RoamingScott wrote:
hah, you're exactly right, if you're a tripod/base ISO kind of shooter, i'm sure the R4 or high MP Canon would be an amazing camera.
Along these lines, and regarding a potential high MP full frame Canon mirrorless body — or the current 5DsR for that matter...
About half of my photography is what you describe — landscape photography done from the tripod at base ISO. Ever since the Pentax 645d came out about a decade ago I have looked at and considered the miniMF cameras, first the Pentax 645d, then the 645z, and more recently the Fujifilm GFX 50s. (The 100x is out of the question for several reasons, though I have a colleague who uses one...)
My thinking was that these cameras would offer additional image quality potential that could pay off in very large prints, say at the 30" x 40" range and upwards.
In the past year or two I went as far as getting my hands on a GFX 50S and doing some side-by-side comparison shooting with that camera (with one of the excellent Fujifilm lenses) and the 5DsR... and then making prints of sections of the images interpolated for various prints sizes up to as large as 90" x 120". (No, I didn't make prints that large! I scaled images up to prepare printable files at those dimensions, then printed letter-size sections for comparison.)
Is the miniMF result better than the FF 50MP result? The simple answer is "yes." But the fuller answer is much more complex.
The baseline of what you can get from a current high MP full frame file from Canon, Nikon, or Sony is quite excellent. You can produce very large, very excellent prints from any of them at sizes above 20" x 30". 30" x 40" (or 30" x 45") prints are absolutely first rate if the original image file is good.
From my testing (making the various sizes of test prints and asking a bunch of other photographers to compare) any differences at the below the 30" x 40" size are insignificant, to the point that most people can't tell what the source camera format was, and those who can have to a) be very astute printers, b) know what to look for, and c) very carefully go back and forth between side-by-side prints. My sense is that there is a very tiny difference starting at about 30" x 40", but that prints from 50MP full frame and 50MP miniMF at that size both look really good.
If you make a fair number of, say, 40" x 60" prints and look closely, you'll start to see some differences. They are subtle, and even here the FF system can do a very good job.
One thing that some folks overlook is the fact that the miniMF format is actually significantly smaller than 645, the smallest of the traditional MF film formats. In fact, it lies right between that old smallest MF format and FF. The difference between miniMF and FF is about half the percentage of the difference between FF and APS-C. So miniMF is larger, with the attendant potential benefits that come from a larger format, but but a smaller increment that many imagine.
There's another issue. Let's say that you are a Canon (or other full frame) system photographer used to working with a range of focal lengths. For example, I often carry 16-35, 24-70, 70-200, and 100-400 lenses and count on having and using that range in the field. You can't get there with miniMF at this point — you'll need to give up the ability to do certian things that you can do with your FF system. I can't do that. (If you can, the miniMF systems start to look a lot more interesting.)
All of this is my way of saying that while the grass may be a bit greener on the other side of the format fence... when you stop and look around it is also very, very green on the high MP full frame side of the fence, too! There's not a whole lot that you cannot do with the current 50MP-60MP FF systems out there, and a potential 75MP or 83MP FF system will likely be very good.
Dan