Hi - I'm trying the Canon RF 35mm f1.8 lens on the Canon 5R and finding it's not very sharp at infinity focus for landscapes. It's adequate at f5.6 - f8 but not better than adequate at infinity focus. . . . At closer focusing distances, such as for portraits, etc. it's extremely sharp. . . . Has anyone else had the same experience? I'm thinking that I should try the Canon EF 35mm f2 IS lens with an adapter. It will be bigger and doesn't do macro, but from what I gather, it should be a better all around lens with better rending. Thoughts?
My observation is that everything closer than about 12" creates 3/4 of the noise, slowness, and irritation. Wish it has a lockout switch for non-macro use. See my video here.
Ben (Optics Patent) - How do you find the lens at infinity focus at f5.6 - f8 away from the center - midfield and corners? Is it in your video? . . . I don't watch videos, but if you tell me it's covered in your video, I'll watch, I guess. Thanks!
I just got the 35/1.8 yesterday and just fiddling with it around the house, I found mine to be very sharp (sharp enough for me as the R + 35 isn't my main camera). What I've found with mine is that the focus in video is S - L - O - W. Like... painfully so. And not particularly accurate in my limited experience. I was hoping I could use it as a sort of tabletop review setup for my YouTube channel, but the old 28/3.5 EF-M lens on the Canon M5 was MUCH faster.
I'm still on the fence as to whether or not I'll keep the 35 at this point. Canon needs to do better.
httivals wrote:
Ben (Optics Patent) - How do you find the lens at infinity focus at f5.6 - f8 away from the center - midfield and corners? Is it in your video? . . . I don't watch videos, but if you tell me it's covered in your video, I'll watch, I guess. Thanks!
No complaints. Great lens. But I sold it in favor of 15-35, 24-70, Nifty 50, "Hefty 50."
I find the 50 f1.8 EF STM has slow focus, which makes it pretty useless for anything moving rapidly. Perhaps its the same with the 35 RF? Shame, for street shooting a fast AF is an asset.
The 35mm RF has quick autofocus, actually, on a 5R. It's an excellent lens, for example, for taking photos of two rambunctious dogs playing and holds focus admirably.
But at infinity distances it's soft in the midfield even at f8, at least for the two copies I've tried. I have a Canon EF35 mm f2 IS on the way from lensrentals and will test it against that lens as well as against my Sony 35mm f2.8 on an A7RIV over the week-end, to get a comparative assessment.
The other thing I'm seeing with the 35mm RF is that it has significant chromatic aberration, which is a pet peeve. This is not uncommon in 35mm lenses in this category (Sony 35mm f1.8 has the same defect), but I really dislike this characteristic. I am optimistic that the EF 35mm f2 IS will address these optical defects, although it will be significantly larger with an RF adapter, so I'll need to see how it balances and feels.
I'm also considering the 28mm ef f2.8 IS as an alternative for a moderate wide angle prime, and just cropping when I want the 35mm perspective. The 28mm EF f2.8 IS is quite a bit smaller than the 35mm and lighter, which makes up for the addition of the RF adapter.
One thing that's becoming apparent to me is how much better the Sony FE prime lens options are than the Canon RF options. Although the Canon 70 - 200 mm and 70-300mm options in EF and RF are so much better than the Sony options . . .
Guess I'll be using two full frame systems for awhile.
matthewm wrote:
I just got the 35/1.8 yesterday and just fiddling with it around the house, I found mine to be very sharp (sharp enough for me as the R + 35 isn't my main camera). What I've found with mine is that the focus in video is S - L - O - W. Like... painfully so. And not particularly accurate in my limited experience. I was hoping I could use it as a sort of tabletop review setup for my YouTube channel, but the old 28/3.5 EF-M lens on the Canon M5 was MUCH faster.
I'm still on the fence as to whether or not I'll keep the 35 at this point. Canon needs to do better....Show more →
The AF is slowed to a crawl in video so it can be silent. You can see the AF is pretty fast when doing stills, but you can hear a motor whine.
tkbslc wrote: matthewm wroteI just got the 35/1.8 yesterday and just fiddling with it around the house, I found mine to be very sharp (sharp enough for me as the R + 35 isn't my main camera). What I've found with mine is that the focus in video is S - L - O - W. Like... painfully so. And not particularly accurate in my limited experience. I was hoping I could use it as a sort of tabletop review setup for my YouTube channel, but the old 28/3.5 EF-M lens on the Canon M5 was MUCH faster.
I'm still on the fence as to whether or not I'll keep the 35 at this point. Canon needs to do better.The AF is slowed to a crawl in video so it can be silent. You can see the AF is pretty fast when doing stills, but you can hear a motor whine.
Yeah. It's absolutely useless for video. Canon's approach to mirrorless continues to suck. Unless you have many thousands of dollars to spend on their lenses. Or want to use their SLR lenses in which case you should just stick with a DSLR.
I'm very satisfied with optical performance, but very disappointed by autofocus performance (on R5).
Usually i use only AF-C and in this mode lens is oscillating back and forth around the subject and many photos are slightly out of focus ...
matthewm wrote: tkbslc wrotematthewm wroteI just got the 35/1.8 yesterday and just fiddling with it around the house, I found mine to be very sharp (sharp enough for me as the R + 35 isn't my main camera). What I've found with mine is that the focus in video is S - L - O - W. Like... painfully so. And not particularly accurate in my limited experience. I was hoping I could use it as a sort of tabletop review setup for my YouTube channel, but the old 28/3.5 EF-M lens on the Canon M5 was MUCH faster.
I'm still on the fence as to whether or not I'll keep the 35 at this point. Canon needs to do better.The AF is slowed to a crawl in video so it can be silent. You can see the AF is pretty fast when doing stills, but you can hear a motor whine.Yeah. It's absolutely useless for video. Canon's approach to mirrorless continues to suck. Unless you have many thousands of dollars to spend on their lenses. Or want to use their SLR lenses in which case you should just stick with a DSLR.
I personally don't use AF for video with any lens. Even with fast and silent lenses, the focus often finds the wrong thing or hunts the wrong way and then it is extremely distracting. You probably didn't notice this with your 28mm f3.5 on crop because the DOF was so deep. With the 35mm f1.8 at product review distances, you likely can't get much of the product in focus just due to DOF. Maybe try stopping down to f5.6 (which is equivalent to f3.5 on crop) and you might see some better accuracy.
I'm not going to go with "Canon continues to suck" because I like the lens. But I would have preferred nano-USM for sure. The 24-105L and 24-240 have much better focus motors.
Reporting back on the RF 35mm f1.8, after having used it for about a week now. On balance, I'm very happy with the lens. Mainly I'll be using it as a general "walk-around" lens, family photos, etc. and for that it's about perfect. Amazing autofocus on the R5, compared to my Sony A7RIV. It's not as sharp as the EF 35mm f2 IS for landscapes that I rented at infinity focus on the RF. But it's nicely sharp across the frame by f5.6 at infinity focus.
For closer distances it's great to use even wide open. A nice surprise is that it has nice sunstars at f11 without flare; so that increases the usefulness quite a bit to me for landscapes. . . . I'm also finding that using DXO PhotoLab 4 is sharper with the 5R files than Capture One, and it's also better with noise using Deep Prime. The EF 35mm f2 IS is a great lens, but a lot heavier and bigger with the RF adapter, and the autofocus seems a bit slower than with the RF. I've tried two brand new copies of the 35mm f1.8. One is quite a bit better and more even across the frame than the other.
httivals wrote:
It's not as sharp as the EF 35mm f2 IS for landscapes that I rented at infinity focus on the RF.
This surprises me somewhat; the EF 35/2 IS is a nice lens for what it is and I do enjoy using mine, but I've never found it to be particularly sharp. I've also seen some pretty distracting rendering from it as shot by others, though I haven't yet encountered (or engineered) the appropriate subject to bring that out. Not EF 35/1.4L II bad, of course, that's a pretty high bar, but enough that I was hesitant to pick up the 35/2 when I did.
I should probably go shoot more landscapes with it!
johnctharp wrote:
I've also seen some pretty distracting rendering from it as shot by others, though I haven't yet encountered (or engineered) the appropriate subject to bring that out. Not EF 35/1.4L II bad, of course, that's a pretty high bar, but enough that I was hesitant to pick up the 35/2 when I did.
I should probably go shoot more landscapes with it!
Can you elaborate on what exactly you mean by that. I have shot landscape with the 35L II and never seen an issue (so far)
I just shot the RF35 and EF35 on my R5 and my RF35 was a tad sharper. I would say they're okay but not on a L level or Sony GM level that I'm shooting now. Of course it's only 1/3 the price so you get what you pay for.
jj1804 wrote:
Can you elaborate on what exactly you mean by that. I have shot landscape with the 35L II and never seen an issue (so far)
Foliage in the transition zone has been wildly noisy in some user samples. Otherwise excellent photography exhibiting extremely noisy backgrounds.
Of note, I can't speak to the rate of occurrence, nor whether it was enhanced or suppressed by postprocessing, just that it jumped off the screen when present.