fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...

  
 
thedutt
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
RDKirk wrote:
mb126 wroteI think it's safe to assume we will only get the combined effect for RF glass. Still, all the cases here look pretty good!
1) RF glass with IS + R5 - great
2) RF glass without IS + R5 - great (most RF glass has IS!)
3) EF glass without IS + R5 - great
4) EF glass with IS + R5 - pick one or the other, depending what is more effective.
With #4, I expect the camera to force the choice. It will know what lens is mounted, it will know whether IS is on, and it will know whether IBIS is better than the IS in that lens.

It will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.


Technically speaking, is there any reason why the two wont work together for (4)? Camera knows what ef lens is attached, camera can be programmed knows its IS capabilities and how it functions, camera knows if its on or off. I bet the math is pretty complex


Feb 27, 2020 at 06:15 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
thedutt wrote:
RDKirk wrote
mb126 wroteI think it's safe to assume we will only get the combined effect for RF glass. Still, all the cases here look pretty good!
1) RF glass with IS + R5 - great
2) RF glass without IS + R5 - great (most RF glass has IS!)
3) EF glass without IS + R5 - great
4) EF glass with IS + R5 - pick one or the other, depending what is more effective.
With #4, I expect the camera to force the choice. It will know what lens is mounted, it will know whether IS is on, and it will know whether IBIS is better than the IS in that lens.

It will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.
Technically speaking, is there any reason why the two wont work together for (4)? Camera knows what ef lens is attached, camera can be programmed knows its IS capabilities and how it functions, camera knows if its on or off. I bet the math is pretty complex



I don't think the camera will decide. I think it will be user's choice. Canon has been adement for years that their lens IS is superior to IBIS so with that in mind if Canon was left to decide they would only use the lens IS if they can't combine them. But I'm fairly sure I'd rather use 5-stop IBIS over the 2 stops IS on the older 300/4 and 100-400 generation lenses.
Feb 27, 2020 at 06:55 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
thedutt wrote:
RDKirk wrote
mb126 wroteI think it's safe to assume we will only get the combined effect for RF glass. Still, all the cases here look pretty good!
1) RF glass with IS + R5 - great
2) RF glass without IS + R5 - great (most RF glass has IS!)
3) EF glass without IS + R5 - great
4) EF glass with IS + R5 - pick one or the other, depending what is more effective.
With #4, I expect the camera to force the choice. It will know what lens is mounted, it will know whether IS is on, and it will know whether IBIS is better than the IS in that lens.

It will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.
Technically speaking, is there any reason why the two wont work together for (4)? Camera knows what ef lens is attached, camera can be programmed knows its IS capabilities and how it functions, camera knows if its on or off. I bet the math is pretty complex



I have already discussed that. The camera, knowing which EF lens is mounted and knowing the IS capability of that lens, might be able to provide complementary stabilization.

For instance, if IS is stabilizing motion on the X- and Y-axes, IBIS can provide yaw and pitch stabilization. That would be independent and complementary operation, not integration.

I don't believe actual integration of stabilization operations can be possible between RF IBIS and EF IS...that would require high-speed real-time communication that EF lenses are not capable of.

However, when RF IS working integrally with RF IBIS, IBIS can add its stabilization along the same planes as IS in real time to increase the total level of stabilization.
Feb 27, 2020 at 06:57 PM
mikeinctown
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
If Canon really has come up with IBIS with 5 stops for RF lenses, I don't see many people buying a 24-70 IS when they can get a 28-70 F2 and get those 5 stops of IS. The F2 is insanely big, but not much worse than the 85 1.2. Having F2 plus improved sensor performance would be huge. I'd be selling my Tamron 24-70 G2 for sure.
Feb 27, 2020 at 08:02 PM
AJSJones
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
RDKirk wrote:
I don't believe actual integration of stabilization operations can be possible between RF IBIS and EF IS...that would require high-speed real-time communication that EF lenses are not capable of.

However, when RF IS working integrally with RF IBIS, IBIS can add its stabilization along the same planes as IS in real time to increase the total level of stabilization.


One of the RF mount improvements is in the area of (additional) high speed communication with the lens. I would expect that applies to IS as well as AF, so RF IS will "talk" to IBIS while EF IS can't.

Edited to add Improved communications is a critical part of the RF mount design. Along with a new microprocessor in the lens, the RF mount implements a 12-pin connection between the camera and the lens, a 50% increase over the 8 pins found on the EF mount. Along with more data channels, the new design provides higher speed data transfer for extremely fast AF, enhanced image stabilization and image quality optimization.

Edited on Feb 28, 2020 at 11:19 AM · View previous versions
Feb 27, 2020 at 08:02 PM
technic
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
arbitrage wrote:
thedutt wrote
RDKirk wrote
mb126 wroteI think it's safe to assume we will only get the combined effect for RF glass. Still, all the cases here look pretty good!
1) RF glass with IS + R5 - great
2) RF glass without IS + R5 - great (most RF glass has IS!)
3) EF glass without IS + R5 - great
4) EF glass with IS + R5 - pick one or the other, depending what is more effective.
With #4, I expect the camera to force the choice. It will know what lens is mounted, it will know whether IS is on, and it will know whether IBIS is better than the IS in that lens.

It will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.
Technically speaking, is there any reason why the two wont work together for (4)? Camera knows what ef lens is attached, camera can be programmed knows its IS capabilities and how it functions, camera knows if its on or off. I bet the math is pretty complex
I don't think the camera will decide. I think it will be user's choice. Canon has been adement for years that their lens IS is superior to IBIS so with that in mind if Canon was left to decide they would only use the lens IS if they can't combine them. But I'm fairly sure I'd rather use 5-stop IBIS over the 2 stops IS on the older 300/4 and 100-400 generation lenses.


The question is though how effective IBIS will be for those long lenses; I have my doubts because it requires relatively big sensor movements. More interesting: does it work well with non-IS lenses like the 2.0/135 and 2.8/200? These lenses are optically pretty good (without any use of software corrections), compact for their spec compared to some recent designs and relatively affordable. I would love a 2.8/200 with effective IBIS, without the size/weight penalty that comes with most of the recent IS designs. I guess giving old lenses a new life isn't a high priority for Canon, but with the right price for IBIS it might lead to more R body sales.

Same story BTW for lenses like the 55-250 IS STM that could benefit from IBIS on an APS-C body. IS on this lens is pretty weak at the long end and close-up. If it could use effective IBIS for those situations (even better if IBIS and IS in tandem) it would be even more interesting. Undoubtedly there are more examples of relatively cheap lenses that would become a lot more interesting.

---------------------------------------------

mikeinctown wrote:
If Canon really has come up with IBIS with 5 stops for RF lenses, I don't see many people buying a 24-70 IS when they can get a 28-70 F2 and get those 5 stops of IS. The F2 is insanely big, but not much worse than the 85 1.2. Having F2 plus improved sensor performance would be huge. I'd be selling my Tamron 24-70 G2 for sure.


If the IBIS works well they could also build smaller but high quality non-IS zooms in the WA to normal range instead of the current IS versions. IS often leads to significantly bigger lenses or IQ compromise.
Feb 28, 2020 at 05:19 AM
amacal1
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...


RDKirk wrote:


It will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.


It would sure make Canon look bad if IBIS was more effective than ILIS for many of their lenses, since they almost chose that as their hill to die on.
Feb 28, 2020 at 07:29 AM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Speculation on compatibility on EF lens with IS and IBIS in R5...
amacal1 wrote:
RDKirk wroteIt will have the ability to turn off IBIS if lens IS is better (although I don't expect that to be often). It might not have the ability to turn off IS, but it can complain about it.
It would sure make Canon look bad if IBIS was more effective than ILIS for many of their lenses, since they almost chose that as their hill to die on.


I think they will pretend they never said that.

My understanding is that Canon's IBIS will stabilize yaw and pitch, which I don't believe IS does.
Mar 01, 2020 at 08:04 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister