fredmiranda.com Login

Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review

  
 
tsdevine
Online
Details
p.18 #1Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
What about this guy, would you say the same about him?

For best renders you should get the original:

https://leica-camera.com/en-MY/photography/lenses/m/summaron-m28-f5-6-matte-black-paint


https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1776588/3#16061723

What I don't understand is you just seem to jump in this thread and attack people, without expressing your thoughts on the GM 35. I wish you would contribute on why you disagree with someone's opinion, not just go after someone who expresses their opinion.

In any case....vacating this thread as well.

If at some point I look to pickup a faster AF 35 (than what I have), I would probably look at the GM 35/1.4 and Sigma i35/2. There are some I find interesting which are in non-native mounts, but not sure I want to adapt.

vdo1 wrote:
tsdevine wroteIMO means In My Opinion....he prefaced the snippet you quoted with that qualification. We all have individual opinions on what we think it's the best. And we can all disagree. And based on our style, preferences, etc.....the things we value the most, we might be right in our eyes.

But at long as we present it as opinion, I don't see the issue. And each person can explain the qualities that make them think one lens is better than another.

And we can disagree. And that's ok.

vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
tsdevine wroteThis context is extremely helpful, and if you you had given more in the earlier post I think I would have (maybe others) interpreted it in a more constructive way. Just came across a little confrontational as is.

I tend to buy the sharpest/best corrected lenses, as I do mainly landscape shooting. But I do also see shots from some lenses that I am drawn to, which aren't necessarily the sharpest or most corrected. For example, looking at shots with the Sigma i35/2 (I know that thread went south...and I do want to drag there into here) and the Tamron 35/1.4 (non Sony E mount). But the GM seems like a fantastic lens.

I'm shooting mainly the CV 35/2 APO for 35mm. But I often think of maybe getting a faster 35mm with AF. Right now I have the Tamron 35/2.8 and the Zony 35/2.8. But I don't *need* another 35 really.
You will never be able to reduce it to one single 35mm lens, for the simple reason that there will never be a single lens that is best in all usage scenarios.

Pretty much like I wouldn't chose a pneumatic screwdriver to fix a loose screw on my eyeglasses, I wouldn't pick a f/1.2 lens for my travel snapshots at f/8.

Yet some people will try to find an "universal winner" in all categories. Or will declare a lens as "best" without also mentioning the use case.
I don't think any one has tried to find a "universal winner," or declared there is one or even declared a lens as "best" without mentioning a use case. I agree that shouldn't happen and I am glad it hasn't.
Some did try, like Steve Spencer here: "the 200 f/2 VR is the best portrait lens for Nikon".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1742143/1#15859081
The use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact. And it doesn't excuse one from making the connected statement.

Don't worry though, I can find other examples from the times when the RX1 lens was the best 35mm or when the 24 GM was the best E-mount 35mm ("when shot in crop mode").


Nov 14, 2022 at 06:46 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.18 #2Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
tsdevine wrote:
What about this guy, would you say the same about him?

Earlier quoteFor best renders you should get the original:

https://leica-camera.com/en-MY/photography/lenses/m/summaron-m28-f5-6-matte-black-paint
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1776588/3#16061723

What I don't understand is you just seem to jump in this thread and attack people, without expressing your thoughts on the GM 35. I wish you would contribute on why you disagree with someone's opinion, not just go after someone who expresses their opinion.

In any case....vacating this thread as well.

If at some point I look to pickup a faster AF 35 (than what I have), I would probably look at the GM 35/1.4 and Sigma i35/2. There are some I find interesting which are in non-native mounts, but
...Show more →
vdo1 wrote
tsdevine wroteIMO means In My Opinion....he prefaced the snippet you quoted with that qualification. We all have individual opinions on what we think it's the best. And we can all disagree. And based on our style, preferences, etc.....the things we value the most, we might be right in our eyes.

But at long as we present it as opinion, I don't see the issue. And each person can explain the qualities that make them think one lens is better than another.

And we can disagree. And that's ok.

vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wroteYou will never be able to reduce it to one single 35mm lens, for the simple reason that there will never be a single lens that is best in all usage scenarios.

Pretty much like I wouldn't chose a pneumatic screwdriver to fix a loose screw on my eyeglasses, I wouldn't pick a f/1.2 lens for my travel snapshots at f/8.

Yet some people will try to find an "universal winner" in all categories. Or will declare a lens as "best" without also mentioning the use case.
I don't think any one has tried to find a "universal winner," or declared there is one or even declared a lens as "best" without mentioning a use case. I agree that shouldn't happen and I am glad it hasn't.
Some did try, like Steve Spencer here: "the 200 f/2 VR is the best portrait lens for Nikon".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1742143/1#15859081
The use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact. And it doesn't excuse one from making the connected statement.

Don't worry though, I can find other examples from the times when the RX1 lens was the best 35mm or when the 24 GM was the best E-mount 35mm ("when shot in crop mode").


If you feel that anywhere in this thread I attacked you personally or I used abusive language against you, please point me to the offending post and I'll offer you my apologies and I will delete that post.

Nov 14, 2022 at 07:20 PM
tsdevine
Online
Details
p.18 #3Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review

No you didn't, so no worries.

What got me riled up was the national geographer's not accepting photos from non-approved lenses comment. Seemed to be just meant to be inflammatory. If I offended you, my apologies.

I'm really "out" now.

vdo1 wrote:
tsdevine wroteWhat about this guy, would you say the same about him?

Earlier quoteFor best renders you should get the original:

https://leica-camera.com/en-MY/photography/lenses/m/summaron-m28-f5-6-matte-black-paint
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1776588/3#16061723

What I don't understand is you just seem to jump in this thread and attack people, without expressing your thoughts on the GM 35. I wish you would contribute on why you disagree with someone's opinion, not just go after someone who expresses their opinion.

In any case....vacating this thread as well.

If at some point I look to pickup a faster AF 35 (than what I have), I would probably look at the GM 35/1.4 and Sigma i35/2. There are some I find interesting which are in non-native mounts, but not sure I want to adapt.

vdo1 wrote
tsdevine wroteIMO means In My Opinion....he prefaced the snippet you quoted with that qualification. We all have individual opinions on what we think it's the best. And we can all disagree. And based on our style, preferences, etc.....the things we value the most, we might be right in our eyes.

But at long as we present it as opinion, I don't see the issue. And each person can explain the qualities that make them think one lens is better than another.

And we can disagree. And that's ok.

vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wroteI don't think any one has tried to find a "universal winner," or declared there is one or even declared a lens as "best" without mentioning a use case. I agree that shouldn't happen and I am glad it hasn't.
Some did try, like Steve Spencer here: "the 200 f/2 VR is the best portrait lens for Nikon".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1742143/1#15859081
The use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact. And it doesn't excuse one from making the connected statement.

Don't worry though, I can find other examples from the times when the RX1 lens was the best 35mm or when the 24 GM was the best E-mount 35mm ("when shot in crop mode").
If you feel that anywhere in this thread I attacked you personally or I used abusive language against you, please point me to the offending post and I'll offer you my apologies and I will delete that post.



Nov 14, 2022 at 07:28 PM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #4Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
Nov 16, 2022 at 12:08 PM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #5Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review


Nov 23, 2022 at 06:43 AM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #6Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
Nov 24, 2022 at 03:05 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.18 #7Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review


vdo1 wrote:
tsdevine wroteIMO means In My Opinion....he prefaced the snippet you quoted with that qualification. We all have individual opinions on what we think it's the best. And we can all disagree. And based on our style, preferences, etc.....the things we value the most, we might be right in our eyes.

But at long as we present it as opinion, I don't see the issue. And each person can explain the qualities that make them think one lens is better than another.

And we can disagree. And that's ok.

vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
tsdevine wroteThis context is extremely helpful, and if you you had given more in the earlier post I think I would have (maybe others) interpreted it in a more constructive way. Just came across a little confrontational as is.

I tend to buy the sharpest/best corrected lenses, as I do mainly landscape shooting. But I do also see shots from some lenses that I am drawn to, which aren't necessarily the sharpest or most corrected. For example, looking at shots with the Sigma i35/2 (I know that thread went south...and I do want to drag there into here) and the Tamron 35/1.4 (non Sony E mount). But the GM seems like a fantastic lens.

I'm shooting mainly the CV 35/2 APO for 35mm. But I often think of maybe getting a faster 35mm with AF. Right now I have the Tamron 35/2.8 and the Zony 35/2.8. But I don't *need* another 35 really.
You will never be able to reduce it to one single 35mm lens, for the simple reason that there will never be a single lens that is best in all usage scenarios.

Pretty much like I wouldn't chose a pneumatic screwdriver to fix a loose screw on my eyeglasses, I wouldn't pick a f/1.2 lens for my travel snapshots at f/8.

Yet some people will try to find an "universal winner" in all categories. Or will declare a lens as "best" without also mentioning the use case.
I don't think any one has tried to find a "universal winner," or declared there is one or even declared a lens as "best" without mentioning a use case. I agree that shouldn't happen and I am glad it hasn't.
Some did try, like Steve Spencer here: "the 200 f/2 VR is the best portrait lens for Nikon".

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1742143/1#15859081
The use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact. And it doesn't excuse one from making the connected statement.

Don't worry though, I can find other examples from the times when the RX1 lens was the best 35mm or when the 24 GM was the best E-mount 35mm ("when shot in crop mode").


Both true by the way IMHO
Nov 25, 2022 at 05:23 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.18 #8Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
vdo1 wrote:
The use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact.

I think it is not superfluous at all, assuming both parties can tell opinion from knowledge. I also think it is an important distinction, even if a vocal fraction in political discussions appears to disagree. And yes, what I'm writing here is merely my opinion.
Nov 25, 2022 at 09:52 AM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.18 #9Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
Daran wrote:
vdo1 wroteThe use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact.
I think it is not superfluous at all, assuming both parties can tell opinion from knowledge. I also think it is an important distinction, even if a vocal fraction in political discussions appears to disagree. And yes, what I'm writing here is merely my opinion.


if I were to write "The best VW sedan is the Passat 2019, IMHO", would the "IMHO" also disculpate me from implicitily affirming that a "best" sedan exists, or just from the opinion that the Passat 2019 is the one?


Nov 26, 2022 at 08:47 PM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.18 #10Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
vdo1 wrote:
Daran wrote
vdo1 wroteThe use of "IMHO" is superfluous, as everything is opinion unless it is an independently verifiable fact.
I think it is not superfluous at all, assuming both parties can tell opinion from knowledge. I also think it is an important distinction, even if a vocal fraction in political discussions appears to disagree. And yes, what I'm writing here is merely my opinion.
if I were to write "The best VW sedan is the Passat 2019, IMHO", would the "IMHO" also disculpate me from implicitily affirming that a "best" sedan exists, or just from the opinion that the Passat 2019 is the one?

It would clarify that you don't think your statement is the only possible valid statement about the subject, including acceptance that better informed opinions may exist. This is contrary to stating your experience or otherwise factual statements (e.g. this is the lightest 35mm by 5g), where any conflicting statements would have to imply that your statement is invalid (your are uninformed, mistaken, or deliberately lying).

Regarding the "best": problem rarely is whether it exists, but rather that there is no agreed upon definition of "good".

PS: in my opinion car analogies suck.
Nov 27, 2022 at 08:53 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

lensfan
Offline
Details
p.18 #11Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review


Little Island in NYC.
@1.4. Handheld. Wind. 1/6400. Electronic shutter/curtain.
Nov 27, 2022 at 10:01 PM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #12Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review


Nov 28, 2022 at 09:38 AM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #13Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
What happend to the "love" for this lens.....?

Sunrise & sunset images on the 9th of December


Dec 10, 2022 at 03:20 PM
jaggedhorizon
Offline
Details
p.18 #14Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
From a few days ago:






  ILCE-9    FE 35mm F1.4 GM lens    35mm    f/1.4    1/125s    800 ISO    0.0 EV  

Dec 11, 2022 at 02:01 PM
Oogappeltje
Offline
Details
p.18 #15Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
jaggedhorizon wrote:
From a few days ago:



Thats what I'm talking about. Lots of love in this picture! TFS

Dec 11, 2022 at 02:17 PM
Grenache
Offline
Details
p.18 #16Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
I don’t know about “best,” as I have not extensively used every possible 35 that can work on Sony, but the GM easily gives me the greatest reliability across a wide range of subjects. It is crazy sharp, has lovely bokeh, and I would say decent 3D character in good light. While fotogafur had a couple of well executed examples of how the 35 and 50 GMs create nearly identical images when subjects at middle distances are shot at equivalent framing, I can more easily get brilliant images with the 50 and 135 than the 35. This is likely user error and me being too conservative on aperture. Either way, the 35GM is a great lens, having now owned one for more than two years. I have sold off all of my other 35s and have rarely missed them.

Jim

These lenses I owned were easily outperformed by the 35GM:

Canon EF 35/1.4L
Nikon 35/1.4 Ai-S
Voigtlander 35/1.7 Ultron
Zeiss Milvus 35/1.4
Leica R 35/2 3-cam
Minolta 35/1.8 Rokkor
Loxia 35/2

These great lenses I have owned generated comparable quality images to the GM but ultimately were let go because of one or more areas (in parentheses) where the GM won out:

Zeiss ZE/ZF 35/1.4 (amazing but heavy on Sony; my most used 35 over the years)
Leica M 35/2 ASPH (sold my M9, this lens smears on Sony; otherwise wonderful)
Sony/Zeiss 35/1.4 ZA (stellar rendering but CA made landscape work frustrating)

These are lenses I have yet to own that I feel can offer rendering that the GM cannot (though are unlikely to be as versatile):

Leica M 35/1.4 pre-ASPH (not ideal on Sony but wonderful character)
Carl Zeiss Jena 35/2.4 (iconic 1950s-70s vintage look)

Couple of examples:

2020 lonely by Jim, on Flickr

Blue Vision by Jim, on Flickr

Shark Fin Cove by Jim, on Flickr

Good night coastline by Jim, on Flickr
Dec 11, 2022 at 05:20 PM
Peire
Offline
Details
p.18 #17Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
A7R2+Sony GM 35/1.4
























Dec 24, 2022 at 04:06 AM
SNJOps
Offline
Details
p.18 #18Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
From a shoot I did a few months ago with my 35mm GM stopped down to f2.8 - shot on my A7RIV




Dec 24, 2022 at 06:42 AM
JVan_02
Offline
Details
p.18 #19Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
Picked up this lens, got a fairly good copy. Some thoughts:

* Excellent color rendition, and further away from the occasional-frequent yellow emphasis you'll see with the 20 and 40 G lenses. Might actually be more accurate than my Batis 40, though I still prefer the 40 CF's rendition of color, slightly. There was a nice nuetrality to the reds and a saturation of the blues in the CF that reminded me of a color palette one would see in oil paintings. Still, the GM's color is very, very good. Easily 2nd place over all the lenses I've tried in ~24 years of shooting.
* Sharp, right from the word go. I'm not sure if it has a sharper central zone at 1.4 than the 20 G has at 1.8, but this is good enough that I really don't see the need of anything higher. As I've never owned a 1.4 since the C/Y 50mm 1.4 Planar, it's a goddamn treat to not have to do the mental math on whether the softness wide open or the higher noise from more acceptable apertures will have a greater negative effect on my image. Suffice it to say that the resolution from this lens seems like alien technology in comparison to what I cut my teeth on in the film days.
* AF is very good, but I think the AF on the 20 G and 40 G might be better still. This isn't surprising, as it has the same motors as the 20 G while that lens has smaller elements, and the 40 G might be the best AF lens I've ever used in that the motors seem excessive for the wafer thin elements on that lens. If there's one thing I'm disappointed by, and to be fair I'm stretching the definition here, it's that we didn't get one or two more motors with the GM badge over the 20 G.
* Bokeh is similarly excellent. I don't think it holds up quite to the 20 G in terms of quality due to the 20 G's excellent (lack of) optical vignetting, but you certainly get more of it than you do with the 20 G. I think 1.4 is best at mid-distance. At traditional portrait framing you can get like, half an iris in focus. While it's certainly a look, I don't think I'll be using it that often. It's certainly nothing I can fault the GM for, but it does raise the question of whether I'd rather have a f=1.8 or 2 that's more compact or the current 1.4 that has excellent use in low light.

In summation, there's barely anything to fault the lens for in terms of execution and almost everything to compliment Sony for here. The lens is astoundingly good, and even though I'm not sure I'd rather have a 2/1.8 it has been said nigh-innumerable times already how compact it is for the specs and performance. All-in-all, you're probably getting the best lens of its kind for a decent price. Highly-recommended.
Mar 12, 2023 at 09:46 AM
Kalainen
Offline
Details
p.18 #20Sony FE 35mm f/1.4 GM Review
JVan_02 wrote:
Picked up this lens, got a fairly good copy. Some thoughts:

* Excellent color rendition, and further away from the occasional-frequent yellow emphasis you'll see with the 20 and 40 G lenses. Might actually be more accurate than my Batis 40, though I still prefer the 40 CF's rendition of color, slightly. There was a nice nuetrality to the reds and a saturation of the blues in the CF that reminded me of a color palette one would see in oil paintings. Still, the GM's color is very, very good. Easily 2nd place over all the lenses I've tried in ~24
...Show more →

Nice to see you finally got the 35GM.

Looks like this will be a keeper and will finally solve the AF-issues you had with the Batis CF. Looking forward to see some pictures!
Mar 13, 2023 at 02:29 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister