Morning everyone. Finally got a chance to test some things and right out of the gate I have excellent copies of all 3 lenses . Yes there is a photo God.
Test are done on a A7C.
Couple things that are not exactly making me happy. Now before I even start NO ONE is paying me anything and if a lens is not cutting the cheese I will send it back. Im no Sony fan boy. Frankly all I care about is having top notch glass. If I upset you because I may not like what you like . Than that one is on you. I am totally not brand agnostic and let me say right away I dont care about size, weight, bulk, price or you expect these lenses to pick your nose.
Out of the gate the Sigma is a bit wider than the Sony which in a way I say thats not a bad thing. One its nice to have wider but also by the time you clean up the distortion its back to the same as the Sony focal length. The Sony distortion is very very slight I can see it but also I could even ignore it. Sorry the Sigma it is very obvious. BTW these are MY lenses out of my pocket and frankly not sure if im keeping any of them or not
So lets start here Focal length and distortion. These are without any corrections . Not even vignetting. I will say in my test of the Sigma before ei was able to clean it up quite well. But lets remember this is extra work and time is money at least for me it is.
You notice after correcting all that on the Sigma its actually slightly longer. Now this may vary when we get lens profiles but I just want to show how this all comes out in the wash. I did have a shift in my tripod moving but it really has no effect at all. im still square to the building and sharp is sharp and you can fake that.
So this is the Sony 35mm 1.4 at 1.4 and if you think this is BS well than you dont know me and how many freaking lenses I put against this wall. Im shocked but I NEVER seen a lens this sharp at 1.4 in those corners. NEVER and no one is getting this lens
Let me add something here on that left crop with the shiny silver lamp there should be CA in that and along the metal strap across the frame and im simply not seeing any plus I did another test for CA and im not seeing any.
Point here I have NOT read ANY tests from Fred or anyone else yet. So I have no idea if it does or does not.
Honestly the Sony is so good not sure it would get any better. Not that we always needs laser images on corners its nice to know it can do that. Thats why I test is to know the limits
Im just going to show the crops now on both lenses for 2.8 and f4.
So these are the Sigma at 2.8 and than F4. Very good for this lens and I say at F4 across the frame is the ticket. I know 5.6 there is some small improvement but thats not really why your buying this lens. Lets face it there are 4 35mm lenses to beat the band.
In all truth and honesty the Sigma is not for me, so I will sell it and the only reason is the distortion and its a nice small lens but I think with this Sony to do the heavy lifting I just want a bolt on run out the door manual focus very small 35. That sounds like a Voigtlander but I dont want to spend more money either so something . So given todays yes it will be up for sale as id rather have a member get a good copy but let me finish posting this as you may want to see more of this comparison. I kinda knew this would happen. My photography is more about serving clients than my personal stuff.
I still see a hint of CA at 2.8 but thats a easy correction too
Had a little lightness on the Sony but Sony 1.4 looks very well with Sigma F2 so both very good at wide open on Bothe lenses . Sony just gets there faster.
Nice feature on both these lenses and I may just buy in the future is the aperture rings . As with my A7c I can select what I want in focus and with tracking hold AF down and with left hand just go through the aperture series. Love it
Okay so this is the Sigma series and I want to point I have done absolutely nothing to any of these files or the Sonys. So if you want to compare than here it is straight out of camera basically. I do NOT see any major differences in rendering . Maybe a touch but we need to remember your NEVER EVER going to shoot like this. These comparisons outside of seeing what you like will never come up after you buy a lens. I know its fun to test and see.
GMPhotography wrote:
Sony F2 than Sigma F2 than Sigma 2.8
Had a little lightness on the Sony but Sony 1.4 looks very well with Sigma F2 so both very good at wide open on Bothe lenses . Sony just gets there faster.
When I thought the Sigma was screaming sharp at f/2 (center), the Sony GM was even sharper at infinity.
Your test confirms this trend at a closer distance.
The Sigma has moderate distortion but I feel it helps with environment portraits. (barrel distortion makes faces look more natural imo). Like you wrote. All three great options!
Im shocked but I NEVER seen a lens this sharp at 1.4 in those corners.
I agree. I have never seen corners like this at f/1.4 either.
GMPhotography wrote:
Fred I agree these lenses are just amazing . Sure some little issues but nothing like before.
Not posted yet but Infinity images are crazy and im not seeing any bad mid field stuff either
Here is a bokeh ball test watch the Exif and watch the shapes
Very nice busy background to compare the two lenses. The FE 35mm f/1.4 GM @ f/2 is just amazing in terms of resolution and rendering. I like the rendering better than the Sigma 35/2's wide open. There is way less optical vignetting (which means softer corners on the GM) as well as less shade vignetting. A big bump in resolution is noticeable even on resized images.
I hate to say anything negative to the Sigma because it's a very capable compact AF lens. It's imo the best 35mm compact we have with AF. Great lens for the smaller A7C.
Yea im thinking twice on it as I like this Sigma. Maybe a lens profile may help or I may have to build something in C1. The only smaller options are the 2.8
Oh crap I just remember I did the Sigma 65 too on BB this morning . Let me work on that
Oh and just to let folks know im trying to do something different than what Fred does so well on this testing. I only hope it adds to that and help make decisions easier