fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...

socalsteve
Offline

p.1 #1Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Hi all,

I read on the B & H site that only some RF lenses will work in tandem with the new EOS R5. First off, not sure what “tandem”
in this instance even means ( not the most technical person here ).

Can anyone elaborate on this and if my EF lens with IS ( 28-300 ) will give me even more stops with the R5?

Thank you all in advance and excuse my ignorance. No flames, please!

Steve

From the B and H website:

What's more, the EOS R5 will be the first Canon camera equipped with a high-performance coordinated image stabilization (IS) system that integrates the camera's in-body IS with IS systems on attached RF lenses.

And this too:

Another major addition to the R5 is an in-body image stabilization system, a first for Canon’s interchangeable-lens cameras. It will even work in tandem with select RF lenses equipped with their own stabilizers.

Edited on Feb 26, 2020 at 11:00 PM · View previous versions
Feb 26, 2020 at 06:50 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Where did you read that on the B&H site? I haven't seen a Canon statement to that effect.

I would be surprised and shocked if Canon's IBIS does not work cooperatively with any RF lens IS. I think the "select RF lenses equipped with their own stabilizers" is an exclusion of RF lenses that don't have IS.

Feb 26, 2020 at 08:03 PM
slowdad
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
From what I have read about this
This was from DP ReviewSpecifically, Canon claims the IBIS will offer five stops of image stabilization on its own and up to 7–8 stops when used with in-lens stabilization as well.

Feb 26, 2020 at 09:24 PM
Chimping
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
My worry is that the IBIS and lens IS will only work in tandem if you’re using an RF IS-equipped lens. In other words, the IS-equipped EF lenses won’t be supported.
Feb 26, 2020 at 09:27 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
I think that the IBIS will work in conjunction with an RF IS lens to give the maximum possible stops.
I think that EF lenses with IS will have the choice to use the lens IS or use IBIS. They won't function in tandem.
Any non IS lens be it EF or RF will make use of the IBIS.

Feb 26, 2020 at 09:29 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Chimping wrote:
My worry is that the IBIS and lens IS will only work in tandem if you’re using an RF IS-equipped lens. In other words, the IS-equipped EF lenses won’t be supported.


Yes, with an EF lens with IS, you will have the choice...use the lens IS or switch it off and use the IBIS. For longer lenses you will be better to use the lens IS.
Feb 26, 2020 at 09:33 PM
mikeinctown
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Chimping wrote:
My worry is that the IBIS and lens IS will only work in tandem if you’re using an RF IS-equipped lens. In other words, the IS-equipped EF lenses won’t be supported.


I'm still fine with this as long as IBIS works with any lens. 5 stops is still 5 stops more than I'm currently getting with my 85 Art and 1-2 stops better than I'm getting with my 70-200 III. At 5 stops I doubt I could keep my subjects still long enough to need more than that.

Feb 26, 2020 at 09:54 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
arbitrage wrote:
I think that the IBIS will work in conjunction with an RF IS lens to give the maximum possible stops.
I think that EF lenses with IS will have the choice to use the lens IS or use IBIS. They won't function in tandem.
Any non IS lens be it EF or RF will make use of the IBIS.



That may be the most likely scenario, but there are other possibilities.

As far as we know, an EF IS lens does not inform the body that IS is operating. At least, it's not in the EXIF. The body will know that the lens has IS because it has the lens identification data, but we don't know that the body can know IS is operating. It must know what IS functions are operating in real-time in order to integrate with it, and it must have high-speed communication to integrate with it as well.

So we can presume that RF IBIS will not operate cooperatively with EF IS. But that is going to set up some annoying situations. It will mean that whenever an EF lens is attached, the camera must nag the user to make sure one system or the other is off.

However, what if the EF lens does tell the body that it's operating? It would only take one bit of data, and maybe Canon has just never encoded that into EXIF. Knowing which lens is attached and knowing whether its IS is turned on, the RF IBIS could then do whatever it knows the lens IS is not doing. I think that would just be correction of yaw. So EF lens IS could operate simultaneously, yet independently, with RF IBIS without conflict.

But of course, that's just conjecture, but it seems to me the least complex way to operate...if the lens does indeed send an undisclosed IS status bit to the camera.
Feb 26, 2020 at 09:57 PM
socalsteve
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
arbitrage wrote:
Chimping wroteMy worry is that the IBIS and lens IS will only work in tandem if you’re using an RF IS-equipped lens. In other words, the IS-equipped EF lenses won’t be supported.
Yes, with an EF lens with IS, you will have the choice...use the lens IS or switch it off and use the IBIS. For longer lenses you will be better to use the lens IS.


Do you know this for fact or are you speculating? If you do know this for fact, where did you hear it from?

Thank you!

Steve
Feb 26, 2020 at 11:35 PM
greenfield
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
RDKirk wrote:
arbitrage wroteI think that the IBIS will work in conjunction with an RF IS lens to give the maximum possible stops.
I think that EF lenses with IS will have the choice to use the lens IS or use IBIS. They won't function in tandem.
Any non IS lens be it EF or RF will make use of the IBIS.
That may be the most likely scenario, but there are other possibilities.

As far as we know, an EF IS lens does not inform the body that IS is operating. At least, it's not in the EXIF. The body will know that the lens has IS because it has the lens identification data, but we don't know that the body can know IS is operating. It must know what IS functions are operating in real-time in order to integrate with it, and it must have high-speed communication to integrate with it as well.

So we can presume that RF IBIS will not
...Show more →

The IS information is in the EXIF, including on/off and mode. You can check this with latest exiftoolgui/exiftool. Look for tagname ImageStabilization in the Maker metadata.









Feb 26, 2020 at 11:44 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
greenfield wrote:
RDKirk wrote
arbitrage wroteI think that the IBIS will work in conjunction with an RF IS lens to give the maximum possible stops.
I think that EF lenses with IS will have the choice to use the lens IS or use IBIS. They won't function in tandem.
Any non IS lens be it EF or RF will make use of the IBIS.
That may be the most likely scenario, but there are other possibilities.

As far as we know, an EF IS lens does not inform the body that IS is operating. At least, it's not in the EXIF. The body will know that the lens has IS because it has the lens identification data, but we don't know that the body can know IS is operating. It must know what IS functions are operating in real-time in order to integrate with it, and it must have high-speed communication to integrate with it as well.

So we can presume that RF IBIS will not operate cooperatively with EF IS. But that is going to set up some annoying situations. It will mean that whenever an EF lens is attached, the camera must nag the user to make sure one system or the other is off.

However, what if the EF lens does tell the body that it's operating? It would only take one bit of data, and maybe Canon has just never encoded that into EXIF. Knowing which lens is attached and knowing whether its IS is turned on, the RF IBIS could then do whatever it knows the lens IS is not doing. I think that would just be correction of yaw. So EF lens IS could operate simultaneously, yet independently, with RF IBIS without conflict.

But of course, that's just conjecture, but it seems to me the least complex way to operate...if the lens does indeed send an undisclosed IS status bit to the camera.
The IS information is in the EXIF, including on/off and mode. You can check this with latest exiftoolgui/exiftool. Look for tagname ImageStabilization in the Maker metadata.




Ah, well, good.

In that case, the camera has information to do several things. It can, at least, determine what corrections EF lens IS is not making (it's not making any, if EF IS is not on) and make independent but complementary IBIS corrections. For instance, if IBIS knows the EF lens is limited to stabilizing in the X- and Y-axes, then it would stabilize pitch and yaw independently.

Or if that's too complicated at this time, it may turn IBIS off when EF lens IS is operating.

Or maybe it can even turn EF lens IS off when IBIS is operating.

But I would be surprised and amazed if RF IBIS can actually integrate with EF IS.

Feb 27, 2020 at 06:31 AM
greenfield
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
RDKirk wrote:
Or maybe it can even turn EF lens IS off when IBIS is operating.


That would be a huge surprise. If that kind of control would be possible it would be there already for EF.

Feb 27, 2020 at 07:04 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
socalsteve wrote:
arbitrage wrote
Chimping wroteMy worry is that the IBIS and lens IS will only work in tandem if you’re using an RF IS-equipped lens. In other words, the IS-equipped EF lenses won’t be supported.
Yes, with an EF lens with IS, you will have the choice...use the lens IS or switch it off and use the IBIS. For longer lenses you will be better to use the lens IS.
Do you know this for fact or are you speculating? If you do know this for fact, where did you hear it from?

Thank you!

Steve


Just speculating. But based off Canon's statement that combined stops will be available with "select RF lenses with IS" makes me pretty certain that only RF IS lenses will be combinable with IBIS. You can interpret that statement to mean all RF IS lenses or only some RF IS lenses (I think it will be all) but I don't see any indication that EF IS lenses will be combinable with IBIS.

When I adapt a Canon lens onto a Sony if I have lens IS on then it uses that. If I switch lens IS off then it uses IBIS. This is most likely how the R system will function also. But I still can't say 100% for sure that Canon won't be able to combine some EF IS lenses (most likely only the newer ones) with IBIS...but my bets are that it won't happen.
Feb 27, 2020 at 07:11 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Canon EF bodies know when IS on a lens is enabled but the IS runs autonomously with no communication with the body about what the IS is doing at any given moment. That was because without IBIS the body never needed to know. Canon knew it would eventually implement IBIS on R bodies so the IS in RF lenses communicate their movements in real-time to the body, thus allow coordination with IBIS.

That is my guess anyway...
Feb 27, 2020 at 07:23 AM
socalsteve
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Thanks to everyone who responded!

I’m hoping my EF 28-300 L IS will work in tandem with the R5. It’s a really special lens, especially for travel ( save its weight and size ). I also have the RF 24-240 IS. Much less weight and size, still good for travel, but matched with the EOS R, it wasn’t as fast to autofocus as I would have liked.

If the RF 24-240 IS lens works better with the R5, I’ll put the EF 28-300 up for sale.

Thoughts?

Thanks again!

Steve

Feb 27, 2020 at 09:48 AM
amacal1
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...


snapsy wrote:
Canon EF bodies know when IS on a lens is enabled but the IS runs autonomously with no communication with the body about what the IS is doing at any given moment. That was because without IBIS the body never needed to know. Canon knew it would eventually implement IBIS on R bodies so the IS in RF lenses communicate their movements in real-time to the body, thus allow coordination with IBIS.

That is my guess anyway...


Or allow the body to command/suggest IS movements to the lens. Either way, it represents a significant change from how independent the IS is in current EF implementation and communication protocol.
Feb 27, 2020 at 10:30 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
amacal1 wrote:
snapsy wroteCanon EF bodies know when IS on a lens is enabled but the IS runs autonomously with no communication with the body about what the IS is doing at any given moment. That was because without IBIS the body never needed to know. Canon knew it would eventually implement IBIS on R bodies so the IS in RF lenses communicate their movements in real-time to the body, thus allow coordination with IBIS.

That is my guess anyway...
Or allow the body to command/suggest IS movements to the lens. Either way, it represents a significant change from how independent the IS is in current EF implementation and communication protocol.

Certainly possible but I tend to doubt it - the gyros inside the IS mechanism would be more accurate and specific for the lens IS movements since they're measuring motion at the lens itself, which could be significantly different than the motion the sensor is seeing, esp for telephoto lenses where the physical distance between the two is significant.
Feb 27, 2020 at 10:56 AM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
Canon annoucement was "What's more, the EOS R5 will be the first Canon camera equipped with a high-performance coordinated image stabilization (IS) system that integrates the camera's in-body IS with IS systems on attached RF lenses. "

Which suggests that

- R5 IBIS will work with manual focus EF lens. Why not? What would be the sense of IBIS if it did not work with manual focus adapted lens. There are maybe 2 RF lens. There would be a revolt if this did not work.

- You will have to choose EF IS or IBIS on EF lens with IS. EF IS is likely better - Canon has told us this for 20 years. This is likely, otherwise the above quote would not have had "on attached RF lenses" at the end of the sentence.

- If you have a RF lens, you can improve the in lens IS with IBIS, by having them run together, but you will have a choice of together, or separate.
Feb 27, 2020 at 11:20 AM
mb126
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
I think it's safe to assume we will only get the combined effect for RF glass. Still, all the cases here look pretty good!
1) RF glass with IS + R5 - great
2) RF glass without IS + R5 - great (most RF glass has IS!)
3) EF glass without IS + R5 - great
4) EF glass with IS + R5 - pick one or the other, depending what is more effective.
Feb 27, 2020 at 02:53 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
mb126 wrote:
I think it's safe to assume we will only get the combined effect for RF glass. Still, all the cases here look pretty good!
1) RF glass with IS + R5 - great
2) RF glass without IS + R5 - great (most RF glass has IS!)
3) EF glass without IS + R5 - great
4) EF glass with IS + R5 - pick one or the other, depending what is more effective.


With #4, I expect the camera to force the choice. It will know what lens is mounted, it will know whether IS is on, and it will know whether IBIS is better than the IS in that lens.

It will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.
Feb 27, 2020 at 06:11 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell