fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.

  
 
fsiagian
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
nehemiahphoto wrote:
fsiagian wroteI know the modification makes m-mount lenses work much better. But does it affect other lenses (Sony, Sigma, etc) that do not need any modification?
Yeah, for native glass, lens by lens depends. This is very helpful:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/

Thank you. That is very helpful.

Dec 10, 2021 at 06:57 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #2Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
fsiagian wrote:
I know the modification makes m-mount lenses work much better. But does it affect other lenses (Sony, Sigma, etc) that do not need any modification?


It may actually benefit fast native glass when shooting wide open at close/mid distance as the corners will be more out of focus.
Dec 10, 2021 at 09:18 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
realVivek wrote:
Rich uses a WB standard I gave him. You set the WB using this every time with your lens mounted under the lighting condition you would be shooting. It is a special PTFE material.

Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
naturephoto1 wrote
realVivek wroteBreathe easy, Rich. I have no doubt that they (Kolari) will do a professional job and everything will be top notch.

The one I am fixing up was done by someone else who should not be handling any cameras at all, IMHO.
Hi Vivek,

I am shocked. Kolari Vision just sent me an e-mail that my A7rII is completed and shipped back to me via USPS Priority Mail (USPS only shows the label has been completed at this point). If this is correct, I should have the camera back in my hands by Friday? or Saturday. So, Kolari Vision received my camera on Monday, performed the UT modification, and shipped it back to me on Wednesday. Amazing turnaround time. Rich
I just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.


Hi Vivek,

Thank you again for your most generous white Balance cards. For me at this point, I have taken test shots under Daylight, Cloudy, and Shade conditions that I have stored in the memory of my Kolari Vision UT Sensor Modified A7rII and my Kolari Vision Thin Sensor V3 modified A7r cameras. It is faster and easier for me to use the 3 saved lighting White Balance settings in the field. I could as Vivek indicated take an image with the White Card in those conditions and save it with the other images taken under the conditions. I know that that will be my practice for taking photos on my planned trip to Italy when photos are taken when my saved settings in my Kolari Vision UT sensor modified A7rII when those conditions are different as an example in churches and indoors.

Rich

Dec 10, 2021 at 09:29 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #4Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
naturephoto1 wrote:
realVivek wroteRich uses a WB standard I gave him. You set the WB using this every time with your lens mounted under the lighting condition you would be shooting. It is a special PTFE material.

Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
naturephoto1 wroteHi Vivek,

I am shocked. Kolari Vision just sent me an e-mail that my A7rII is completed and shipped back to me via USPS Priority Mail (USPS only shows the label has been completed at this point). If this is correct, I should have the camera back in my hands by Friday? or Saturday. So, Kolari Vision received my camera on Monday, performed the UT modification, and shipped it back to me on Wednesday. Amazing turnaround time. Rich
I just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
Hi Vivek,

Thank you again for your most generous white Balance cards. For me at this point, I have taken test shots under Daylight, Cloudy, and Shade conditions that I have stored in the memory of my Kolari Vision UT Sensor Modified A7rII and my Kolari Vision Thin Sensor V3 modified A7r cameras. It is faster and easier for me to use the 3 saved lighting White Balance settings in the field. I could as Vivek indicated take an image with the White Card in those conditions and save it with the other images taken under the conditions. I know that
...Show more →

That's a great way of doing it but I think a custom camera profile could work very well to account for the temperature and tilt shift.
Dec 10, 2021 at 10:34 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.3 #5Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
naturephoto1 wrote
realVivek wroteBreathe easy, Rich. I have no doubt that they (Kolari) will do a professional job and everything will be top notch.

The one I am fixing up was done by someone else who should not be handling any cameras at all, IMHO.
Hi Vivek,

I am shocked. Kolari Vision just sent me an e-mail that my A7rII is completed and shipped back to me via USPS Priority Mail (USPS only shows the label has been completed at this point). If this is correct, I should have the camera back in my hands by Friday? or Saturday. So, Kolari Vision received my camera on Monday, performed the UT modification, and shipped it back to me on Wednesday. Amazing turnaround time. Rich
I just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.


I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
Dec 10, 2021 at 07:31 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #6Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
freaklikeme wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
naturephoto1 wrote
realVivek wroteBreathe easy, Rich. I have no doubt that they (Kolari) will do a professional job and everything will be top notch.

The one I am fixing up was done by someone else who should not be handling any cameras at all, IMHO.
Hi Vivek,

I am shocked. Kolari Vision just sent me an e-mail that my A7rII is completed and shipped back to me via USPS Priority Mail (USPS only shows the label has been completed at this point). If this is correct, I should have the camera back in my hands by Friday? or Saturday. So, Kolari Vision received my camera on Monday, performed the UT modification, and shipped it back to me on Wednesday. Amazing turnaround time. Rich
I just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.


thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.
Dec 10, 2021 at 10:10 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.3 #7Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
naturephoto1 wroteHi Vivek,

I am shocked. Kolari Vision just sent me an e-mail that my A7rII is completed and shipped back to me via USPS Priority Mail (USPS only shows the label has been completed at this point). If this is correct, I should have the camera back in my hands by Friday? or Saturday. So, Kolari Vision received my camera on Monday, performed the UT modification, and shipped it back to me on Wednesday. Amazing turnaround time. Rich
I just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.


Are you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
Dec 10, 2021 at 10:35 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #8Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
freaklikeme wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wroteI just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.
Are you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.


What you do you mean by constant?
Dec 10, 2021 at 10:38 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.3 #9Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wroteVery cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.
Are you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
What you do you mean by constant?


Sorry, I was on my phone and mistyped custom, which it changed to "constant." Setting WB up via custom setting and the WB card on the passport (assuming you're using the passport) before shooting the card.
Dec 11, 2021 at 12:44 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
This is why a special WB standard and custom WB in camera helps.

Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
naturephoto1 wroteHi Vivek,

I am shocked. Kolari Vision just sent me an e-mail that my A7rII is completed and shipped back to me via USPS Priority Mail (USPS only shows the label has been completed at this point). If this is correct, I should have the camera back in my hands by Friday? or Saturday. So, Kolari Vision received my camera on Monday, performed the UT modification, and shipped it back to me on Wednesday. Amazing turnaround time. Rich
I just received my A7R II with the Kolari UT (v4). My preliminary findings is that performance with my M lenses is on pair with the Leica M10-R. White balance's tweak seems easy too as I just see a bit of warm temp./magenta tint but his can be adjusted permanently in camera.
Very cool, Fred. You're the first person I know of using the newest filter, so it's good to hear all is positive so far.
So far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.


Dec 11, 2021 at 02:22 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #11Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
freaklikeme wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wroteSo far, no complaints, except for the color shift. It's just an extra step.

Has anyone tried making a custom profile for the modded A7R II? I will try that tomorrow using color checker camera calibration. If successful, I will make it available.
I have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.
Are you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
What you do you mean by constant?
Sorry, I was on my phone and mistyped custom, which it changed to "constant." Setting WB up via custom setting and the WB card on the passport (assuming you're using the passport) before shooting the card.


This should make zero difference when creating a profile. To test this out:
Take 3 images of the color checker target (same lighting). One with custom WB, another with Auto WB and another using Daylight.. Create a profile for each of the DNG files and give them different names. Load a regular raw image (from the modded camera) in Lightroom and compare the profiles. All three profiles should affect the RAW file the same exact way.
Dec 11, 2021 at 09:28 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.3 #12Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wroteI have them for the original UT and rIII, but not the latest. My feeling is you'd be better off making them yourself since the color response seems to change with each new version, but I can try to figure out how to share mine if you want them.
thank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.
Are you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
What you do you mean by constant?
Sorry, I was on my phone and mistyped custom, which it changed to "constant." Setting WB up via custom setting and the WB card on the passport (assuming you're using the passport) before shooting the card.
This should make zero difference when creating a profile. To test this out:
Take 3 images of the color checker target (same lighting). One with custom WB, another with Auto WB and another using Daylight.. Create a profile for each of the DNG files and give them different names. Load a regular raw image (from the modded camera) in Lightroom and compare the profiles. All three profiles should affect the RAW file the same exact way.


Should, yes, but the profiles should also eliminate any tint issues.
Dec 11, 2021 at 03:29 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #13Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
freaklikeme wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrotethank you for the offer!

I have created a profile using ColorChecker and it's ok. The main issue is temperature/tint shift and I don't think color profiles will fix this. I am still working on it.
Are you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
What you do you mean by constant?
Sorry, I was on my phone and mistyped custom, which it changed to "constant." Setting WB up via custom setting and the WB card on the passport (assuming you're using the passport) before shooting the card.
This should make zero difference when creating a profile. To test this out:
Take 3 images of the color checker target (same lighting). One with custom WB, another with Auto WB and another using Daylight.. Create a profile for each of the DNG files and give them different names. Load a regular raw image (from the modded camera) in Lightroom and compare the profiles. All three profiles should affect the RAW file the same exact way.
Should, yes, but the profiles should also eliminate any tint issues.


