p.28 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Mr. Teller, I do appreciate your Summilux/Nokton images, very much. The Summilux ASPH is a useful point of reference, for me, as that is the lens that lured me into adding the Leica M system, in the first place. (Of course, I will not part with it, willingly, as long as I retain the gift of eyesight.)
p.28 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
Thanks for posting those. The Voigtländer is sharper, right? It appears much clearer in the focus zone.
The Noctilux f/1.0 has visible barrel distortion and more vignetting. Am I right that it has a longer real focal length?
Missed this earlier, sorry. The Noctilux does have a longer actual focal length than the Nokton, whatever they are. And the Nokton is definitely sharper and contrastier than the Noctilux, at least as seen in these SOOC standard in camera jpgs, opened in LR with no processing applied.
Any differences in field of view or just that, different field of view for the different lenses. Tripod did not move.---------------------------------------------
rscheffler wroteEdward Teller wroteSecond series.
Any differences in field of view or just that, different field of view for the different lenses. Tripod did not move.Thanks for these. I'm curious what the actual focal length is of your Leica lenses? Beside the infinity symbol is usually a tiny number. For example my 50 Lux ASPH is "16" which means the actual focal length is 51.6mm. Please let us know!
Also in the second sequence the VM seems to retain higher contrast at wider apertures despite the windows at both sides of the frame. That can be a challenging situation for the 50 Lux from my experience.
BTW, I think you're OK to post these in the "official" review thread started by Fred as it's simply more useful information all in one thread. His review threads typically evolve into image threads as more members receive their copy of a given lens and share their images.Hi Edward,
As Ron wrote, you can definitely post your tests on the official review thread as well. I actually incentive member posting their own tests and would link it to the review front page. Thanks. First time I've done this here, didn't want to crash the official party, as these are not as rigorous as yours are in a lot of ways. I'll finish it up here then post them over there so they stay more or less together.
Yes, post it over there in a sequence so I can link to them in one place.
Thanks for your samples!
p.28 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
RexGig0 wrote:
Mr. Teller, I do appreciate your Summilux/Nokton images, very much. The Summilux ASPH is a useful point of reference, for me, as that is the lens that lured me into adding the Leica M system, in the first place. (Of course, I will not part with it, willingly, as long as I retain the gift of eyesight.)
That's why I included it, as the down to earth reference. At the end of the day many people will probably say, "I think I'll just get the Summilux."
p.28 #5New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
The Lux is hard to beat for being a well balanced lens, both optically and also relatively compact, with good ergonomics.
rscheffler wrote:
Thanks for these. I'm curious what the actual focal length is of your Leica lenses? Beside the infinity symbol is usually a tiny number. For example my 50 Lux ASPH is "16" which means the actual focal length is 51.6mm. Please let us know!
Also in the second sequence the VM seems to retain higher contrast at wider apertures despite the windows at both sides of the frame. That can be a challenging situation for the 50 Lux from my experience.
BTW, I think you're OK to post these in the "official" review thread started by Fred as it's simply more useful information all in one thread. His review threads typically evolve into image threads as more members receive their copy of a given lens and share their images. ...Show more → Edward Teller wrote:
I'd forgotten about the number next to the infinity symbol, if I ever knew that. For the Summilux it's 14. For the Noctilux, I'm not sure what is going on. There is no number, but there is a symbol of two small white rectangles one on top of the other.
But the focal lengths are definitely different between the three lenses. During one of the lens changes, one time, in one of those series, the tripod was bumped a very small amount, but nothing changed for the rest of them. There are more series coming, which might be more definitive. It takes me a while to label them, slowly to make sure they are all labeled correctly.
I'll let others decide on the sharpness and contrast between the Nokton and the Noctilux, but they are not the same ...Show more →
Thanks for checking that so quickly! If the 50 Lux ASPH is "14" (51.4mm), then your Nocti must be very similar given the nearly identical framing between the two. IIRC something with the Leica rangefinder is actually optimized to around 52mm and that apparently Leica "50mm" lenses are slightly longer. It's possible the Nokton is actually 50mm and not wider, just wider than Leica 50mm.
p.28 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote
Thanks for checking that so quickly! If the 50 Lux ASPH is "14" (51.4mm), then your Nocti must be very similar given the nearly identical framing between the two.
According to Leica's official specs:
- The Noctilux f/1 is 52.4 mm.
- The Summilux f/1.4 ASPH is 51.6 mm.
p.28 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Steve Spencer wrote: LarsHP wroteOne more image from L-camera-forum.com which demonstrates reverse field curvature (in combination with optical vignetting). To me, the right side really looks bad. https://cdn.l-camera-forum.com/uploads/monthly_2022_02/MehrdadAbedi_Qimago_1427.jpg.c36a1a243c815bbfa04fae09e75d0aa0.jpgThis image has me wondering how many images could be saved by cropping to a 4 X 3 (24mm X 32mm instead of 24mm X 36mm) or even 4 X 5 (24mm X 30mm) aspect ratio. That right side is really ugly to me, but it seems like this image could likely be saved by simply cropping out the ugliness. The left side has its issues too, but I think the image would be improved a lot with a fairly simple crop.
Steve, please tell me you’re kidding. So CV should put a sticker on the box saying: “WARNING! For best results some (many?) images may need to be cropped to a 4x3 or a 4x5 aspect ratio”?
p.28 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Due to 4 different kinds of lighting in this scene, the jpg colors SOOC were a mess, so this series is done a little differently. YMMV. Lens coding off as with the others.
Instead of using the SOOC jpg files, .DNG files opened in LR, B+W LR profile applied, medium sharpening applied, LR Auto Tone applied.
Focus for all was on the edge of the moose nose on the left. Live View focus peaking with magnification for all.
p.28 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
RexGig0 wrote:
There seem to be no really good, low-distortion, faster-than-f/2 aperture, flat-field, M-mount 50mm lenses. (Actually, that is not just an M-mount problem.)
It’s not a problem for Sony users. The Sony FE 50/1.2 GM is a phenomenally good, low distortion, faster than f/2, flat field 50mm lens.
p.28 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
If these look cold, it was. Wanting to get out early before the sun started hitting the snow, so I would not have to introduce the variable of different ND filters, and still be able to get something at f/1.
It was minus 14 deg F when I started and minus 8F when I finished the next set, 20 minutes later. Didn't quite finish the next set after this, because the fresh battery was gone in 20 minutes. Hands pretty much gone by then anyway.
And, the fact that there is nothing flat around here, never mind that a field, or even a patch, of flat gravel or grass, for checking field curvature, won't be seen within 200 miles of here for at least another two and a half months, is why I don't have those. Snow and ice, and inside mostly.
These are back to SOOC jpgs.
forgot to shoot the Summilux at f/5.6
The following is a crop from the .DNG file of the Nokton at f/5.6
p.28 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Tried to replicate the "hideous hedge bokeh" shot with the NX 50/1 wide open.
Took several tries, but I can now proudly say this is the worst I can do with this lens.
The lower image shows the outward FC. The lens has no centering/skew issues.
p.28 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Wow, OK then it's 'normal' behaviour, haha. I guess you just have to find the right (wrong) combination of camera to subject to background ratios to provoke it. Same can be said for pretty much any lens.
rscheffler wrote
Thanks for checking that so quickly! If the 50 Lux ASPH is "14" (51.4mm), then your Nocti must be very similar given the nearly identical framing between the two.
CheshireCat wrote:
According to Leica's official specs:
- The Noctilux f/1 is 52.4 mm.
- The Summilux f/1.4 ASPH is 51.6 mm.
Let's remind that's at infinity.
Thanks for looking it up. Interestingly in these images the Nocti is wider than the Lux at closer distances, so one of the two is breathing more than the other, or they're both doing it, but in opposite 'directions.'
A couple observations: it's interesting how close the VM and NX are in rendering some of these. The Lux ASPH appears to vignette a lot less than the NX at f/1.4! The VM is between the two.
I briefly used the NX 50/1 for one day nine years ago. I posted this image from that session in the 50/1 review thread. It's the worst rendering I got from it:
p.28 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Thanks for waking up so early during this cold weather to do this testing.
Appreciate that!
Edward Teller wrote:
If these look cold, it was. Wanting to get out early before the sun started hitting the snow, so I would not have to introduce the variable of different ND filters, and still be able to get something at f/1.
It was minus 14 deg F when I started and minus 8F when I finished the next set, 20 minutes later. Didn't quite finish the next set after this, because the fresh battery was gone in 20 minutes. Hands pretty much gone by then anyway.
And, the fact that there is nothing flat around here, never mind that a field, or even a patch, of flat gravel or grass, for checking field curvature, won't be seen within 200 miles of here for at least another two and a half months, is why I don't have those. Snow and ice, and inside mostly.
Unfortunately, there is no Summilux at f/5.6 because this is when the battery said "I'm done, let's go inside."
This comparison really shows the FC shape just by looking at what's in focus on the mail boxes and trees. The Leica Noctilux 50/1 seems to have an even stronger outwards FC shape compared to the Voigtlander 50/1's. The Summilux's FC still bends outwards but in a much more controlled way.
We are close analyzing this stuff which I think it's relevant. However, I think most people, including photographers, would not really notice this stuff.
I will also post some rendering comparisons when I get both Leica Noctilux lenses (F0.95 and F1) in hands. Thanks for posting these samples!
p.28 #20New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Thanks for the additions Larry. For me, the trees in the upper left and top right tell the story - for this particular point-of-focus with this distance to far objects. It's where I would expect to see it. Field curvature appears to be better controlled with the Nokton.
Edit: Any one of the three would more than meet my needs...