p.6 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Right. A confirmation from the chief lens designer should be the final word.
I don't understand why Cosina didn't state it has FLE if it actually has. I expect the Japanese text at Cosina's site to be the original, and the English and German to be translations. Even the video at the German page doesn't mention FLE.
We hope for the best. Time will tell.
Fred Miranda wrote:
It was mentioned in the Voigtlander's site (German version). Also the main Voigtlander USA Distributor confirmed that it has FLE.
We should have Mr. Kobayashi confirm it as well.
p.6 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
Right. A confirmation from the chief lens designer should be the final word.
I don't understand why Cosina didn't state it has FLE if it actually has. I expect the Japanese text at Cosina's site to be the original, and the English and German to be translations. Even the video at the German page doesn't mention FLE.
We hope for the best. Time will tell.
Fred Miranda wroteIt was mentioned in the Voigtlander's site (German version). Also the main Voigtlander USA Distributor confirmed that it has FLE.
We should have Mr. Kobayashi confirm it as well.
Honestly based on how short the lens is (for a 50/1) at 55mm, my initial thought was that it does not have a floating element or group. Furthermore, the optical design is very similar to the other recent 40/50 f/1.2 Nokton lenses which do not have such feature. Although Stephen @ Cameraquest confirmed it to me, we should be able to evaluate this by testing the performance at MFD.
p.6 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
So far, we have the German description and the US distributors word that the lens has a FLE.
The English and the Japanese description as well as the video at the German site, plus the drawing of the lens construction (at all sites) that indicates it hasn't.
Either way, this is not good marketing communication. Hopefully we get this settled before Christmas. ;-)
It is exactly the same story with the 29mm f/0.8 lens. FLE with no indication of which group/elements moves to be the floating elements.
FLE in a Leica mount lens is not that easy. I am very skeptical if the Cosina 50/1 would have it.
LarsHP wrote:
So far, we have the German description and the US distributors word that the lens has a FLE.
The English and the Japanese description as well as the video at the German site, plus the drawing of the lens construction (at all sites) that indicates it hasn't.
Either way, this is not good marketing communication. Hopefully we get this settled before Christmas. ;-)
p.6 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I also doubt it has it based on size. I’d like to be wrong.
However, I personally don’t mind SA at close distance. It looks interesting to my eyes. At that distance, for sharp lens at this speed, DOF is paper thin, nothing really in focus actually. SA will wide DOF to more interesting look that show some focus transition actually.
40mm f1.2 show strong glow at 0.5M, at 1M it improves a lot already. I can tolerate it without FLE personally at 0.9M.
After this one, I paid attention to their m43 29mm f0.8. It is at 750g, much bigger but rendering is gorgeous. If this one looks like that 29mm, I will get it.
p.6 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
realVivek wrote:
FLE in a Leica mount lens is not that easy. I am very skeptical if the Cosina 50/1 would have it.
How do you define FLE? Is it necessary for a secondary element or group to move separately when the focusing element/group moves? IIRC, this is how the 50 Lux ASPH's FLE works.
Alternatively, FLE could be defined as a fixed element/group separate from the focusing element/group. For example the Canon EF85/1.2L's rear element remains fixed during focusing. Not sure if this method would be any easier to implement in M mount due to the need to accommodate the RF cam's movement.
p.6 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote: realVivek wroteFLE in a Leica mount lens is not that easy. I am very skeptical if the Cosina 50/1 would have it.How do you define FLE? .
I would send that question to Cosina.
There is no indication where this FLE is in Zeiss ZM Distagon 35/1.4 either. One would think that third party lens makers for the Leica M mount would try and emulate the original makers Leica on the lens details. Sadly, that is not the case at all.
p.6 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Japanese site Digital Camera Watch also mentioned the floating element on their article about the lens. They should be getting their info from Cosina. It's still strange that Cosina hasn't mentioned it on their website though.
In addition, by adopting a floating mechanism that moves a specific group of lenses to the optimum position according to the shooting distance, stable image quality can be obtained from the shortest shooting distance to distant motifs.
Fred asked Stephen Gandy at Cameraquest (the US distributor of Voigtlander lenses) and he said it has an FLE. That settles it for me. Stephen in my experience is both a straight shooter and has direct contact with the designers at Cosina.,
p.6 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I checked with the Australian distributor and he confirmed that the 50/1.0 has floating elements. (One can only assume that Cosina provided this information to their distributors.)
p.6 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Thanks @Juha Kannisto for finding further confirmation from Cosina themselves (their Facebook account). This helps convincing me that the 50mm f/1 Nokton does have a FLE.
Regarding Steve at Camera Quest and other sources, they may be honest and serious, but they only say and write what they have been informed. They are not insiders like a Cosina representative, who actually knows.
It is beyond me why Cosina haven't mentioned this in their description in either Japanese or English, given the asset a FLE is.
p.6 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Juha Kannisto wrote:
In addition, by adopting a floating mechanism that moves a specific group of lenses to the optimum position according to the shooting distance, ..
p.6 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Fred Miranda wrote:
There is no more doubt at this point. I also trust Stephen because his source is Cosina.
The Voigtlander 50/1 Nokton has a floating group. We don't know which group but who cares as long as performance at 0.9m is improved.
I was kind of hoping it wasn't FLE for easier use on non-M bodies. Like the 35/50 APOs, this lens will require a perfectly-shimmed adapter so that it hits infinity focus right at the hard stop for best performance when adapted. I use a macro adapter when adapting to the R5, and the helicoid acts as an adjustable shim. But for the GFX there is no macro M adapter, and I haven't wanted to mess with actually shimming the regular adapters.
p.6 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Still have a Sonnar 1.5. It's a very special lens but limited. I have trouble letting it go. Every time I think about it, I remember certain shots I've taken with it and stand down. Was thinking of picking up the 1.2 recently. Had a cron, but wasn't crazy over it. If I shot mostly 50 I'd invest in a lux. There's an abundance of 50mm choices for M mount, which is awesome. There's only so many focal lengths you're going to use on an M. So owning overlapping choices is normal.
If you like rangefinder or manual focus lenses, thank goodness for Voigtlander keeping the products coming. It's a shame that Zeiss can't offer anything up. It's like they don't exist anymore.
p.6 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Nick Dakota wrote:
If you like rangefinder or manual focus lenses, that goodness for Voigtlander keeping the products coming. It's a shame that Zeiss can't offer anything up. It's like they don't exist anymore.
Zeiss will come roaring back. They’re currently overwhelmed by the demand for the ZX1.