p.20 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
@LarsHP
It does not look pleasant to me either but where are you getting these samples? The processing is way over the top (contrast, sharpness applied, who known even extra clarity/texture). It's hard to get a fair assessment like this. Can we be sure this is wide open and also shot on a Leica?
I'm pretty sure there will be pronounced optical vignetting just by looking at the specular highlights' shape towards the corners. Isn't it expected though? It happens with all f/0.95-1 lenses and Voigtlander is famous for lenses with this character.
There will likely be some FC as well but it's difficult to quantify from these samples.
p.20 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Fred Miranda wrote:
@LarsHP@
It does not look pleasant to me either but where are you getting these samples? The processing is way over the top (contrast, sharpness applied, who known even extra clarity/texture). It's hard to get a fair assessment like this. Can we be sure this is wide open and also shot on a Leica?
I'm pretty sure there will be pronounced optical vignetting just by looking at the specular highlights' shape towards the corners. Isn't it expected though? It happens with all f/0.95-1 lenses and Voigtlander is famous for lenses with this character.
There will likely be some FC as well but it's difficult to quantify from these samples.....Show more →
I couldn't agree more! To anybody that's a little disheartened by a lot of the test images: For me personally, all of the applied color presets and the sharpening really take away from the really beautiful color rendering that the lens has. Really makes portraits look extra pretty.
He's getting the images from the following link btw:
The user has a Leica M10-P. The crop I shared earlier in this thread was from the same user, and is based on a DNG file he uploaded (but the link is now deleted from his post). That file said it was a M10-P.
Fred Miranda wrote:
@LarsHP@@
It does not look pleasant to me either but where are you getting these samples? The processing is way over the top (contrast, sharpness applied, who known even extra clarity/texture). It's hard to get a fair assessment like this. Can we be sure this is wide open and also shot on a Leica?
I'm pretty sure there will be pronounced optical vignetting just by looking at the specular highlights' shape towards the corners. Isn't it expected though? It happens with all f/0.95-1 lenses and Voigtlander is famous for lenses with this character.
There will likely be some FC as well but it's difficult to quantify from these samples....Show more →
The user has a Leica M10-P. The crop I shared earlier in this thread was from the same user, and is based on a DNG file he uploaded (but the link is now deleted from his post). That file said it was a M10-P.
Fred Miranda wrote@LarsHP@@@@
It does not look pleasant to me either but where are you getting these samples? The processing is way over the top (contrast, sharpness applied, who known even extra clarity/texture). It's hard to get a fair assessment like this. Can we be sure this is wide open and also shot on a Leica?
I'm pretty sure there will be pronounced optical vignetting just by looking at the specular highlights' shape towards the corners. Isn't it expected though? It happens with all f/0.95-1 lenses and Voigtlander is famous for lenses with this character.
There will likely be some FC as well but it's difficult to quantify from these samples.
Thanks!
You are the voice of reason over there! The photographer seems to love the lens no matter what.
I do wish we could see the DNG files from those samples at mid-distance.
The user has a Leica M10-P. The crop I shared earlier in this thread was from the same user, and is based on a DNG file he uploaded (but the link is now deleted from his post). That file said it was a M10-P.
Fred Miranda wrote@LarsHP@@@@@
It does not look pleasant to me either but where are you getting these samples? The processing is way over the top (contrast, sharpness applied, who known even extra clarity/texture). It's hard to get a fair assessment like this. Can we be sure this is wide open and also shot on a Leica?
I'm pretty sure there will be pronounced optical vignetting just by looking at the specular highlights' shape towards the corners. Isn't it expected though? It happens with all f/0.95-1 lenses and Voigtlander is famous for lenses with this character.
There will likely be some FC as well but it's difficult to quantify from these samples.Thanks!
You are the voice of reason over there! The photographer seems to love the lens no matter what.
I do wish we could see the DNG files from those samples at mid-distance.
Lol—I thought this too. Distinctly non-objective. Wonder if he has an in or vested interest.
Bokeh looks ok, and vignette is not a problem with modern sensors (i.e. push corners a couple stops in post).
I am mostly worried about the huge field curvature, as it will definitely affect bokeh in the corners (or lack thereof).
The user has a Leica M10-P. The crop I shared earlier in this thread was from the same user, and is based on a DNG file he uploaded (but the link is now deleted from his post). That file said it was a M10-P.
Fred Miranda wrote@LarsHP@@@@@@
It does not look pleasant to me either but where are you getting these samples? The processing is way over the top (contrast, sharpness applied, who known even extra clarity/texture). It's hard to get a fair assessment like this. Can we be sure this is wide open and also shot on a Leica?
I'm pretty sure there will be pronounced optical vignetting just by looking at the specular highlights' shape towards the corners. Isn't it expected though? It happens with all f/0.95-1 lenses and Voigtlander is famous for lenses with this character.
There will likely be some FC as well but it's difficult to quantify from these samples.Thanks!
You are the voice of reason over there! The photographer seems to love the lens no matter what.
I do wish we could see the DNG files from those samples at mid-distance.
LarsHP@ is indeed the voice of reason! My favourite exchange was about the obvious field curvature evident in the orange wall picture:
LarsHP@: However, I do think we are seeing reverse field curvature here (on the right side of the image).
Mefty (Nokton 50/1 owner): Won't agree. There is nothing in focus except the orange wall on the left.
p.20 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Someone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.
p.20 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
If you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wrote:
Someone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.
p.20 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
If you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.
Since Mefty neither understands what field curvature is nor recognizes obvious field curvature when it’s pointed out to him, I’d rate the probability of his testing for it at less than 1%.
p.20 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
You are probably right. However, I thought describing the procedure would make him think and perhaps check it out - at least for himself. Given his comments so far, it will require a scientific attitude from him to test it. Whether he has that kind of mindset and curiosity, time will tell.
genji wrote: LarsHP wroteIf you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics. Since Mefty neither understands what field curvature is nor recognizes obvious field curvature when it’s pointed out to him, I’d rate the probability of his testing for it at less than 1%.
p.20 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
You are probably right. However, I thought describing the procedure would make him think and perhaps check it out - at least for himself. Given his comments so far, it will require a scientific attitude from him to test it. Whether he has that kind of mindset and curiosity, time will tell.
genji wroteLarsHP wroteIf you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics. Since Mefty neither understands what field curvature is nor recognizes obvious field curvature when it’s pointed out to him, I’d rate the probability of his testing for it at less than 1%.
You are more generous and optimistic than I am! Unquestioning adoration to pragmatic evaluation is quite a shift in attitude.
p.20 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
rscheffler wrote:
Someone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.
If shot wide open with a widening point-of-focus (2m, 3m, 5m, 8m etc), this will show the plane-of-focus as it extends across the frame. The plane-of-focus can turn into an arc in many cases. If you know what to look for you don't need to go into PS, but YMMV.
For field curvature effects, near and far objects (a field with trees and shrubs on the periphery are especially helpful), closer to and more distant from the point of focus, will give you an idea about how the field curvature is interacting with the point of focus. If you know what to look for and have this type of scene, you can dial the effect in and out with a change in the point-of-focus.
With some recently released Voigtländer lenses, this type of curvature can be seen on M cameras, with appropriately spaced objects. The strength and appearance of the effect is heavily reliant on a combination of the aperture and distance of the point of focus. However, this doesn't speak to the "wavy" type of curvature one finds on lenses like the WATE...
p.20 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
genji wrote: LarsHP wroteIf you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics. Since Mefty neither understands what field curvature is nor recognizes obvious field curvature when it’s pointed out to him, I’d rate the probability of his testing for it at less than 1%.
My thinking 100%
p.20 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Yes I saw your post there after I wrote my comment here. Unfortunately I agree with the general consensus that Mefty will ignore your request and carry on in bliss with the lens. But it’s his lens and if he’s happy with it, that’s all that matters (to him).
LarsHP wrote:
If you read the thread over at L-camera-forum.com, that is what I suggested to the user (Mefty), except I asked him to shoot wide open with focus bracketing in order to clearly see the reverse field curvature.
rscheffler wroteSomeone with the lens needs to shoot an aperture series of a grass field or gravel parking lot at a slight downward angle and run the images through the find edges filter in PS to give us a better idea of the lens's FC characteristics.