This movement is very interesting for those who were (like me) about to buy the 50mm 1.2. Considering the rendering of the CV 65 & 110mm, I'd say the 1.2 will be more appealing for portrait shooters while the new APO will be a beast of a lens for landscapers.
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteInstall Exiftool (https://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/)
Go to terminal and enter:
exiftool -focusdistance2My Mac is doing an annoying security thing where it won't let me install it becomes it is from an unidentified developer. If someone else could check the photo I mentioned that would be great.Check out this link, https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491
Scroll almost to the bottom for the procedure to follow.Thanks I got exiftool installed, but now I have to figure out how to specify a file.Open terminal and paste:
exiftool -focusdistance2
(Notice there is a space after focusdistance2)
Then just drag a ARW file to the command line. (It must be a raw file...can't be a jpeg file to show distance for some reason)
If it shows "inf" and the image was not shot at infinity, it does not report distance. If it shows the precise distance, than it does.I can get it to work with ARW files, but not the NEF raws. Not sure why, but thank you for you detailed instructions. It may be due to the fact that the OS can't read the Nikon Z7 files either.
If your Mac is the newest version of macOS it should support Z6/Z7, since they are about a year old now.
nhsonyshooter wrote: ftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.
If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that
I wonder just how 'APO' this new 50 will actually be. I hope that purple fringing in particular, and to a lesser extent LoCA, are virtually non existent which is already the case with the Sony 1.4/50 and in a faster lens. If there is an pf with this lens then I see no point in owning it.
For mine, the Nokton 1.2/50 fails dramatically in the pf stakes although it seems to be a beautiful lens in almost every other respect.
bjornthun wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteSteve Spencer wrotebjornthun wroteSteve Spencer wroteMy Mac is doing an annoying security thing where it won't let me install it becomes it is from an unidentified developer. If someone else could check the photo I mentioned that would be great.Check out this link, https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202491
Scroll almost to the bottom for the procedure to follow.Thanks I got exiftool installed, but now I have to figure out how to specify a file.Open terminal and paste:
exiftool -focusdistance2
(Notice there is a space after focusdistance2)
Then just drag a ARW file to the command line. (It must be a raw file...can't be a jpeg file to show distance for some reason)
If it shows "inf" and the image was not shot at infinity, it does not report distance. If it shows the precise distance, than it does.I can get it to work with ARW files, but not the NEF raws. Not sure why, but thank you for you detailed instructions. It may be due to the fact that the OS can't read the Nikon Z7 files either.If your Mac is the newest version of macOS it should support Z6/Z7, since they are about a year old now.
I’m still running an old version of the OS on my laptop which is all I have with me.
zhangyue wrote:
See my reply above. I can’t put more to illustrate it now and I know many people love that lens.
I did enjoy reading your 75mm lux review. I was trying reply you with detail but have to scratch that in the end. Too much information and too involved, so I give up. but you did a great job with lots of effort.
It is not easy to generalize in traditional category. The using case and how to use it had to be considered. The review of technical part didn’t do justice of that lens even I agree with your conclusion of loving it
...Show more →nehemiahphoto wrotezhangyue wroteSteve Spencer wroteI am definitely getting this lens as I loved the Leica M 50 f/2 APO, and this lens promises to be very similar at a much reduced price. I am in the process of getting my MF lenses set for a very long time at 21mm and 50mm. I have the CV 21 f/1.4 and I am planning on supplementing it with the 21 f/3.5 for when I want to go lighter. I have the CV 50 f/1.2, now this lens will be the perfect complement for a smaller and likely more used option.
I am keeping the 65 f/2 APO and the 110 f/2.5 APO, however, they are fantastic. I have the Voigtlander M 75 f/1.5 and I feel the 65 f/2 APO is an excellent complement to it. So now just what to do between 21mm and 50mm. I have the 7 Artisans 28 f/1.4 as a place holder right now, but I would love a Voigtlander or Loxia 28 f/2 to fill out my set. I would love a travel/everyday set of Voigtlander 21 f/3.4; 28 f/2; 50 f/2 APO; 75 f/1.5 and Leica M 135 f/3.4 APO; and then a Voigtlander 21 f/1.4; 28 f/1.4; 50 f/1.2; 75 f/1.5, and a 100 f/2 for when I wanted low light performance and more subject/background separation.On paper, this is a great lens but I will wait for more images coming before too excited
A side note, I am not a fan of VC65mm other than macro distance shots, and I also sold 40mm f1.2 for rendering reason. I don't acquire lenses to shooting flat objects so i don't put high priority on how it perform on flat object
Finger crossed.What didn’t you like on the cv 40 1.2 rendering wise?
I ask because I sold my CV 40 1.2 too. Thanks for the kind words on the 75 Lux review. I am confused though—you didn’t think I tested the lens well or correctly? Or you think I should have explicitly judged it as a portrait lens?
theacguy71 wrote: nhsonyshooter wroteftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that
Fred Miranda wrote: theacguy71 wrotenhsonyshooter wroteftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that
Fred Miranda wrote: theacguy71 wrotenhsonyshooter wroteftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that
I guess we have to look at this while taking into account what the lens’ purpose is. Who cares about bokeh with let’s say a short macro intended as a repro lens? It has to answer to a completely different set of requirements than a portrait lens.
Same with this one. f/2 is not the goto aperture for bokeh seekers anyway. This, I believe, is for the cityscape / landscape guys. It has to take clean, clear pictures of objects at a distance. With perfect colors and sans LoCA and stuff. If it works that way, I’m buying, bokeh be damned. It could have onion rings and ninja stars and I would still be unfazed.
OTOH if you’re trying to sell me a portrait lens with 6 straight blades.....
ysultan wrote:
How could we get that excited for yet another 50mm lens? 😃😃
I would also get excited with a FE 50/1.8 Mk II with internal focus, or a GM 50/1.4 with fast AF, or a GM 50/1.2 or anything new and with up to date technology. The reality is that all the available ones are lacking from one pov or other. The APO on this one is the ticket for me. Small APO travel lens? yay I’m in. Only the Leica guys used to have this priviledge.
vdo1 wrote: Fred Miranda wrotetheacguy71 wrotenhsonyshooter wroteftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/48471013056_6f2ab04959_b.jpgDSC00193 by Vaughn Adams, on FlickrFrom my experience, the more corrected the lens, the less pleasant the rendering is...but there are exceptions. I hope this lens will be one of them. I guess we have to look at this while taking into account what the lens’ purpose is. Who cares about bokeh with let’s say a short macro intended as a repro lens? It has to answer to a completely different set of requirements than a portrait lens.
Same with this one. f/2 is not the goto aperture for bokeh seekers anyway. This, I believe, is for the cityscape / landscape guys. It has to take clean, clear pictures of objects at a distance. With perfect colors and sans LoCA and stuff. If it works that way, I’m buying, bokeh be damned. It could have onion rings and ninja stars and I would still be unfazed.
OTOH if you’re trying to sell me a portrait lens with 6 straight blades..... ...Show more →
Although the lens could be used that way, there are indications that the designer expect more from the lens. It has a floating element after all, which suggests they paid close attention to short focus distance shooting. The made the aperture blades round to f/2.8 which suggests they care about OOF highlights being round at wider apertures even when not at fully wide open aperture. For me I want this to be an all purpose lens. Yes, it should be spectacular at landscapes. I want it to be good at close ups too, however, and I want it to be a decent portrait lens as well. Rendering will matter to me. I loved the Leica M 50 f/2 APO when I had it. It did all of these things very well, IMO. I have high hopes this lens will as well.
vdo1 wrote: Fred Miranda wrotetheacguy71 wrotenhsonyshooter wroteftllens wroteI'm expecting this to be my endgame compact standard. Will the journey finally end?Based on their other APO's I know it will be sharp. The OOF rendering is the big question mark for me.If it is a mix between the CV65 APO and CV50 Nokton, im cool with that
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/48471013056_6f2ab04959_b.jpgDSC00193 by Vaughn Adams, on FlickrFrom my experience, the more corrected the lens, the less pleasant the rendering is...but there are exceptions. I hope this lens will be one of them. I guess we have to look at this while taking into account what the lens’ purpose is. Who cares about bokeh with let’s say a short macro intended as a repro lens? It has to answer to a completely different set of requirements than a portrait lens.
Same with this one. f/2 is not the goto aperture for bokeh seekers anyway. This, I believe, is for the cityscape / landscape guys. It has to take clean, clear pictures of objects at a distance. With perfect colors and sans LoCA and stuff. If it works that way, I’m buying, bokeh be damned. It could have onion rings and ninja stars and I would still be unfazed.
OTOH if you’re trying to sell me a portrait lens with 6 straight blades..... ...Show more →
Generally speaking, once we stop a fast lens down to ~f/5.6 or smaller (eg.: Landscapes), the most offending LoCA is pretty much gone while Lateral CA is almost a lossless correction in post. I think that APO lenses really show off their strength when shooting wide open or close to it.
My point was that in some cases, too much aberration correction (color + spherical) can produce a lens without much character.
davidmarinero wrote:
I’m amazed that sunstars don't have much impact on people’s opinions of lenses!! :
I agree. Sunstars have a huge impact on my opinion of a lens. I regard them as a cheap trick, not quite as bad as overcooked HDR but getting there. But this 50 APO would appear to offer the perfect compromise. I’ll only use it from f/2 to f/4 so there’ll be no sunstars for me but plenty of sunstars from then on for those who love them.