fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary

  
 
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.25 #1Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
jhinkey wroteFirst images from actual real use with the 90/2.8 Sigma.
A7C on the South side of Mt. Baker camped at 5,500 ft.
It was a cold overnight in my 3-Season tent . . .
Beautiful series John!
The 90/2.8i did well here.


Thanks!
Oct 09, 2021 at 08:19 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.25 #2Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
jhinkey wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
jhinkey wroteFirst images from actual real use with the 90/2.8 Sigma.
A7C on the South side of Mt. Baker camped at 5,500 ft.
It was a cold overnight in my 3-Season tent . . .
Beautiful series John!
The 90/2.8i did well here.
Thanks.
My light weight backpacking kit has now evolved to:
A7C
21/3.5 CV
40/2.5G
90/2.8i

just need Sony to come out with at 16mm fisheye that's spectacular and someone to come out with a light weight 200/4 that's excellent right from wide open. Ah the wait continues . .


Nice images! Beautiful area. Nice small kit as well.
Oct 09, 2021 at 11:20 PM
Patrick Kolb
Offline
Details
p.25 #3Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
First outing with the 90mm f2.8 - Oak Tree Detail

Oak by Patrick Kolb, on Flickr
Oct 12, 2021 at 01:03 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #4Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Still undecided if I will keep my 24/3.5i or trade it for the 24/2i.

What I don't love about the 24/2i:
  1. Strong barrel distortion. The f/3.5 is virtually distortion free
  2. Higher optical vignetting wide open (cats-eye bokeh shape, swirling rendering) compared to the f/3.5 wide open. They would probably be comparable when both set to f/3.5 but the 24/3.5's specular highlights are round to the edges from wide open
  3. Size and weight: Almost twice as heavy/big than the f/3.5
  4. Maximum magnification. It's not bad at 1:6.7 but the f/3.5 version does half-size macro lens at 1:2


What I don't love about the 24/3.5i:
  1. Not much blur at mid/long distance (subject separation)
  2. f/3.5 under low light: I wish it were 2/3 stop brighter at f/2.8 in exchange for extra weight/size

----------

Sigma 24/3.5i's strengths: Very low distortion, size/weight, 1:2 macro
Sigma 24/2i's strength: Faster aperture (1.5 stops!)

Unclear: IQ and rendering

I have not received my 24/2i yet but it would be great to compare their resolution/contrast/rendering side by side.
Oct 12, 2021 at 03:28 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.25 #5Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
Still undecided if I will keep my 24/3.5i or trade it for the 24/2i.

What I don't love about the 24/2i:
  1. Strong barrel distortion. The f/3.5 is virtually distortion free
  2. Higher optical vignetting wide open (cats-eye bokeh shape, swirling rendering) compared to the f/3.5 wide open. They would probably be comparable when both set to f/3.5 but the 24/3.5's specular highlights are round to the edges from wide open
  3. Size and weight: Almost twice as heavy/big than the f/3.5
  4. Maximum magnification. It's not bad at 1:6.7 but the f/3.5 version does half-size macro lens at 1:2


What I don't love about the 24/3.5i:
  1. Not much
  2. f/3.5 under low light: I wish it were 2/3 stop brighter at f/2.8 in exchange for extra weight/size

----------

Sigma 24/3.5i's strengths: Very low distortion, size/weight, 1:2 macro
Sigma 24/2i's strength: Faster aperture (1.5 stops!)

Unclear: IQ and rendering

I have not received my 24/2i yet but it would be great to compare their resolution/contrast/rendering side by side.
...Show more →


To me, this reads like a good case for the 24/3.5 and not much of a case for the 24/2.0. If you wanted to shoot more open than 3.5 and were willing to accept the size/weight to do so, why wouldn't you just go the Sony 24/1.4 GM?

The 24/3.5, 45/2.8, and (perhaps) the 90/2.8 seem to excel at rendering in a very small, light, and well-built form factor. Does the 24/2.0 fit in there?
Oct 12, 2021 at 04:24 PM
offtraildog
Offline
Details
p.25 #6Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
chiron wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote:
Still undecided if I will keep my 24/3.5i or trade it for the 24/2i.

The 24/3.5, 45/2.8, and (perhaps) the 90/2.8 seem to excel at rendering in a very small, light, and well-built form factor. Does the 24/2.0 fit in there?



Plus those three lens all use 55mm filters ...

Oct 12, 2021 at 06:39 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #7Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
chiron wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteStill undecided if I will keep my 24/3.5i or trade it for the 24/2i.

What I don't love about the 24/2i:
  1. Strong barrel distortion. The f/3.5 is virtually distortion free
  2. Higher optical vignetting wide open (cats-eye bokeh shape, swirling rendering) compared to the f/3.5 wide open. They would probably be comparable when both set to f/3.5 but the 24/3.5's specular highlights are round to the edges from wide open
  3. Size and weight: Almost twice as heavy/big than the f/3.5
  4. Maximum magnification. It's not bad at 1:6.7 but the f/3.5 version does half-size macro lens at 1:2


What I don't love about the 24/3.5i:
  1. Not much blur at mid/long distance (subject separation)
  2. f/3.5 under low light: I wish it were 2/3 stop brighter at f/2.8 in exchange for extra weight/size

----------

Sigma 24/3.5i's strengths: Very low distortion, size/weight, 1:2 macro
Sigma 24/2i's strength: Faster aperture (1.5 stops!)

Unclear: IQ and rendering

I have not received my 24/2i yet but it would be great to compare their resolution/contrast/rendering side by side.
To me, this reads like a good case for the 24/3.5 and not much of a case for the 24/2.0. If you wanted to shoot more open than 3.5 and were willing to accept the size/weight to do so, why wouldn't you just go the Sony 24/1.4 GM?

The 24/3.5, 45/2.8, and (perhaps) the 90/2.8 seem to excel at rendering in a very small, light, and well-built form factor. Does the 24/2.0 fit in there?


Just brainstorming in case someone else is also in a pickle.
Oct 12, 2021 at 06:44 PM
TravelinBriNY
Offline
Details
p.25 #8Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I thought I had read that off center sharpness at close focusing on the 24/3.5 is not stellar; but will appreciate reading your findings here!
Oct 12, 2021 at 06:57 PM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.25 #9Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred Miranda wrote:
Still undecided if I will keep my 24/3.5i or trade it for the 24/2i.

What I don't love about the 24/2i:
  1. Strong barrel distortion. The f/3.5 is virtually distortion free
  2. Higher optical vignetting wide open (cats-eye bokeh shape, swirling rendering) compared to the f/3.5 wide open. They would probably be comparable when both set to f/3.5 but the 24/3.5's specular highlights are round to the edges from wide open
  3. Size and weight: Almost twice as heavy/big than the f/3.5
  4. Maximum magnification. It's not bad at 1:6.7 but the f/3.5 version does half-size macro lens at 1:2


What I don't love about the 24/3.5i:
  1. Not much
  2. f/3.5 under low light: I wish it were 2/3 stop brighter at f/2.8 in exchange for extra weight/size

----------

Sigma 24/3.5i's strengths: Very low distortion, size/weight, 1:2 macro
Sigma 24/2i's strength: Faster aperture (1.5 stops!)

Unclear: IQ and rendering

I have not received my 24/2i yet but it would be great to compare their resolution/contrast/rendering side by side.
...Show more →

I'm also finding more benefits for 24/3.5i and my 24/1.4 GM is also making it easier to stick to my current options even though I have 24/3.5i in both E and L mounts and swapping one of them for 24/2i could be interesting. Haven't found any strong motivation to do that though as I really like many aspects of the 24/3.5i and it fills a purpose for me in both mounts.
Oct 12, 2021 at 08:00 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #10Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
TravelinBriNY wrote:
I thought I had read that off center sharpness at close focusing on the 24/3.5 is not stellar; but will appreciate reading your findings here!


Yes, even at center, resolution/contrast at close distance is not optimal wide open, especially at MFD due to SA. However, stopping it down to f/5.6 improves things dramatically. So for 1:2 macro, I would use f/5.6 or smaller on the 24/3.5i.
Oct 12, 2021 at 09:02 PM
memzinla
Offline
Details
p.25 #11Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I ended up returning my Sigma 24mm F2, and now I'm stuck without a lens. I ended up selling the 24mm F3.5 for a good price. I regret it! lol

What is SA? I think I know from what I also saw from close up shots.
Oct 13, 2021 at 12:01 AM
keepcoding
Offline
Details
p.25 #12Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
memzinla wrote:
I ended up returning my Sigma 24mm F2, and now I'm stuck without a lens. I ended up selling the 24mm F3.5 for a good price. I regret it! lol

What is SA? I think I know from what I also saw from close up shots.


memzinla wrote:
I ended up returning my Sigma 24mm F2, and now I'm stuck without a lens. I ended up selling the 24mm F3.5 for a good price. I regret it! lol

What is SA? I think I know from what I also saw from close up shots.


SA is spherical aberration. AFAIK it is basically the lens' inability to bundle all rays in one focal point. Instead, the rays are scattered along the optical axis, which creates a soft glow.

Sigma 24/3.5 at F3.5:
https://blog.keepcoding.ch/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/sigma24mm_locatest_f3.5.jpg

At F5.6:
https://blog.keepcoding.ch/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/sigma24mm_locatest_f5.6.jpg
Oct 13, 2021 at 01:03 AM
memzinla
Offline
Details
p.25 #13Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Oh ok.
Thank you! Was just reading about that with the Nikon 40mm F2.
Oct 13, 2021 at 01:11 AM
keepcoding
Offline
Details
p.25 #14Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
memzinla wrote:
Oh ok.
Thank you! Was just reading about that with the Nikon 40mm F2.


Wow, that Nikon 40/2 looks very interesting. I wish we had such a compact F2 lens for E mount!
Oct 13, 2021 at 03:20 AM
FJR1
Offline
Details
p.25 #15Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
I've always liked the build quality and overall aesthetic of the Sigma I-series lenses, and the 24mm f/2 is no exception. Although the lens gives me a nice travel set of I series primes at 24 f/2, 65 f/2, and 90 f/2.8, the barrel distortion is concerning with the 24 f/2. Pictured first is a low-light SOOC photo taken from about four meters with center focus on the wall-hangings showing quite noticeable barrel distortion. There is no ACR Sigma 24i f/2 profile yet, but the second photo shows Photoshop correction using the Sigma 24-70 f/2.8 DG DN Adobe Camera Raw profile resulting in some improvement but with some slight pincushion distortion. The third photo shows a Photoshop correction of the Sigma 24-70 f/2.8 DG DN ACR profile by moving the slider 10 points to the left at 90 from a base of 100, and it could probably use a few more clicks to the left.

The problem with swapping the 24i f/2 out for the 24i 3.5 lies in light gathering capabilities. In a travel lens, a small form factor with more versatility for indoor/outdoor wide shots is what I prefer. Yes, I had and sold the 24 f/1.4 as I already have the 35 GM that can cover IQ shots, and I wanted something a little smaller that was within a stop of the 24 GM's aperture. I'll see what Fred says in his comparisons and may go to the 24i 3.5 after all. But, if I go with the 24i 3.5, I'll be wondering why I just didn't keep Sony's very good 28-60. Plus, I'm just a hobbyist who has time to fiddle with distortion corrections. Decisions, decisions.




24I f/2 SOOC from four meters with focus on wall hangings






ACR profile correction using Sigma 24-70 f/2.8 DG DN profile






Photoshop correction of the Sigma 24-70 f/2.8 DG DN ACR profile by moving the slider 10 points to the left at 90 from a base of 100.

Oct 13, 2021 at 03:36 AM
memzinla
Offline
Details
p.25 #16Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
keepcoding wrote:
memzinla wroteOh ok.
Thank you! Was just reading about that with the Nikon 40mm F2.
Wow, that Nikon 40/2 looks very interesting. I wish we had such a compact F2 lens for E mount!


Me too but for L-Mount! That Nikon 28mm also looks really good.
Oct 13, 2021 at 10:59 AM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.25 #17Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
nhsonyshooter wrote:
jhinkey wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
jhinkey wroteFirst images from actual real use with the 90/2.8 Sigma.
A7C on the South side of Mt. Baker camped at 5,500 ft.
It was a cold overnight in my 3-Season tent . . .
Beautiful series John!
The 90/2.8i did well here.
Thanks.
My light weight backpacking kit has now evolved to:
A7C
21/3.5 CV
40/2.5G
90/2.8i

just need Sony to come out with at 16mm fisheye that's spectacular and someone to come out with a light weight 200/4 that's excellent right from wide open. Ah the wait continues . .
Nice images! Beautiful area. Nice small kit as well.


Thanks!
Oct 13, 2021 at 01:13 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #18Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
FJR1 wrote:
I've always liked the build quality and overall aesthetic of the Sigma I-series lenses, and the 24mm f/2 is no exception. Although the lens gives me a nice travel set of I series primes at 24 f/2, 65 f/2, and 90 f/2.8, the barrel distortion is concerning with the 24 f/2. Pictured first is a low-light SOOC photo taken from about four meters with center focus on the wall-hangings showing quite noticeable barrel distortion. There is no ACR Sigma 24i f/2 profile yet, but the second photo shows Photoshop correction using the Sigma 24-70 f/2.8 DG DN Adobe Camera Raw
...Show more →


Thanks for the comparison!

I don't mind higher distortion zoom lenses but it bothers me to see it in a prime regardless of the fact that it can be corrected in post with minimal loss in IQ. Yes, it a design compromise that Sigma seems to embrace to achieve their size and price goal.
Still, looks to be a great lens.

Oct 13, 2021 at 01:30 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #19Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
keepcoding wrote:
memzinla wroteI ended up returning my Sigma 24mm F2, and now I'm stuck without a lens. I ended up selling the 24mm F3.5 for a good price. I regret it! lol

What is SA? I think I know from what I also saw from close up shots.
memzinla wroteI ended up returning my Sigma 24mm F2, and now I'm stuck without a lens. I ended up selling the 24mm F3.5 for a good price. I regret it! lol

What is SA? I think I know from what I also saw from close up shots.
SA is spherical aberration. AFAIK it is basically the lens' inability to bundle all rays in one focal point. Instead, the rays are scattered along the optical axis, which creates a soft glow.

Sigma 24/3.5 at F3.5:
https://blog.keepcoding.ch/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/sigma24mm_locatest_f3.5.jpg

At F5.6:
https://blog.keepcoding.ch/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/sigma24mm_locatest_f5.6.jpg


Great samples!

More tests showing SA, Focus shift and close-up performance here:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1687217/0#15500616
Oct 13, 2021 at 01:32 PM
zugzwang2
Offline
Details
p.25 #20Sigma 90mm and 24mm F2 DG DN | Contemporary
Fred, when you get around to making your usual thorough landscape tests for the 90/2.8, could you please include some images that are corrected for distortion?
Oct 13, 2021 at 01:44 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister