fredmiranda.com Login

Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame

  
 
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Iunno, I shot with just the CV 10mm for a few months exclusively, and those definitely look wider. A little birdie told me Laowa is working on a 7.5mm FF for Sony, is this true? lol
Jun 24, 2020 at 08:12 AM
Bob_S
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
I probably shouldn't be typing 'shooting 9mm'.
Jun 24, 2020 at 04:02 PM
MAubrey
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Bob_S wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Bob_S wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Bob_S wroteNo offense, but there is t a single shot I can see that couldn't be shot with a 10, 11 or 12mm.

If you're going to demonstrate the lens you need to leverage it's only strength, the unique perspective, which wasn't done.

Yes, that's going to be difficult, which is why the lens will only sell to those people that want to know they have it, but don't need it.
I have zero interest in this lens. I don't want anything this wide or really anything wider than 14 or 15mm and even that I wouldn't shoot very often. That said, what you write here just isn't accurate. There are several architectural shots (including the one posted two posts above your post) that simply needed a lens that wide to get the buildings in with as much coverage as was in the photo. So, those shots can't be shot with even a 10mm. Personally, as I said I have no use for a lens this wide, but that doesn't mean that the posted shots didn't need a lens that wide.
I disagree. If you asked me what focal length it was I'd say somewhere between 10 and 14mm.

Nobody I showed here guessed 9mm, they all said 12-14mm.
Could it be because 9mm rectilinear lenses did not exist until this one? There is definitely a difference in FOV between 9mm and a 12mm lens just like a 28mm to 35mm.
I see your point though. Ultra wide lenses have a similar ultra wide "look".
Possibly, perhaps I should clarify my point which was that this groundbreaker didn't make anyone here (with collectively 500+ years of experience in pro photography) say anything like 'that's definitely wider than 12mm'.

My point is the lens needs to be demonstrated to produce something a CV10 or the Sony 12-24 can't, in order to sell it to people other than those who simply want to tell their buddies they are shooting at 9mm.

It's like most supercar drivers, they can't possibly demonstrate the skill to maximise 1000 horsepower (or a third of that), so why buy the product?


But doesn't that go back to (and challenge) your point about "need"? Nobody buys a supercar because they need it.
Jun 24, 2020 at 04:59 PM
Bob_S
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame


MAubrey wrote:
Bob_S wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Bob_S wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Bob_S wroteNo offense, but there is t a single shot I can see that couldn't be shot with a 10, 11 or 12mm.

If you're going to demonstrate the lens you need to leverage it's only strength, the unique perspective, which wasn't done.

Yes, that's going to be difficult, which is why the lens will only sell to those people that want to know they have it, but don't need it.
I have zero interest in this lens. I don't want anything this wide or really anything wider than 14 or 15mm and even that I wouldn't shoot very often. That said, what you write here just isn't accurate. There are several architectural shots (including the one posted two posts above your post) that simply needed a lens that wide to get the buildings in with as much coverage as was in the photo. So, those shots can't be shot with even a 10mm. Personally, as I said I have no use for a lens this wide, but that doesn't mean that the posted shots didn't need a lens that wide.
I disagree. If you asked me what focal length it was I'd say somewhere between 10 and 14mm.

Nobody I showed here guessed 9mm, they all said 12-14mm.
Could it be because 9mm rectilinear lenses did not exist until this one? There is definitely a difference in FOV between 9mm and a 12mm lens just like a 28mm to 35mm.
I see your point though. Ultra wide lenses have a similar ultra wide "look".
Possibly, perhaps I should clarify my point which was that this groundbreaker didn't make anyone here (with collectively 500+ years of experience in pro photography) say anything like 'that's definitely wider than 12mm'.

My point is the lens needs to be demonstrated to produce something a CV10 or the Sony 12-24 can't, in order to sell it to people other than those who simply want to tell their buddies they are shooting at 9mm.

It's like most supercar drivers, they can't possibly demonstrate the skill to maximise 1000 horsepower (or a third of that), so why buy the product?
But doesn't that go back to (and challenge) your point about "need"? Nobody buys a supercar because they need it.


Again, I have to disagree, supercars are usually designed for a need, if your business is racing, you need race cars.

If your business is photography and you can capture your scene with a 12mm, using a 9mm may improve the output, to demonstrate that well would be prudent of the company that is offering the product.
Jun 24, 2020 at 05:10 PM
TravelinBriNY
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Really, a rectangular one? That would be quite remarkable.
Jun 25, 2020 at 05:23 AM
MAubrey
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Bob_S wrote:
MAubrey wrote
Bob_S wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Bob_S wrote
Steve Spencer wroteI have zero interest in this lens. I don't want anything this wide or really anything wider than 14 or 15mm and even that I wouldn't shoot very often. That said, what you write here just isn't accurate. There are several architectural shots (including the one posted two posts above your post) that simply needed a lens that wide to get the buildings in with as much coverage as was in the photo. So, those shots can't be shot with even a 10mm. Personally, as I said I have no use for a lens this wide, but that doesn't mean that the posted shots didn't need a lens that wide.
I disagree. If you asked me what focal length it was I'd say somewhere between 10 and 14mm.

Nobody I showed here guessed 9mm, they all said 12-14mm.
Could it be because 9mm rectilinear lenses did not exist until this one? There is definitely a difference in FOV between 9mm and a 12mm lens just like a 28mm to 35mm.
I see your point though. Ultra wide lenses have a similar ultra wide "look".
Possibly, perhaps I should clarify my point which was that this groundbreaker didn't make anyone here (with collectively 500+ years of experience in pro photography) say anything like 'that's definitely wider than 12mm'.

My point is the lens needs to be demonstrated to produce something a CV10 or the Sony 12-24 can't, in order to sell it to people other than those who simply want to tell their buddies they are shooting at 9mm.

It's like most supercar drivers, they can't possibly demonstrate the skill to maximise 1000 horsepower (or a third of that), so why buy the product?
But doesn't that go back to (and challenge) your point about "need"? Nobody buys a supercar because they need it.
Again, I have to disagree, supercars are usually designed for a need, if your business is racing, you need race cars.

If your business is photography and you can capture your scene with a 12mm, using a 9mm may improve the output, to demonstrate that well would be prudent of the company that is offering the product.


Supercars are street cars modeled off of race track cars that millionaires and billionaires buy. They don't buy them to race.
Jun 25, 2020 at 12:19 PM
Bob_S
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame


MAubrey wrote:
Bob_S wrote
MAubrey wrote
Bob_S wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Bob_S wroteI disagree. If you asked me what focal length it was I'd say somewhere between 10 and 14mm.

Nobody I showed here guessed 9mm, they all said 12-14mm.
Could it be because 9mm rectilinear lenses did not exist until this one? There is definitely a difference in FOV between 9mm and a 12mm lens just like a 28mm to 35mm.
I see your point though. Ultra wide lenses have a similar ultra wide "look".
Possibly, perhaps I should clarify my point which was that this groundbreaker didn't make anyone here (with collectively 500+ years of experience in pro photography) say anything like 'that's definitely wider than 12mm'.

My point is the lens needs to be demonstrated to produce something a CV10 or the Sony 12-24 can't, in order to sell it to people other than those who simply want to tell their buddies they are shooting at 9mm.

It's like most supercar drivers, they can't possibly demonstrate the skill to maximise 1000 horsepower (or a third of that), so why buy the product?
But doesn't that go back to (and challenge) your point about "need"? Nobody buys a supercar because they need it.
Again, I have to disagree, supercars are usually designed for a need, if your business is racing, you need race cars.

If your business is photography and you can capture your scene with a 12mm, using a 9mm may improve the output, to demonstrate that well would be prudent of the company that is offering the product.
Supercars are street cars modeled off of race track cars that millionaires and billionaires buy. They don't buy them to race.



I do. Everyone I track them with does also. Your data/perception is incorrect.
Jun 25, 2020 at 04:56 PM
kevin_laowa
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
ftllens wrote:
Iunno, I shot with just the CV 10mm for a few months exclusively, and those definitely look wider. A little birdie told me Laowa is working on a 7.5mm FF for Sony, is this true? lol



One at a time, my friend.
Jun 25, 2020 at 07:49 PM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Any news on this lens' release date? Does anyone have a comparison shot of what 9mm looks like vs 10?
Jun 26, 2020 at 01:49 PM
kevin_laowa
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Official launch on 29th. Will share more sample images vs Voigt 10/5.6
Jun 27, 2020 at 09:55 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
kevin_laowa wrote:
Official launch on 29th. Will share more sample images vs Voigt 10/5.6


Awesome. Thanks so much!
Jun 27, 2020 at 10:04 AM
MAubrey
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Bob_S wrote:
MAubrey wrote
Bob_S wrote
MAubrey wrote
Bob_S wrote
Fred Miranda wroteCould it be because 9mm rectilinear lenses did not exist until this one? There is definitely a difference in FOV between 9mm and a 12mm lens just like a 28mm to 35mm.
I see your point though. Ultra wide lenses have a similar ultra wide "look".
Possibly, perhaps I should clarify my point which was that this groundbreaker didn't make anyone here (with collectively 500+ years of experience in pro photography) say anything like 'that's definitely wider than 12mm'.

My point is the lens needs to be demonstrated to produce something a CV10 or the Sony 12-24 can't, in order to sell it to people other than those who simply want to tell their buddies they are shooting at 9mm.

It's like most supercar drivers, they can't possibly demonstrate the skill to maximise 1000 horsepower (or a third of that), so why buy the product?
But doesn't that go back to (and challenge) your point about "need"? Nobody buys a supercar because they need it.
Again, I have to disagree, supercars are usually designed for a need, if your business is racing, you need race cars.

If your business is photography and you can capture your scene with a 12mm, using a 9mm may improve the output, to demonstrate that well would be prudent of the company that is offering the product.
Supercars are street cars modeled off of race track cars that millionaires and billionaires buy. They don't buy them to race.
I do. Everyone I track them with does also. Your data/perception is incorrect.

I'm glad to hear they're used in your circle, but I'm not inexperienced here and my own experiences are totally different. Opposite, actually. My perception is correct.

But to make a better anology. If a 9mm is a supercar, then a 10mm is also a supercar. Maybe your expectations are wrong because you're acting like a 10mm is a Prius.
Jun 27, 2020 at 12:51 PM
serhan_
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
I see that the orders are open. Is there any optical differences between M and Sony E mount? Is it optimized for each camera sensor thickness or can M Mount be used on on other cameras eg Sony?

kevin_laowa wrote:
Official launch on 29th. Will share more sample images vs Voigt 10/5.6


Jun 30, 2020 at 09:26 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #14Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
serhan_ wrote:
I see that the orders are open. Is there any optical differences between M and Sony E mount? Is it optimized for each camera sensor thickness or can M Mount be used on on other cameras eg Sony?

kevin_laowa wroteOfficial launch on 29th. Will share more sample images vs Voigt 10/5.6


In the case of the slow ultra wide Voigtlander lenses (10,12 and 15mm), there is no difference in performance when using the VM version on the Sony. So, it's likely the same with this new Laowa. I am guessing there is only a mount and flange distance change between the versions.
Jun 30, 2020 at 11:53 AM
Kry27
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
There is a difference in what a race car driver (member of a smaller group) calls a 'supercar' and what the non-race-car-drivers call 'supercar', maybe.
I would call a race car a race car. A supercar indeed is a billionaire's toy that nobody would risk damaging on track. I doubt Bob drives, races and regularly damages Koenigseggs, Bugattis and the like...
Bob_S wrote:
MAubrey wrote... cars that millionaires and billionaires buy. They don't buy them to race.
I do. Everyone I track them with does also. Your data/perception is incorrect.

Jun 30, 2020 at 01:24 PM
serhan_
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Thanks. It looks like Bastian started the M Mount Review:
https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-laowa-9mm-5-6-ff-rl/

Fred Miranda wrote:
serhan_ wroteI see that the orders are open. Is there any optical differences between M and Sony E mount? Is it optimized for each camera sensor thickness or can M Mount be used on on other cameras eg Sony?

kevin_laowa wroteOfficial launch on 29th. Will share more sample images vs Voigt 10/5.6
In the case of the slow ultra wide Voigtlander lenses (10,12 and 15mm), there is no difference in performance when using the VM version on the Sony. So, it's likely the same with this new Laowa. I am guessing there is only a mount and flange distance change between the versions.


Jun 30, 2020 at 02:20 PM
hanay78
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
yes, and it looks like in one photograph appeared a 14mm small lens with metric 52 thread for filters. I hope it performs well, as i look for something wider than lox 21 with filters for a long time
Jun 30, 2020 at 02:48 PM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
I wish the philipreeve review had a picture of the 10 vs 9 side by side, just for perspective change.
Jun 30, 2020 at 04:14 PM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
shadow9d9 wrote:
I wish the philipreeve review had a picture of the 10 vs 9 side by side, just for perspective change.

It has now.
I just got the review sample last week and completed some comparisons to the 5.6/10 in the meantime,
but I had to rush the review a bit this morning as I wanted these comparisons to be out with today's official press release, as I thought these will be most interesting to many of you.
Now the article is a bit rounder with also much better product pictures

Fred Miranda wrote:
serhan_ wroteI see that the orders are open. Is there any optical differences between M and Sony E mount? Is it optimized for each camera sensor thickness or can M Mount be used on on other cameras eg Sony?

kevin_laowa wroteOfficial launch on 29th. Will share more sample images vs Voigt 10/5.6
In the case of the slow ultra wide Voigtlander lenses (10,12 and 15mm), there is no difference in performance when using the VM version on the Sony. So, it's likely the same with this new Laowa. I am guessing there is only a mount and flange distance change between the versions.

I got told they change some element spacing, but I think this may very well be within mount tolerances,
as my M version actually performs slightly better on Sony (not a big difference though).

hanay78 wrote:
yes, and it looks like in one photograph appeared a 14mm small lens with metric 52 thread for filters. I hope it performs well, as i look for something wider than lox 21 with filters for a long time

There will also be a 14mm 4.0 (very low distortion, 52mm filter thread) and a 11mm 4.5 (62mm filter thread).
I also think the 14mm 4.0 might be the ultra wide Loxia lens we have been waiting for, sharing the 52mm filter thread of the series.

I have a good sample of the 11mm 4.5 in E-mount, but for now I will prioritize reviewing the 9mm 5.6.
When it comes to the 14mm 4.0 I have to wait for a replacement as this one is not centered good enough.
Jun 30, 2020 at 04:55 PM
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Laowa 9mm f/5.6 M-mount Full frame
Thanks! Definitely getting it.
Jun 30, 2020 at 06:10 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister