fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO

  
 
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.17 #1RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
padam19 wrote:
arbitrage wroteIs there still hope for this one?

Not like that, no.
There will probably be a new RF 600mm f/4 DO lens at some point (and I wouldn't rule out an 800mm f/5.6 either, 300mm f/2.8 isn't that young either), but they will not rush it and pricing will be inevitably higher on that one.

Since Nikon did not upgrade their 400mm f/2.8 and 600mm f/4 lenses to the same level as Canon, I would expect them to come out with the mirrorless equivalents earlier than Canon.


How about a Z600mm f5.6S?
The Z S-line lenses are very, very sharp with lots of detail and a very nice rendering. I would assume that with the right AF hardware a Nikon Z600S on the coming Z7s would be a much more enticing proposition than the 600 and 800F11 lenses on a 4500,- body
Jul 08, 2020 at 02:58 PM
quantumloop
Offline
Details
p.17 #2RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
arbitrage wrote:
Is there still hope for this one?



Arbitrage..(I think your name is Geoff!)...you obviously are incredible with your bird photography and have great experience with all of the major brands of equipment, and I take it that you really like the Canon 400 DO II lens. Do you mind briefly explaining why? And in your estimation how does it compare with the Nikon 500 PF/300PF lenses? Obviously the 400 DO II is a lot more expensive and so one would hope that offers better optical qualities.

BTW, I hope that Canon introduces some higher end DO lenses for the RF lineup. One would think that would eventually happen.

Thanks.



Jul 08, 2020 at 03:36 PM
padam19
Offline
Details
p.17 #3RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
ChrisMak wrote:
padam19 wrote
arbitrage wroteIs there still hope for this one?

Not like that, no.
There will probably be a new RF 600mm f/4 DO lens at some point (and I wouldn't rule out an 800mm f/5.6 either, 300mm f/2.8 isn't that young either), but they will not rush it and pricing will be inevitably higher on that one.

Since Nikon did not upgrade their 400mm f/2.8 and 600mm f/4 lenses to the same level as Canon, I would expect them to come out with the mirrorless equivalents earlier than Canon.
How about a Z600mm f5.6S?
The Z S-line lenses are very, very sharp with lots of detail and a very nice rendering. I would assume that with the right AF hardware a Nikon Z600S on the coming Z7s would be a much more enticing proposition than the 600 and 800F11 lenses on a 4500,- body


Of course, it would be at least 4600$ though, so proportionally more than the 2 extra stops of light compared to the 600mm f/11 DO for a mere 700$

If we compare the Nikon 800/5.6 FL to the Canon 800/11 DO the difference is even more brutal for those 2 extra stops, it is 900$ versus 16200$ nice!

I am sure the Nikon is a lot sharper and the AF is a lot faster as well. It should be for that kind of money.

But ain't that exciting for those who can't justify the cost and don't fancy heavier gear...
Jul 08, 2020 at 04:18 PM
ChrisMak
Offline
Details
p.17 #4RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
padam19 wrote:
ChrisMak wrote
padam19 wrote
arbitrage wroteIs there still hope for this one?

Not like that, no.
There will probably be a new RF 600mm f/4 DO lens at some point (and I wouldn't rule out an 800mm f/5.6 either, 300mm f/2.8 isn't that young either), but they will not rush it and pricing will be inevitably higher on that one.

Since Nikon did not upgrade their 400mm f/2.8 and 600mm f/4 lenses to the same level as Canon, I would expect them to come out with the mirrorless equivalents earlier than Canon.
How about a Z600mm f5.6S?
The Z S-line lenses are very, very sharp with lots of detail and a very nice rendering. I would assume that with the right AF hardware a Nikon Z600S on the coming Z7s would be a much more enticing proposition than the 600 and 800F11 lenses on a 4500,- body
Of course, it would be at least 4600$ though, so proportionally more than the 2 extra stops of light compared to the 600mm f/11 DO for a mere 700$

If we compare the Nikon 800/5.6 FL to the Canon 800/11 DO the difference is even more brutal for those 2 extra stops, it is 900$ versus 16200$ nice!

I am sure the Nikon is a lot sharper and the AF is a lot faster as well. It should be for that kind of money.

But ain't that exciting for those who can't justify the cost and don't fancy heavier gear...


True, both 600/11 and 800/11 lenses are an unexpected move by Canon, but should be very nice when used in very good light. It is just an odd idea to spend 4500,- on a body for these lenses. Nikon has the 3000,- Z7 at 46mp, and even the 800,- Z50 when you want to go really low with equivalent pixel density.

I sold the Canon 400DOII reluctantly, mostly because the R-line has no 1.6x crop option a la 7DII, forcing you to go up FF, but then you sacrifice a lot of pixel density, unless you spend 4500,- on a R5.
I find the system lacks balance of bodies and lenses. Still, as a Canon user you have no choice but to embrace the system, unless you want to shoot the aging 7DII forever.

Jul 08, 2020 at 05:04 PM
padam19
Offline
Details
p.17 #5RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
ChrisMak wrote:
True, both 600/11 and 800/11 lenses are an unexpected move by Canon, but should be very nice when used in very good light. It is just an odd idea to spend 4500,- on a body for these lenses. Nikon has the 3000,- Z7 at 46mp, and even the 800,- Z50 when you want to go really low with equivalent pixel density.

I sold the Canon 400DOII reluctantly, mostly because the R-line has no 1.6x crop option a la 7DII, forcing you to go up FF, but then you sacrifice a lot of pixel density, unless you spend 4500,- on a
...Show more →

It's still very much a new system, so it's inevitably going to be lacking in terms of lenses (just like Nikon, not to mention Panasonic), and it relies on those old EF lenses for now.

I wonder if the RF teleconverters will work with EF lenses with the adapter.
The extra glass due to the space with the flange probably can improve the performance over the EF III teleconverters, I am just not sure if they implement the correct function with these old lenses.

For instance, m43 teleconverters did work with 43 SLR lenses and m43 adapters with less IQ degradation, but the camera did not know that there was a teleconverter in the chain, so the IBIS worked incorrectly.
Jul 08, 2020 at 05:46 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.17 #6RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Stepper motors....not weather sealed....accept both TCs....R5/R6 can AF at f/22
Jul 09, 2020 at 06:29 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #7RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
MTF for the 800. Looks good in the center, not so hot in the edges:






Jul 09, 2020 at 06:31 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #8RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
These lenses are fixed aperture. f/11 only.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:06 AM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.17 #9RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Even that's fairly meh, even in the center. That's worse sharpness than the 100-400mm II with a 2X TC attached. I wouldn't expect it to match L glass bare, but to be worse than a zoom lens with a 2x on it is a little disappointing for a prime lens.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:12 AM
deepbluejh
Offline
Details
p.17 #10RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Not sure I'd call that "meh" in the center, but whatever. Agree edge sharpness isn't wonderful, but will it even matter? At 800mm its very likely you're photographing animals or the moon, and not landscapes. It might not work for everyone, but given the price differential between this and the 800/5.6L, it will find many buyers.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:16 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #11RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
Jman13 wrote:
Even that's fairly meh, even in the center. That's worse sharpness than the 100-400mm II with a 2X TC attached. I wouldn't expect it to match L glass bare, but to be worse than a zoom lens with a 2x on it is a little disappointing for a prime lens.


No it's better than the 100-400 II + 2X TC.

These are the new type of MTF charts which account for diffraction. The center sharpness of the 800 is truly diffraction limited.

See how the 100-400 II with 2X TC performs in the same type of MTF chart here:

https://cweb.canon.jp/ef/lineup/extender/extender-ef2-iii/spec.html







Edited on Jul 09, 2020 at 07:53 AM · View previous versions
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:17 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.17 #12RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
ChrisMak wrote:
padam19 wrote
ChrisMak wrote
padam19 wrote
arbitrage wroteIs there still hope for this one?

Not like that, no.
There will probably be a new RF 600mm f/4 DO lens at some point (and I wouldn't rule out an 800mm f/5.6 either, 300mm f/2.8 isn't that young either), but they will not rush it and pricing will be inevitably higher on that one.

Since Nikon did not upgrade their 400mm f/2.8 and 600mm f/4 lenses to the same level as Canon, I would expect them to come out with the mirrorless equivalents earlier than Canon.
How about a Z600mm f5.6S?
The Z S-line lenses are very, very sharp with lots of detail and a very nice rendering. I would assume that with the right AF hardware a Nikon Z600S on the coming Z7s would be a much more enticing proposition than the 600 and 800F11 lenses on a 4500,- body
Of course, it would be at least 4600$ though, so proportionally more than the 2 extra stops of light compared to the 600mm f/11 DO for a mere 700$

If we compare the Nikon 800/5.6 FL to the Canon 800/11 DO the difference is even more brutal for those 2 extra stops, it is 900$ versus 16200$ nice!

I am sure the Nikon is a lot sharper and the AF is a lot faster as well. It should be for that kind of money.

But ain't that exciting for those who can't justify the cost and don't fancy heavier gear...
True, both 600/11 and 800/11 lenses are an unexpected move by Canon, but should be very nice when used in very good light. It is just an odd idea to spend 4500,- on a body for these lenses. Nikon has the 3000,- Z7 at 46mp, and even the 800,- Z50 when you want to go really low with equivalent pixel density.

I sold the Canon 400DOII reluctantly, mostly because the R-line has no 1.6x crop option a la 7DII, forcing you to go up FF, but then you sacrifice a lot of pixel density, unless you spend 4500,- on a
...Show more →

I think the 600 and 800 f11's are aimed directly at the RP and R6 users. They're tiny, cheap and long. Just what the newbie wildlife shooter needs. The 600 in particular seems to me as a perfect emergency tele for a landscape shooter who goes backcountry a fair bit. It's small and cheap.

Lenses like these has this Nikon/Fuji shooter looking hard at the RF system. The 600 is excellent for my light usage of tele's.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:38 AM
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.17 #13RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO


Jul 09, 2020 at 07:38 AM
JohanEickmeyer
Offline
Details
p.17 #14RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
alundeb wrote:
MTF for the 800. Looks good in the center, not so hot in the edges:



You gotta stop it down a couple of stops to get better edges.

Joking aside, the MTF is for f11, so hard to say how the MTF compares at f11 to other lenses.

The sample images in 4K look pretty nice.

https://youtu.be/O_B3bs7d76U

Edited on Jul 09, 2020 at 07:42 AM · View previous versions
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:39 AM
dolina
Offline
Details
p.17 #15RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
F/11 lens prices

600mm = $699, 930 grams
800mm = $899, 1260 grams

RF 1.4x TC = $499
RF 2.0x TC = $599

https://youtu.be/EZ9y5YCHnn8

Perfect birding lenses that are COVID-19 budget & back friendly
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:40 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #16RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
JohanEickmeyer wrote:
alundeb wroteMTF for the 800. Looks good in the center, not so hot in the edges:
You gotta stop it down a couple of stops to get better edges.

Joking aside, the MTF is for f11, so hard to say how the MTF compares at f11 to other lenses.

The sample images in 4K look pretty nice.

https://youtu.be/O_B3bs7d76U


But it can't be stopped down. Fixed aperture, zero aperture blades.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:44 AM
deepbluejh
Offline
Details
p.17 #17RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
alundeb wrote:
Jman13 wroteEven that's fairly meh, even in the center. That's worse sharpness than the 100-400mm II with a 2X TC attached. I wouldn't expect it to match L glass bare, but to be worse than a zoom lens with a 2x on it is a little disappointing for a prime lens.
No it's better than the 100-400 II + 2X TC.

These are the new type of MTF charts which account for diffraction. The center sharpness of the 800 is truly diffraction limited.

See how the 100-400 II with 2X TC performs in the same type of MTF chart here:

https://cweb.canon.jp/ef/lineup/extender/extender-ef2-iii/spec.html


Looks like the 800 is as good as the 100-400II is at 400mm, without a TC. Decent performance, especially considering the price.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:45 AM
JohanEickmeyer
Offline
Details
p.17 #18RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
alundeb wrote:
JohanEickmeyer wrote
alundeb wroteMTF for the 800. Looks good in the center, not so hot in the edges:
You gotta stop it down a couple of stops to get better edges.

Joking aside, the MTF is for f11, so hard to say how the MTF compares at f11 to other lenses.

The sample images in 4K look pretty nice.

https://youtu.be/O_B3bs7d76U
But it can't be stopped down. Fixed aperture, zero aperture blades.


Ughh.... that's the joke...
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:47 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #19RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
deepbluejh wrote:
alundeb wrote
Jman13 wroteEven that's fairly meh, even in the center. That's worse sharpness than the 100-400mm II with a 2X TC attached. I wouldn't expect it to match L glass bare, but to be worse than a zoom lens with a 2x on it is a little disappointing for a prime lens.
No it's better than the 100-400 II + 2X TC.

These are the new type of MTF charts which account for diffraction. The center sharpness of the 800 is truly diffraction limited.

See how the 100-400 II with 2X TC performs in the same type of MTF chart here:

https://cweb.canon.jp/ef/lineup/extender/extender-ef2-iii/spec.html
Looks like the 800 is as good as the 100-400II is at 400mm, without a TC. Decent performance, especially considering the price.


Don't know if you are referring to the charts shown, but that is actually with the 2X even if it says 400 mm.

Looking at the MTF charts for the 100-500 with extenders, it is very close to the 800 at 700 mm with the 1,4X. Looks like the 100-500 will be my choice, but I really want to see images from both.
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:48 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.17 #20RF 600mm F11 DO and 800mm F11 DO
JohanEickmeyer wrote:
alundeb wrote
JohanEickmeyer wrote
alundeb wroteMTF for the 800. Looks good in the center, not so hot in the edges:
You gotta stop it down a couple of stops to get better edges.

Joking aside, the MTF is for f11, so hard to say how the MTF compares at f11 to other lenses.

The sample images in 4K look pretty nice.

https://youtu.be/O_B3bs7d76U
But it can't be stopped down. Fixed aperture, zero aperture blades.
Ughh.... that's the joke...


I though the joke was f/22 being better than f/11
Jul 09, 2020 at 07:50 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister