fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR

  
 
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #1Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
genji wrote:
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.


Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:09 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.


He might given Cosina’s state’s goal to have round oof highlights at both F2 and 2.8.
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:17 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.


Judging by what they say (special shape to guarantee round aperture at f2.8) my hunch is that there are using the curved on the tip straight after design that 7A have been playing with, which gives you a round aperture and no sunstars at the first one or two stops down, and effectively straight blades thereafter.

Since they specifically mention f2.8, it might be that @genji will get his wish at f2.8; but it'll be straight and starry after that

(If I'm right it's perfect for my taste)

Oct 04, 2019 at 06:18 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
vdo1 wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
theacguy71 wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
ftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?
Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.
If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that

CV65

https://live.staticflickr.com/7812/47415567821_1483aee31a_b.jpg_DSC1593 by Vaughn Adams, on Flickr

CV50 Nokton

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/48471013056_6f2ab04959_b.jpgDSC00193 by Vaughn Adams, on Flickr
From my experience, the more corrected the lens, the less pleasant the rendering is...but there are exceptions. I hope this lens will be one of them.
I guess we have to look at this while taking into account what the lens’ purpose is. Who cares about bokeh with let’s say a short macro intended as a repro lens? It has to answer to a completely different set of requirements than a portrait lens.

Same with this one. f/2 is not the goto aperture for bokeh seekers anyway. This, I believe, is for the cityscape / landscape guys. It has to take clean, clear pictures of objects at a distance. With perfect colors and sans LoCA and stuff. If it works that way, I’m buying, bokeh be damned. It could have onion rings and ninja stars and I would still be unfazed.

OTOH if you’re trying to sell me a portrait lens with 6 straight blades.....
Generally speaking, once we stop a fast lens down to ~f/5.6 or smaller (eg.: Landscapes), the most offending LoCA is pretty much gone while Lateral CA is almost a lossless correction in post. I think that APO lenses really show off their strength when shooting wide open or close to it.

My point was that in some cases, too much aberration correction (color + spherical) can produce a lens without much character.


I look at visible LoCA as an extreme and readily identifiable manifestation of color imperfection. When closing the aperture, you reduce it, maybe to the point you can’t distinctly discern it anymore, but the color imperfection is still there. I went through the 65mm and 110mm threads several times until now, and the landscape images are outstanding. It can’t be just the sharpness, as I was inspecting them at web resolution. It must be the colors too, and I believe that with the A7R4 they will be only better. If you got that camera you’ll want this lens too.

As for character lenses, we do have some choice, the 40, 50/1.2 and why not, the funky 35mm. As much as I like the STF, I also like funky stuff (when not applied to portraits that is ).


Edited on Oct 04, 2019 at 06:21 PM · View previous versions
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:19 PM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
I think it's perfect. 2-2.8 for portraits round highlites, stop down more for scape stars
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:21 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.


Not according to Cosina’s statement: “The total of 12 diaphragm blades have a special shape, so that not only at aperture F2.0 but also at aperture F2.8 creates a circular opening.“

I’ll be happy enough with no sunstars at f/2 and f/2.8.
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:21 PM
zhangyue
Online
Details
p.8 #7Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
The later. You did an good job on review, very objectively. I think the lens will score higher in real world for its intend usage. That is it

nehemiahphoto wrote:
zhangyue wroteSee my reply above. I can’t put more to illustrate it now and I know many people love that lens.

I did enjoy reading your 75mm lux review. I was trying reply you with detail but have to scratch that in the end. Too much information and too involved, so I give up. but you did a great job with lots of effort.

It is not easy to generalize in traditional category. The using case and how to use it had to be considered. The review of technical part didn’t do justice of that lens even I agree with your conclusion of loving it

nehemiahphoto wrote
zhangyue wrote
Steve Spencer wroteI am definitely getting this lens as I loved the Leica M 50 f/2 APO, and this lens promises to be very similar at a much reduced price. I am in the process of getting my MF lenses set for a very long time at 21mm and 50mm. I have the CV 21 f/1.4 and I am planning on supplementing it with the 21 f/3.5 for when I want to go lighter. I have the CV 50 f/1.2, now this lens will be the perfect complement for a smaller and likely more used option.
I am keeping the 65 f/2 APO and the 110 f/2.5 APO, however, they are fantastic. I have the Voigtlander M 75 f/1.5 and I feel the 65 f/2 APO is an excellent complement to it. So now just what to do between 21mm and 50mm. I have the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 as a place holder right now, but I would love a Voigtlander or Loxia 28 f/2 to fill out my set. I would love a travel/everyday set of Voigtlander 21 f/3.4; 28 f/2; 50 f/2 APO; 75 f/1.5 and Leica M 135 f/3.4 APO; and then a Voigtlander 21 f/1.4; 28 f/1.4; 50 f/1.2; 75 f/1.5, and a 100 f/2 for when I wanted low light performance and more subject/background separation.
On paper, this is a great lens but I will wait for more images coming before too excited

A side note, I am not a fan of VC65mm other than macro distance shots, and I also sold 40mm f1.2 for rendering reason. I don't acquire lenses to shooting flat objects so i don't put high priority on how it perform on flat object

Finger crossed.
What didn’t you like on the cv 40 1.2 rendering wise?
I ask because I sold my CV 40 1.2 too. Thanks for the kind words on the 75 Lux review. I am confused though—you didn’t think I tested the lens well or correctly? Or you think I should have explicitly judged it as a portrait lens?


Oct 04, 2019 at 06:26 PM
magiclight
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
I was about to purchase a Loxia 50mm.

I will now hold off until I see the the 50mm Apo rendering. Know doubt it will be sharp.
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:53 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Mhhh I just read the first post again and noticed the “anniversary” thing... I hope they don’t take this opportunity to price it like an “Anniversary Edition” Leica.....
Oct 04, 2019 at 06:57 PM
Justin Stone
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
I was about to purchase a Sigma 45 2.8. This looks better, but I need it soon. Like by mid November. Doesn’t look promising on that front.
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:00 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.8 #11Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
genji wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Not according to Cosina’s statement: “The total of 12 diaphragm blades have a special shape, so that not only at aperture F2.0 but also at aperture F2.8 creates a circular opening.“

I’ll be happy enough with no sunstars at f/2 and f/2.8.


Genji,
That would be a first for them and I don't think it will be the case. IMO, it's just marketing words but it would be great if it's true.
What I think they meant is that at f/2.8, it will still look 'more circular' compared to using 10 blades...(Same as CV 21/1.4 and CV 50/1.2)
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:03 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
genji wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Not according to Cosina’s statement: “The total of 12 diaphragm blades have a special shape, so that not only at aperture F2.0 but also at aperture F2.8 creates a circular opening.“

I’ll be happy enough with no sunstars at f/2 and f/2.8.
Genji,
That would be a first for them and I don't think it will be the case. IMO, it's just marketing words but it would be great if it's true.
What I think they meant is that at f/2.8, it will still look 'more circular' compared to using 10 blades...(Same as CV 21/1.4 and CV 50/1.2)


Hadn't thought of that interpretation; probably right since they have so recently moved from 10 to 12. Still it's not impossible that they'll have the hybrid shape that 7A are using. But agree much less likely than I thought...
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:06 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
genji wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Not according to Cosina’s statement: “The total of 12 diaphragm blades have a special shape, so that not only at aperture F2.0 but also at aperture F2.8 creates a circular opening.“

I’ll be happy enough with no sunstars at f/2 and f/2.8.
Genji,
That would be a first for them and I don't think it will be the case. IMO, it's just marketing words but it would be great if it's true.
What I think they meant is that at f/2.8, it will still look 'more circular' compared to using 10 blades...(Same as CV 21/1.4 and CV 50/1.2)


Fred, I’ve been here long enough to learn to trust your experience-based opinions/predictions over marketing bumph. I guess, like Michael, I’ll adopt a wait-and-see-what-the-lens-actually-produces approach. But I’ll be relying on you to test the sunstar issue with your usual thoroughness!

Edited on Oct 04, 2019 at 07:22 PM · View previous versions
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:16 PM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Judging by what they say (special shape to guarantee round aperture at f2.8) my hunch is that there are using the curved on the tip straight after design that 7A have been playing with, which gives you a round aperture and no sunstars at the first one or two stops down, and effectively straight blades thereafter.

Since they specifically mention f2.8, it might be that @genji@ will get his wish at f2.8; but it'll be straight and starry after that

(If I'm right it's perfect for my taste)



From reading the press release from Voigtländer Germany on the photoscala.de, I believe you are correct about the new and improved design of the aperture blades. This is a goldilocks situation yielding both good bokeh at wide apertures as well as well defined sun stars stopped down. Cosina thus addresses what I have disliked in e.g. the Voigtländer 110/2.5, namely polygonal bokeh at wide aperturs f/2.8-f/4, as shown in the Voigtländer thread here on FM. I wish Cosina could revisit the aperture design on some of their recent FE lenses, though I think it’s not likely they will.
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:21 PM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
genji wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Not according to Cosina’s statement: “The total of 12 diaphragm blades have a special shape, so that not only at aperture F2.0 but also at aperture F2.8 creates a circular opening.“

I’ll be happy enough with no sunstars at f/2 and f/2.8.
Genji,
That would be a first for them and I don't think it will be the case. IMO, it's just marketing words but it would be great if it's true.
What I think they meant is that at f/2.8, it will still look 'more circular' compared to using 10 blades...(Same as CV 21/1.4 and CV 50/1.2)


This is not how I read the German press release. It’s very explicit in stating that the aperture blades have a special shape (spezielle Form), and that the opening also at f/2.8 is circle round (kreisrund) just like at f/2. Then they go on to say that this provides a circularly shaped (kreisförmiges) bokeh from a point light source.
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:32 PM
davidjl
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
FWIW, the 21/1.4 produces lovely (for me, wild and ugly for genji) sunstars at f/2.0. (I.e. one stop down from wide open.)

Also, FWIW, _bokeh_ is an effect that occurs in an out of focus area, and sunstars is an effect that occurs in an in-focus area. Since I just thought of it, how a sunstar transitions to a bokeh circle as you move the focus closer might be an interesting test. Or might not. Whatever.
Oct 04, 2019 at 07:53 PM
billsamuels
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
It would be nice if the world world would remember that there are other cameras out there besides Sony.
Oct 04, 2019 at 08:04 PM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
billsamuels wrote:
It would be nice if the world world would remember that there are other cameras out there besides Sony.


I think CV's philosophy just matches Sony's of keeping everything compact but also high quality.
Oct 04, 2019 at 08:06 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
That's how I read it originally too, Bjorn, but Fred might well be right.

CV have only recently moved to the 12 blade system from 10, presumably exactly because dodecagons are closer to circular than decagons, and so the marketing folks might call that circular, and a "special shape". And the dodecagons become pretty defined at f4, so that might explain the mention of f2.8.

Of course they do seem to suggest that the blades themselves have a special shape (which supports our hypothesis) but once marketers are involved it might only mean the aperture opening has a special shape...

I hope not though, and that your and my original reading is right! We'll soon know...


bjornthun wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
genji wrote
davidmarinero wroteI’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.
Cosina's straight aperture blades (10 or 12) can already produce well-defined sunstars one stop from wide open. I don't think you will be able to avoid them.
Not according to Cosina’s statement: “The total of 12 diaphragm blades have a special shape, so that not only at aperture F2.0 but also at aperture F2.8 creates a circular opening.“

I’ll be happy enough with no sunstars at f/2 and f/2.8.
Genji,
That would be a first for them and I don't think it will be the case. IMO, it's just marketing words but it would be great if it's true.
What I think they meant is that at f/2.8, it will still look 'more circular' compared to using 10 blades...(Same as CV 21/1.4 and CV 50/1.2)

Oct 04, 2019 at 08:09 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
billsamuels wrote:
It would be nice if the world world would remember that there are other cameras out there besides Sony.


Other camera makers should probably make their mounts an open standard, but don't worry. I'm sure we will eventually see all mounts.
Oct 04, 2019 at 08:12 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister