This thread hasn't seen as much love lately. The RF 50mm has been one of my favorite lenses of all time and it rarely comes off of my EOS R. Here are some recent family photos I took with this lens for some friends.
h00ligan wrote:
I feel like the 24-105 variable aperture (which I do t really want but I guess will make an ok walks round in decent light or for still subjects) is probably the only other lens I’d really NEED if I got this. The rendering is incredible. I’ve been very critical of canon lately (and I feel justifiably so) but this lens in the hands of decent photographers offers some amazing images. But then it’s basically Leica pricing so yah. No.
I own the Leica SL2 with the APO Summicron-SL 35, 50 and 90. I took the R5 out with the RF 50 1.2 today (see above) and I may sell all of my Leica Gear. With the sale of my preowned Leica kit I should be able to cover the cost of...
The R5 body
RF 50 1.2
RF 85 1.2
RF 28-70 f2
RF 70-200 f2.8
Battery grip
extra battery
512GB CF express card
So yeah, no - the Canon gear isn't the same price as the Leica gear (but it's 95% the performance of it and, in some cases, performs much better).
This lens is bonkers good. I rented it for the week, but unfortunately I haven't had a chance to really put it through it's paces yet. Combine with the AF of the R6, though, getting absolutely spot on focus on the eyes is trivially easy for quick shots:
I've only briefly tried out the RF 85/1.2, but from that small test, and everything else I've seen, it's at least as good if not better. These two f/1.2 primes are exceptional (as they should be for what they cost).
saxguy wrote:
Does anyone have the RF 50 1.2 and the RF 85 1.2? If so, how is the image quality of the RF 85 1.2, comparatively?
I haven't used the RF 85 1.2, but from what I gathered from reviews is that the RF 85 1.2 has the edge over the RF 50 1.2 when it comes to how it controls chromatic abberations. It has an extra element that pretty much eliminates it. The RF 50 1.2 is no slouch though and I have really enjoyed it. It does have fairly heavy vignetting, but I kind of like the look.
Mtmountainman wrote: saxguy wroteDoes anyone have the RF 50 1.2 and the RF 85 1.2? If so, how is the image quality of the RF 85 1.2, comparatively?I haven't used the RF 85 1.2, but from what I gathered from reviews is that the RF 85 1.2 has the edge over the RF 50 1.2 when it comes to how it controls chromatic abberations. It has an extra element that pretty much eliminates it. The RF 50 1.2 is no slouch though and I have really enjoyed it. It does have fairly heavy vignetting, but I kind of like the look.
I have the 85 on order, can’t wait. I took the APO 50 Summicron-SL out last night with the SL2-S. Many times people say that Canon images look flat as compared to Leica, but from what I was seeing the Canon R5 with the RF 50 1.2 has an amazing look close up. I still may prefer the SL2 (Not SL2-S) for high contrast detailed black and white conversions, probably due to the lack of an anti aliasing filter, but I’m very happy with the R5 so far.
Mtmountainman wrote: saxguy wroteDoes anyone have the RF 50 1.2 and the RF 85 1.2? If so, how is the image quality of the RF 85 1.2, comparatively?I haven't used the RF 85 1.2, but from what I gathered from reviews is that the RF 85 1.2 has the edge over the RF 50 1.2 when it comes to how it controls chromatic abberations. It has an extra element that pretty much eliminates it. The RF 50 1.2 is no slouch though and I have really enjoyed it. It does have fairly heavy vignetting, but I kind of like the look.
I have both, and can confirm that they are both amazing. The 85 may have the slightest bit advantage, but at no point would it ever stop me from using the 50mm lens, under any circumstances, ever. Get the focal length you prefer.
Photography is a hobby for me, so I don't get to pick up new lenses all that often. Do you find the 50 and the 85 different enough to own both? I was initially wanting the RF 50 (Which I now own) and the RF 70-200, but after seeing how sharp the 50 is, I kind of want to stick with primes. I really wish they would release a RF 135, but sadly there is no word on one.
ChrisLovesUgly wrote: Mtmountainman wrotesaxguy wroteDoes anyone have the RF 50 1.2 and the RF 85 1.2? If so, how is the image quality of the RF 85 1.2, comparatively?I haven't used the RF 85 1.2, but from what I gathered from reviews is that the RF 85 1.2 has the edge over the RF 50 1.2 when it comes to how it controls chromatic abberations. It has an extra element that pretty much eliminates it. The RF 50 1.2 is no slouch though and I have really enjoyed it. It does have fairly heavy vignetting, but I kind of like the look.I have both, and can confirm that they are both amazing. The 85 may have the slightest bit advantage, but at no point would it ever stop me from using the 50mm lens, under any circumstances, ever. Get the focal length you prefer.
Mtmountainman wrote:
Photography is a hobby for me, so I don't get to pick up new lenses all that often. Do you find the 50 and the 85 different enough to own both? I was initially wanting the RF 50 (Which I now own) and the RF 70-200, but after seeing how sharp the 50 is, I kind of want to stick with primes. I really wish they would release a RF 135, but sadly there is no word on one.
As a hobbyist, that's a hard sell. I really like 85, but 50 is more useful (and the 85 is just plain large for a lens). It's often the same discussion between 35mm and 50mm - are they close enough to justify both? For what it's worth, I suspect they'll have a 135 sooner, rather than later - but you can always adapt the great EF 135/2 until then.
However, I would go with zooms over primes and a nice 50, which you already have. I think stopped down, you won't see much difference in sharpness. Also, the ability to zoom from 100-500 (for example) is more useful then super thin depth of field.
I think you'll enjoy whatever lens you get, but a tele zoom would give you something quite a bit different then just a longer version of the 50mm you already have.
I do not have the RF 50mm but I do have the RF 85mm f/1.2 and just love it. I am considering the RF 50 for when I am restricted in room size. Here is a sample from my 85 and I just love the contrast and pop it has. Krystal by rgollar, on Flickr
Mtmountainman wrote:
This thread hasn't seen as much love lately. The RF 50mm has been one of my favorite lenses of all time and it rarely comes off of my EOS R. Here are some recent family photos I took with this lens for some friends.
Just guessing -- but were the kids playing a game as if 3 were like tall straight trees and the one on the left representing a leaning stem?