RoamingScott wrote: Theodoric wroteRoamingScott wroteNikon failed to acquire the background in both dynamic and single point, and had this odd glitchy behavior in dynamic:
Thank you.
I'm not an expert on AF area modes, but could the can still have been under one of the focus points, thereby preventing the camera from switching to the background?
Also, isn't there some kind of setting that determines the time a subject can leave the dynamic area before the camera will try to find focus on something else? Something like smooth and eratic, or so. Could that have an effect?
Could you try with just plain old single point?
One more thing, did you release and re-press the shutter or AF-On after moving the camera to the background, or were you AF-ing continuously?
Thanks again!I tried it with a regular single point as well and got the same behavior, minus the flickering AF box. I was AFing the whole time in both clips. If Nikon understood that a green focus acquisition box in AF-C is important, you'd be able to tell