I recently discovered Leica SL glass (own the 35mm and 90mm f2 APO-Summicron SL lenses), shooting them on LUMIX S1R. There’s a tangible dimension to the images. That’s the Leica look.
Factors contributing to this… Great micro-contrast. Sharp but natural separation of focused and unfocused borders, with smooth roll off. Terrific color, without chromatic aberration- as close to a genuinely APO lens as it gets. Smooth tonal transitions. Bokeh with almost perfect characteristics (no onion, true to underlying subject color).
They are masterfully designed and carefully manufactured for great subject separation. The SL line seems rather aperture invariant, very sharp from wide open to f11 (and f16 with diffraction correction) across the frame.
Ps - I have owned 4x5 Schneider and Rodenstock, Fuji GFX 100 with most GF lenses, a lot of Nikon (F and Z mounts), and Canon EF lenses over the last 30 years. Lots of benchmark glass. Some of the others certainly come close, but the Leica SL line is the best glass for 3d pop I’ve seen and used. A benchmark among benchmarks.
woodstork wrote:
I recently discovered Leica SL glass (own the 35mm and 90mm f2 APO-Summicron SL lenses), shooting them on LUMIX S1R. There’s a tangible dimension to the images. That’s the Leica look.
Factors contributing to this… Great micro-contrast. Sharp but natural separation of focused and unfocused borders, with smooth roll off. Terrific color, without chromatic aberration- as close to a genuinely APO lens as it gets. Smooth tonal transitions. Bokeh with almost perfect characteristics (no onion, true to underlying subject color).
They are masterfully designed and carefully manufactured for great subject separation. The SL line seems rather aperture invariant, very sharp from wide open to f11 (and f16 with diffraction correction) across the frame.
Ps - I have owned 4x5 Schneider and Rodenstock, Fuji GFX 100 with most GF lenses, a lot of Nikon (F and Z mounts), and Canon EF lenses over the last 30 years. Lots of benchmark glass. Some of the others certainly come close, but the Leica SL line is the best glass for 3d pop I’ve seen and used. A benchmark among benchmarks. ...Show more →
To my eyes, it's color hue separation and tonal transition that lead to a rich looking picture. Never fail to amaze me after a year of shooting with one (two, as of recently). Specifically both are rather modern ASPH lens designed during the late film era, when pixel peeping wasn't even a thing back then.
rw11 wrote:
I'm interested in learning about the "look" or rendering of certain Leica lenses for landscapes or portraits.
I keep hearing that some of their lenses (esp. some of the older lenses?) have a special quality to them.
Can anyone explain this?
Not sure it can be objectively explained. My feeling is with the older lenses, what people tend to appreciate are optical imperfections, for example the 'glow' due to under-corrected SA present at wider apertures. This could be potentially appealing for some portrait situations with 50mm and longer lenses. Examples that come to mind are the 75 Lux-M and its sibling the 80 Lux-R, the 90 Cron pre-ASPH, but there are others, too. Generally the lenses designed by Walter Mandler are held in high regard for desirable (or interesting) rendering characteristics. Some lenses are very much 'dual character' giving a certain look wide open and another stopped down a bit. 35 Lux pre-ASPH comes to mind as soft and glowy wide open but quite sharp and high contrast stopped down. IME the 50 Lux ASPH has similarities, but because it's a more modern design, it has an interesting mix of sharpness and SA in the plane of focus wide open with really nice Gaussian blur. Stopped down a bit and contrast really ratchets up a lot.
Then there are aspects such as color quality. Of the Leica lenses I've owned/used, I felt they all had very good color richness. But it's difficult to determine how much of this was just the lenses, or how much was related to the sensor in a given camera, the color profile, whether in-camera or applied by a raw converter, such as Lightroom. That said, I have used non-Leica glass on Leica digital M cameras and some have not had as nice color richness.
The post by woodstorck refers to Leica's modern SL lenses, which have been designed with the goal of achieving extremely high, modern, optical standards. The SL lenses appear to have very high micro contrast (sharpness in the plane of focus) with quick and graceful transition to defocus. Rendering of theses lenses is very consistent and could be described as somewhat sterile because of how clean they are (lacking optical flaws found in older lenses that translate into interesting character/rendering).
I wouldn't say there is a consistent look to Leica's lenses if you don't break them down into smaller groups based on production date and lens designer. A Mandler lens will be different than a Karbe lens.
woodstork wrote:
I recently discovered Leica SL glass (own the 35mm and 90mm f2 APO-Summicron SL lenses), shooting them on LUMIX S1R. There’s a tangible dimension to the images. That’s the Leica look.
That’s not the Leica look. It’s one of a number of Leica looks, as Ron correctly points out below. It’s what I would also describe as the sterile, characterless Karbe SL look.
---------------------------------------------
rscheffler wrote:
Rendering of [Leica's modern SL lenses] is very consistent and could be described as somewhat sterile because of how clean they are (lacking optical flaws found in older lenses that translate into interesting character/rendering).
I wouldn't say there is a consistent look to Leica's lenses if you don't break them down into smaller groups based on production date and lens designer. A Mandler lens will be different than a Karbe lens.
I’ve just purchased a Summaron 35mm f/2.8 lens (production era: 1958-1968) mainly because its rendering represents a thoroughgoing rejection of Leica’s current optical design philosophy. The head might say Karbe but the heart says Mandler and his predecessors.
genji wrote: woodstork wrote:
I recently discovered Leica SL glass (own the 35mm and 90mm f2 APO-Summicron SL lenses), shooting them on LUMIX S1R. There’s a tangible dimension to the images. That’s the Leica look.
That’s not the Leica look. It’s one of a number of Leica looks, as Ron correctly points out below. It’s what I would also describe as the sterile, characterless Karbe SL look.
------------------------------------
Every system evolves and offers multiple looks. Some people found 'the Leica look' in particular vintage lenses that were optically flawed and put out a wonderful subject edge glow at particular settings and that looked terrific for models. So I get your point, but I categorically disagree that Karbe's designs render sterile.
They are rather magical to me. Its like the first time I put on a pair of well-made polarizing sunglasses and you had this revelation that the world could look like that. Karbe's render just pops. If great dimension and color are sterile, so be it. I'll gladly take 'sterile' for my work. Sterile is probably the last word I'd apply to Karbe's work though. Vibrant, exciting, dimensional, colorful, high-resolved, and stunning are the words that come to my mind.
woodstork wrote:
They are rather magical to me. Its like the first time I put on a pair of well-made polarizing sunglasses and you had this revelation that the world could look like that. Karbe's render just pops. If great dimension and color are sterile, so be it. I'll gladly take 'sterile' for my work. Sterile is probably the last word I'd apply to Karbe's work though. Vibrant, exciting, dimensional, colorful, high-resolved, and stunning are the words that come to my mind.
I have the Summicron-SL 35mm as well.
It really to a large extent can depend on your subject matter.
If you are into landscapes you will probably adore the combination of the SL2 and the APO lenses with their insane sharpness and the almost total lack of vignetting, distortions and aberrations.
If you on the other hand are into shooting people, well, you might find that same hyper perfect look a bit clinical and sterile... and you might prefer the more pleasant rendering of "less perfect" lenses...
SlowDriver wrote:
It really to a large extent can depend on your subject matter.
If you are into landscapes you will probably adore the combination of the SL2 and the APO lenses with their insane sharpness and the almost total lack of vignetting, distortions and aberrations.
If you on the other hand are into shooting people, well, you might find that same hyper perfect look a bit clinical and sterile... and you might prefer the more pleasant rendering of "less perfect" lenses...
As much as I love the character of imperfect older Leica glass, I also love a lot of what Karbe has done, though I agree his lenses are generally not the ones people are thinking about when discussing the "Leica look."
I enjoy the dual character nature of the 50 Lux ASPH as touched on in my earlier post and its smooth Gaussian blur (in the right situations) that could be considered a precursor to the look of his most recent lenses. The 28 Lux is extremely versatile and consistent, though technically imperfect in some respects. I lust after the new 35 Cron APO-M because it combines insane sharpness with smooth rendering (my primary disappointment with sample images from the Cosina VM 35 APO is the lack of such smoothness at certain distances) in what appears to be another versatile and consistent package.