Well done custom profiles should not affect tint or color temperature. That's a WB adjustment which still have to be addressed in camera or in post when dealing with the UT coverglass.

I suggest using the grey on the colorchecker passport or similar. On a sunny day, take a picture the a gray card and register it as daylight setting. Do the same for other lighting conditions mostly used.
Dec 12, 2021 at 10:47 AM
Grenache
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wroteAre you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
What you do you mean by constant?
Sorry, I was on my phone and mistyped custom, which it changed to "constant." Setting WB up via custom setting and the WB card on the passport (assuming you're using the passport) before shooting the card.
This should make zero difference when creating a profile. To test this out:
Take 3 images of the color checker target (same lighting). One with custom WB, another with Auto WB and another using Daylight.. Create a profile for each of the DNG files and give them different names. Load a regular raw image (from the modded camera) in Lightroom and compare the profiles. All three profiles should affect the RAW file the same exact way.
Should, yes, but the profiles should also eliminate any tint issues.
Well done custom profiles should not affect tint or color temperature. That's a WB adjustment which still have to be addressed in camera or in post when dealing with the UT coverglass.

I suggest using the grey on the colorchecker passport or similar. On a sunny day, take a picture the a gray card and register it as daylight setting. Do the same for other lighting conditions mostly used.


Actually, in the recently re-relaeased Adobe DNG Profiler, it is trivial to edit color bias/shifts, independent of WB, it is analogous to editing the HSL/Color widgets in LR. If a camera has a particular shift, that can bake in the "fix." The downside with that approach is that you can't apply other Profiles, like Cobalt. Saving a Preset with the same adjustments in the HSL/Color and applying that on image Import can serve the same purpose and allow other Profiles to be used.

Dec 12, 2021 at 02:06 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.3 #15Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wroteAre you setting your WB as a constant? That improved my satisfaction with the CC results.
What you do you mean by constant?
Sorry, I was on my phone and mistyped custom, which it changed to "constant." Setting WB up via custom setting and the WB card on the passport (assuming you're using the passport) before shooting the card.
This should make zero difference when creating a profile. To test this out:
Take 3 images of the color checker target (same lighting). One with custom WB, another with Auto WB and another using Daylight.. Create a profile for each of the DNG files and give them different names. Load a regular raw image (from the modded camera) in Lightroom and compare the profiles. All three profiles should affect the RAW file the same exact way.
Should, yes, but the profiles should also eliminate any tint issues.
Well done custom profiles should not affect tint or color temperature. That's a WB adjustment which still have to be addressed in camera or in post when dealing with the UT coverglass.

I suggest using the grey on the colorchecker passport or similar. On a sunny day, take a picture the a gray card and register it as daylight setting. Do the same for other lighting conditions mostly used.


You're right, it shouldn't affect WB, nor should it leave you with a skewed tint, but unless you've set your dual luminance profile to opposite ends of the spectrum or you've created individual profiles for specific lighting conditions, getting an accurate white balance when shooting may not leave you with an accurate profile to apply. And shooting your Passport with Sony's auto WB (outside of daylight conditions), in my experience, may lead to inaccurate profiling as well, which is why I recommend setting a custom WB before shooting the Passport. That's my whole point.
Dec 12, 2021 at 10:03 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.3 #16Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
freaklikeme wrote:
And shooting your Passport with Sony's auto WB (outside of daylight conditions), in my experience, may lead to inaccurate profiling as well, which is why I recommend setting a custom WB before shooting the Passport. That's my whole point.


I do not see what you described and this is easy to test: At around noon on a sunny day, shoot the CC passport color swatches using Daylight, Custom WB or even Tungsten.

Create 3 profiles using the CC app from different WB raw images.

Then, load a real world raw file in LR and try the profiles created on it. The result should look identical!

Dec 12, 2021 at 10:44 PM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.3 #17Sony A7 "thin filter" mod.
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wroteAnd shooting your Passport with Sony's auto WB (outside of daylight conditions), in my experience, may lead to inaccurate profiling as well, which is why I recommend setting a custom WB before shooting the Passport. That's my whole point.
I do not see what you described and this is easy to test: At around noon in a sunny day, shoot the CC passport color swatches using Daylight, Custom WB or even Tungsten.

Create 3 profiles using the CC app from different WB raw images.

Then, load a real world raw file in LR and try the profiles created on it. The result should look identical!



Yes, on a sunny day, it will probably work because every camera can get good white balance on the sun. It’s when you have more complex lighting that auto WB will fail.
Dec 13, 2021 at 04:04 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister