fredmiranda.com Login

Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread

  
 
_jim_
Offline
Details
p.55 #1Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
azenis wrote:
Ok, I finally mounted the LLL 50mm F1.2 Titanium on the M9P as well as my original 50mm F1.2 Noctilux.

The test was on a tripod, focus was done to the best of my ability. Everything from ISO, and shutter were all manual to make sure they were matched.

Now, without further ado, let's dive in.

The hardware:
LLL did replicate the original Noctilux to the T. Not only you can hardly tell from looking at it (other than the color), but one of the problem I was having with the original Noctilux with Techart TZM-02 adapter was that the focus ring would not
...Show more →


Thanks for doing this comparison!

Incredible that you have an original 50/1.2. Very rare, indeed!

Would you mind taking some photos of with out-of-focus point light sources with both lense? I am curious how the onion ring pattern of LLL compares to the vintage Leica (as the Leica re-issue shows none...and my LLL shows lots). Also, can you shed any more light on what you mean by "their digital machines"? The English language marketing copy that exists around the production of the LLL aspheric elements isn't super clear (i.e. it reads like marketing copy), but it gives the impression that LLL are hand grinding the lenses (like the original). That being said, the amount of onion rings/imperfections in the surface of the elements makes me think that they are still molding the elements or some kind of of hybrid process.

Apr 29, 2024 at 12:01 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.55 #2Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
azenis wrote:
Ok, I finally mounted the LLL 50mm F1.2 Titanium on the M9P as well as my original 50mm F1.2 Noctilux.

The test was on a tripod, focus was done to the best of my ability. Everything from ISO, and shutter were all manual to make sure they were matched.

Now, without further ado, let's dive in.

The hardware:
LLL did replicate the original Noctilux to the T. Not only you can hardly tell from looking at it (other than the color), but one of the problem I was having with the original Noctilux with Techart TZM-02 adapter was that the focus ring would not
...Show more →

Thanks for posting these tests, Jay.

It seems to me that the LLL shot was more front-focused than the Leica. (You can see the marker is sharper in the LLL shot, while the mannequin is sharper in the Leica shot).

It would be great if you could post some comparisons showing how the specular highlights look in particular, especially patterns like onion patterns.
Apr 29, 2024 at 12:33 PM
azenis
Offline
Details
p.55 #3Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
I will look into it. Will post another set done with Z8. But the result that I'm seeing is pretty much on par with the files from the M9P, although with higher resolution.
Apr 29, 2024 at 12:51 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.55 #4Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
azenis wrote:
I will look into it. Will post another set done with Z8. But the result that I'm seeing is pretty much on par with the files from the M9P, although with higher resolution.


I understand that focusing these lenses isn't easy. Focusing with the RF may not be desired as the lenses may not be perfectly aligned with the rangefinder. Using focus peaking in LV can sometimes exacerbate the issue, as peak resolution doesn't necessarily mean peak contrast.
Apr 29, 2024 at 02:02 PM
mgscheu
Offline
Details
p.55 #5Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
LLL has posted plans to make an entire line of SP-II lenses of various focal lengths. 75 mm f/2 next.
May 06, 2024 at 08:23 AM
tommmi
Offline
Details
p.55 #6Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Would be interesting to know which f-number they are targeting on each focal length.
May 06, 2024 at 11:26 AM
Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.55 #7Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
_jim_ wrote:
ZacharyHH wrote
_jim_ wrotehttps://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53615448346_d5853b271a_b.jpgRubber Plant by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/2 'Elcan,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53614837978_a1b4ac2c32_b.jpgPigeon by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600810272_51abfea83f_b.jpgStranger by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Cinestill 800T.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600276676_bbeda8a703_b.jpgAbandoned Car by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 35mm f/2 '8-Element,' Ilfrod HP5+, Xtol 1:1
Love your work, how to you like this LLL 50 1.2 vs your VM 50 1.0?
Good question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1.
...Show more →

I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?
May 09, 2024 at 01:33 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.55 #8Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Knowing you appreciate characterful lenses, I would suggest the CV 50/1.1 Nokton. Similar rendering to the 50/1 Noct.

Sonnar-7 wrote:
_jim_ wrote
ZacharyHH wrote
_jim_ wrotehttps://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53615448346_d5853b271a_b.jpgRubber Plant by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/2 'Elcan,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53614837978_a1b4ac2c32_b.jpgPigeon by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600810272_51abfea83f_b.jpgStranger by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Cinestill 800T.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600276676_bbeda8a703_b.jpgAbandoned Car by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 35mm f/2 '8-Element,' Ilfrod HP5+, Xtol 1:1
Love your work, how to you like this LLL 50 1.2 vs your VM 50 1.0?
Good question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1. The rendering is gorgeous. I can't explain it. It's so difficult to know what will be in focus...but when it all comes together, it just looks lovely. Unlike any other lens I've had.
2. The size. Even though it's heavier than the Nokton, it is significantly smaller.
3. The knurling on the focus ring is fantastic (much, much better than the Nokton). The valleys are deep and knurled, the ridges are smooth (the Nokton’s pattern is the inverse of this…and shallower). Its very grippy and comfortable.

In summary, I feel more confident when using the Nokton that what I am photographing will be usably sharp. With the '1966' I feel like I'm gambling...that the juice is worth the squeeze...I am going to blow a lot of shots for the chance at nailing focus and getting to enjoy the beautiful draw from the lens.
I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?

May 09, 2024 at 01:36 PM
Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.55 #9Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Fred Miranda wrote:
Knowing you appreciate characterful lenses, I would suggest the CV 50/1.1 Nokton. Similar rendering to the 50/1 Noct.

Sonnar-7 wrote
_jim_ wrote
ZacharyHH wrote
_jim_ wrotehttps://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53615448346_d5853b271a_b.jpgRubber Plant by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/2 'Elcan,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53614837978_a1b4ac2c32_b.jpgPigeon by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600810272_51abfea83f_b.jpgStranger by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Cinestill 800T.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600276676_bbeda8a703_b.jpgAbandoned Car by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 35mm f/2 '8-Element,' Ilfrod HP5+, Xtol 1:1
Love your work, how to you like this LLL 50 1.2 vs your VM 50 1.0?
Good question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1. The rendering is gorgeous. I can't explain it. It's so difficult to know what will be in focus...but when it all comes together, it just looks lovely. Unlike any other lens I've had.
2. The size. Even though it's heavier than the Nokton, it is significantly smaller.
3. The knurling on the focus ring is fantastic (much, much better than the Nokton). The valleys are deep and knurled, the ridges are smooth (the Nokton’s pattern is the inverse of this…and shallower). Its very grippy and comfortable.

In summary, I feel more confident when using the Nokton that what I am photographing will be usably sharp. With the '1966' I feel like I'm gambling...that the juice is worth the squeeze...I am going to blow a lot of shots for the chance at nailing focus and getting to enjoy the beautiful draw from the lens.
I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?


I was pondering a lot about this one, it got me quite confused, in some shots it looks like it has a lot of structure in the bokeh and in other it’s very creamy. I was a bit bummed out to see that it barely flares artefact wise(how odd for such an old Voigtlander).
But still it’s on my list, I might just go for it since it still can be found for kind of a bargain and see for myself.
I was surprised by looking lately at the 1.0, it looks more interesting than I thought but the 1.1 on paper should be a better match for me, I looked at your comparison with it and the shots were quite pleasing.
I’m on the market for a big 50mm with wide aperture but the LLL still is a bit pricey to my taste.
May 09, 2024 at 01:45 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.55 #10Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Sonnar-7 wrote:
Fred Miranda wroteKnowing you appreciate characterful lenses, I would suggest the CV 50/1.1 Nokton. Similar rendering to the 50/1 Noct.

Sonnar-7 wrote
_jim_ wrote
ZacharyHH wrote
_jim_ wrotehttps://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53615448346_d5853b271a_b.jpgRubber Plant by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/2 'Elcan,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53614837978_a1b4ac2c32_b.jpgPigeon by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600810272_51abfea83f_b.jpgStranger by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Cinestill 800T.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600276676_bbeda8a703_b.jpgAbandoned Car by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 35mm f/2 '8-Element,' Ilfrod HP5+, Xtol 1:1
Love your work, how to you like this LLL 50 1.2 vs your VM 50 1.0?
Good question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1. The rendering is gorgeous. I can't explain it. It's so difficult to know what will be in focus...but when it all comes together, it just looks lovely. Unlike any other lens I've had.
2. The size. Even though it's heavier than the Nokton, it is significantly smaller.
3. The knurling on the focus ring is fantastic (much, much better than the Nokton). The valleys are deep and knurled, the ridges are smooth (the Nokton’s pattern is the inverse of this…and shallower). Its very grippy and comfortable.

In summary, I feel more confident when using the Nokton that what I am photographing will be usably sharp. With the '1966' I feel like I'm gambling...that the juice is worth the squeeze...I am going to blow a lot of shots for the chance at nailing focus and getting to enjoy the beautiful draw from the lens.
I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?
I was pondering a lot about this one, it got me quite confused, in some shots it looks like it has a lot of structure in the bokeh and in other it’s very creamy. I was a bit bummed out to see that it barely flares artefact wise(how odd for such an old Voigtlander).
But still it’s on my list, I might just go for it since it still can be found for kind of a bargain and see for myself.
I was surprised by looking lately at the 1.0, it looks more interesting than I thought but the 1.1 on
...Show more →

For these vintage lenses, I lean towards lenses that offer sharper images with more structure in the rendering, which is why I'm not particularly drawn to the Leica 50/1.2. Its softness and somewhat smooth rendering don't align with my preferences. Therefore, I didn't hesitate to pass on the new LLL or the re-issued Leica. However, I'm a big fan of the Leica 50/1 Noctilux, which I find even more appealing than the bulkier 50/0.95 Noct. The Voigtlander 50/1.1, while smaller and lighter, delivers a similar aesthetic to the Noctilux, although with higher contrast, which can be adjusted in post-processing.
May 09, 2024 at 02:14 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.55 #11Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Fred Miranda wrote:
Sonnar-7 wrote
Fred Miranda wroteKnowing you appreciate characterful lenses, I would suggest the CV 50/1.1 Nokton. Similar rendering to the 50/1 Noct.

Sonnar-7 wrote
_jim_ wrote
ZacharyHH wroteLove your work, how to you like this LLL 50 1.2 vs your VM 50 1.0?
Good question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1. The rendering is gorgeous. I can't explain it. It's so difficult to know what will be in focus...but when it all comes together, it just looks lovely. Unlike any other lens I've had.
2. The size. Even though it's heavier than the Nokton, it is significantly smaller.
3. The knurling on the focus ring is fantastic (much, much better than the Nokton). The valleys are deep and knurled, the ridges are smooth (the Nokton’s pattern is the inverse of this…and shallower). Its very grippy and comfortable.

In summary, I feel more confident when using the Nokton that what I am photographing will be usably sharp. With the '1966' I feel like I'm gambling...that the juice is worth the squeeze...I am going to blow a lot of shots for the chance at nailing focus and getting to enjoy the beautiful draw from the lens.
I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?
I was pondering a lot about this one, it got me quite confused, in some shots it looks like it has a lot of structure in the bokeh and in other it’s very creamy. I was a bit bummed out to see that it barely flares artefact wise(how odd for such an old Voigtlander).
But still it’s on my list, I might just go for it since it still can be found for kind of a bargain and see for myself.
I was surprised by looking lately at the 1.0, it looks more interesting than I thought but the 1.1 on paper should be a better match for me, I looked at your comparison with it and the shots were quite pleasing.
I’m on the market for a big 50mm with wide aperture but the LLL still is a bit pricey to my taste.
For these vintage lenses, I lean towards lenses that offer sharper images with more structure in the rendering, which is why I'm not particularly drawn to the Leica 50/1.2. Its softness and somewhat smooth rendering don't align with my preferences. Therefore, I didn't hesitate to pass on the new LLL or the re-issued Leica. However, I'm a big fan of the Leica 50/1 Noctilux, which I find even more appealing than the bulkier 50/0.95 Noct. The Voigtlander 50/1.1, while smaller and lighter, delivers a similar aesthetic to the Noctilux, although with higher contrast, which can be adjusted in post-processing.


I would concur on those preferences, that’s why I went from buying every M42 vintage lenses I could find to some new old formula lenses, the softness is not really what I like either in the vintage rendering, structure in the bokeh would be the main thing and then I don’t mind contrast and sharpness.
Calling it vintage is a disservice to some of those « character lenses » it could just be a matter of choice, the consensus in modern photography is to lean toward ultra creamy bokeh and I don’t think it’s necessarily synonymous to optical perfection.
I thought the LLL 50mm 1.2 would be my dream lens but I’m not that sure now even though I would still be curious to try one.
The 50mm 1.1 is indeed interesting, I’m surprised in all that, that my favorite lens these days might be the Panchro, my old self wouldn’t believe me to have fallen for a f2 lens. How moderate have I become.

May 09, 2024 at 02:32 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.55 #12Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Sonnar-7 wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Sonnar-7 wrote
Fred Miranda wroteKnowing you appreciate characterful lenses, I would suggest the CV 50/1.1 Nokton. Similar rendering to the 50/1 Noct.

Sonnar-7 wrote
_jim_ wroteGood question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1. The rendering is gorgeous. I can't explain it. It's so difficult to know what will be in focus...but when it all comes together, it just looks lovely. Unlike any other lens I've had.
2. The size. Even though it's heavier than the Nokton, it is significantly smaller.
3. The knurling on the focus ring is fantastic (much, much better than the Nokton). The valleys are deep and knurled, the ridges are smooth (the Nokton’s pattern is the inverse of this…and shallower). Its very grippy and comfortable.

In summary, I feel more confident when using the Nokton that what I am photographing will be usably sharp. With the '1966' I feel like I'm gambling...that the juice is worth the squeeze...I am going to blow a lot of shots for the chance at nailing focus and getting to enjoy the beautiful draw from the lens.
I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?
I was pondering a lot about this one, it got me quite confused, in some shots it looks like it has a lot of structure in the bokeh and in other it’s very creamy. I was a bit bummed out to see that it barely flares artefact wise(how odd for such an old Voigtlander).
But still it’s on my list, I might just go for it since it still can be found for kind of a bargain and see for myself.
I was surprised by looking lately at the 1.0, it looks more interesting than I thought but the 1.1 on paper should be a better match for me, I looked at your comparison with it and the shots were quite pleasing.
I’m on the market for a big 50mm with wide aperture but the LLL still is a bit pricey to my taste.
For these vintage lenses, I lean towards lenses that offer sharper images with more structure in the rendering, which is why I'm not particularly drawn to the Leica 50/1.2. Its softness and somewhat smooth rendering don't align with my preferences. Therefore, I didn't hesitate to pass on the new LLL or the re-issued Leica. However, I'm a big fan of the Leica 50/1 Noctilux, which I find even more appealing than the bulkier 50/0.95 Noct. The Voigtlander 50/1.1, while smaller and lighter, delivers a similar aesthetic to the Noctilux, although with higher contrast, which can be adjusted in post-processing.
I would concur on those preferences, that’s why I went from buying every M42 vintage lenses I could find to some new old formula lenses, the softness is not really what I like either in the vintage rendering, structure in the bokeh would be the main thing and then I don’t mind contrast and sharpness.
Calling it vintage is a disservice to some of those « character lenses » it could just be a matter of choice, the consensus in modern photography is to lean toward ultra creamy bokeh and I don’t think it’s necessarily synonymous to optical perfection.
I thought the LLL 50mm
...Show more →

Another advantage of the CV 50/1.1 is its black front thread (instead of brass chrome) and the aperture ring, which has a satisfyingly tactile feel (cliquey) reminiscent of older Leica lenses. I appreciate these details too. The filter thread is 58mm just like the first version of the 50/1 Noct.
May 09, 2024 at 03:12 PM
tunisia
Offline
Details
p.55 #13Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
In the context of these two lenses, the CV 50/1.1 and LLL 50mm f/1.2, where do you guys think the MS-Optics Elnomaxim 55/1.2 fits in?
Thanks,
Joe D
May 09, 2024 at 04:27 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.55 #14Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
tunisia wrote:
In the context of these two lenses, the CV 50/1.1 and LLL 50mm f/1.2, where do you guys think the MS-Optics Elnomaxim 55/1.2 fits in?
Thanks,
Joe D


Hi Joe,

It's definitely a small lens, but I've never tried the Elnomaxim 55/1.2. Given that it's a 4-element f/1.2 lens, I expect there will be lots of coma and spherical aberration wide open.
May 09, 2024 at 10:12 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.55 #15Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
tunisia wrote:
In the context of these two lenses, the CV 50/1.1 and LLL 50mm f/1.2, where do you guys think the MS-Optics Elnomaxim 55/1.2 fits in?
Thanks,
Joe D


I have Elnomaxim 55/1.2 and I really like it a lot, but as I don't have CV 50/1.1 nor LLL 50/1.2 I can't really say how it compares to those. Elnomaxim is very soft and extremely glowy wide open and it sharpens up quite dramatically when stopped down. At f8 it's pretty sharp corner-to-corner for infinity shots (on my Sony A7CII). I mostly use it wide open (I like it's wide open extreme character better than slightly stopped down where the glow goes away pretty fast) and at f8. Some albums of samples:

https://photos.app.goo.gl/wUgWZdX7vpCgdfN86
https://photos.app.goo.gl/LDYPFCi8BLfaWGZi7
https://photos.app.goo.gl/vqgBtDUeZnpgAnG87
https://photos.app.goo.gl/PtmJJo5UBPKEfdGv9
https://photos.app.goo.gl/Ag4vjrVzEUDJ6pA7A
May 10, 2024 at 04:34 AM
catacore
Offline
Details
p.55 #16Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
.

Edited on Jan 13, 2025 at 06:31 AM · View previous versions
May 10, 2024 at 12:55 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.55 #17Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Fred Miranda wrote:
Knowing you appreciate characterful lenses, I would suggest the CV 50/1.1 Nokton. Similar rendering to the 50/1 Noct.

Sonnar-7 wrote
_jim_ wrote
ZacharyHH wrote
_jim_ wrotehttps://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53615448346_d5853b271a_b.jpgRubber Plant by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/2 'Elcan,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53614837978_a1b4ac2c32_b.jpgPigeon by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Ilford HP5+, Xtol 1:1

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600810272_51abfea83f_b.jpgStranger by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M7, Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.2 '1966,' Cinestill 800T.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53600276676_bbeda8a703_b.jpgAbandoned Car by Jim Fischer, on Flickr
Leica M5, Light Lens Lab 35mm f/2 '8-Element,' Ilfrod HP5+, Xtol 1:1
Love your work, how to you like this LLL 50 1.2 vs your VM 50 1.0?
Good question:

I really like both. Let me elaborate...

Pros of the Nokton f/1:
1. It is sharper at every aperture at every distance in every part of the frame.
2. Shorter focus throw (I find the very, very long throw of the LLL to be slow and doesn't necessarily aid in more precise focusing).
3. It's lighter.
4. Bayonet mount hoods are the best. I can grab my camera from my bag without concern that I am grabbing a free spinning hood (like on the LLL) and gouging the paint job.
5. Very low geometric distortion.
6. Modern high contrast.
7. Very good flare resistance.

Pros of the '1966':
1. The rendering is gorgeous. I can't explain it. It's so difficult to know what will be in focus...but when it all comes together, it just looks lovely. Unlike any other lens I've had.
2. The size. Even though it's heavier than the Nokton, it is significantly smaller.
3. The knurling on the focus ring is fantastic (much, much better than the Nokton). The valleys are deep and knurled, the ridges are smooth (the Nokton’s pattern is the inverse of this…and shallower). Its very grippy and comfortable.

In summary, I feel more confident when using the Nokton that what I am photographing will be usably sharp. With the '1966' I feel like I'm gambling...that the juice is worth the squeeze...I am going to blow a lot of shots for the chance at nailing focus and getting to enjoy the beautiful draw from the lens.
I have become curious about the Voigtlander 1.0 by looking at your photos and reading about it.
I initially thought that it would be of no interest to me since I have the Voigtlander 50mm 1.2 and had assumed it was all about the same in rendering, but discovered that it yields more character than I thought it would.
It looks like it has some structure in the bokeh, could it be that it has more than the LLL 50mm 1.2?



I keep forgetting I have the Nokton 1.1!
May 10, 2024 at 01:22 PM
tunisia
Offline
Details
p.55 #18Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
Juha Kannisto wrote:
tunisia wroteIn the context of these two lenses, the CV 50/1.1 and LLL 50mm f/1.2, where do you guys think the MS-Optics Elnomaxim 55/1.2 fits in?
Thanks,
Joe D
I have Elnomaxim 55/1.2 and I really like it a lot, but as I don't have CV 50/1.1 nor LLL 50/1.2 I can't really say how it compares to those. Elnomaxim is very soft and extremely glowy wide open and it sharpens up quite dramatically when stopped down. At f8 it's pretty sharp corner-to-corner for infinity shots (on my Sony A7CII). I mostly use it wide open (I like it's wide open extreme character better than slightly stopped down where the glow goes away pretty fast) and at f8. Some albums of samples:

https://photos.app.goo.gl/wUgWZdX7vpCgdfN86
https://photos.app.goo.gl/LDYPFCi8BLfaWGZi7
https://photos.app.goo.gl/vqgBtDUeZnpgAnG87
https://photos.app.goo.gl/PtmJJo5UBPKEfdGv9
https://photos.app.goo.gl/Ag4vjrVzEUDJ6pA7A

Hi Juha,
Thanks for the photos. They're really great and give a good idea of its performance. I ordered a couple of days ago from Japan Exposures but am getting antsy. You know, not much info out there on these lenses. I really appreciate what you guys do here with regard to MS-Optics lenses, especially you and Fred. I already have an MS-Optics Vario-Petz PZ 57mm /2 F-MC and love it. I use it mainly on the Leica 11 Mono but sometimes on the GFX 100ii where it is good at close distances.
Joe D
May 10, 2024 at 04:07 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.55 #19Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
A few shots with the 50mm SPII on the M11M from the south entrance/south rim overlooks of the Grand Canyon last weekend. All shot at f/2 with no color filter. Vignetting added in C1.





LLL 50mm SPII







LLL 50mm SPII







LLL 50mm SPII







LLL 50mm SPII

May 10, 2024 at 05:19 PM
Sonnar-7
Offline
Details
p.55 #20Light Lens Lab (LLL) replica lenses discussion & image thread
highdesertmesa wrote:
A few shots with the 50mm SPII on the M11M from the south entrance/south rim overlooks of the Grand Canyon last weekend. All shot at f/2 with no color filter. Vignetting added in C1.


Those are beautiful shots, I like character lenses but I’m not oblivious to the fact that it might not sit well with landscapes but it does some wonders there.
May 11, 2024 at 04:00 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister