fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020New Canon R5 Rumor

  
 
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.4 #1New Canon R5 Rumor
benCKS wrote:
If those Videospecs are true, instant buy on my End. Just wondering if Canon will seriously cannibalize half of their Cinemacameras. As with those Specs, c100/c200/c300 are imho dead.


IMO they won't have any where near the read speed to offer AF with 8K30p, that would require 4x the read speed of the 1DXIII in 4K30p and 2x it's FF 4K60p read speed. If they had the tech to do that then they would have done in it the 1DXIII. None of these video specs make sense if they have AF except the 4K30p, the other modes would require heavy crops.
Jan 29, 2020 at 01:41 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #2New Canon R5 Rumor
There will of course be a lot of fine print regarding the video specs, and also the stills specs.
Excpect bad rolling shutter, EVF slideshow effect, 2X crop at 120p, etc.
Jan 29, 2020 at 02:04 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.4 #3New Canon R5 Rumor
benCKS wrote:
If those Videospecs are true, instant buy on my End. Just wondering if Canon will seriously cannibalize half of their Cinemacameras. As with those Specs, c100/c200/c300 are imho dead.


They won't be dead once you read the supplemental 100 page manual of asterisks Canon will include with those video specs
Jan 29, 2020 at 07:31 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.4 #4New Canon R5 Rumor
rbeasley wrote:
I am surprised there is so much grumbling and a meh reaction to the specs of this. If the rumors are true this is a powerhouse camera. I am beginning to think if someone offered some of the posters here a truckload of gold bars they would pass complaining they are not shiny enough or they don't feel like carrying them around.

It is Canon so I don't fault the trust but verify on the rumor but holy smokes this thing sounds like an all around beast. I am almost second guessing my 1dx3. Almost.



It's like what my father use to say.
"Some people would bitch if they were hung with a new rope."

And yes, I agree this thing looks like a an amazing beast. If the specs hold even close to what is out there right now, I want one in my bag.
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:02 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.4 #5New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteGlad to see Canon getting serious, but none of the video-related specs mean squat to me as a still-stills shooter. I have a feeling that I'm going to pass on this one in favor of the 60-80mp R unless the R5 has insanely-clean high ISO and no AA filter.
If the R5 (45 MP) and R6 (20 MP) rumors are true, it means that there will be no higher resolution camera this time around, and possibly even for a long time. While the R5 specs are good for the majority, it is not a camera that I will rush to buy. I think the R5 will have AA filter as well.


Canon Rumors had a recent article stating that there would be four new full frame Canon cameras this year. I can't see them letting Sony retain the title of highest resolution full frame camera for very long.

But if this indeed is as high as they go on resolution, hopefully there are other benefits for stills shooters like better dynamic range and very low noise at high ISO.

My completely unrealistic hope is that Canon will scale the R5 sensor to 44x33 and introduce a medium format body that uses the RF mount and a new line of RF(x) lenses – all while allowing us to use existing EF and RF either in crop mode or full 44x33 like we do now on the GFX. It would be amazing to use many of the EF and RF lenses that have larger image circles on 44x33 while retaining native AF and IS performance.

---------------------------------------------

benCKS wrote:
If those Videospecs are true, instant buy on my End. Just wondering if Canon will seriously cannibalize half of their Cinemacameras. As with those Specs, c100/c200/c300 are imho dead.


Certainly we know Canon has no problem letting product lines die when they need to. But maybe they will move the same sensor tech over to the Cinema line and give them an edge we can't yet imagine.
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:25 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #6New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
I can't see them letting Sony retain the title of highest resolution full frame camera for very long.


I'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:47 AM
guidostow
Offline
Details
p.4 #7New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
I'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.


I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:51 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.4 #8New Canon R5 Rumor
Canon Rumors just made an update saying that their reliable source that confirmed the specs yesterday (bumping it to CR3) had told them it isn't RAW in 8K. Supposedly he wasn't sure what form the 8K would take. Could still be just 8K time-lapse or 8K/30 with no DPAF.
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:52 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #9New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteI can't see them letting Sony retain the title of highest resolution full frame camera for very long.
I'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.


If you are coming from A7rIII, I can understand what you mean. Coming from the 5DSR, an upscaled M6II sensor to 83 MP FF will be an upgrade in every respect, low ISO DR, high ISO DR, resolution, frame rate. Of course medium format will be even better, but it won't happen for the RF mount. Going for a medium format camera has so many other implications that it is a complicated discussion.
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:55 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #10New Canon R5 Rumor
guidostow wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?


The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right? We want to carry shorter lenses and crop instead, very very few of us are printing building sized advertisements.
Jan 29, 2020 at 08:56 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.4 #11New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right?
...Show more →

Yes, my 2 weeks with the R4 showed me it was very difficult to realize the benefits of all those pixels. There were a lot of color artifacts (blues and purples) in dark feathers and darker backgrounds showed more color noise and blotches (green, magenta). Similar color artifacts in feathers that I had found with my 5DSR back in the day. And yes for birds, wildlife (maybe sports) we are really buying high MP cameras to crop and use shorter lenses or even just to crop with our longest lenses when birds are tiny and skittish. But time and time again, I keep reaching for that holy grail and always end up disappointed when I get to those really high pixel densities and try to use them to crop big. I'm sure for printing large landscapes shot at base ISO they would be phenomenal. But not for my use case.

As far as higher MPs cameras go, I've been most happy with the D850 at 46MP so that is why I'd choose 45 over 70+. I also really liked the 5D4 at 30MPs. So I think 35-45 would be great.

Edited on Jan 29, 2020 at 09:03 AM · View previous versions
Jan 29, 2020 at 09:02 AM
guidostow
Offline
Details
p.4 #12New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right?
...Show more →

Thanks for this!

For someone who shoots over ISO100 probably 3 times a year it doesn't sound like a deal breaker...
Jan 29, 2020 at 09:03 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #13New Canon R5 Rumor
guidostow wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right? We want to carry shorter lenses and crop instead, very very few of us are printing building sized advertisements.
Thanks for this!

For someone who shoots over ISO100 probably 3 times a year it doesn't sound like a deal breaker...


hah, you're exactly right, if you're a tripod/base ISO kind of shooter, i'm sure the R4 or high MP Canon would be an amazing camera.
Jan 29, 2020 at 09:06 AM
guidostow
Offline
Details
p.4 #14New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
hah, you're exactly right, if you're a tripod/base ISO kind of shooter, i'm sure the R4 or high MP Canon would be an amazing camera.


Indeed. I'd use a Phase One XT kit if it didn't cost more than my truck...
Jan 29, 2020 at 09:12 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.4 #15New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
hah, you're exactly right, if you're a tripod/base ISO kind of shooter, i'm sure the R4 or high MP Canon would be an amazing camera.


Along these lines, and regarding a potential high MP full frame Canon mirrorless body — or the current 5DsR for that matter...

About half of my photography is what you describe — landscape photography done from the tripod at base ISO. Ever since the Pentax 645d came out about a decade ago I have looked at and considered the miniMF cameras, first the Pentax 645d, then the 645z, and more recently the Fujifilm GFX 50s. (The 100x is out of the question for several reasons, though I have a colleague who uses one...)

My thinking was that these cameras would offer additional image quality potential that could pay off in very large prints, say at the 30" x 40" range and upwards.

In the past year or two I went as far as getting my hands on a GFX 50S and doing some side-by-side comparison shooting with that camera (with one of the excellent Fujifilm lenses) and the 5DsR... and then making prints of sections of the images interpolated for various prints sizes up to as large as 90" x 120". (No, I didn't make prints that large! I scaled images up to prepare printable files at those dimensions, then printed letter-size sections for comparison.)

Is the miniMF result better than the FF 50MP result? The simple answer is "yes." But the fuller answer is much more complex.

The baseline of what you can get from a current high MP full frame file from Canon, Nikon, or Sony is quite excellent. You can produce very large, very excellent prints from any of them at sizes above 20" x 30". 30" x 40" (or 30" x 45") prints are absolutely first rate if the original image file is good.

From my testing (making the various sizes of test prints and asking a bunch of other photographers to compare) any differences at the below the 30" x 40" size are insignificant, to the point that most people can't tell what the source camera format was, and those who can have to a) be very astute printers, b) know what to look for, and c) very carefully go back and forth between side-by-side prints. My sense is that there is a very tiny difference starting at about 30" x 40", but that prints from 50MP full frame and 50MP miniMF at that size both look really good.

If you make a fair number of, say, 40" x 60" prints and look closely, you'll start to see some differences. They are subtle, and even here the FF system can do a very good job.

One thing that some folks overlook is the fact that the miniMF format is actually significantly smaller than 645, the smallest of the traditional MF film formats. In fact, it lies right between that old smallest MF format and FF. The difference between miniMF and FF is about half the percentage of the difference between FF and APS-C. So miniMF is larger, with the attendant potential benefits that come from a larger format, but but a smaller increment that many imagine.

There's another issue. Let's say that you are a Canon (or other full frame) system photographer used to working with a range of focal lengths. For example, I often carry 16-35, 24-70, 70-200, and 100-400 lenses and count on having and using that range in the field. You can't get there with miniMF at this point — you'll need to give up the ability to do certian things that you can do with your FF system. I can't do that. (If you can, the miniMF systems start to look a lot more interesting.)

All of this is my way of saying that while the grass may be a bit greener on the other side of the format fence... when you stop and look around it is also very, very green on the high MP full frame side of the fence, too! There's not a whole lot that you cannot do with the current 50MP-60MP FF systems out there, and a potential 75MP or 83MP FF system will likely be very good.

Dan
Jan 29, 2020 at 09:55 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.4 #16New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right?
...Show more →

Interesting that I've never heard this about the GFX 100 aside from a little more noise at 1:1 than the 50S/R. The 100 uses a scaled up version of the same A74 sensor. I wonder if somehow Fujifilm's take on the sensor micro lenses, etc. help mitigate these issues.

Canon may or may not have the same issues since we don't know how far they've advanced with the R5 sensor tech over the 5DsR.
Jan 29, 2020 at 10:08 AM
Ziffl3
Offline
Details
p.4 #17New Canon R5 Rumor
RoamingScott wrote:
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right?
...Show more →
Well I think that is your use case.
You want a camera manufacturer to design a sensor large enough with the purpose of cropping in what 1/2 or more and have the same performance as the full sensor.
Makes sense for all the complaining you do.

Actually not sure why you are on this board if you really don’t care for canon equipment.
A head scratcher.

Jan 29, 2020 at 10:17 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.4 #18New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right? We want to carry shorter lenses and crop instead, very very few of us are printing building sized advertisements.
Interesting that I've never heard this about the GFX 100 aside from a little more noise at 1:1 than the 50S/R. The 100 uses a scaled up version of the same A74 sensor. I wonder if somehow Fujifilm's take on the sensor micro lenses, etc. help mitigate these issues.

Canon may or may not have the same issues since we don't know how far they've advanced with the R5 sensor tech over the 5DsR.


In some tests I have seen, the GFX 100 sensor comes out better than the A7rIV sensor, compared at the same sensor area. Not sure why.
Jan 29, 2020 at 10:29 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #19New Canon R5 Rumor
Ziffl3 wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
guidostow wrote
RoamingScott wroteI'm definitely in the camp of, if you're going to try to go over 60mp, do so in a 44x33 format and not full frame. The R4 is showing us that even at 62mp, full frame is starting to burst at the seams.
I don't follow the sony boards enough to understand what you mean by "burst at the seams"
Could you elaborate?
The pixels are getting so small that high iso looks considerably worse than the R3 sensor, more noise in general but more worryingly, a lot more false color in that noise.

Where the R3 has grain at high ISO, the R4 has lots of green and magenta within the noise. It's very noticeable in controlled tests.

Most of the Sony apologists on that board say "well that's at 100% crop, it looks fine when viewed full size!", which...is true, until you do a deep crop on a high ISO image. That's the point of all this resolution in the first place right? We want to carry shorter lenses and crop instead, very very few of us are printing building sized advertisements.
Well I think that is your use case.
You want a camera manufacturer to design a sensor large enough with the purpose of cropping in what 1/2 or more and have the same performance as the full sensor.
Makes sense for all the complaining you do.

Actually not sure why you are on this board if you really don’t care for canon equipment.
A head scratcher.



what? Your posts are borderline incomprehensible, buddy.
Jan 29, 2020 at 10:31 AM
mdvaden
Offline
Details
p.4 #20New Canon R5 Rumor
arbitrage wrote:
These specs are so far out there that there is just no way they could be true...

7-8 stops of stabilization on a FF sensor? Even the combined systems on the M43 don't achieve that (Olympus 6.5 at best).


"So far out there"? When lenses can crank out 4 or more stops IS, why would 7 stops be extreme as a sensor and lens combined?

************************************************

Onto another aspect.

They updated the battery part from being similar, to what I'm reading as "compatible" with 5D mk iv batteries. That would be a big plus for my wants.

I'd prefer SD / CF ... but for cards I can enjoy whatever the final option is. Apparently the cards are still a mystery





Edited on Jan 29, 2020 at 10:48 AM · View previous versions
Jan 29, 2020 at 10:43 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister