p.21 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
highdesertmesa wrote:
Matt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:
I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
p.21 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Interesting first look, but I expected at least one portrait rendering comparison.
The lens is definitely sharper than the Noctilux f/1, but how does the character compare ?
I use fast 50s only for portraiture. Pure sharpness is not a critical factor.
p.21 #5New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote: highdesertmesa wroteMatt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.
If you fell under the Matt Osborne POV you'd be half-dressed
I like his simple and to the point vids. Some viewfinder blockage in the footage for those interested.
p.21 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I agree this lens is geared towards "portraiture" of subjects in the MFD-1.5m, maybe 2m range. And I do generally like the images I have seen from it at nearer distances. However that is not the only way in which the lens is being showcased in other forums, which obviously present scenarios that reveal some less desirable characteristics.
The discussion here IMO is about finding and knowing the technical capabilities of the lens across a broad range of uses, which each photographer can then weigh according to their own requirements and expectations.
p.21 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
CheshireCat wrote:
Interesting first look, but I expected at least one portrait rendering comparison.
The lens is definitely sharper than the Noctilux f/1, but how does the character compare ?
I use fast 50s only for portraiture. Pure sharpness is not a critical factor.
Yeah, he said in the video that "all 15 of my models were busy on short notice". I guess he wanted to get the video out and be one of the first. I suspect we'll see some portrait examples soon.
p.21 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote:
I agree this lens is geared towards "portraiture" of subjects in the MFD-1.5m, maybe 2m range. And I do generally like the images I have seen from it at nearer distances. However that is not the only way in which the lens is being showcased in other forums, which obviously present scenarios that reveal some less desirable characteristics.
The discussion here IMO is about finding and knowing the technical capabilities of the lens across a broad range of uses, which each photographer can then weigh according to their own requirements and expectations.
I think all the photographers on the planet concerned with mid-distance bokeh, mid-frame sharpness, and field curvature impacting bokeh at the edges of the frame – they are all here in this one Alt forum
p.21 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I don't expect him to actually test for reverse field curvature when he claims he doesn't see it and don't care. However, the reason I suggested the test to him was to get him thinking (and making my point to readers of the thread). So, I am proposing a way for him to discover it, nothing more.
rscheffler wrote:
Yes I saw your post there after I wrote my comment here. Unfortunately I agree with the general consensus that Mefty will ignore your request and carry on in bliss with the lens. But it’s his lens and if he’s happy with it, that’s all that matters (to him).
LarsHP wroteIf you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.
p.21 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
I don't expect him to actually test for reverse field curvature when he claims he doesn't see it and don't care. However, the reason I suggested the test to him was to get him thinking (and making my point to readers of the thread). So, I am proposing a way for him to discover it, nothing more.
The only thinking he will do is think you are annoying him with such an inane request in an attempt to keep him from enjoying his latest purchase.
p.21 #11New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote:
I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.
To me, the issue with field curvature in an f/1 lens isn't how this impacts sharpness at infinity, but the impact FC has on blur outside the center at medium distances, and that will be of interest to photographers who mainly does portraits etc.
p.21 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
I don't expect him to actually test for reverse field curvature when he claims he doesn't see it and don't care. However, the reason I suggested the test to him was to get him thinking (and making my point to readers of the thread). So, I am proposing a way for him to discover it, nothing more.
rscheffler wroteYes I saw your post there after I wrote my comment here. Unfortunately I agree with the general consensus that Mefty will ignore your request and carry on in bliss with the lens. But it’s his lens and if he’s happy with it, that’s all that matters (to him).
LarsHP wroteIf you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.
I appreciated the post. It's a test I'll definitely run on my lenses in the future.
p.21 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
peasant_slave wrote: Desmolicious wrotehighdesertmesa wroteMatt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.If you fell under the Matt Osborne POV you'd be half-dressed .
p.21 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote: Desmolicious wroteI like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.To me, the issue with field curvature in an f/1 lens isn't how this impacts sharpness at infinity, but the impact FC has on blur outside the center at medium distances, and that will be of interest to photographers who mainly does portraits etc.
