Since we have the old EF 50/1.2 image thread, I thought having one dedicated for the RF version is appropriate. The response for this lens has been lukewarm so far and I'm not sure why. But here are some WO pics at the Route 60 Car Show taken with this lens.
patotts wrote:
This lens would be the main reason I would buy a Canon mirrorless system. Keep those images coming!
I second this as someone sitting on the fence and also looking at Sony! This and the 28-70 f/2 keep calling me for my new foray into portraits and eventually weddings...
If you shoot for money, this one is a step towards some very pleased clients. What a leg up for the shooter working under the duress of tough conditions.
I shoot Sony but I'm an brand-impartial lens guy first and foremost, the rest is less important downstream workflow. This one is an instant classic, and I've not seen a poor image from it, its signature imbues images with a special grace. These days anyone can produce sharp lenses but the aesthetic look is much harder to achieve.
Out-of-focus foliage and strong contrasty light are the toughest tests for fast lenses because what appears cannot be remedied in post. The other comment to make is that lenses such as this and big brother RF85 are important to photography at this particular time of industry flux - due to the leap in image quality, they educate users in image appreciation and they serve as reference lenses for what comes after.
'I'm not sure why.'
People will come around in time. You might see the strange situation where paying clients are ahead of the photographic community, because honest new-old comparisons will be brutal. Kudos to Canon.
philip_pj wrote:
If you shoot for money, this one is a step towards some very pleased clients. What a leg up for the shooter working under the duress of tough conditions.
I shoot Sony but I'm an brand-impartial lens guy first and foremost, the rest is less important downstream workflow. This one is an instant classic, and I've not seen a poor image from it, its signature imbues images with a special grace. These days anyone can produce sharp lenses but the aesthetic look is much harder to achieve.
Out-of-focus foliage and strong contrasty light are the toughest tests for fast lenses because what appears cannot be remedied in post. The other comment to make is that lenses such as this and big brother RF85 are important to photography at this particular time of industry flux - due to the leap in image quality, they educate users in image appreciation and they serve as reference lenses for what comes after.
'I'm not sure why.'
People will come around in time. You might see the strange situation where paying clients are ahead of the photographic community, because honest new-old comparisons will be brutal. Kudos to Canon....Show more →
I'm mostly in the same boat with Philip. I was a Canon guy most of my life and didn't fully transition out until about 2013. Regardless, I don't really care what the brand of my rig is, I just want something that pumps out images I love and offers and enjoyable shooting experience. I am willing to forego the latter if the former can convince me enough.
In very recent memory, I almost pulled the trigger on an RP or R just so I could get my hands on this lens. But then I looked through the images on the flickr group and was just generally underwhelmed. The images just in this thread seem to show otherwise though. So in other words, I need more FMers to show me more.
I really want to jump in. But as this would require picking up a fourth rig (again), I really need to be convinced since I already have more than I need rotting in my closet.
So many great cameras around, these days and overall lenses are getting better. Nice problems to have. Flickr might do some processing, so I've read, but what you see from FM people is a very good guide.
Most of these have been posted elsewhere here, but thought I'd put them in this lens-specific thread as well.
Canon really has shaken up the paradigm – combining super-engineered, high-element count, sharp corner-to-corner wide open lenses with the (micro)contrast and bokeh character of vintage low-element count lenses. Amazing really.
philip_pj wrote:
If you shoot for money, this one is a step towards some very pleased clients. What a leg up for the shooter working under the duress of tough conditions.
I shoot Sony but I'm an brand-impartial lens guy first and foremost, the rest is less important downstream workflow. This one is an instant classic, and I've not seen a poor image from it, its signature imbues images with a special grace. These days anyone can produce sharp lenses but the aesthetic look is much harder to achieve.
Out-of-focus foliage and strong contrasty light are the toughest tests for fast lenses because what appears cannot be remedied in post. The other comment to make is that lenses such as this and big brother RF85 are important to photography at this particular time of industry flux - due to the leap in image quality, they educate users in image appreciation and they serve as reference lenses for what comes after.
'I'm not sure why.'
People will come around in time. You might see the strange situation where paying clients are ahead of the photographic community, because honest new-old comparisons will be brutal. Kudos to Canon....Show more →
I'm sure it's a fantastic lens. But I'm not sure that most clients can tell the difference between this and most other 50mm lenses. The reason: lots of 50mm lenses produce a very beautiful look, and pleased clients. If someone doesn't have pleased clients, it is probably not the fault of their 50mm lens.
NJPhotographer wrote:
I'm sure it's a fantastic lens. But I'm not sure that most clients can tell the difference between this and most other 50mm lenses. The reason: lots of 50mm lenses produce a very beautiful look, and pleased clients. If someone doesn't have pleased clients, it is probably not the fault of their 50mm lens.
Wrong way to look at it .. or put in different words, there's another way to look and ponder this ...
There will be a difference they can tell, but probably won't realize. But if a skilled photographer used both 50mm lenses and placed 20 inch prints in front of someone, odds are they will like one better.
A lesson was learned about 35 years ago ...
We worked at a public golf course, where every morning we found a few sets of footprints in EVERY SINGLE sand trap / bunker. Over a few months, we reshaped the depth, corrected and put a crisp edge on every trap, where the look exceeded all the best private clubs in the area. It's a fact, because golfing at every and any golf course was our industry benefit.
After the maintenance upgrade, we could return after TWO weekend days, and on Monday, only find a few footprints among EVERY AND ALL sand traps of all 18 holes combined. We literally changed the behavior of golfers. But part of the lesson learned was they didn't realize why their behavior changed. It was based on something different they could see, but did not connect the dots about.
NJPhotographer wrote: philip_pj wroteIf you shoot for money, this one is a step towards some very pleased clients. What a leg up for the shooter working under the duress of tough conditions.
I shoot Sony but I'm an brand-impartial lens guy first and foremost, the rest is less important downstream workflow. This one is an instant classic, and I've not seen a poor image from it, its signature imbues images with a special grace. These days anyone can produce sharp lenses but the aesthetic look is much harder to achieve.
Out-of-focus foliage and strong contrasty light are the toughest tests for fast lenses because what appears cannot be remedied in post. The other comment to make is that lenses such as this and big brother RF85 are important to photography at this particular time of industry flux - due to the leap in image quality, they educate users in image appreciation and they serve as reference lenses for what comes after.
'I'm not sure why.'
People will come around in time. You might see the strange situation where paying clients are ahead of the photographic community, because honest new-old comparisons will be brutal. Kudos to Canon.I'm sure it's a fantastic lens. But I'm not sure that most clients can tell the difference between this and most other 50mm lenses. The reason: lots of 50mm lenses produce a very beautiful look, and pleased clients. If someone doesn't have pleased clients, it is probably not the fault of their 50mm lens.
Well, at the same time, you gotta enjoy using your tools to make good pictures. It's just like those Leica pros or the MF guys. You can certainly get good enough results for much less. At the same time, sometimes one can develop their own post to enhance that certain looks from their tools that would appeal certain set of clients.
I'm just saying there are a lot of really good 50mm lenses that have pleased a lot of clients and pleased a lot of photographers. And this has been so for many years. These are lenses that are not just "good enough", but really, really good. I say that while recognizing that the RF50 might be better than all of them.
The scenario of a photographer placing 20-inch prints in front of a client to see which lens they like better is a possible survey project for someone, but is extremely unlikely to happen in everyday photography life.
NJPhotographer wrote:
I'm just saying there are a lot of really good 50mm lenses that have pleased a lot of clients and pleased a lot of photographers. And this has been so for many years. These are lenses that are not just "good enough", but really, really good. I say that while recognizing that the RF50 might be better than all of them.
The scenario of a photographer placing 20-inch prints in front of a client to see which lens they like better is a possible survey project for someone, but is extremely unlikely to happen in everyday photography life.
You are right !!
I usually place 30 inch photos in front of half the people I photograph. I carry 18 inchers in my van, but have a stack of 30 inch prints that I show folks at every opportunity so they can see extra detail.
I bought back into Canon (in a small way) only because of this RF 50/1.2 lens. It is everything. Sure, it is heavy, big and expensive, but it produces magic.
Once we get a R body with higher resolution, improved AF and IBIS, I'll be set and can retire my Sony gear ;-)