Hi
My camera and lens combo is the A7C with the 35GM f/1.4 mounted.
When focusing is set to either Manual or DMF the focusing ring on the lens is sensitive. Touch it, as in touch it at all, and the camera/lens reacts immediately. When actually focusing the focus throw is very short.
How sensitive?
Here is an example. The camera was on tripod, and initially I focused at something. The distance between Camera and the target was 1.15 meters.
Then I focused at something else that was another 2.05 meters away from the camera.
Finally I focused at something else againC which in turn was another 0.7 meters away.
This was annoying so I measured
Focusing from 1.15 meters to 3.20 meters was done by turning the focusing ring approx. 11 degrees or 7.5mm.
Focusing from 3.20 meters to 3.90 meters demanded a mere 1.2 degree turn of the focusing ring. That is 0,8 mm (which I think is about 1/32 of an inch).
The short throw makes manual focusing a delicate task.
I wonder if it is the lens or the combination of the A7C and the 35GM? I think one of them needs a firmware update. Is it the same when using the 35GM with other cameras? No need to measure here, with my combo the difference compared to any other lens is obvious.
I just done a quick and nasty check there. Focussed on something about 1m away and then something about 2m away and it only turned about 5mm at a guess. I didn’t measure any of these distances with a tape but it did seem to overshoot the 2m target without much turning at all. I don’t manual focus much so won’t be an issue but seems to shift focus without much turning
Edit - let me know if you want me to check precisely and I’ll use a tripod and tape measure
xpfloyd wrote: I just done a quick and nasty check there. (...) this is with the a9ii
Thank you!
No need to measure, I think your impression is confirmation enough. In a way it is good that you notice this with an other camera model - it increases my hope for a firmware update (if a such is possible).
chez wrote: Unfortunately, many of the AF lenses suck at manual focus. There's nothing better than manually focusing with a lens designed for manual focus.
So it is. Then again I also like modern AF lenses for their other features. In this case very good resolution, flat field, resistance against flare and so on. Right now it is a bit finicky to focus manually though.
Seems like something that could be updated with firmware. I noticed the focus throw was pretty short on the 135GM for MF astro work. Especially compared to the sigma 85 DG DN.
This is a firmware decision by Sony. They need to add a menu option for adjusting manual focusing speed and an option for linear performance. My panasonic S1 and S1r offer these options and it makes manual focusing, even with the fly-by-wire lenses, extremely pleasant. I have it set to where it takes almost a full turn to go from mfd to infinity. Really nice for deliberate careful focusing and manual focus stacking. When I mount my Canon EF lenses via a converter the fast focus throw is always irritating.
When I get some time I’ll do a more accurate check between the 24GM, 35GM and 135GM. Like I said I don’t MF with these particular lenses but this has got me curious now, want to see if there’s much difference between them all
I can't say my measures were high precision exact. It isn't easy to measure 0,8 mm with the marks done on a tape attached to a focusing ring. But, the numbers certainly differ between the three lenses I tried.
Starting point was, as mentioned, a defined target at a distance of 1.15 meters.
The next target was 3.2 meters away and the last target at 3.9 meters. Manually focusing between the two last targets was a challenge with the 35GM.
With the Samyang I took care moving the focusing ring slowly. The SY35 was a pleasure to focus manually compared to the GM despite the GM's better resolution and higher contrast.
The SMC-P FA31/1.8 Limited is pure mechanics and known to be a bit finicky to focus manually as the focusing ring isn't damped (an old type screw drive AF lens.
The numbers were calculated by measuring the diameter (girth?) of the lenses, multiplying with pi and dividing by 360, translating millimeters to grades - well, you get it. Not exact as mentioned but good enough for a comparison in this case.