p.25 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Xtol.ren wrote:
Thank you Fred. I really appreciated. Maybe when you retake the photos can you please also take one from the top view(?) showing the size/diameter of the rear-pertruding element side by side with others. I can use 50lux/Ultron 35/1.7chrome/nok50/1.2 no problem. I am sorry I maybe asked too much as an new guy here.
The limiting factor for rear element diameter will be the requirement to accommodate the rangefinder cam located between the outside of the rear element housing and the inside of the mount flange. The extended rear element also can't interfere with the corresponding rangefinder roller & arm inside an M camera. If there is a problem with the adapter, then I would lean towards it being the fault of the adapter and not the lens.
p.25 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Wow. Surprising, and not in a good way. Why would they not optimize the FC at near and mid distance rather than infinite on a 50/1?
I guess that would have required more elements, hence a bigger, heavier, and more expensive lens.
p.25 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
CheshireCat wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteWow. Surprising, and not in a good way. Why would they not optimize the FC at near and mid distance rather than infinite on a 50/1?I guess that would have required more elements, hence a bigger, heavier, and more expensive lens.
I meant leave the infinite performance with more pronounced FC, nearer distance flatter. But perhaps my thinking is too simple and you simply can’t “swap” like that and maintain the same or similar size. I realize the more correction the more complexity and size. Just an odd decision, but perhaps CV knows many people looks less at FC at certain distances and more about infinite performance (how lenses often seem tested/referred to).
p.25 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Wow. Surprising, and not in a good way. Why would they not optimize the FC at near and mid distance rather than infinite on a 50/1?
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I meant leave the infinite performance with more pronounced FC, nearer distance flatter. But perhaps my thinking is too simple and you simply can’t “swap” like that and maintain the same or similar size. I realize the more correction the more complexity and size. Just an odd decision, but perhaps CV knows many people looks less at FC at certain distances and more about infinite performance (how lenses often seem tested/referred to).
Or they just prioritize differently.
Yep, they’ve prioritized for the multitudes of photographers who want to shoot landscapes with a 50mm lens at f/1.
p.25 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
genji wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteWow. Surprising, and not in a good way. Why would they not optimize the FC at near and mid distance rather than infinite on a 50/1?Or they just prioritize differently.
Yep, they’ve prioritized for the multitudes of photographers who want to shoot landscapes with a 50mm lens at f/1.
I take that as fair criticism.
But on the other hand, why not make an infinity focused version for the f1 market? Some considerations:
Focusing an f1 very close with a rangefinder is difficult indeed, especially in the challenging conditions under which an f1 is actually useful (at night, dimly lit, etc).
There's an ample amount of fine f1.2 lenses (including the current Voigtlander) which work well enough for close to midrange work.
Now it seems there's even an f1.1 from Syoptic that accomplishes the purpose of fine bokeh for $350.
What's missing from the market? A street shooter f1 with sharp rendering at far distances.
Astro (but this lens might not be that either, but an infinity oriented f1 would be fine indeed)
Of course, we could ask "might we get an 'all-arounder' f1 in the vm 50/1 mk2"?
Personally I'm hoping that Voigtlander offers other designs that aren't hobbled by the rangefinder mechanism. I wonder what type of f1 lens they could make if they could make the lens longer and push the exit pupil further out, which may help with the optical vignetting and thus make for better bokeh in the mid range (as well as better resolution across the frame).
As it is...no free lunch.
I expect that the GFX will show more of the deficiencies of this lens.
Look forward to more of 'Fred's shots and thoughts'.
p.25 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
nehemiahphoto wrote
I meant leave the infinite performance with more pronounced FC, nearer distance flatter. But perhaps my thinking is too simple and you simply can’t “swap” like that and maintain the same or similar size.
That is my point. I guess that optimizing FC for infinity is easier than optimizing it over the full focusing range.
But IANAOE (I am not an optical engineer), so I may be wrong.
I also guess that 99% of potential buyers won't even notice this issue, and the rest will just say "it's a lens with a lot of character".