Edge shading/vignetting with these types of lenses is best left uncorrected, as it can help obscure objects near the frame edges coming into focus that shouldn't. The Canon RF 50 f/1.2 had this issue, and I never found it problematic.
The only audience that will find this issue distracting to overall picture impact are other photographers.
p.21 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Desmolicious wrote: highdesertmesa wroteMatt Osborne's video on the CV 50 f/1 is up:I like his reviews but the way he tests lenses is very different than how people on this site test them.
Matt is concerned with how they work with portraiture, FM is concerned (it seems) mostly with landscape type photography where stuff like infinity performance, FC etc matters.
I fall under the Matt Osborne POV.
Although landscape photography is not the primary application for this lens, I do like to test resolution at infinity because it removes the alignment variable and the results usually correlate to closer distances as well. (MFD being the exception)
I am also interested in rendering and usually compare many lenses side by side.
With fast lenses and especially ultra fast ones, the focus transition zone character at close distance (say head and shoulders portraits with a 50mm) do not matter much as it will be masked by the high amount of blur, so I'm more interested in testing subjects focused a mid and long distance (like in full body portraits for example) so we can have a better idea of how the transition zone behaves in the background/foreground, the shape and intensity of FC, amount of optical vignetting, etc...
p.21 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
highdesertmesa wrote:
Edge shading/vignetting with these types of lenses is best left uncorrected, as it can help obscure objects near the frame edges coming into focus that shouldn't. The Canon RF 50 f/1.2 had this issue, and I never found it problematic.
The only audience that will find this issue distracting to overall picture impact are other photographers.
Well, as a photographer - and I expect everyone here falls in that category - we may consider a new, expensive lens, with a specific selling point, its main raison d'être, being extremely shallow depth of field. If that lens has a considerable amount of reverse field curvature, this will reduce or even nullify it's supposed extra degree of blur outside the center. That is precisely what we saw in the comparison that @lookert posted a few pages back where he tested the two fast Nokton 50mm lenses. The f/1.2 lens had more blur (and smoother blur, too) on the left side of the background. To me, it is a big deal, since the sole reason I would buy the f/1.0 lens is its capacity to throw the background out of focus.
p.21 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote: highdesertmesa wroteEdge shading/vignetting with these types of lenses is best left uncorrected, as it can help obscure objects near the frame edges coming into focus that shouldn't. The Canon RF 50 f/1.2 had this issue, and I never found it problematic.
The only audience that will find this issue distracting to overall picture impact are other photographers.Well, as a photographer - and I expect everyone here falls in that category - we may consider a new, expensive lens, with a specific selling point, its main raison d'être, being extremely shallow depth of field. If that lens has a considerable amount of reverse field curvature, this will reduce or even nullify it's supposed extra degree of blur outside the center. That is precisely what we saw in the comparison that @lookert@ posted a few pages back where he tested the two fast Nokton 50mm lenses. The f/1.2 lens had more blur (and smoother blur, too) on the left side of the background. To me, it is a big deal, since the sole reason I would buy the f/1.0 lens is its capacity to throw the background out of focus....Show more →
I think we are in alignment – it's important to some (many?) photographers but not to anyone else.
p.21 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Without knowing lens character you will not use it wisely. Just saying.
The video didn't show anything new other than sharpness and flare that we have known. At 3:05, judging the cat eye size make me estimate this is a f2.5 lens at corner at that distance. Around 4:30, comparing to 50mm F1 Leica, I prefer Leica look a lot more. Judged from samples so far, I believe I prefer TTA 0.95 as well at close distance but I wish I am wrong. So far, nothing changed my view regarding it after initial samples. I am only hoping I can see some good user cases justify it. Ergo wise, it is very lovely. I have no doubt about sharpness.
Don't tell me Alt FMers are more analytical, if we are not talk about that but just photography, you may well just use a nifty fifty and call it a day. A good photo will be good with those. Who care about background if it is really a good photo? IF f1 give you f2.5 corner DOF with strong FC and doesnt offer you something special, why this? VC f1.2 seems have a much lovely bokeh than this IMHO.