GMPhotography wrote:
Well I'm processing in C1 so that can have something to do with it. I have no profile but this is not a issue. Lots of lenses under expose in C1. But yes that will lead to looking a little more saturated. Remember I'm doing nothing to these but every reviewer on the planet fixes stuff and they should not. It's a test and should be pure. I did not even bother fixing the vignetting this test
But it can be very normal in C1 . Don't look into that if it was a issue I'd bring it up for sure
That's very useful - I appreciate the effort it takes to do these and you're right that a lot of the value is in the consistency of your approach. Seeing the vignetting gives a really good indication of what to expect in real life.
I'm a little surprised that there's such an exposure difference with AE, and how it changes the overall look of the image in C1 - I should pay more attention to that myself in my own pictures (though i have a feeling that LR compensates for that somewhat).
LR and C1 are for sure certainly different on exposure . That I have seen on import into both programs. Again don’t read into that either, it’s just there mechanics of design and programming. Remember it’s raw we are the masters of that raw file. Our job like mission impossible is to accept the terms and plow forward. Lol
But seriously that was good to bring up. We go on the notion that we are in manual mode, to be a good shooter, processors and artist that’s how we should really operate or you don’t really learn.
I’m not sure how many times I have said this but be a expert at at least one of these programs
GMPhotography wrote:
I know I went through the old 35 FE 5 times
Here is my sample wide open,center left and center right side with the upside down method (100% crop on my A7III). I can't say the left side is blurry but the right side is sharper. Mid right frame is a tiny bit sharper than mid left too. Do you think it is acceptable.
I bought one as well. Read your review and I really liked nearly all the sample images across multiple reviewers and early adopters, which only a few lenses have done for me. Tempted to get the Sigma 35 for consistency but I’ll get the GM if AF-C is considerably better than the Sigma 35. I have the FE 35/1.8 and while often harsh in its faults, it gives me almost 100% keepers shooting my kids and I’m loathe to lose that…
This test is really useful. Thx. Just curious if it is possible to have in-camera lens corrections for the 35i, on Sony cameras? I also noticed when shooting close distance with the 35 i, there is some pincushion distortion. Is it normal for a 35mm? thank you
chemsslu wrote:
This test is really useful. Thx. Just curious if it is possible to have in-camera lens corrections for the 35i, on Sony cameras? I also noticed when shooting close distance with the 35 i, there is some pincushion distortion. Is it normal for a 35mm? thank you
Yes, you just need to enable lens distortion correction in the menus (and maybe have "settings on" also).
That's one of the point of mirrorless IMHO, that you see exactly what you shoot .
j4nu wrote: chemsslu wroteThis test is really useful. Thx. Just curious if it is possible to have in-camera lens corrections for the 35i, on Sony cameras? I also noticed when shooting close distance with the 35 i, there is some pincushion distortion. Is it normal for a 35mm? thank youYes, you just need to enable lens distortion correction in the menus (and maybe have "settings on" also).
That's one of the point of mirrorless IMHO, that you see exactly what you shoot .
Would it be possible to point out which setting needs to be updated for this to work properly? I have "Distortion Comp." set to auto (other choice is off) on my A9 and I still see significant amount of distortion correction in Capture One 20, when I apply "manufacturer profile" to my 35I pictures.
It is based on the embedded (in RAW) distortion correction data produced by the lens/camera combination I guess.
If this is not enough, then you need to wait for a custom CO profile I think.
This applies both to what you seen in the viewfidner / on the LCD and the resulting RAW files (at least CO opens them already with "Manufacturer Profile" - distortion 100 applied if you have distortion compensation enabled in camera).
I tested it ("Distortion Comp." -> AUTO with "Live View Display" -> "Setting Effect" ON) sometime ago on the Bigma and that's the results I got...
ramesesthe2nd wrote: j4nu wrotechemsslu wroteThis test is really useful. Thx. Just curious if it is possible to have in-camera lens corrections for the 35i, on Sony cameras? I also noticed when shooting close distance with the 35 i, there is some pincushion distortion. Is it normal for a 35mm? thank youYes, you just need to enable lens distortion correction in the menus (and maybe have "settings on" also).
That's one of the point of mirrorless IMHO, that you see exactly what you shoot .Would it be possible to point out which setting needs to be updated for this to work properly? I have "Distortion Comp." set to auto (other choice is off) on my A9 and I still see significant amount of distortion correction in Capture One 20, when I apply "manufacturer profile" to my 35I pictures.
Distortion Compensation getting applied to live-view for non-forced distortion compensated lenses is a somewhat recent change. I was surprised when I noticed that the A7RIV did it.
In Capture One both check the profile and make sure the Distortion slider is set to 100.
Distortion Compensation getting applied to live-view for non-forced distortion compensated lenses is a somewhat recent change. I was surprised when I noticed that the A7RIV did it.
In Capture One both check the profile and make sure the Distortion slider is set to 100.