If I had an L mount camera and the budget, I'd own all of the SL Crons because I have not seen any other family of lenses with such consistency and ability to achieve such high technical performance in combination with smooth transition to defocus.
If there is a look to Karbe recently, it's the deceptive simplicity of extreme sharpness in the plane of focus with nondescript OOF rendering. His look is no look. The lack of character (noticeable imperfections that affect rendering). He makes it look easy, but apparently it's not, which perhaps is yet another example/criticism of spending a lot with not much to show for it (from Leica).
I switched to Leica from Fuji four years ago. Prior to my five year stint with Fuji, I was a lifelong Canon SLR and Pro DSLR shooter since high school, about 45 years.
I love my M10, M10R, SL2, Leica SL zooms and M primes. My favorite travel kit is my M10R, Summilux 35mm FLE and APO Summicron 50mm. Gear Lust is done! I'm very happy with the way Leica cameras work and the outstanding image quality.
Regards,
Bud James
Please check out my fine art and travel photography at www.budjames.photography or on Instagram at www.instagram.com/budjamesphoto
SlowDriver wrote: woodstork wroteThey are rather magical to me. Its like the first time I put on a pair of well-made polarizing sunglasses and you had this revelation that the world could look like that. Karbe's render just pops. If great dimension and color are sterile, so be it. I'll gladly take 'sterile' for my work. Sterile is probably the last word I'd apply to Karbe's work though. Vibrant, exciting, dimensional, colorful, high-resolved, and stunning are the words that come to my mind.I have the Summicron-SL 35mm as well.
It really to a large extent can depend on your subject matter.
If you are into landscapes you will probably adore the combination of the SL2 and the APO lenses with their insane sharpness and the almost total lack of vignetting, distortions and aberrations.
If you on the other hand are into shooting people, well, you might find that same hyper perfect look a bit clinical and sterile... and you might prefer the more pleasant rendering of "less perfect" lenses...
There are often two sides to every story.
I shoot people with both Mandler and Karbe lenses all day long. Well, I did before our pandemic and I decided to semi-retire.
I think the difference is more that with character lenses the look is baked in at shooting. The combination of distortions, CA, fall-off, vignetting etc are extremely pleasing but difficult to remove. Even some Karbe lenses have this. The SL50 Summilux is very different to the Summicron and I wouldn't describe the 24-90 as clinical. The S lenses and the SL Summicron primes are more of a blank canvas. You start with no aberrations and then add them in post. Better if you have your own thing you want to do, like your own secret sauce but more work after the shot is taken.
Gordon
p.s. there are generally three Leica *looks*. pre-Mandler, Mandler and Karbe, plus a dozen mini *looks*. So describing a single Leica look is impossible in the modern era. Plus now we also have Voigtlander, Zeiss and others making extremely nice glass, some as good as Leicas, which just didn't happen in the Mandler era. Some of these are deliberately going against what Karbe designs. Choice is good.
Two things come in mind from my experience with Leica M lenses:
1. Glow with older vintage Leica M/LTM lenses - for example seen with the 50/1.5 Summarit and also to some degree with the 50/2 Summitar wide open.
2. Bokeh circles: often distinct rings/ovals typical for most Leica M lenses in opposite to much smoother rendering (meaning less of a circular glow frame around the circle itself) of these circles in other lens brands. Most extreme in this regard so far from my experience: Leica 40/2 Summicron-C lens. It shows the strongest bokeh circles.
flash wrote: SlowDriver wrotewoodstork wroteThey are rather magical to me. Its like the first time I put on a pair of well-made polarizing sunglasses and you had this revelation that the world could look like that. Karbe's render just pops. If great dimension and color are sterile, so be it. I'll gladly take 'sterile' for my work. Sterile is probably the last word I'd apply to Karbe's work though. Vibrant, exciting, dimensional, colorful, high-resolved, and stunning are the words that come to my mind.I have the Summicron-SL 35mm as well.
It really to a large extent can depend on your subject matter.
If you are into landscapes you will probably adore the combination of the SL2 and the APO lenses with their insane sharpness and the almost total lack of vignetting, distortions and aberrations.
If you on the other hand are into shooting people, well, you might find that same hyper perfect look a bit clinical and sterile... and you might prefer the more pleasant rendering of "less perfect" lenses...
There are often two sides to every story.I shoot people with both Mandler and Karbe lenses all day long. Well, I did before our pandemic and I decided to semi-retire.
I think the difference is more that with character lenses the look is baked in at shooting. The combination of distortions, CA, fall-off, vignetting etc are extremely pleasing but difficult to remove. Even some Karbe lenses have this. The SL50 Summilux is very different to the Summicron and I wouldn't describe the 24-90 as clinical. The S lenses and the SL Summicron primes are more of a blank canvas. You start with no aberrations and then add them in post. Better if you have your own thing you want to do, like your own secret sauce but more work after the shot is taken.
Gordon
p.s. there are generally three Leica *looks*. pre-Mandler, Mandler and Karbe, plus a dozen mini *looks*. So describing a single Leica look is impossible in the modern era. Plus now we also have Voigtlander, Zeiss and others making extremely nice glass, some as good as Leicas, which just didn't happen in the Mandler era. Some of these are deliberately going against what Karbe designs. Choice is good....Show more →
"p.s. there are generally three Leica *looks*. pre-Mandler, Mandler and Karbe, plus a dozen mini *looks*. So describing a single Leica look is impossible in the modern era."
I like what you wrote here and thinking this might explain the forum debates when someone comments on what the Leica Look is or isn't.
I am a Peter Karbe,"iteration to optical perfection" fan 110%. I would call the Karbe look, true to life with as much realistic depth/3D-ness as possible. Peter keeps pushing those MTF curves closer and closer to a horizontal flat line at the very top of the MTF and I love it! My budget might not like it, but my eyes sure do
There's been some great observations shared here, and as a noob to Leica I find it very interesting. My work is indeed in landscape (and underwater), so now I have good context for why I like Karbe's SL APO-Summicron glass so much, and where it fits among the pantheon of great Leica rendering. Another thing I like is all the SL APO-'Crons have good magnification. It enables one to put viewers into the scene rather intimately, and the 3-Dness maybe makes them imagine being there a bit more effectively.
flash wrote:
The SL50 Summilux is very different to the Summicron and I wouldn't describe the 24-90 as clinical.
Neither would I but those are non-APO lenses.
flash wrote:
The S lenses and the SL Summicron primes are more of a blank canvas. You start with no aberrations and then add them in post. Better if you have your own thing you want to do, like your own secret sauce but more work after the shot is taken.
I agree with this although I certainly would not put S and SL lenses in the same bucket. The S lenses (mostly non-APO) have a much more cinematic (and much more pleasant) look in general I find.
With regards to portraits I often find the SL glass too sharp and too harsh (at least for the 99.99% of us who aren't top models...).
That being said, all of that goes through the window when you convert to B&W, then the APO glass is pretty brilliant... turns out is not that simple...
There isn't a 'Leica look' there are many. If you want to pick and choose a few that look similar then I'm sure it can be done but at the same time there are lenses that are dramatically different to each other too.
I have about a dozen R lenses and they are largely quite different, not all R lenses are Leica designs. My summilux-r 35 and 80 are kind of close but nothing like the Elmarit-R 28E55 or apo-summicron-r 180, and they are from about the same era too so it's not comparing lenses fro the '60s with lenses from the '90s. The apo-summicron-r 180 is clinically sharp (at F2) whilst the summilux-r 80 has just the right aberrations for portraits (ie to my taste, maybe not yours), and I do use them both for portraits and the images stand out as being quite different.
JohnJ wrote:
My summilux-r 35 and 80 are kind of close but nothing like the Elmarit-R 28E55 or apo-summicron-r 180, and they are from about the same era too so it's not comparing lenses fro the '60s with lenses from the '90s.
The 35 & 80 Summilux are from the 1984 and 1980, the 28E55 and Apo-Summicron from the 90s.
Leica will start building apo lenses such as the 100/2.8 Apo macro from 1987 and from then, the lenses will be better corrected, even the non-APO.
I would argue that the ones you refer to are indeed from two different eras.