philip_pj wrote:
'..and yet people keep referring to “the Leica look.”'
If you know a little about mind control, repetition and message simplicity are all-important to achieving the goal. People can be convinced of almost anything, but you have to keep clear and straightforward information 'nuggets' for them to grasp - it's akin to the receptors in the human brain.
Nuance and context (and of course alternative messaging) are anathema to the process, because doubt has to be expunged from the take up stage. Propaganda is a fascinating and complex field, if somewhat depressing for the unprepared. One big tell: layering of flowery prose extolling superiority with abstract ill-defined terms, to the point where supporting material, let alone evidence or comparisons, is no longer required. A Leica example:
'I learned that this new range of lenses would raise the bar with regards to optical performance. Again. The XXX lenses would represent the best prime lenses Leica has ever made. In his words, “These primes redefine everything. They are simply amazing in terms of total optical performance, as well as mechanical. Fast autofocus. Next level image quality.”'
Except of course the Leica APO-SL Summicron Primes do in fact set new high optical performance benchmarks when you look at the MTF charts, CA, vignetting, and aberration tests. This is not opinion, these are objective and verifiable. So, in that sense this is not false or propaganda.
However, this kind of resolution may not be the rendering a photographer considers the "best" for the work and look that artist is trying to create.
A Leica employee explained this to me with a lot of enthusiasm last summer: Back in the film era, Leica was usually the choice for people and portraits, while Zeiss was preferred for architecture and product work.
Leica lenses were designed to render a warmer image, something people liked for nicer skin tones (on top of film choice). Zeiss lenses, on the other hand, tended to render cooler (not necessarily more accurate), which was preferred for buildings and objects.
Makes total sense to me, since I had already noticed that warmer tone in many Leica lenses.
In the digital age, with white balance and all the other tools we have, it obviously doesn’t define the final image as strongly anymore.
for me the Leica look is not a product of the camera, but rather of shooting certain Leica pre-asph, non coated/corrected vintage lenses. Those are looks that immensely appeal to me and I've not seen approximated by any other camera/lens combo whose images are generally sharp across the entire frame at the pixel level and are to me clinically modern and boring, lacking any real character. Even my 35 APO which is pretty sharp wide open across the frame is more charming and character filled than shooting, for example, my Sony 35/1.4 GM.
Of course than you add shooting the 35 APO as well as some vintage (or remake) Leica glass (such as my 35 steel rim reissue or summilux 50/1.4 pre-asph v2) wide open, and, again IMO on a M body with the absolute enjoyment of rangefinder focus, and voila, unparalleled enjoyment and magical images.
gammarART wrote:
A Leica employee explained this to me with a lot of enthusiasm last summer: Back in the film era, Leica was usually the choice for people and portraits, while Zeiss was preferred for architecture and product work.
Leica lenses were designed to render a warmer image, something people liked for nicer skin tones (on top of film choice). Zeiss lenses, on the other hand, tended to render cooler (not necessarily more accurate), which was preferred for buildings and objects.
.
I agree here, but I tend to categorize it as Leica for people and Zeiss for landscape. It also is a lot more involved than just warmer vs cooler colors. Zeiss lenses IMO tended to be more planar and better corrected than Leica with higher micro contrast and better flare control. Leica tended to allow for more curvature in their designs. A planar lens is better for landscape and curvature can be beneficial for portraits. Zeiss bokeh is more contrasty and structured while Leica bokeh tends to be less contrasty and structured. The high micro contrast in a Zeiss lens is a benefit when you are photographing landscapes trying to capture contrast in very fine details. However, once you photograph a person having stronger micro contrast in something such as skin pores becomes less desirable and less flattering and natural. The Leica lenses I have used have also had better skin tone rendering. Some Zeiss lenses the skin tones tend to be worse especially on darker skin. Zeiss has always had superior flare control. Flare, especially veiling, seems to be an issue for Leica even today when compared to the competition. Of course, there are exceptions depending on the particular lens and design.
A great quote by Weston
."..so called “composition” becomes a personal thing, to be developed along with technique, as a personal way of seeing."-Edward Weston
My thoughts are finding glass, cameras and processing that capture ones vision can include the way a lens renders along with the way one composes can all be part of a personal way of seeing as Weston talks about above. It's all a piece of a large whole.
The term "the Leica Look" was coined a looong time ago, before the Apos, ASPHs, and all the newer stuff. Back then I think it had a lot to do with character, not only performance. Some of the most famous Leica lenses were sharp in the middle wide open, but not in the corners. Some of my favourite Leica lenses, like the 75/80mm f/1.4 Summiluxes, had a way of having sufficient sharpness and contrast, and punchy colour in the in-focus areas, and an extremely soft boke with low contrast, and less punchy colours. The 50mm f/1 Noctilux has this look in spades, and I have some really great portraits with it. Some of these lenses have some of the most beautiful rendering ever. They don't have the 3D rendering and very high micro-contrast of the best Zeiss lenses though.
I am much less keen on the modern Leica look, which is all about removing as many aberrations as possible, even at the cost of some unruliness in the boke. Sharpness is, as is well known, a bourgeois concept...
In a nod to Ron, the 50 Lux-M ASPH. is one of my very favourite lenses of all time, but I would not include it in the Mandler-era Leica Look lenses.