... well, apart from us in this thread, but we are virtually 0%.
p.25 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
CheshireCat wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteI meant leave the infinite performance with more pronounced FC, nearer distance flatter. But perhaps my thinking is too simple and you simply can’t “swap” like that and maintain the same or similar size.That is my point. I guess that optimizing FC for infinity is easier than optimizing it over the full focusing range.
But IANAOE (I am not an optical engineer), so I may be wrong.
I also guess that 99% of potential buyers won't even notice this issue, and the rest will just say "it's a lens with a lot of character".
... well, apart from us in this thread, but we are virtually 0%.
Ahh. I see. Yes, many won't notice. True true. I do wonder if infinite is the easier correction. IANAOE either
p.25 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Fred Miranda wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteFred Miranda wroterscheffler wroteI guess we'll have a better idea once Fred does his testing.
IMO BostonBoy's photo of Burg Hohenzollern is shockingly bad, technically. An infinity scene, apparently wide open, with nothing in focus anywhere. I wonder if he just put the lens at infinity and hoped for the best? His RV photo (nice RV!) linked above also has me wondering what his intended plane of focus was. Also the tree trunk photo is seemingly back-focused. But at least what is in focus, looks sharp. And his wife is placed perfectly in the mid-zone where the lens seems weakest, and the focus/sharpness on her is also funky. But contrast and lack of SA in the general plane of focus at that distance looks great. Definitely a modern, clean quality.
The more I see, the more I think this lens will have a steeper than usual learning curve...Definitely not homogenous OOF background rendering from center to corners with the subject focused after 1.5m. This ill-effect is usually caused by prominent field curvature and/or optical vignetting. What's interesting is that FC is low at infinity distance (Lower than the 50/1.2 Nokton's), so perhaps it changes dramatically at close and mid distance which I didn't check yet. Optical vignetting is high which definitely contributes to this as well. I will start the review today with some tests and comparisons. It is a beautiful well crafted f/1 lens for sure though.Wow. Surprising, and not in a good way. Why would they not optimize the FC at near and mid distance rather than infinite on a 50/1?I don't see noticeable FC at 3 meter distance either! Aside from optical vignetting, perhaps something else in the lens design is causing this issue.
In the sample below, the hedge wall located at 3m was intentionally focused at 2m, so it's obviously out of focus. I did this to show how the corners sharpen up quite a bit. This is the wall I tested for field curvature and I don't see any. I am starting to think this is mainly an optical vignetting issue.
Could different sensor tech help out optical vignetting? Wondering if it would render a bit better on the SL2-S.
On the above link we saw the unevenness where corners get shaper when I focus at 2m but when I focus on the wall at center (3m), I don't detect any field curvature towards the corners. If I focus closer in very tiny increments to see how it affects the off-axis area, the mid-field and corners never look better, which proves the lens it's pretty much flat field at 3m just like it is at infinity. Very surprising results.
I am starting to think that the rendering unevenness could be due to optical vignetting alone, where the corners show deeper DOF compared to center. I will test this more tomorrow to make sure.
On the above link we saw the unevenness where corners get shaper when I focus at 2m but when I focus on the wall at center (3m), I don't detect any field curvature towards the corners. If I focus closer in very tiny increments to see how it affects the off-axis area, the mid-field and corners never look better, which proves the lens it's pretty much flat field at 3m just like it is at infinity. Very surprising results.
I am starting to think that the rendering unevenness could be due to optical vignetting alone, where the corners show deeper DOF compared to center. I will test this more tomorrow to make sure....Show more →
Try the same test while stopping down in increments. If it's caused by vignetting, the center and corners will be more and more similar before getting into full focus. :-)
On the above link we saw the unevenness where corners get shaper when I focus at 2m but when I focus on the wall at center (3m), I don't detect any field curvature towards the corners. If I focus closer in very tiny increments to see how it affects the off-axis area, the mid-field and corners never look better, which proves the lens it's pretty much flat field at 3m just like it is at infinity. Very surprising results.
I am starting to think that the rendering unevenness could be due to optical vignetting alone, where the corners show deeper DOF compared to center. I will test this more tomorrow to make sure.Try the same test while stopping down in increments. If it's caused by vignetting, the center and corners will be more and more similar before getting into full focus. :-)
But wouldn't stopping down also mask the effects of FC?
p.25 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Yes and no. As you may recall with the 50 Lux ASPH, FC/mid-zone weakness becomes more noticeable a couple stops down until overtaken by DOF around f/5.6.
Your results don't really align with what I've seen in the only full-res images from this lens so far: those from BostonBoy over at DPR shot on the M10-R. His stopped down far distance images show signs of mid-zone weakness, though I'm not sure if it's FC.
As a reminder, this is one of his images which shows funkiness:
(I added the red circles to indicate the area which appears to be affected). If you go back some pages to when I originally posted this, there should be a link to his full-res SOOC Jpeg.
p.25 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Fred Miranda wrote:
If I focus closer in very tiny increments to see how it affects the off-axis area, the mid-field and corners never look better, which proves the lens it's pretty much flat field at 3m just like it is at infinity.
Not necessarily.
The corners have such a high amount of aberrations (especially coma and astigmatism), so that the sharpness doesn't improve does not equal no field curvature.
And the field curvature seems very obvious in your hydrant picture:
But I also claimed some 10 pages ago this lens will set new optical vignetting records (thanks to the too small and far proturding rear element),
so what leads to that (to my eyes) very ugly bokeh rendering will always be a combination of both things.
p.25 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
BastianK wrote: Fred Miranda wroteIf I focus closer in very tiny increments to see how it affects the off-axis area, the mid-field and corners never look better, which proves the lens it's pretty much flat field at 3m just like it is at infinity.Not necessarily.
The corners have such a high amount of aberrations (especially coma and astigmatism), so that the sharpness doesn't improve does not equal no field curvature.
But I also claimed some 10 pages ago this lens will set new optical vignetting records (thanks to the too small and far proturding rear element),
so what leads to that (to my eyes) very ugly bokeh rendering will always be a combination of both things.
This could be also DOF get deeper and deeper at corner due to smaller equivalent aperture FC shouldn't have a huge band of focus zone. (the cat eyes is even less than f2.5 I estimated early) There is Van image shown early in this thread that show decent performance without too much FC.
Either there is indeed strong FC or the lens show different behavior depend on distance. No matter what, this lens behave almost like zoom lens (14-24 nikon F) that show complicate characteristics depend on focus distance and maybe even aperture which we have not investigate yet. Looks like this won't be a Z Noct58 killer I was hoping for.
On the above link we saw the unevenness where corners get shaper when I focus at 2m but when I focus on the wall at center (3m), I don't detect any field curvature towards the corners. If I focus closer in very tiny increments to see how it affects the off-axis area, the mid-field and corners never look better, which proves the lens it's pretty much flat field at 3m just like it is at infinity. Very surprising results.
I am starting to think that the rendering unevenness could be due to optical vignetting alone, where the corners show deeper DOF compared to center. I will test this more tomorrow to make sure.Try the same test while stopping down in increments. If it's caused by vignetting, the center and corners will be more and more similar before getting into full focus. :-)But wouldn't stopping down also mask the effects of FC?
Yes, but you'd still have the borders more in focus than the middle. If the field is flat, the circles of confusion will be roughly the same size across the sensor when stopped down a bit. Say to ~f/2.8 or so.
p.25 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Fred Miranda wrote:
I am starting to think that the rendering unevenness could be due to optical vignetting alone, where the corners show deeper DOF compared to center.
If it were only optical vignetting, then the lower right corner of the yellow hydrant picture would not be so much in front of the focus field.
p.25 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
CheshireCat wrote: Fred Miranda wroteI am starting to think that the rendering unevenness could be due to optical vignetting alone, where the corners show deeper DOF compared to center.If it were only optical vignetting, then the lower right corner of the yellow hydrant picture would not be so much in front of the focus field.
Don't forget that there are a lot of other aberrations in the corners that can cause total blur no matter if they are in focus or not. The field can also be flat over almost the entire frame, except for the corners that bends in either direction. It could even bend backwards towards the borders and then significantly back again in the corners.
So, I would not use the corners to judge curvature of field for most of the frame.