fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022

  
 
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #1New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Further screenshots.

The two first are showing the amount of LoCA (longitudinal chromatic aberration). Again, not great, but not bad either. This is an f/1 lens, so no-one is expecting apochromatic performance...

The third shows smooth and soft bokeh quality at extra short focus distance (using VM-E Close Focus adapter) and the fourth how big the lens is on a Sony a7 series camera.

https://cdn.l-camera-forum.com/uploads/monthly_2022_01/snapshot3.jpg.e6b7f3b5cdb4a414af139a9f6b22955c.jpg


https://cdn.l-camera-forum.com/uploads/monthly_2022_01/snapshot4.jpg.a8e5e4f1c9da52904b48600d7833278a.jpg


https://cdn.l-camera-forum.com/uploads/monthly_2022_01/snapshot5.jpg.e16610d1c9f42468639e085814202faa.jpg


https://cdn.l-camera-forum.com/uploads/monthly_2022_01/snapshot6.jpg.2a476037dd4fc092412e0f6cc8ff42d4.jpg
Jan 07, 2022 at 01:16 PM
raul jarquin
Offline
Details
p.14 #2New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
It looks like I have to wait a bit to have my hands on this lens. I ordered it from Cameraquest and today I received this email saying it will not arrive in January as promised.

"Greetings,

Last night we were notified by Cosina that due to much greater world wide factory M 50/1 orders than originally expected, we will receive only a small portion of our M 50/1 order in our first shipment the end of January.

As a result your lens order was pushed back to the next factory run in early March...."
Jan 07, 2022 at 08:38 PM
bluloo
Offline
Details
p.14 #3New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Ditto.
I’d much rather wait and not have them cut corners in any way, just to meet delivery times.
Jan 07, 2022 at 11:34 PM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #4New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Thanks. This means I will stop debating whether I should preorder or not...

raul jarquin wrote:
It looks like I have to wait a bit to have my hands on this lens. I ordered it from Cameraquest and today I received this email saying it will not arrive in January as promised.

"Greetings,

Last night we were notified by Cosina that due to much greater world wide factory M 50/1 orders than originally expected, we will receive only a small portion of our M 50/1 order in our first shipment the end of January.

As a result your lens order was pushed back to the next factory run in early March...."

Jan 08, 2022 at 06:03 AM
4ALL
Offline
Details
p.14 #5New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
My last glass purchase was the VM40 1.2 which I stopped on and thanked. What I love to buy new for $ 999 is now $ 699 or the VM21 for $ 999. I can already see what has happened over two decades with the Voigtlander brand. Unfortunately, I have to look for the development of my hobby elsewhere at a higher level. I bought each of my Voigtalnder lenses a long time ago, the first one almost twenty years ago, and hit the nail on the head. Buying a Voigtalnder now reminds me of a shot in the foot. I returned the Apo series and unfortunately looked at the ZM ZEISS. And the new Heliar was the nail in the coffin. I have several dozen lenses, including a lot of Voigtlander and I am not going to sell any of them, I have been doing it for almost 20 years. I have over a dozen Voigtlander lenses and I always wait for new ones, hoping for a better tomorrow. The lens showed great photos of the heroes and those awaited. I just love them. I am currently using Rm2 and viewing photos on a large TV. I'll be using the lenses over and over again. The same shots with a different lens give me great fun. Maybe my expectations are too high and Voigtalnder has stopped at a certain stage and changed its sales policy, or maybe it is struggling to survive.
Jan 08, 2022 at 06:19 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.14 #6New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
mapgraphs wrote:
"Optical vignetting is caused by


I'll get a bunch of flack for this, but ...


There may be certain amounts mechanical vignetting in the lens construction, but that isn't the culprit as much as it is the angle of incidence, when we are talking about the radial vignetting at the film plane.

The real issue is that of vector forces.

Light is energy, energy is a force. Force is directional. The angle of incidence effects the amount of energy that is applied in a directional vector.

As the angle changes, the trigonometric value of that angle is changed. Thus, the more collimated the light path, the less vignetting becomes because the trigonometric value changes least (remain closer to 1), when the angles are closer to 90. The less collimated the light path, the greater vignetting becomes, as the trigonometric values become closer to 0. ... it is a product of trigonometry, as the light radiates spherically from the lens. It may correlate to the lens construction, but once the light leaves the lens (we see this trigonometric function also in the roots of ISL) and angles of incidence (vector forces) are in play, the resultant reduction in energy impacting / transferring onto the capture media is thus reduced. Hence, the vignetting is a reduction in applied energy.

The wider you go, the tougher it gets ... as things are not progressively linear ... rather trigonometric, vector forces.

Sometimes photographers have a different way of trying to explain physics than actual physics (although, those derived languages are rooted in the actual physics, it gets lost in pass-down over time), via an attempt with a re-formulated / simplified language. Then folks try to unravel / explain that modified language, then we wrangle with getting it back to what is actually happening.

Sin Values:

90 - 1
60 - .866
45 - .7071
30 - .5
15 - .26
10 - .17
0 - 0

So, the light emitting from the lens that is being applied to the sensor / film at 90 degrees (on axis center) has a vector force of 1X (from the remainder of the mechanical / optical aperture reduction). As that angle radiates (off axis) into the subsequent zones, that angle of incidence is further reduced from 90 degress, and as those angles (from the film plane) are reduced, the trigonometric factor reduces also to something less than 1X as it moves closer to 0X

So, as the lenses are brought closer to the film plane, and the width of the optic is increased, the angles of incidence are further reduced as the light path radiates outward. It is the reduction in trig value, caused by the angle of incidence that results in less light energy being applied.

If you think about either a "glancing blow" or "feathering light" vs. a "direct blow" or a parabolic umbrella (collimated light path) vs. a softbox (or other angular diffusion), in pragmatic terms, the same issue of energy sent vs. energy received / transferred applies to the light coming from the lens. Straight on = most energy. Sideways = less energy (vector force applied / transferred). Micro lenses try to redirect the energy, and to different degree (along with stack height, etc.) of effectiveness.

For this ^ reason ... when I learned of how Leica has designed their micro lenses in the M bodies, I took greater interest in the M. For those shooting lenses with more collimated light paths, this isn't as noticeable. But, for those shooting with lenses that have those steep angles (either wide FL or wide physical optic), the matter may be of greater significance (imo). Imo, this also is part of the reason for the amount of realized contrast / acutance that is differentiated in Leica optical engineering. i.e. Leica knows their trig, both at the lens and the film plane. Other sensors that have uniform micro-lenses are less likely to capture the extent of the light (amount and wavelength) that the M micro-lenses can ... in the perimeter where the angle is most challenged.

Now, switch from the M micro-lens approach to a flat, uniform micro-lens approach and the limits of what you can do on the lens trig is altered. For this reason, there may be some designs that can perform well on the M, but not so much for others. Of course, we have already known this on a pragmatic basis. But when asking why a certain lens is made ONLY in M mount, it could be that the designers recognize the limits being applied have a trig basis that restricts the attainable performance with linear micro-lenses.


So, again ... the wider you go, the tougher it gets (to transfer energy, to align wavelengths).

Thus, the wide body, exit pupil is going to have some challenging angles, and the vector force reduction is inevitable. The closer we put it to the film plane, the steeper those angle get. On axis, things remain to harness 1X of the light being transmitted. Moving off axis, not so much.



Edited on Jan 08, 2022 at 08:29 AM · View previous versions
Jan 08, 2022 at 07:33 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #7New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
What you describe is natural vignetting, not optical vignetting. Optical vignetting is caused by limitations in the size of lens elements. There is also mechanical vignetting and pixel vignetting. The latter is what Leica tries to minimize in their micro-lens / sensor design.

RustyBug wrote:
mapgraphs wrote"Optical vignetting is caused by
I'll get a bunch of flack for this, but ...

There may be certain amounts mechanical vignetting in the lens construction, but that isn't the culprit as much as it is the angle of incidence, when we are talking about the radial vignetting at the film plane.

The real issue is that of vector forces.

Light is energy, energy is a force. Force is directional. The angle of incidence effects the amount of energy that is applied in a directional vector.

As the angle changes, the trigonometric value of that angle is changed. Thus, the more collimated the light path, the less vignetting becomes
...Show more →
Jan 08, 2022 at 08:27 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.14 #8New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
What you describe is natural vignetting, not optical vignetting. Optical vignetting is caused by limitations in the size of lens elements. There is also mechanical vignetting and pixel vignetting. The latter is what Leica tries to minimize in their micro-lens / sensor design.

RustyBug wrote
mapgraphs wrote"Optical vignetting is caused by
I'll get a bunch of flack for this, but ...

There may be certain amounts mechanical vignetting in the lens construction, but that isn't the culprit as much as it is the angle of incidence, when we are talking about the radial vignetting at the film plane.

The real issue is that of vector forces.

Light is energy, energy is a force. Force is directional. The angle of incidence effects the amount of energy that is applied in a directional vector.

As the angle changes, the trigonometric value of that angle is changed. Thus, the more collimated the light path, the less vignetting becomes because the trigonometric value changes least (remain closer to 1), when the angles are closer to 90. The less collimated the light path, the greater vignetting becomes, as the trigonometric values become closer to 0. ... it is a product of trigonometry, as the light radiates spherically from the lens. It may correlate to the lens construction, but once the light leaves the lens (we see this trigonometric function also in the roots of ISL) and angles of incidence (vector forces) are in play, the resultant reduction in energy impacting / transferring onto the capture media is thus reduced. Hence, the vignetting is a reduction in applied energy.

The wider you go, the tougher it gets ... as things are not progressively linear ... rather trigonometric, vector forces.

Sometimes photographers have a different way of trying to explain physics than actual physics (although, those derived languages are rooted in the actual physics, it gets lost in pass-down over time), via an attempt with a re-formulated / simplified language. Then folks try to unravel / explain that modified language, then we wrangle with getting it back to what is actually happening.

Sin Values:

90 - 1
60 - .866
45 - .7071
30 - .5
15 - .26
10 - .17
0 - 0

So, the light emitting from the lens that is being applied to the sensor / film at 90 degrees (on axis center) has a vector force of 1X (from the remainder of the mechanical / optical aperture reduction). As that angle radiates (off axis) into the subsequent zones, that angle of incidence is further reduced from 90 degress, and as those angles (from the film plane) are reduced, the trigonometric factor reduces also to something less than 1X as it moves closer to 0X

So, as the lenses are brought closer to the film plane, and the width of the optic is increased, the angles of incidence are further reduced as the light path radiates outward. It is the reduction in trig value, caused by the angle of incidence that results in less light energy being applied.

If you think about either a "glancing blow" or "feathering light" vs. a "direct blow" or a parabolic umbrella (collimated light path) vs. a softbox (or other angular diffusion), in pragmatic terms, the same issue of energy sent vs. energy received / transferred applies to the light coming from the lens. Straight on = most energy. Sideways = less energy (vector force applied / transferred). Micro lenses try to redirect the energy, and to different degree (along with stack height, etc.) of effectiveness.

For this ^ reason ... when I learned of how Leica has designed their micro lenses in the M bodies, I took greater interest in the M. For those shooting lenses with more collimated light paths, this isn't as noticeable. But, for those shooting with lenses that have those steep angles (either wide FL or wide physical optic), the matter may be of greater significance (imo). Imo, this also is part of the reason for the amount of realized contrast / acutance that is differentiated in Leica optical engineering. i.e. Leica knows their trig, both at the lens and the film plane. Other sensors that have uniform micro-lenses have are less likely to capture the extent of the light (amount and wavelength) that the M micro-lenses can.

So, again ... the wider you go, the tougher it gets (to transfer energy, to align wavelengths).

Thus, the wide body, exit pupil is going to have some challenging angles, and the vector force reduction is inevitable. The closer we put it to the film plane, the steeper those angle get. On axis, things remain to harness 1X of the light being transmitted. Moving off axis, not so much.



Yes, we can attribute loss of energy to various components. But, once the light leaves the rear element of the lens, it is what it is. Great in the center, not so great in the corners ... as you say, natural occurrence, based on the trig.

My .02 is that while there is the lens construction elements that reduce transmission, and pixel level lenses that redirect / capture the energy to varying degree, the predominant occurrence of the vignetting is the natural vignetting, relative to the trig of a given lens.

Lens transmission
Natural vignetting
Micro-lens transmission

Each have their play in how much energy gets transferred. I'm just saying that when you start going wider, those angles take a (non-linear, trig function) toll on the natural vignetting. So, when you have a lens that has wide attributes that impact the angle of incidence, the natural vignetting is going to take a hit ... to be expected.
Jan 08, 2022 at 08:42 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #9New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Given your mathematical values for natural vignetting, the corners should be down about one stop at the maximum for modern lenses. Most lenses around f/1 will vignette much, much more - typically three to four stops.

https://photographylife.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Optical-Vignetting.png

Generally, I would refer to these sources among others:
https://photographylife.com/what-is-vignetting
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vignetting

RustyBug wrote:
Yes, we can attribute loss of energy to various components. But, once the light leaves the rear element of the lens, it is what it is. Great in the center, not so great in the corners ... as you say, natural occurrence, based on the trig.

My .02 is that while there is the lens construction elements that reduce transmission, and pixel level lenses that redirect / capture the energy to varying degree, the predominant occurrence of the vignetting is the natural vignetting, relative to the trig of a given lens.

Lens transmission
Natural vignetting
Micro-lens transmission

Each have their play in how much
...Show more →

Jan 08, 2022 at 09:01 AM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.14 #10New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I suspect one would also need to factor in the transmission value of the curvature of each surface of each element/group, for each wavelength. If the curvature is more acute (as on the edge of a curved surface) is the transmission value less?

Or, to put it another way, why is vignetting more pronounced with the point of focus racked in to infinity than it is with the point of focus at 2m?

edit:
As it relates to the new Nokton, I suspect whatever vignetting is present wide open at f/1.0 with the point-of-focus at around 2m is going to be irrelevant to my usage...
Jan 08, 2022 at 09:21 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #11New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
mapgraphs wrote:
(...) Or, to put it another way, why is vignetting more pronounced with the point of focus racked in to infinity than it is with the point of focus at 2m?

edit:
As it relates to the new Nokton, I suspect whatever vignetting is present wide open at f/1.0 with the point-of-focus at around 2m is going to be irrelevant to my usage...


As you know, when the lens focuses shorter, it moves away from the sensor. This means that the image circle (at the sensor plane) becomes larger, and this causes less vignetting. The light rays in the corners also become less angled, which in itself means less (natural) vignetting. That said, the difference in vignetting between infinity and 2 meters won't make a dramatic difference.
Jan 08, 2022 at 09:35 AM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.14 #12New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
...
That said, the difference in vignetting between infinity and 2 meters won't make a dramatic difference.


Sorry, but it can be quite significant...

Edit:
This might help elucidate...

Infinity
https://www.rangefinderforum.com/node/4762076#post4762085

Close focus
https://www.rangefinderforum.com/node/4762076#post4762098

And...
https://www.rangefinderforum.com/node/176490
Jan 08, 2022 at 10:08 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #13New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
mapgraphs wrote:
LarsHP wrote...
That said, the difference in vignetting between infinity and 2 meters won't make a dramatic difference.
Sorry, but it can be quite significant...

Edit:
This might help elucidate...

Infinity
https://www.rangefinderforum.com/node/4762076#post4762085

Close focus
https://www.rangefinderforum.com/node/4762076#post4762098

And...
https://www.rangefinderforum.com/node/176490


My comment was referring to the difference between infinity and 2 meters (the distance you mentioned in the previous post), not 0.7 meters.

And regarding the graphs you point to, even at 0.7 meters, there isn't much of a difference at f/1.1. You will be able to see it, yes, but we are talking about a third of a stop. That's not dramatic by my standards.
Jan 08, 2022 at 11:28 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.14 #14New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
I think you guys are expecting too much from this lens.

Here are my expectations:

High optical vignetting with the ill-effects caused by it.
High color aberration.
Poor resolution off-axis at large apertures. The corners will likely need f/4 or f/5.6.
At center, I expect it to be ok at f/1, sharp at f/1.4 and very sharp at f2.8.

In some ways, I've just described the characteristics of the Leica Noctilux 0.95.

If it performs any better than above, it will be an incredible lens.
Jan 08, 2022 at 11:36 AM
LarsHP
Offline
Details
p.14 #15New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Right. What we hope and what is realistic to expect is probably not the same... Might be a good idea to wait and see some real world test images before letting go of $2,000.
Jan 08, 2022 at 11:50 AM
Ihmemies2
Offline
Details
p.14 #16New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
It is not exactly crowded in the 50/1 or faster lens market. Whatever we get is better than nothing
Jan 08, 2022 at 01:26 PM
CheshireCat
Offline
Details
p.14 #17New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Fred Miranda wrote:
Here are my expectations:
[…]
High color aberration.
[…]
In some ways, I've just described the characteristics of the Leica Noctilux 0.95.


In a 2022 lens, I expect much better longitudinal chromatic aberration control than the Noctilux 0.95 (a 2008 lens).
The steep price (for a CV lens) suggests a technically superior lens than any 50 f/1-ish lens currently available from the competition. And that includes Leica.
Jan 09, 2022 at 02:33 AM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.14 #18New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
Given how the design intent of the 50mm Heliar f/1.5 was misconstrued by some, I suspect this lens will receive the same level of expectation disappointment by the same some; c'est la opiner...

I expect this Nokton to have exceptional rendering of the out of focus, first and foremost. Which is, I suspect, what it is designed to do.

At any rate, one really can't manage another's expectations.
Jan 09, 2022 at 05:54 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.14 #19New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
LarsHP wrote:
Given your mathematical values for natural vignetting, the corners should be down about one stop at the maximum for modern lenses. Most lenses around f/1 will vignette much, much more - typically three to four stops.

https://photographylife.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Optical-Vignetting.png

Generally, I would refer to these sources among others:
https://photographylife.com/what-is-vignetting
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vignetting

RustyBug wroteYes, we can attribute loss of energy to various components. But, once the light leaves the rear element of the lens, it is what it is. Great in the center, not so great in the corners ... as you say, natural occurrence, based on the trig.

My .02 is that while there is the lens construction elements that reduce transmission, and pixel level lenses that redirect / capture the energy to varying degree, the predominant occurrence of the vignetting is the natural vignetting, relative to the trig of a given lens.

Lens transmission
Natural vignetting
Micro-lens transmission

Each have their play in how much energy gets transferred. I'm just saying that when you start going wider, those angles take a (non-linear, trig function) toll on the natural vignetting. So, when you have a lens that has wide attributes that impact the angle of incidence, the natural vignetting is going to take a hit ... to be expected.


I appreciate the light path ... but, the relationship between the perpendicular distance from exit pupil to the film plane vs. the distance to the extent of the film plane is the aspect to which I'm referring. This is the trigonometric relationship in play for vignetting.

NOTE: The formula's didn't copy, but the source is listed below if you're so inclined.

Because the film plane is perpendicular to the exit pupil plane, . We can further take advantage of the fact that the distance between and is equal to the axial distance from the film plane to the exit pupil (which we’ll denote here by ) divided by . Putting this all together, we have

(6.5)
For cameras where the extent of the film is relatively large with respect to the distance , the term can meaningfully reduce the incident irradiance—this factor also contributes to vignetting.


https://www.pbr-book.org/3ed-2018/Camera_Models/Realistic_Cameras


The assertion that only 1 stop should be the amount of vignetting suggests that you aren't understanding the mathematical relationships between the distance from exit pupil to on axis film plane vs. the distance from exit pupil to film plane corner, as that pertains to the trig.

I haven't seen the actual value for it, but what is the distance from the exit pupil (on axis) to the film plane for the new lens? Looking at the photo next to the the 1.2, it appears that it will be even closer to the film plane than the 1.2. As the distance to the film plane is reduced (and that concentration of light is increased), the relationship of the distance on axis to the film plane vs. the distance to the corners will be changed even further.

At this point of exit, the issue isn't solely about the light path previously through the lens, rather the distribution of the light from the lens to the film plane. Move the exit pupil closer to the film plane, and the relationship to the corner is different than if the exit pupil is farther from the film plane. Of course, the dimension and curvature of the rear element complicates the math, but the principle remains that as the ratio of distance to center of film plane (on axis) vs. peripheral distance changes, so does the vignetting.
Jan 09, 2022 at 09:29 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.14 #20New Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton in January 2022
While the new 50/1 appears to have a significantly protruding rear element, IIRC, exit pupil distance is not necessarily the distance from the last glass surface to the sensor. However, such a design combined with a longer exit pupil, probably has a higher likelihood of physically blocking off-axis light rays.

Kent, as already mentioned, what you're describing is 'natural' vignetting due to light intensity loss as it travels farther to reach the corners vs. the center. I don't think anyone disputes this is a factor in lenses. But it's not the only type of vignetting, at least at wider apertures.

As the diagram in your post above illustrates, the total amount of light reaching the corners is a fraction of the center because the corner never has the full 'view' through the lens that the center does. It's not until the aperture is stopped down a fair amount that most points across the sensor see the same size opening through which the image forming light rays pass. Meaning, the same quantity of light rays reach most of the image, though still travel farther to reach the corner and will have slightly less intensity.

Maybe we're all just talking in circles describing the same thing with different words.
Jan 09, 2022 at 12:47 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister