fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2021 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2021Leica-R 28mm V2

  
 
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Leica-R 28mm V2
Taken at Milliken Park in Spartanburg, SC
(open public in free access all the time - 700+ acre)
Used Sony A7R2 and Leica Elmarit-R 28mm F2.8 E55 V2 with Novoflex adapter





1. Milliken Park Trail

Nov 25, 2021 at 04:22 PM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Leica-R 28mm V2
Actually I sold out Leica Elmarit-R 28mm F2.8 V2 E55 and purchased Voigtlander VM 28mm F2 V2.
I am very happy with Elmarit-R 35mm F2.8 V3 that is comparable sharpness and most lovely cinematic Leica character and color and prefer to it than 28mm v2.
Jan 06, 2022 at 03:58 PM
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Leica-R 28mm V2
I thought I would ask a question here which is pretty much in the weeds, but wouldn’t hurt to ask. I’ve got a 28mm Elmarit-R VII, which I have used on R bodies, and mirrorless, both Leica SL, and now Nikon Z 7. Have found it, over time, to be a lens I really like the rendering of, but have found a couple of lenses I prefer at this focal length for mirrorless, which I never thought I’d say.
Have also got a M10-R with a Visoflex, and no 28mm M lens. I get the same results from the lens, which I like, on the M as I did everywhere else, but the handling is a bit clunky. More than a bit. Is there an M version Elmarit which duplicates the results, in rendering, of the 28mm Elmarit-R VII? Usually I can answer that question myself by just going to flickr pages for the two lenses and having a long look, but in this case all the M versions are jumbled in together, and comparing the two pages I end up preferring what I am seeing from the R lens. It seems less contrasty, in a good way, but there are other rendering differences that just suit me a little better, but I don’t trust the flickr pages comparison in this case.
The Elmarit-R VII and the 4th version of the Elmarit-M both came out in 1992, and both are coincidentally 8 elements in 7 groups, whereas all the other versions of both lenses are 8 elements in 6 groups. Maybe that doesn’t mean anything, or maybe it does.
After all that windup, is the rendering of the 4th version, pre-asph, of the 28 Elmarit-M going to be indistinguishable from the VII Elmarit-R, or not really? I’d likely finally sell off the R and get the M in that case, just for better handling on an M body, but if any of the M lenses are more “modern” or “better” as the 28/2 Ultron II is, it probably would not be what I wanted.
Maybe the one person in a million who can answer that question will see this post. My other way to find out is just to buy an assortment of M elmarits and find out for myself, which is how I usually do things, just a little overextended right now, though.
Apr 22, 2022 at 08:45 AM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Leica-R 28mm V2
I used exactly same lenses, Leica Elamrit-R 28mm V2 E55 and Elamrit-M V4 (pre asph). I really liked both of them, but I sold out these two and settle down with Pentax 35mm F3.5 K, and Contax G 28mm F2.8, and C/Y 28mm F2.8 MMJ, and VM 28mm f2 V2 due to financial issue from Tax Issue due to Ebay over 20K. I am happy with these budget classes but quality of image is closer/par to Leica's images.
Apr 22, 2022 at 08:58 AM
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Leica-R 28mm V2
junglialoh wrote:
I used exactly same lenses, Leica Elamrit-R 28mm V2 E55 and Elamrit-M V4 (pre asph). I really liked both of them, but I sold out these two and settle down with Pentax 35mm F3.5 K, and Contax G 28mm F2.8, and C/Y 28mm F2.8 MMJ, and VM 28mm f2 V2 due to financial issue from Tax Issue due to Ebay over 20K. I am happy with these budget classes but quality of image is closer/par to Leica's images.


As of 2022, there are now tax issues of anything over $600 for eBay, Venmo, and Paypal, for those in the U.S. but that’s a different sad discussion.
I’ve had most of the lenses you mention outside of the Pentax, and would agree with you as to their usefulness, but I should probably clarify that what I am trying to find out is if the 28mm Elmarit-R VII and the 28 Elmarit-M Version IV are “the same”.
And, if they are different, how are they different, in rendering.
There are a ton of nice 28s out there, but that’s a different, more complicated, minefield. I’m just trying to figure out if I can swap out my R for what seems to be (?) the M version and get the same results.
Apr 22, 2022 at 09:44 AM
steve.chang
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Leica-R 28mm V2
Did anyone compare the R 28V2 with R 21-35 at 28mm? Thanks.
Apr 22, 2022 at 10:15 AM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Leica-R 28mm V2
I used both, but I found our that Elamrit-R 28mm V2 E55 is best on Sony System, but Elmarit-M 28mm has visible field curvature, so I definetly recommend R system on Sony FE system.
Apr 22, 2022 at 10:51 AM
ocean2059
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Leica-R 28mm V2
Edward Teller wrote:
junglialoh wroteI used exactly same lenses, Leica Elamrit-R 28mm V2 E55 and Elamrit-M V4 (pre asph). I really liked both of them, but I sold out these two and settle down with Pentax 35mm F3.5 K, and Contax G 28mm F2.8, and C/Y 28mm F2.8 MMJ, and VM 28mm f2 V2 due to financial issue from Tax Issue due to Ebay over 20K. I am happy with these budget classes but quality of image is closer/par to Leica's images.
As of 2022, there are now tax issues of anything over $600 for eBay, Venmo, and Paypal, for those in the U.S. but that’s a different sad discussion.
I’ve had most of the lenses you mention outside of the Pentax, and would agree with you as to their usefulness, but I should probably clarify that what I am trying to find out is if the 28mm Elmarit-R VII and the 28 Elmarit-M Version IV are “the same”.
And, if they are different, how are they different, in rendering.
There are a ton of nice 28s out there, but that’s
...Show more →

The optical formulas for these two 28/2.8 lens are different. Ewin Puts wrote in this book that the optical performance of Elmarit-R 28 is slightly better than that of the Elamrit-M (IV) 28. I have both lenses but I didn't really use them on head-to-head comparison on a same camera. My own experience suggests that the R version is great for mid and infinity distance with great color, contrast and outer zone sharpness while the M version is better for close-up and short distance with great and gentle color rendering but a bit less contrasty. The corners performance of the M version don't really sharpen up until f/5.6 or so. But the close-up rendering is one of the bests that I ever used for a 28mm focal length. Although both lenses came onto the market about the same time, I feel that they were optimized for slightly different performance priorities.

If you are using them on Nikon Z7, the Elmarit-R should perform better in the outer zone and corners. I am keeping both of them as they are truly unique lenses even compared with today's best 28mm lenses.


Edited on Aug 16, 2022 at 08:33 PM · View previous versions
Apr 22, 2022 at 11:45 AM
Edward Teller
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Leica-R 28mm V2
Thanks, everyone, that helps significantly. I must not have looked at the right Puts booklet.
All of this helps. Yes, the R lens is great on the Z 7.
“keeping both of them”, that’s the sinkhole I always seem to step into. I buy one thing to replace another thing, sometimes to save money, and then keep them both.
But thanks, everyone, for the feedback, that really helps. Still don’t know what I am going to do, but at least my indecision is better informed now.
Apr 22, 2022 at 01:00 PM
pmeheut
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Leica-R 28mm V2
steve.chang wrote:
Did anyone compare the R 28V2 with R 21-35 at 28mm? Thanks.


I just did and added the Summicron 28mm M v2. I lack time to upload the images but I shot everything on a sturdy tripod, a 60 Mpix Leica M11 at 200 ISO and checked for focus-shift.
When I found chromatic aberration, I asked Capture One to fix it and compared with and without.
Here is what I found:

wide-open, center: they are very, very close but it would be 21-35mm > 28mm R > 28mm M.
borders/corners: 28mm R > 28mm M > 21-35mm. The primes are close, the zoom is really behind with some CA.

f/4, center: they are so close I do not see a difference.
borders/corners: 28mm M > 28mm R > 21-35mm. The M is slightly better than the Elmarit. The zoom did not improved because we are close to wide-open.

f/8, center: they are so close I hardly see a difference. But it would be 21-35mm = 28mm M > 28mm R. But this is pixel-peeping.
borders/corners: they are very close once CA is fixed. If I had to choose, it would be: 21-35mm > 28mm M > 28mm R

The most impressive is the 28mm Summicron because it is as good as the others in the center at f/2. The 28mm R is everything it is said to be. I've had this lens a long time 25 years ago and I was always impressed.

The zoom is very good too especially in the center and on the whole field from f/8. I had it too for years and it never disappointed. The 19mm v2 was better on film but the 21-35 had the edge with the DMR.

Apr 23, 2022 at 02:32 AM
steve.chang
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Leica-R 28mm V2
Thank you, pmeheut. Very very helpful.

I am thinking to get a R 21-35mm for travelling with a RED Komodo (1.33x crop horizontally). The focal length will be more like Tri-Elmar 28-35-50, which I love a lot.
Apr 23, 2022 at 05:03 AM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Leica-R 28mm V2
Milliken Park in January 16, 2021 Taken with Panasonic S1R
Leica Elmarit-R 28mm F2.8 V2 E55 is one of the finest 28mm lens ever used.
Its sharpness is par with
Otus 28mm f1.4 or Sigma 28mm F1.4 Art, or Nikon 28mm F1.4 E (<--- these 3 are top tier)
I used Sigma, Nikon E for a while but heavy, so sold out.






Leica Elmarit-R 28mm F2.8 V2 E55



Edited on Jun 19, 2022 at 08:29 PM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2022 at 01:48 PM
theHUN
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Leica-R 28mm V2
This lens is indeed an absolute gem. It was also the first time I regretted judging a lens by its MTF charts. I remember comparing this lens to the 28/2 Zeiss Distagon ZF.2, purely on MTF charts and decided on the Zeiss. While it performed well, I found this review comparing the two lenses, and I got intrigued by the Leica again. A used copy came up, so I quickly bought it, and my comparisons largely agreed with those of the linked review.
Jun 13, 2022 at 03:12 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Leica-R 28mm V2
Interesting info, I should dig out my R 28 and see which version it is.
Jun 16, 2022 at 09:20 AM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Leica-R 28mm V2
Which version is mine (that I never use)? It has the drop in filter that goes into the lens hood



Jun 18, 2022 at 02:20 PM
ocean2059
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Leica-R 28mm V2
This looks like the first version of Elmarit-R that Leica produced from 1970 to 1994. Leica first made that for Leicaflex SL and SL2 (code: 11204), then later made the lens for R series bodies (code: 11247). You should definitely use it on your R8.
Jun 18, 2022 at 02:44 PM
theHUN
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Leica-R 28mm V2
Most certainly not V2 as the V2 has a build-in rectangular hood and "E55" written between "28" and the serial number.
Jun 18, 2022 at 05:35 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Leica-R 28mm V2
ocean2059 wrote:
This looks like the first version of Elmarit-R that Leica produced from 1970 to 1994. Leica first made that for Leicaflex SL and SL2 (code: 11204), then later made the lens for R series bodies (code: 11247). You should definitely use it on your R8.


Sold the R8 a while back. Have the R7 and the R9. I've used it on the 7 but not the 9.

Thinking about that 28-90 R zoom, and selling this and my 35-70 F4 ROM.
Jun 18, 2022 at 09:37 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Leica-R 28mm V2
Do you have the Vario-Elmar-R 21-35?

Desmolicious wrote:
ocean2059 wroteThis looks like the first version of Elmarit-R that Leica produced from 1970 to 1994. Leica first made that for Leicaflex SL and SL2 (code: 11204), then later made the lens for R series bodies (code: 11247). You should definitely use it on your R8.
Sold the R8 a while back. Have the R7 and the R9. I've used it on the 7 but not the 9.

Thinking about that 28-90 R zoom, and selling this and my 35-70 F4 ROM.

Jun 18, 2022 at 10:46 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Leica-R 28mm V2
genji wrote:
Do you have the Vario-Elmar-R 21-35?

Desmolicious wrote
ocean2059 wroteThis looks like the first version of Elmarit-R that Leica produced from 1970 to 1994. Leica first made that for Leicaflex SL and SL2 (code: 11204), then later made the lens for R series bodies (code: 11247). You should definitely use it on your R8.
Sold the R8 a while back. Have the R7 and the R9. I've used it on the 7 but not the 9.

Thinking about that 28-90 R zoom, and selling this and my 35-70 F4 ROM.


No. Sounds pricey!
Jun 19, 2022 at 05:31 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister