rscheffler wrote:
rscheffler wrote
I'm in a similar situation and looking forward to the option to use Leica M lenses on Canon FF mirrorless. I'm very glad the R5 will have IBIS, which hopefully can be easily set up for non-dedicated lenses. That said, given Canon's sensors so far haven't been BSI and with some questions about cover glass thicknesses, I'm not too optimistic about the performance of some M lenses on the R5. I tried the 50 Lux-M on the M6II and there are signs of image smearing towards the edges of the APS-C frame, though that sensor's pixel density might also be pushing the limits of some lenses, including the 50 Lux-M. And on a non-BSI FF sensor I think we'll see more edge color shifts than we'd like...highdesertmesa wrote
I've not read of adapted M glass performing as well as it does natively on the M outside of the SL/SL2, especially the wide angles. Even on sensors with BSI, the IQ is not the same as using them on the M/SL/SL2 – those sensors are designed to accommodate the quirks of the M lens designs. If a non-Leica sensor some day ends up on the market that improves M wide angle performance, it's going to be by accident and not by design, and IMO not worth waiting for. Neither have I.
I don't expect M wides to work as well as on my M bodies, but in some situations it won't be critical. The benefit of BSI is considerably reduced edge color shifts vs. older, deep pixel well designs. I'm more interested in how the R5 IBIS will work with something like the 50 Lux ASPH, 90AA, 90 Macro Elmar or 180/3.4 APO-Telyt. Most of those lenses will work with the R's thicker sensor cover glass. Only the 50 Lux ASPH may not be quite as good as on a digital M.
I have a Leica Q for my normal/wide Leica fix. Seems like the 50 lux and more telephoto lenses will be mostly fine. Having dig through pages of reviews on 35 and wider lenses, those seem to be where the color shift and smearing start getting brutal even on the thinner sensor glass of the Z6/7. Regardless, been looking forward to puttering around with a 50 lux for years since I love the rendering style. Hoping that zeiss makes some native lenses for RF eventually so I can get my 21mm and 15mm fix from them.
Really just plan on replacing my 70-200II with the RF version for compact hiking. Maybe pick up an RF 85 and 50 to replace my 85L II at some point but I love the old drawing style of the 85L II and the swirl. Plus, they are cheaper and smaller than the Leica SL equivalents...