fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020New Canon R5 Rumor

  
 
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.14 #1New Canon R5 Rumor
guidostow wrote:
Some interesting thoughts on where Canon is and has been in the market...

https://petapixel.com/2020/02/13/why-did-canon-just-now-decide-to-wake-up/


Thanks for sharing. If the author of the article is right, it could explain a lot of things. The pro RF lenses Canon launched last year certainly indicate that Canon knew they would soon have something really big in the camera deparment.
Feb 15, 2020 at 08:11 AM
zjoewang
Offline
Details
p.14 #2New Canon R5 Rumor
Interesting video. If 8K video has no crop and decent compression, together with R6 later on, it could certainly have a profound impact on the industry. I can even envision Nikon being bought by Sony and other type of consolidations and alliances.
Feb 15, 2020 at 08:29 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #3New Canon R5 Rumor
wordfool wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
stanj wrote
highdesertmesa wroteRF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.
That under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.
It's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
So it’ll go from f/4.5 to f/5.6 in 300mm, then f/5.6 to f/7.1 in 100mm? Is that actually confirmed by someone privy to Canon’s design, or is it someone’s back of envelope calculation?


I had the same question, but not being a math person, I don't know enough to dispute it. I think the argument being made is the physics of a given zoom lens drive the aperture calculation – the longest focal length and the smallest f/stop dictate the aperture at any given focal length. The math looked pretty simple, and it was separately posted by different people in different conversations in the Facebook R group:

400/(500/7.1)=5.68

But I'm not sure this makes sense because when I plug in 100 instead of 400 it doesn't give me the correct minimum lens aperture. Not sure I fully understand the logic.



Feb 15, 2020 at 09:08 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.14 #4New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
wordfool wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
stanj wrote
highdesertmesa wroteRF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.
That under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.
It's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
So it’ll go from f/4.5 to f/5.6 in 300mm, then f/5.6 to f/7.1 in 100mm? Is that actually confirmed by someone privy to Canon’s design, or is it someone’s back of envelope calculation?
I had the same question, but not being a math person, I don't know enough to dispute it. I think the argument being made is the physics of a given zoom lens drive the aperture calculation – the longest focal length and the smallest f/stop dictate the aperture at any given focal length. The math looked pretty simple, and it was separately posted by different people in different conversations in the Facebook R group:

400/(500/7.1)=5.68

But I'm not sure this makes sense because when I plug in 100 instead of 400 it doesn't give me the correct minimum lens aperture. Not sure I
...Show more →

Those calculations only give the best case, what is physically possible from a pure front element diameter standpoint. Real lenses are always worse than that at some point, because as you zoom back the aperture is limited other places than in the front element. There is little precedence for a 5X zoom range starting in pure tele, so we really don't know what to expect.
Feb 15, 2020 at 09:32 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #5New Canon R5 Rumor
dmcphoto wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
dmcphoto wrote
JohnSil wrote
burningheart wrotePricing it above or too far above the Sony A7R4 the technology had better be far in advance or many will choose the Sony, Nikon, Panasonic or other vendor route and so forth.
It seems to me that the average photographer just idly jumps from brand to brand or owns 3 or 4 brands as a more hyped up camera comes out? I guess they love to spread the love around and keep the economy humming!
Would I jump to Sony, Nikon, Pano etc. for a few dollars?
I shoot with a Canon system and have since around 07 when I moved to Digital. Canon had the best glass and finally with ML other companies are also starting to make FAST glass a-la Canon.
I have also belonged to CPS for the last ten years.
There are a lot of reasons to use a camera system, the very LEAST of which are the cameras. Would I move to Panasonic? Was it mentioned just to be politically correct? I used to own Panasonic cordless drills, they were the best! And my office had/has all Panasonic phones, they're great!! Will Panasonic turn my camera repair around in 24 hours or send me a loaner? Will Nikon? Will Sony? Are all their help lines in the continental US and are they 24/7/365? Do the colors produced by their cameras integrate into the papers and inks I'm printing with or do I need to get a Custom Color Profile for every different paper I print on?
People can jump to any brand they want every time a new camera comes out but some people shoot Canon for a reason and it has nothing to do with the cameras or their cost!!! There is not a Sony on this planet that will help me get a better pic than I'm getting now!!!
John
I've shot Canon exclusively for more than 40 years. Their stagnation and lack of innovation between 2007 and 2015 had me looking seriously at Sony. Now that they are getting their act back together the lack of any form of contrast AF in one shot mode (so far on their MILCs), the direction they took with the uber-slow 100-500mm, their RF lens pricing (every lens I've looked at is between $2000 and $3000), and the fact my closet full of EF-L lenses can adapt to Sony or Canon all has me pretty sure I'll switch to Sony this summer. I don't idly jump around between brands, but barring any huge surprises I don't see my future with this brand.
RF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach. The 100-400 II is f/5.6 @ 400 and the RF will be identical at 400mm (others have done the math). If there was such a thing as a 1.25x EF teleconverter, the 100-400 II would be exactly f/7.1 @ 500mm. The RF 100-500 can do this without the TC, which is an amazing thing. And given Canon's RF L lens track record so far, it's likely the IQ at 500mm is going to equal what the 100-400 II was producing at 400mm, which will be incredible. Further, I believe Canon is also going to still produce the rumored RF 70-400 that will maintain the same 100-400 II top aperture of f/5.6.

RF lens pricing is fair if you consider many of the top lenses like the 50, 85, and 28-70 have Zeiss-quality IQ and bokeh character AND very fast autofocus (especially considering how much glass is being moved around). The 50 and 85 are sharp wide open at infinity out to the corners and the 28-70 is also amazing wide open considering it's a zoom. A few years ago, I would have never imagined lens IQ like this was possible. And right now these lenses are at introductory price – they WILL come down over time. And Canon WILL make less expensive alternatives.

I would consider the Sony switch very carefully with regard to using your EF lenses on the A7 bodies. They will function, but the performance is never going to match native Sony glass, and frankly the EF AF performance will feel decades behind native RF performance by the time you adapt it.

You've waited this long – let's see what the dynamic range and high-ISO performance of the R5 and R6 bring. Canon made the same bold statements about needing to improve these two things as they did about improving their video capabilities, so I feel fairly confident we will not be disappointed.
I very sincerely appreciate what you are saying, but I think I've thought this through pretty reasonably:

1. After buying a 1DS3 in 2007 I had to wait until 2015 before Canon produced anything with better IQ. That was the 5DSR I pre-ordered in 2015, which except for pixel density was well behind Nikon and Sony when arrived. Assuming the R5 is not the forever rumored and never delivered high resolution 5DSR replacement, I'd likely be waiting 7 years again with my 5DSR, or buying an R5 as a stop gap, which seems completely crazy. I'm really tired of waiting,
...Show more →

I agree that three years ago would have been the perfect time. But given you've waited this long, doesn't it make sense to see if the R5 does everything you expect the Sony to do?

Most of your concerns seem to be about the R. We're used to new Canon bodies having similar drawbacks to the previous models, but I think Canon is about to shatter that assertion.
Feb 15, 2020 at 09:34 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #6New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
wordfool wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
stanj wrote
highdesertmesa wroteRF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.
That under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.
It's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
So it’ll go from f/4.5 to f/5.6 in 300mm, then f/5.6 to f/7.1 in 100mm? Is that actually confirmed by someone privy to Canon’s design, or is it someone’s back of envelope calculation?
I had the same question, but not being a math person, I don't know enough to dispute it. I think the argument being made is the physics of a given zoom lens drive the aperture calculation – the longest focal length and the smallest f/stop dictate the aperture at any given focal length. The math looked pretty simple, and it was separately posted by different people in different conversations in the Facebook R group:

400/(500/7.1)=5.68

But I'm not sure this makes sense because when I plug in 100 instead of 400 it doesn't give me the correct minimum lens aperture. Not sure I fully understand the logic.
Those calculations only give the best case, what is physically possible from a pure front element diameter standpoint. Real lenses are always worse than that at some point, because as you zoom back the aperture is limited other places than in the front element. There is little precedence for a 5X zoom range starting in pure tele, so we really don't know what to expect.


I'm not trusting the math anyway because when I substitute "100" for "400" in the formula, the maximum aperture calculates to 1.42, which is obviously wrong. I think I'm going to go with "back of the envelope math" on this one. I think someone made up this formula based the expectation of f/5.6 not knowing anything about lens design.
Feb 15, 2020 at 09:44 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.14 #7New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
alundeb wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
wordfool wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
stanj wroteThat under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.
It's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
So it’ll go from f/4.5 to f/5.6 in 300mm, then f/5.6 to f/7.1 in 100mm? Is that actually confirmed by someone privy to Canon’s design, or is it someone’s back of envelope calculation?
I had the same question, but not being a math person, I don't know enough to dispute it. I think the argument being made is the physics of a given zoom lens drive the aperture calculation – the longest focal length and the smallest f/stop dictate the aperture at any given focal length. The math looked pretty simple, and it was separately posted by different people in different conversations in the Facebook R group:

400/(500/7.1)=5.68

But I'm not sure this makes sense because when I plug in 100 instead of 400 it doesn't give me the correct minimum lens aperture. Not sure I fully understand the logic.
Those calculations only give the best case, what is physically possible from a pure front element diameter standpoint. Real lenses are always worse than that at some point, because as you zoom back the aperture is limited other places than in the front element. There is little precedence for a 5X zoom range starting in pure tele, so we really don't know what to expect.
I'm not trusting the math anyway because when I substitute "100" for "400" in the formula, the maximum aperture calculates to 1.42, which is obviously wrong. I think I'm going to go with "back of the envelope math" on this one. I think someone made up this formula based the expectation of f/5.6 not knowing anything about lens design.


The math for 100 mm f/1.42 is right for a ca 70 mm front element that we have in these lenses.
Feb 15, 2020 at 09:47 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #8New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
alundeb wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
wordfool wrote
highdesertmesa wroteIt's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
So it’ll go from f/4.5 to f/5.6 in 300mm, then f/5.6 to f/7.1 in 100mm? Is that actually confirmed by someone privy to Canon’s design, or is it someone’s back of envelope calculation?
I had the same question, but not being a math person, I don't know enough to dispute it. I think the argument being made is the physics of a given zoom lens drive the aperture calculation – the longest focal length and the smallest f/stop dictate the aperture at any given focal length. The math looked pretty simple, and it was separately posted by different people in different conversations in the Facebook R group:

400/(500/7.1)=5.68

But I'm not sure this makes sense because when I plug in 100 instead of 400 it doesn't give me the correct minimum lens aperture. Not sure I fully understand the logic.
Those calculations only give the best case, what is physically possible from a pure front element diameter standpoint. Real lenses are always worse than that at some point, because as you zoom back the aperture is limited other places than in the front element. There is little precedence for a 5X zoom range starting in pure tele, so we really don't know what to expect.
I'm not trusting the math anyway because when I substitute "100" for "400" in the formula, the maximum aperture calculates to 1.42, which is obviously wrong. I think I'm going to go with "back of the envelope math" on this one. I think someone made up this formula based the expectation of f/5.6 not knowing anything about lens design.
The math for 100 mm f/1.42 is right for a ca 70 mm front element that we have in these lenses.


So what you're saying is f/5.6 for 400mm is best case scenario – it's possible but no confirmation. Likewise f/1.42 is possible at 100mm from the physics, just unlikely.
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:00 AM
kezeka
Offline
Details
p.14 #9New Canon R5 Rumor
rscheffler wrote:
rscheffler wroteI'm in a similar situation and looking forward to the option to use Leica M lenses on Canon FF mirrorless. I'm very glad the R5 will have IBIS, which hopefully can be easily set up for non-dedicated lenses. That said, given Canon's sensors so far haven't been BSI and with some questions about cover glass thicknesses, I'm not too optimistic about the performance of some M lenses on the R5. I tried the 50 Lux-M on the M6II and there are signs of image smearing towards the edges of the APS-C frame, though that sensor's pixel density might also be pushing the limits of some lenses, including the 50 Lux-M. And on a non-BSI FF sensor I think we'll see more edge color shifts than we'd like...
highdesertmesa wroteI've not read of adapted M glass performing as well as it does natively on the M outside of the SL/SL2, especially the wide angles. Even on sensors with BSI, the IQ is not the same as using them on the M/SL/SL2 – those sensors are designed to accommodate the quirks of the M lens designs. If a non-Leica sensor some day ends up on the market that improves M wide angle performance, it's going to be by accident and not by design, and IMO not worth waiting for.
Neither have I.

I don't expect M wides to work as well as on my M bodies, but in some situations it won't be critical. The benefit of BSI is considerably reduced edge color shifts vs. older, deep pixel well designs. I'm more interested in how the R5 IBIS will work with something like the 50 Lux ASPH, 90AA, 90 Macro Elmar or 180/3.4 APO-Telyt. Most of those lenses will work with the R's thicker sensor cover glass. Only the 50 Lux ASPH may not be quite as good as on a digital M.


I have a Leica Q for my normal/wide Leica fix. Seems like the 50 lux and more telephoto lenses will be mostly fine. Having dig through pages of reviews on 35 and wider lenses, those seem to be where the color shift and smearing start getting brutal even on the thinner sensor glass of the Z6/7. Regardless, been looking forward to puttering around with a 50 lux for years since I love the rendering style. Hoping that zeiss makes some native lenses for RF eventually so I can get my 21mm and 15mm fix from them.

Really just plan on replacing my 70-200II with the RF version for compact hiking. Maybe pick up an RF 85 and 50 to replace my 85L II at some point but I love the old drawing style of the 85L II and the swirl. Plus, they are cheaper and smaller than the Leica SL equivalents...
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:08 AM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.14 #10New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
RF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.

stanj wrote:
That under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.

highdesertmesa wrote:
It's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.


Where, and how? The fact that it can be done (77mm diameter is good for 400/5.6) doesn't mean that it actually will be so. I haven't seen any math that demonstrates that the lens drops to 6.3 at 401mm, and I would love to see it. There are plenty of variable aperture zoom lenses out there that have a smaller aperture than mathematically possible.

Edited on Feb 15, 2020 at 10:15 AM · View previous versions
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:13 AM
dmcphoto
Offline
Details
p.14 #11New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
dmcphoto wrote
JohnSil wrote
burningheart wrotePricing it above or too far above the Sony A7R4 the technology had better be far in advance or many will choose the Sony, Nikon, Panasonic or other vendor route and so forth.
It seems to me that the average photographer just idly jumps from brand to brand or owns 3 or 4 brands as a more hyped up camera comes out? I guess they love to spread the love around and keep the economy humming!
Would I jump to Sony, Nikon, Pano etc. for a few dollars?
I shoot with a Canon system and have since around 07 when I moved to Digital. Canon had the best glass and finally with ML other companies are also starting to make FAST glass a-la Canon.
I have also belonged to CPS for the last ten years.
There are a lot of reasons to use a camera system, the very LEAST of which are the cameras. Would I move to Panasonic? Was it mentioned just to be politically correct? I used to own Panasonic cordless drills, they were the best! And my office had/has all Panasonic phones, they're great!! Will Panasonic turn my camera repair around in 24 hours or send me a loaner? Will Nikon? Will Sony? Are all their help lines in the continental US and are they 24/7/365? Do the colors produced by their cameras integrate into the papers and inks I'm printing with or do I need to get a Custom Color Profile for every different paper I print on?
People can jump to any brand they want every time a new camera comes out but some people shoot Canon for a reason and it has nothing to do with the cameras or their cost!!! There is not a Sony on this planet that will help me get a better pic than I'm getting now!!!
John
I've shot Canon exclusively for more than 40 years. Their stagnation and lack of innovation between 2007 and 2015 had me looking seriously at Sony. Now that they are getting their act back together the lack of any form of contrast AF in one shot mode (so far on their MILCs), the direction they took with the uber-slow 100-500mm, their RF lens pricing (every lens I've looked at is between $2000 and $3000), and the fact my closet full of EF-L lenses can adapt to Sony or Canon all has me pretty sure I'll switch to Sony this summer. I don't idly jump around between brands, but barring any huge surprises I don't see my future with this brand.
RF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach. The 100-400 II is f/5.6 @ 400 and the RF will be identical at 400mm (others have done the math). If there was such a thing as a 1.25x EF teleconverter, the 100-400 II would be exactly f/7.1 @ 500mm. The RF 100-500 can do this without the TC, which is an amazing thing. And given Canon's RF L lens track record so far, it's likely the IQ at 500mm is going to equal
...Show more →

From imaging-resource.com:
"Most mirrorless cameras use a combination of PDAF and CDAF; phase-detect gets the lens close to the correct focus, then contrast-detect fine-tunes it. This appears not to be the case with the EOS R, though. When I asked whether it had a hybrid AF system, the engineers replied that no, it was always only phase-detect. (They seemed particularly proud of this, that their PDAF is accurate enough to take things to final, optimal focus.)"

PDAF, whether it's on the image sensor or not, will always find paraxial focus. Since all lenses have aberrations that create a difference between the visually "best focus" and paraxial focus, mirrorless cameras that use only PDAF need a way to compensate for the difference. That involves guesstimated (there is no way to calculate it) offsets based the particular lens sample (determined during manufacture) or based on averages for the particular lens model. Since the offset would change with zoom and subject distance, there would be multiple offsets for each lens. In addition to being less accurate, a system like that makes the camera less amenable to third party lenses. It also means that electronic manual focus confirmation indicators (which would typically be contrast based) have no more accuracy than the PDAF. If you're manually focusing a third party non-AF lens you may be best off just using your eyes, which can be quite troublesome with no electronic assist, especially as our eyes get older. I believe this is the reason we've seen focus issues with various adapted EF lenses on RF bodies posted here and in other forums, where the lens functions and can be sharply focused manually by eye in a magnified view, but subsequently doing an AF defocuses the image.

To see a small sample of what's involved to derive "best focus" from PDAF determined paraxial focus see https://openphotographyforums.com/forums/threads/best-focus-adjustment-for-canon-ef-lenses.20458/. CDAF finds "best focus" directly without any compensation, making it the best way to achieve accurate focus under the most varied circumstances. For instance, if it was available I think CDAF would accurately focus the problem lenses I mention above. People manually find "best focus" by sensing peak contrast, which is exactly what CDAF does.

I agree that the EVF issue reports were probably based on performance of the R and/or RP. The yet to be released cameras could perform differently, though I read that the bottleneck causing this performance was speed of communication with the lens. I didn't delve into it more deeply and as you say, the best way to find out would be to try it with the actual camera. OTOH keeping a Canon DSLR just for the 600mm until I'm ready to swap out that lens is probably the cheapest thing I can to without losing any performance in the meantime.

I wanted to replace my 5DSR before some extensive shooting I will do in the next couple of months. Given the industry's rumored 2020 MILC developments I held off to see what would happen. I was hopeful that Canon's high resolution Canon MILC 5DSR replacement camera would be available by summer when I'd have time to use and learn it before doing anything costly and important with it. Those rumors, like all 5DSR replacement rumors since 2018, were false. While waiting I discovered details about both the Sony and Canon MILC systems that are not ideal for me. IMO relative to my needs the preponderance of those are on Canon's side.

Sony has had what I wanted to buy from Canon since last October. I'm not waiting yet another year and countless exposures for a 5DSR replacement based only on rumors that have an exceptionally bad track record, so there is really no choice. One can always wait for the something better and I'm sure Canon will eventually produce a fine 5DSR replacement, but not being 20 or 30 years old anymore I can't keep waiting for Canon's glacial development cycles. The A9-II is also of interest, and I see nothing comparable at a similar price point on Canon's MILC horizon. What all of this means to me is that my wife was right when he said I should have already switched. Regardless, thanks for your very reasonable and considered response.

Edited on Feb 15, 2020 at 10:17 AM · View previous versions
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:15 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #12New Canon R5 Rumor
stanj wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteRF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.
stanj wroteThat under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.
highdesertmesa wroteIt's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
Where, and how? The fact that it can be done (77mm diameter is good for 400/5.6) doesn't mean that it actually will be so. I haven't seen any math that demonstrates that the lens drops to 6.3 at 401mm, and I would love to see it.


If you read this thread through to the end, you'll see the final conclusion. Look upward a few posts
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:15 AM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.14 #13New Canon R5 Rumor
highdesertmesa wrote:
RF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.

stanj wrote:
That under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.

highdesertmesa wrote:
It's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.

stanj wrote:
Where, and how? The fact that it can be done (77mm diameter is good for 400/5.6) doesn't mean that it actually will be so. I haven't seen any math that demonstrates that the lens drops to 6.3 at 401mm, and I would love to see it.

highdesertmesa wrote:
If you read this thread through to the end, you'll see the final conclusion. Look upward a few posts


First that was posted after myriginal post, so I could not reference it. Second the way I read it, there isn't uniform agreement that it actually works (putting 100 into the formula doesn't give the right results).

I don't have the reputation of a pessimist but let's say I will not preorder this lens until empirical evidence is here. I have been disappointed by maths before.
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:20 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #14New Canon R5 Rumor
stanj wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteRF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach.
stanj wroteThat under the assumption that the lens is indeed f5.6 @ 400, which is not guaranteed. Wouldn't be the first time that a zoom lens jumps to an unfortunate f-stop earlier than one had wished. Time will tell, but I'm not holding my breath.
highdesertmesa wroteIt's not an assumption – bigger brains than ours have done the math and confirmed it.
stanj wroteWhere, and how? The fact that it can be done (77mm diameter is good for 400/5.6) doesn't mean that it actually will be so. I haven't seen any math that demonstrates that the lens drops to 6.3 at 401mm, and I would love to see it.
highdesertmesa wroteIf you read this thread through to the end, you'll see the final conclusion. Look upward a few posts
First that was posted after myriginal post, so I could not reference it. Second the way I read it, there isn't uniform agreement that it actually works (putting 100 into the formula doesn't give the right results).

I don't have the reputation of a pessimist but let's say I will not preorder this lens until empirical evidence is here. I have been disappointed by maths before.


How I now understand it: the math is correct but it only calculates the theoretical maximum aperture that's possible at each focal length. The end result will depend on how Canon designs the lens – the aperture changes are not linear, so we won't know until the lens is released. So f/1.42 is theoretically possible at 100mm, but extremely unlikely. f/5.6 is possible at 400mm, but we won't know until the lens design is made public.

I've edited my original post to add a note – hopefully this will avoid confusion from people quoting it right away.
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:23 AM
ShootPDX
Offline
Details
p.14 #15New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
ShootPDX wroteDirt’s never been a problem on my mirrorless camera.
My a7ii, a7iii, a9, a7riv, and a9ii have never been wet-cleaned. I’ve used a rocket blower maybe 2-3 times across the lot, and I doubt Canons will be any worse.

I never understand the dust complaints (fears). Even if you do get dust, it’s so easy to clean that it’s moot.

EB-1 wrote
therealthings wrotehttps://www.canonrumors.com/canon-eos-r5-specifications/

Seems about right compared to the first rumors.
arbitrage wroteThat is a post from Feb 2nd.

Did you mean to post this new leak: https://www.canonrumors.com/here-is-the-canon-eos-r5-we-think/
JaimitoFrog wrotedont see the shutter covers on the sensor like the R. Could be just locked open for product view.
I am also very concerned about that. The sensor of the a7r IV gets dirty extremely easily since it has an open sensor due to the poor quality design.

EBH
Do you do a lot of narrow aperture with clean background, like f/16 or even f/22? That's where you see the difference. My A7r was horrible compared to the 5DSR.


I do, but I know there's no dust because I can very plainly see that my sensor has no dust on it. And if it does, it's on the filter, which is very easily cleaned.

I think dust fear is much ado about nothing.


Edited on Feb 15, 2020 at 11:06 AM · View previous versions
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:56 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.14 #16New Canon R5 Rumor
dmcphoto wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
dmcphoto wrote
JohnSil wrote
burningheart wrotePricing it above or too far above the Sony A7R4 the technology had better be far in advance or many will choose the Sony, Nikon, Panasonic or other vendor route and so forth.
It seems to me that the average photographer just idly jumps from brand to brand or owns 3 or 4 brands as a more hyped up camera comes out? I guess they love to spread the love around and keep the economy humming!
Would I jump to Sony, Nikon, Pano etc. for a few dollars?
I shoot with a Canon system and have since around 07 when I moved to Digital. Canon had the best glass and finally with ML other companies are also starting to make FAST glass a-la Canon.
I have also belonged to CPS for the last ten years.
There are a lot of reasons to use a camera system, the very LEAST of which are the cameras. Would I move to Panasonic? Was it mentioned just to be politically correct? I used to own Panasonic cordless drills, they were the best! And my office had/has all Panasonic phones, they're great!! Will Panasonic turn my camera repair around in 24 hours or send me a loaner? Will Nikon? Will Sony? Are all their help lines in the continental US and are they 24/7/365? Do the colors produced by their cameras integrate into the papers and inks I'm printing with or do I need to get a Custom Color Profile for every different paper I print on?
People can jump to any brand they want every time a new camera comes out but some people shoot Canon for a reason and it has nothing to do with the cameras or their cost!!! There is not a Sony on this planet that will help me get a better pic than I'm getting now!!!
John
I've shot Canon exclusively for more than 40 years. Their stagnation and lack of innovation between 2007 and 2015 had me looking seriously at Sony. Now that they are getting their act back together the lack of any form of contrast AF in one shot mode (so far on their MILCs), the direction they took with the uber-slow 100-500mm, their RF lens pricing (every lens I've looked at is between $2000 and $3000), and the fact my closet full of EF-L lenses can adapt to Sony or Canon all has me pretty sure I'll switch to Sony this summer. I don't idly jump around between brands, but barring any huge surprises I don't see my future with this brand.
RF 100-500 is not über slow, it's an imagined problem. It will be the same lens as the 100-400 II with an extra 100mm of reach. The 100-400 II is f/5.6 @ 400 and the RF will be identical at 400mm (others have done the math). If there was such a thing as a 1.25x EF teleconverter, the 100-400 II would be exactly f/7.1 @ 500mm. The RF 100-500 can do this without the TC, which is an amazing thing. And given Canon's RF L lens track record so far, it's likely the IQ at 500mm is going to equal what the 100-400 II was producing at 400mm, which will be incredible. Further, I believe Canon is also going to still produce the rumored RF 70-400 that will maintain the same 100-400 II top aperture of f/5.6.

RF lens pricing is fair if you consider many of the top lenses like the 50, 85, and 28-70 have Zeiss-quality IQ and bokeh character AND very fast autofocus (especially considering how much glass is being moved around). The 50 and 85 are sharp wide open at infinity out to the corners and the 28-70 is also amazing wide open considering it's a zoom. A few years ago, I would have never imagined lens IQ like this was possible. And right now these lenses are at introductory price – they WILL come down over time. And Canon WILL make less expensive alternatives.

I would consider the Sony switch very carefully with regard to using your EF lenses on the A7 bodies. They will function, but the performance is never going to match native Sony glass, and frankly the EF AF performance will feel decades behind native RF performance by the time you adapt it.

You've waited this long – let's see what the dynamic range and high-ISO performance of the R5 and R6 bring. Canon made the same bold statements about needing to improve these two things as they did about improving their video capabilities, so I feel fairly confident we will not be disappointed.
From imaging-resource.com:
"Most mirrorless cameras use a combination of PDAF and CDAF; phase-detect gets the lens close to the correct focus, then contrast-detect fine-tunes it. This appears not to be the case with the EOS R, though. When I asked whether it had a hybrid AF system, the engineers replied that no, it was always only phase-detect. (They seemed particularly proud of this, that their PDAF is accurate enough to take things to final, optimal focus.)"

PDAF, whether it's on the image sensor or not, will always find paraxial focus. Since all lenses have aberrations that create a difference between the visually
...Show more →

Your use case scenarios for AF accuracy may be different than mine, but for my uses I've found the R to be the most accurate auto-focusing camera I've ever owned. Same goes for all lenses with an electronic chip whether RF, EF, or third party. I'm sure Sony is just as good or better, but the R is has been much better than my 5DsR or 5D4 when it comes to perfect focus for non-tracking subjects like landscapes or portraits.

The focus accuracy for RF/EF autofocus even at f/1.2 is astonishing. I regularly use the RF 50 f/1.2 @ f/1.2 for landscapes, and whether I'm focusing on infinity (horizon/cloud) or another object, it's fast and as close to 100% accurate as I've ever seen. I have not seen any meaningful difference in AF accuracy when comparing it to the contrast-based AF in the GFX with GF lenses.

As for manual focus, I've used the Focus Guide feature with the Zeiss ZE 21mm, and the accuracy of the system is frankly mind-blowing. This is not the old-school focus confirmation dot that was rarely accurate in past systems. When the tic marks line up and the box turns green, the manual focus is dead-on accurate. Add to that if I have eye-AF/tracking mode enabled when using the Zeiss, the focus box actually locks onto an eye just like autofocus would. Quite incredible if you like taking portraits with manual focus lenses.

With non-electronic manual focus lenses, the ability to focus accurately is mostly limited by the resolution of the EVF at its highest zoom level. I've found the R to be much easier to focus than the GFX with vintage lenses for this reason, and I'm hoping the R5 will have a much higher res EVF. Focus peaking works well – better than the GFX, too. But I find it's not accurate enough for f/1.2–f/1.4 unless my subject is on a receding plane and I can watch the line of focus move forward and backward in space.
Feb 15, 2020 at 10:59 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.14 #17New Canon R5 Rumor
ShootPDX wrote:
alundeb wrote
ShootPDX wroteDirt’s never been a problem on my mirrorless camera.
My a7ii, a7iii, a9, a7riv, and a9ii have never been wet-cleaned. I’ve used a rocket blower maybe 2-3 times across the lot, and I doubt Canons will be any worse.

I never understand the dust complaints (fears). Even if you do get dust, it’s so easy to clean that it’s moot.

EB-1 wrote
therealthings wrotehttps://www.canonrumors.com/canon-eos-r5-specifications/

Seems about right compared to the first rumors.
arbitrage wroteThat is a post from Feb 2nd.

Did you mean to post this new leak: https://www.canonrumors.com/here-is-the-canon-eos-r5-we-think/
JaimitoFrog wrotedont see the shutter covers on the sensor like the R. Could be just locked open for product view.
I am also very concerned about that. The sensor of the a7r IV gets dirty extremely easily since it has an open sensor due to the poor quality design.

EBH
Do you do a lot of narrow aperture with clean background, like f/16 or even f/22? That's where you see the difference. My A7r was horrible compared to the 5DSR.
I do, but I know there's no dust because I can see my very plainly see that my sensor has no dust on it. And if it does, it's on the filter, which is very easily cleaned.

I think dust fear is much ado about nothing.


Dust handling is the reality of digital photography, and has been a real pita for some cameras. That is experience and not fear or ado.
Feb 15, 2020 at 11:05 AM
ShootPDX
Offline
Details
p.14 #18New Canon R5 Rumor
alundeb wrote:
ShootPDX wrote
alundeb wrote
ShootPDX wroteDirt’s never been a problem on my mirrorless camera.
My a7ii, a7iii, a9, a7riv, and a9ii have never been wet-cleaned. I’ve used a rocket blower maybe 2-3 times across the lot, and I doubt Canons will be any worse.

I never understand the dust complaints (fears). Even if you do get dust, it’s so easy to clean that it’s moot.

EB-1 wrote
therealthings wrotehttps://www.canonrumors.com/canon-eos-r5-specifications/

Seems about right compared to the first rumors.
arbitrage wroteThat is a post from Feb 2nd.

Did you mean to post this new leak: https://www.canonrumors.com/here-is-the-canon-eos-r5-we-think/
JaimitoFrog wrotedont see the shutter covers on the sensor like the R. Could be just locked open for product view.
I am also very concerned about that. The sensor of the a7r IV gets dirty extremely easily since it has an open sensor due to the poor quality design.

EBH
Do you do a lot of narrow aperture with clean background, like f/16 or even f/22? That's where you see the difference. My A7r was horrible compared to the 5DSR.
I do, but I know there's no dust because I can see my very plainly see that my sensor has no dust on it. And if it does, it's on the filter, which is very easily cleaned.

I think dust fear is much ado about nothing.
Dust handling is the reality of digital photography, and has been a real pita for some cameras. That is experience and not fear or ado.


Sure, it happens, but the problem isn't as bad as some folks on these forums would have others believe.
Feb 15, 2020 at 11:06 AM
Chris Anthony
Offline
Details
p.14 #19New Canon R5 Rumor
I have never cleaned my 5D3 sensor, nor my 7D sensor. I cleaned my 20D (1) time and that was the only sensor I ever had an issue with in real world use. I have not had to clone out dust in ages. For my usage, dust is not an issue at all, but Im also not looking for it at F22 against a white wall.
Im hoping this R5 is under 5K, not holding my breath though. Ive waited this long to upgrade, but have some upcoming travel that a mirrorless would be great for.
Feb 15, 2020 at 12:01 PM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.14 #20New Canon R5 Rumor
Chris Anthony wrote:
I have never cleaned my 5D3 sensor, nor my 7D sensor. I cleaned my 20D (1) time and that was the only sensor I ever had an issue with in real world use. I have not had to clone out dust in ages. For my usage, dust is not an issue at all, but Im also not looking for it at F22 against a white wall.
Im hoping this R5 is under 5K, not holding my breath though. Ive waited this long to upgrade, but have some upcoming travel that a mirrorless would be great for.


I had a 5D and now a 5D3. I still get dust in my 5D3 but not as bad as with the 5D. What do you think the difference is? New coating on the glass in front of the sensor? I don't notice it too much since I usually shoot at f/5.6 or wider. I do still have to clone out just in Lightroom on the occasion I find myself shooting something like sky stopped down.
Feb 15, 2020 at 12:35 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister