I am a Canon shooter (7D Mark II but R5 on the way). i shoot mostly wildlife but also some landscape, and of course the occasional obligatory family event. I currently have the Canon 420EX Speedlite, which I got back in 2004. I have tried using it for fill flash, with a Better Beamer, but the cycle time isn't there and it isn't powerful enough for subjects further away. (works fine for those family events) I am looking to soften shadows and/or add catch light.
The Canon Speedlite 600EX-RT looks like the right Canon choice for my needs but at $449US ($600CDN plus taxes) I am looking for more economical alternatives. Recycle time is very important - hoping to use at reduced power during slowish burst speeds. Coverage/range and auto zoom head would seem to be key considerations, as would the Guide number. Decent build would be important too.
I used the B&H site for my research, as it lists 103 flashes for the Canon camera. Looking at recycle time, Guide numbers and auto zoom head left me with the Canon flash, two Godox flashes and one Yongnuo. After further research I dropped the Yongnuo and the Godox TT685C Thinklite; leaving me with:
Canon 600EX-RT: $449, Guide 197', 20-200mm range, auto zoom head, .1 to 5.5s recycle time, 1 - 1/128 power, AA batteries
Godox VING V860IIC: $179, Guide 197', 20-200mm, auto zoom, .1 to 1.5s recycle, 1 - 1/128 power, Li-Ion battery (inc.)
The Canon got about 4.9 on 1080 reviews while the godox got about 4.5 on 301 reviews. The Godox is $270US ($360CDN) less expensive than the Canon.
The Godox looks very tempting BUT the applicable negative reviews it did get were around the shoe mount not being of great construction, a poorly written manual (as in English was a weak second language) and unresponsive customer support.
So my questions are:
1. For those who are actually using flash for fill on wildlife (especially birds), are there any other flashes I should look at?
2. For anybody who uses the Godox V860IIC flash in any way, thoughts on build? Manual? Customer service?
3. Am I putting too much emphasis on the Guide number and 20-200mm range for my intended purpose?
4. Am I overlooking any other important considerations?
I used to own the Canon 580II, but I sold one and the other broke and I refuse to spend $500 or more for a speedlight. Instead, I bought into the Flashpoint ecosystem; 2x Flashpoint speedlight (caught $40 off sale), XPLOR 600 HSS TTL mono light and trigger. The Flashpoint speedlight comes with the li-ion battery that last longer than AA batteries and has better recycle time. I no longer need to carry a bunch of rechargeable AA batteries and battery pack. I also use the better beamer flash extender. I don't use the flash all the time, but it does work great even on sunny days to open up the shadow areas. When I started out, I always used ETTL, but as time went on, I experimented with HSS and manual settings and found 1/16 work well and could get more pops out of the flash vs ETTL. I use flash compensation to get it dialed in. With the Flashpoint speedlight, I no longer need to use a battery pack, which got in the way of shooting at times. The Li-ion battery lasted quiet long. I could also use the trigger in the hot shoe, but figure a direct connection with the cable would eliminate any potential communication issues between camera and flash. One day I will try using the trigger. You just have to get out and use it and find what works best for you.
Canon has introduced their new speedlight that comes with the better battery, but it costs $1100.
One option to consider is the Godox AD200. The head can be removed from the pack and connected with a cable. The head can then be hot-shoe/bracket mounted. The fresnel head can take speedlight gadgets and the round head or bulb head w/Profoto adapter will take any Profoto reflectors like the Magnum (adds 1 stop effective light) or Telezoom, etc.
If don't need 200ws, you'll get faster recycle at lower power and battery will last longer vs. speedlight.
Methodical, how long have you had the Godox/Flashpoint flashes? Which model(s)? Has anything broken on them? Does they function as they first did? How is the battery (charge time, # of flashes now vs when first bought, etc.)? Any overheating issues? Overall were you happy with them and are you still happy with them?
Conner999, thanks for the tip on the AD200. It looks very impressive. I definitely do like the idea of Li-Ion battery over AAs. My problem is I just bought the Canon R5 and will be buying extra camera batteries, CFexpress cards and a card reader this Black Friday. Moving from APS-C (7D Mark II) to FF, I will be looking to buy a used Canon EF 500 f/4 II (probably wait until used prices drop when the Canon RF 500 f/4 comes out next year). So while I want to get a good flash, I do need to reap some savings compared to the Canon Speedlite 600EX-RT. The AD200 is only $30 cheaper.
Unless Canon starts accepting Monopoly money, I won't ever be buying their new $1100 flash!
I've had the Flashpoint speedlight (item in link above) since April 2018.
1. Nothing is broken on the flash.
2. I've had no overheating issues and I've used them with high shutter speed.
3. It fires rapidly and pretty much keeps up with fast shooting.
4. Battery life is really good...way better than AA. With the 580II, I had to use 4 batteries in the flash and 8 batteries in the battery pack (12 AAA) and I carried spares; the one Li-ion battery is still better.
I am very satisfied with the Flashpoint and purchased a 2nd flash early this year.
Conner999 wrote:
One option to consider is the Godox AD200. The head can be removed from the pack and connected with a cable. The head can then be hot-shoe/bracket mounted. The fresnel head can take speedlight gadgets and the round head or bulb head w/Profoto adapter will take any Profoto reflectors like the Magnum (adds 1 stop effective light) or Telezoom, etc.
If don't need 200ws, you'll get faster recycle at lower power and battery will last longer vs. speedlight.
Do you have any photos of that setup? I'd like to see that. Also, can you install a better beamer onto the flash head?
Thanks again Methodical. Read your post, got pulled away from the computer, came back and didn't click on the link. Can see now that your Flashpoint is the V860IIC, the same as the Godox I was looking at. This is very good to know.
i can't find anything on Godox flashes / Better Beamer compatibility. Are you using the FX-6? If yes, does it fit properly or did you need to use "shims"? BB doesn't make anything for the 420EX so I ended up using shims that were just felt furniture padding cut into small strips.
I don't do birds, etc, so no Beamer, but here are some shots of the gear. The dirty remote is for scale ;>
The AD200 base unit connected via the cable extension to the rectangular 'speedlight' head and with the round '(new) Profoto style' head. The rectangular is the same size as a speedlight.
i do stand corrected on one thing - the Profoto adapter (seen in last pic on main body) won't fit the round head when on the extension as the cable and tilt control get in the way. Some Dremel work would fix. The main body, while heavier than a speedlight, should fit on a good flash bracket.
Methodical wrote: Conner999 wroteOne option to consider is the Godox AD200. The head can be removed from the pack and connected with a cable. The head can then be hot-shoe/bracket mounted. The fresnel head can take speedlight gadgets and the round head or bulb head w/Profoto adapter will take any Profoto reflectors like the Magnum (adds 1 stop effective light) or Telezoom, etc.
If don't need 200ws, you'll get faster recycle at lower power and battery will last longer vs. speedlight.Do you have any photos of that setup? I'd like to see that. Also, can you install a better beamer onto the flash head?