p.1 #4Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
#1 Yes as EF Extenders are optically and mechanically designed specifically for EF lenses not RF lenses.
#2 No. See my answer to #1 above. I doubt that the Canon brand RF to EF adapter will mechanically fit or even have the correct focus range/infinity focus in this setup senario and would likely not be optically corrected for that extender/lens combination.
p.1 #5Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
Very unlikely #2 will be compatible. With Sony TC it only works with some Metabones. The Canon RF TCs look to have an even bigger extension than the Sony FE ones.
I think you will be forced to use EF TCs when adapting.
p.1 #7Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
The RF teleconverter is in the correct distance from the sensor. The EF lens with adapter is in the correct position for the RF flange without TC, hence it must also be in the correct position for the RF teleconverter. We are used to thinking that the EF teleconverter must be directly on the lens for correct focus, but the RF teleconverter is designed to be in another place than the EF teleconverter, relative to the sensor. So that part is going to work. The extending parts are big, but there is an upside for Canon to make it fit. Many more EF lenses can be used with TC's.
p.1 #8Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
The TCs are not just extension tubes with no elements. The lenses inside change the throw of the image plane to meet the appropriate place where the sensor will be.
We know that the first version works, as I'm using it right now on an EOS R. I don't have any reason to think that the new TC won't work as well, as it'll be taking in light from the front and projecting it appropriately to the back.
We sometimes hear about TCs being "tuned" to the big whites, but I've never heard of a specific example of such tuning. I *have* seen examples of BS tuning, such as the sigma TC with the Sigma 500 f/4, which turned out to be a very good - but slightly inferior - TC in all ways across all lenses, without any evidence of the marketing department's "tuning" for that particular f/4 lens - of which I owned 2 copies over time. In terms of the glass inside the new RF TC, I doubt that it has been tuned in any fashion that would jeopardize its performance on the only big white f/4s available right now for RF... which are EF lenses.
The upshot: I suspect both work. I have the 1.4x RF version on pre-order, and when I get it I'll report back here not only whether it fits/works, but how the two different TC configurations compare for autofocus and image quality.
p.1 #10Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
arbitrage wrote: alundeb wroteI am positive on #2I’ll take that bet
So what is the stake? I already owe the whole FM alt community pizza for the 28 Otus being 1.4
p.1 #11Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
alundeb wrote: arbitrage wrotealundeb wroteI am positive on #2I’ll take that betSo what is the stake? I already owe the whole FM alt community pizza for the 28 Otus being 1.4
I don’t know, maybe I’ll cover your pizza debt if I lose and if I win you can buy us all a round of beer to go with the pizza
I agree that optically it could work as it works with a Sony FE TC, Metabones and then EF lens. I just don’t think it will physically fit. But it would be a smart idea if Canon ensures it fit so they could sell some more of those outrageously priced RF TCs.
p.1 #14Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
#1 The EF lens and converter are made to work at those distances apart and the RF adpater is meant to be a specific length for the EF-RF sensor spacing.
In scenario #2, the RF converters are made to be a specific distance between RF lens rear mount and the converter/sensor.
We know #1 will work because it works on the R and Canon has said that the combinations will work on the R5/6. I doubt scenario #2 will work or Canon would have made the claim already because there would be a pre-order demand.
p.1 #15Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
The proper way should be #1. The TC is designed to be in a certain position wrsp to the lens. The RF adapter is just a tube.
I wouldn't use #2 unless Canon specifies it for some reason.
Ideally there should be a combined TC/adapter.
p.1 #16Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
EB-1 wrote:
The proper way should be #1. The TC is designed to be in a certain position wrsp to the lens. The RF adapter is just a tube.
I wouldn't use #2 unless Canon specifies it for some reason.
Ideally there should be a combined TC/adapter.
EBH
Exactly. There must be a reason for that protrusion's front element needing to be close the lenses rear element.
p.1 #17Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
Zenon Char wrote: EB-1 wroteThe proper way should be #1. The TC is designed to be in a certain position wrsp to the lens. The RF adapter is just a tube.
I wouldn't use #2 unless Canon specifies it for some reason.
Ideally there should be a combined TC/adapter.
EBHExactly. There must be a reason for that protrusion's front element needing to be close the lenses rear element.
It might work with the loss of infinity focus (separating the TC and lens acts as an extension tube) and/or the loss of autofocus. I could have sworn when I had the GFX that I could put the extension tubes either behind or in front of the TCs, and it still worked (for non-infinity macro of course). Issue for incompatibility could be: it causes a firmware error; it won't physically mount in that order; or, the electronic connections don't match up.
p.1 #19Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
highdesertmesa wrote:
Wonder if the RF TCs will be stackable like the EFs.
That is pretty much impossible with a protruding front element to the extreme we see here. But just like Sony FE they may be able to stack with a 25mm extension tube (like the Mark III EF ones).
p.1 #20Which extenders for EF lenses on RF cameras?
arbitrage wrote: highdesertmesa wroteWonder if the RF TCs will be stackable like the EFs.That is pretty much impossible with a protruding front element to the extreme we see here. But just like Sony FE they may be able to stack with a 25mm extension tube (like the Mark III EF ones).
So a small downgrade from EF TC III functionality that let you stack: body > 1.4x > 2x > lens. Not that the IQ or f/stop was acceptable that way anyway, though.