I thought I would ask a question here which is pretty much in the weeds, but wouldn’t hurt to ask. I’ve got a 28mm Elmarit-R VII, which I have used on R bodies, and mirrorless, both Leica SL, and now Nikon Z 7. Have found it, over time, to be a lens I really like the rendering of, but have found a couple of lenses I prefer at this focal length for mirrorless, which I never thought I’d say.
Have also got a M10-R with a Visoflex, and no 28mm M lens. I get the same results from the lens, which I like, on the M as I did everywhere else, but the handling is a bit clunky. More than a bit. Is there an M version Elmarit which duplicates the results, in rendering, of the 28mm Elmarit-R VII? Usually I can answer that question myself by just going to flickr pages for the two lenses and having a long look, but in this case all the M versions are jumbled in together, and comparing the two pages I end up preferring what I am seeing from the R lens. It seems less contrasty, in a good way, but there are other rendering differences that just suit me a little better, but I don’t trust the flickr pages comparison in this case.
The Elmarit-R VII and the 4th version of the Elmarit-M both came out in 1992, and both are coincidentally 8 elements in 7 groups, whereas all the other versions of both lenses are 8 elements in 6 groups. Maybe that doesn’t mean anything, or maybe it does.
After all that windup, is the rendering of the 4th version, pre-asph, of the 28 Elmarit-M going to be indistinguishable from the VII Elmarit-R, or not really? I’d likely finally sell off the R and get the M in that case, just for better handling on an M body, but if any of the M lenses are more “modern” or “better” as the 28/2 Ultron II is, it probably would not be what I wanted.
Maybe the one person in a million who can answer that question will see this post. My other way to find out is just to buy an assortment of M elmarits and find out for myself, which is how I usually do things, just a little overextended right now, though.