I started out on 4X5 and twin lens reflex in 1968-69 as a student back in the day and shot professionally MF until 1988 when I picked up the first AF camera body as I interned at my major metro daily. I brought the camera - a Nikon 8008 - to the lab to share with the staff - all excited about this new AF technology. The ENTIRE staff walked around it like it was kryptonite and refused to touch it, only *sniffing* insultingly and casting sideways glances at it. The photo director came up to me and said "This is going to make photographers lazy"
Well, that was 30 years ago - and he owns an A9 system now and is plenty proud of the AF focusing tracking results he gets from his sports photographs.
Did AF make photographers lazy?
I'll let everybody answer that question for themselves.
I can tell you this right now, though - without even taking a survey, ima guess that the percentage of photographers who would go back to MF is really tiny compared to those who find AF performance a high priority when choosing a camera/lens setup.
I totally get why static subject/landscape/macro photographers would prefer MF. But the majority of photographers do not. Older photographers don't have as good of eyes as they used to and younger photographers I'm pretty sure wouldn't see the point other than the aforementioned situations.
I love rendering as much as the next guy. I have my own bank of eclectic legacy lenses I love to use. I do know how to MF. I'm intrigued by the 50mm f2 Voight. But at almost $1100, I'm going to wait awhile until people have stopped being in love with their purchase - which inevitably happens.
There is zero chance that a MF lens is going to keep up with tracking as fast as an AF lens. Most photographers who shoot moving subjects - especially as a professional where their rent depends on the results - are going to prefer AF. If it's fun for you to shoot sports or BIF with manual focus, please, be my guest. I won't be joining you.
Different people have different priorities, some based on personal preference, some driven by the the type of photography they do (or other factors.) Even within that there will be outliers.
So at the end of the day, some people will see reasons to buy this lens, some will not. Good luck trying to project your preferences and priorities onto someone who doesn't share them.
We have so many choices now with E mount........ There is no reason that there has to be consensus on what lens has to be the best lens for everyone, as it's just not going to happen.
Someone loves the FE 55/1.8, great. Someone is jazzed about the CV 50/2 APO Lanthar, great.
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
Just a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?...Show more →
I "came up" during the pre-AF years so I am completely comfortable with it.
I think there is a time and place for both approaches.
Certainly the new Sony AF system is extraordinary and I will use it to every advantage when I can.
No matter how good AF is though I will always MF in certain settings (landscape, macro) if the time is there.
My personal feeling is that if you have not mastered the art of MF you have not mastered your camera.
On certain days I will go out with just MF lenses for the sheer pleasure of it all.
Similarly - My everyday car has an automatic transmission but my vintage sports car has a manual and that manual is a big part of what makes the sports car more engaging to drive.
DaveFP wrote: DannyBurkPhoto wroteJust a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?I "came up" during the pre-AF years so I am completely comfortable with it.
I think there is a time and place for both approaches.
Certainly the new Sony AF system is extraordinary and I will use it to every advantage when I can.
No matter how good AF is though I will always MF in certain settings (landscape, macro) if the time is there.
My personal feeling is that if you have not mastered the art of MF you have not mastered your camera.
On certain days I will go out with just MF lenses for the sheer pleasure of it all.
Similarly - My everyday car has an automatic transmission but my vintage sports car has a manual and that manual is a big part of what makes the sports car more engaging to drive.
FWIW, my "vintage" sports car with a manual trans is Honda Del Sol Vtech - have had many other MT vehicles over the years. I'll never part with the manual experience.
I grew up with autofocus available (80s and 90s) but still prefer manual. Most of my stuff is candids, and I almost always frame the subject off-center. For cases like this, manual is ideal. Recently I've been doing events, and manual lets you keep the focus on a subject, even when others may be running in front of them, or to very quickly frame off-center. Here are a couple examples of shots that I took using CV 40/1.2 that would have been harder for me to get with AF.
Granted, I've never used an a9 with eye-af or anything, but I stand by MF, even for kids.
*Edit - oops, sorry should have re-sized those.
DannyBurkPhoto wrote:
Just a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?...Show more →
My 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar arrived today from Robert White (UK).
Dreadful weather outside for any serious testing...So a size comparison instead...
Left to Right... 21mm f/1.4 Nokton, 40mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar, 65mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar & 110mm f/2.5 Apo-Lanthar.
I did carry out a few tests though and the lens is well centered - A keeper :-)
A few observations...
1. Unlike the Voigtlander Noktons (21mm/f1.4, 40mm/f1.2 and 50mm/f1.2 E mount) The lens hood does not have a "inner hood" filter thread.
The front lens cap or filters attach to either the outside of the Hood 58mm (threaded) or the lens itself 49mm (threaded)...Both 49mm and 58mm caps are included.
2. Aperture curved blades form a perfect circle at f/2 + f/2.8 + f/16 only - Otherwise you can just make out the shape of the diaphragm in the OoF bokeh balls...To be honest it's pretty much a mute point by f/11.
3. Aperture bokeh OoF balls, look relatively clean wide open...On stopping down to the other extreme f/16, I see small OoF bokeh balls with a concentric ring pattern.
4. The OoF balls are circular in shape on central axis as you would expect, changing into a typical cats eye shape into the extreme corners of the frame.
5. The OoF areas are nicely smooth/rounded on close-ups at f/2 which I find pleasant enough to my eyes (YMMV)....When the weather improves I shall check at mid-field to see if the bokeh becomes nervous or not.
6. Focusing ring is smooth but all my other Voigtlander lenses (21mm, 40mm, 50mm, 65mm and 110mm) have a little more resistance which I personally prefer...circa 150 deg focus throw (Inf- 0.45m).
7. Very sharp and feels pretty lightweight...reminds me of my old ZM 50mm f/2.0 Planar but on steroids!
imagesfromobjects wrote:
I grew up with autofocus available (80s and 90s) but still prefer manual. Most of my stuff is candids, and I almost always frame the subject off-center. For cases like this, manual is ideal. Recently I've been doing events, and manual lets you keep the focus on a subject, even when others may be running in front of them, or to very quickly frame off-center. Here are a couple examples of shots that I took using CV 40/1.2 that would have been harder for me to get with AF.
Granted, I've never used an a9 with eye-af or anything, but I stand by MF, even for kids.
*Edit - oops, sorry should have re-sized those.
...Show more →DannyBurkPhoto wroteJust a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?
BBF and effective use of spot focus point selection is the method of AF that avoids the pitfalls presented by shutter button focus and objects or subjects coming in front of the chosen subject. This method has been used by photojournalists for decades. One doesn't have to use MF to focus on a subject off-center or shooting through objects or avoiding the focus shifting if things temporarily pass in front.
That said, whatever method works is what a photographer uses. Having AF and not needing it, though, seems preferable to not having AF and needing it.
Beyond that, there are things that are alluring to photographers about certain lenses that probably give the photographer joy more than anyone else. I have a strange little gearbox lens that renders sweetly in a manner that is simply unique. It brings me joy to use it. Otherwise, it's not special. Joy is always a worthwhile reason for doing photography.
It’s here. Sadly, the weather was horrible today. First impressions are very good, though. Very nice haptics, incredible sharpness across the frame even at F2.
I would assume by Thursday/Friday in most places. CameraQuest (US) is shipping Thursday from what I gather (see above, I asked the same question and was answered.) Seems like some in this thread already got theirs (believe non-US.) The official release date is 12/12.
-Tim
HeadshotDeluxe wrote:
Does anyone know when this lens will start shipping?
HeadshotDeluxe wrote:
Does anyone know when this lens will start shipping?
If you haven’t preordered with anyone yet, you are probably looking at January - February if you preorder today.
As of the other day, the first batch to Camera Quest were still in transit. Hopefully those will arrive soon and start going out to customers who were lucky enough to get on the first preorder shipment.
B&H seems to have no idea on when their shipment will arrive and therefore no idea when they will arrive to customers.
CameraQuest is a US distributor for Voigtlander (Cosina). So I wonder if B&H will be getting them from CameraQuest.
I hope CameraQuest ships Thursday. I'm probably going up to NYC on Sunday, would love to take the lens along.
-Tim
alphanumeric wrote: HeadshotDeluxe wroteDoes anyone know when this lens will start shipping?If you haven’t preordered with anyone yet, you are probably looking at January - February if you preorder today.
As of the other day, the first batch to Camera Quest were still in transit. Hopefully those will arrive soon and start going out to customers who were lucky enough to get on the first preorder shipment.
B&H seems to have no idea on when their shipment will arrive and therefore no idea when they will arrive to customers.
As noted earlier in the thread, there appears to be no image of this lens’ rear (without the lens caps)...
leicamera wrote:
My 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar arrived today from Robert White (UK).
Dreadful weather outside for any serious testing...So a size comparison instead...
Left to Right... 21mm f/1.4 Nokton, 40mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar, 65mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar & 110mm f/2.5 Apo-Lanthar.
I did carry out a few tests though and the lens is well centered - A keeper :-)
A few observations...
1. Unlike the Voigtlander Noktons (21mm/f1.4, 40mm/f1.2 and 50mm/f1.2 E mount) The lens hood does not have a "inner hood" filter thread.
The front lens cap or filters attach to either the outside of the Hood 58mm (threaded) or the lens itself 49mm (threaded)...Both 49mm and 58mm caps are included.
2. Aperture curved blades form a perfect circle at f/2 + f/2.8 + f/16 only - Otherwise you can just make out the shape of the diaphragm in the OoF bokeh balls...To be honest it's pretty much a mute point by f/11.
3. Aperture bokeh OoF balls, look relatively clean wide open...On stopping down to the other extreme f/16, I see small OoF bokeh balls with a concentric ring pattern.
4. The OoF balls are circular in shape on central axis as you would expect, changing into a typical cats eye shape into the extreme corners of the frame.
5. The OoF areas are nicely smooth/rounded on close-ups at f/2 which I find pleasant enough to my eyes (YMMV)....When the weather improves I shall check at mid-field to see if the bokeh becomes nervous or not.
6. Focusing ring is smooth but all my other Voigtlander lenses (21mm, 40mm, 50mm, 65mm and 110mm) have a little more resistance which I personally prefer...circa 150 deg focus throw (Inf- 0.45m).
7. Very sharp and feels pretty lightweight...reminds me of my old ZM 50mm f/2.0 Planar but on steroids!
That's an interesting marking on the infinity stop. Wonder if it's meant to focus past infinity to offset FC? None of the other lenses have it.
leicamera wrote:
My 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar arrived today from Robert White (UK).
Dreadful weather outside for any serious testing...So a size comparison instead...
Left to Right... 21mm f/1.4 Nokton, 40mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar, 65mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar & 110mm f/2.5 Apo-Lanthar.
I did carry out a few tests though and the lens is well centered - A keeper :-)
A few observations...
1. Unlike the Voigtlander Noktons (21mm/f1.4, 40mm/f1.2 and 50mm/f1.2 E mount) The lens hood does not have a "inner hood" filter thread.
The front lens cap or filters attach to either the outside of the Hood 58mm (threaded) or the lens itself 49mm (threaded)...Both 49mm and 58mm caps are included.
2. Aperture curved blades form a perfect circle at f/2 + f/2.8 + f/16 only - Otherwise you can just make out the shape of the diaphragm in the OoF bokeh balls...To be honest it's pretty much a mute point by f/11.
3. Aperture bokeh OoF balls, look relatively clean wide open...On stopping down to the other extreme f/16, I see small OoF bokeh balls with a concentric ring pattern.
4. The OoF balls are circular in shape on central axis as you would expect, changing into a typical cats eye shape into the extreme corners of the frame.
5. The OoF areas are nicely smooth/rounded on close-ups at f/2 which I find pleasant enough to my eyes (YMMV)....When the weather improves I shall check at mid-field to see if the bokeh becomes nervous or not.
6. Focusing ring is smooth but all my other Voigtlander lenses (21mm, 40mm, 50mm, 65mm and 110mm) have a little more resistance which I personally prefer...circa 150 deg focus throw (Inf- 0.45m).
7. Very sharp and feels pretty lightweight...reminds me of my old ZM 50mm f/2.0 Planar but on steroids!
tsdevine wrote:
CameraQuest is a US distributor for Voigtlander (Cosina). So I wonder if B&H will be getting them from CameraQuest.
I hope CameraQuest ships Thursday. I'm probably going up to NYC on Sunday, would love to take the lens along.
-Tim
alphanumeric wroteHeadshotDeluxe wroteDoes anyone know when this lens will start shipping?If you haven’t preordered with anyone yet, you are probably looking at January - February if you preorder today.
As of the other day, the first batch to Camera Quest were still in transit. Hopefully those will arrive soon and start going out to customers who were lucky enough to get on the first preorder shipment.
B&H seems to have no idea on when their shipment will arrive and therefore no idea when they will arrive to customers.
No In a word
BH and Adorama get there Voightlanders from the East Coast distributor Photo Village which BTW is across the street from BH. Rich is the owner and a very nice guy. I bought many Voightlanders from him and he also sells Leica . Again very good source but truth is the first to get CV glass is Photo Village and Cameraquest.
You folks just need to ask the person on the stuff. ME been a customer for decades
I'm most interested in seeing how it handles transition zones at f/2.8, especially when repetitive angular or geometric elements (eg grass, fallen leaves) are present. If it can balance sharpness and smoothness, then it will be amazing. This hasn't necessarily been CV's forte in the past, but this design is a whole new animal.
I think not. Did you see the 110 having the same marking?
imagesfromobjects wrote:
That's an interesting marking on the infinity stop. Wonder if it's meant to focus past infinity to offset FC? None of the other lenses have it.
leicamera wroteMy 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar arrived today from Robert White (UK).
Dreadful weather outside for any serious testing...So a size comparison instead...
Left to Right... 21mm f/1.4 Nokton, 40mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/1.2 Nokton, 50mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar, 65mm f/2.0 Apo-Lanthar & 110mm f/2.5 Apo-Lanthar.
I did carry out a few tests though and the lens is well centered - A keeper :-)
A few observations...
1. Unlike the Voigtlander Noktons (21mm/f1.4, 40mm/f1.2 and 50mm/f1.2 E mount) The lens hood does not have a "inner hood" filter thread.
The front lens cap or filters attach to either the outside of the Hood 58mm (threaded) or the lens itself 49mm (threaded)...Both 49mm and 58mm caps are included.
2. Aperture curved blades form a perfect circle at f/2 + f/2.8 + f/16 only - Otherwise you can just make out the shape of the diaphragm in the OoF bokeh balls...To be honest it's pretty much a mute point by f/11.
3. Aperture bokeh OoF balls, look relatively clean wide open...On stopping down to the other extreme f/16, I see small OoF bokeh balls with a concentric ring pattern.
4. The OoF balls are circular in shape on central axis as you would expect, changing into a typical cats eye shape into the extreme corners of the frame.
5. The OoF areas are nicely smooth/rounded on close-ups at f/2 which I find pleasant enough to my eyes (YMMV)....When the weather improves I shall check at mid-field to see if the bokeh becomes nervous or not.
6. Focusing ring is smooth but all my other Voigtlander lenses (21mm, 40mm, 50mm, 65mm and 110mm) have a little more resistance which I personally prefer...circa 150 deg focus throw (Inf- 0.45m).
7. Very sharp and feels pretty lightweight...reminds me of my old ZM 50mm f/2.0 Planar but on steroids!
Yes, Barry, can you do us a back end view a little off centre, pls?
The infinity stop is offset from the engraving, indicating ring rotation from 0.5m to infinity, looks to be about twice that of the 50/1.2 and 65/2. Very good news for open field use, in a short throw lens - slows down your leverage on the smaller diameter ring. Drawer handles show subtle roll-off. f22 not even an option here.
GMPhotography wrote:
BH and Adorama get there Voightlanders from the East Coast distributor Photo Village which BTW is across the street from BH. Rich is the owner and a very nice guy. I bought many Voightlanders from him and he also sells Leica . Again very good source but truth is the first to get CV glass is Photo Village and Cameraquest.
You folks just need to ask the person on the stuff. ME been a customer for decades
nice candid photos, could you tell something about your mf technique? imagesfromobjects wrote:
I grew up with autofocus available (80s and 90s) but still prefer manual. Most of my stuff is candids, and I almost always frame the subject off-center. For cases like this, manual is ideal. Recently I've been doing events, and manual lets you keep the focus on a subject, even when others may be running in front of them, or to very quickly frame off-center. Here are a couple examples of shots that I took using CV 40/1.2 that would have been harder for me to get with AF.
Granted, I've never used an a9 with eye-af or anything, but I stand by MF, even for kids.
*Edit - oops, sorry should have re-sized those.
...Show more →DannyBurkPhoto wroteJust a guess, but I'm wondering whether the percentage of MF lovers is higher among those who've used it for many years (i.e. back when there were no AF lenses) compared to those who grew up using AF and/or digital from the start.
I'm not typical in that I'm basically a 4x5 shooter who converted to digital only 4 years ago. For the previous 20 years, I'd shot 4x5, 5x7, and a variety of medium format film, but no 35mm since the '90s. Of course all of these were manual focus only. When I converted to digital, I sold all of my film equipment at the same time, and it was quite an adjustment getting used to everything simultaneously! Eventually I did, but I retain many of my old ways. I always say that I treat all of my cameras as little view cameras; no, not viewing upside-down or with a darkcloth, but nearly always on a tripod, cable- or IR release, slow and precise composition, etc.
I've tried AF several times, and simply don't like it. I trust my own MF abilities to get more precise focus (proven multiple times by comparisons...results are close, but my manually focused examples are nearly always a little sharper at the point of focus), it makes so many things easier (such as selecting point of focus, keeping it there without the camera changing it, etc), and although it may not affect the final result, the pleasure and good feel of using a real MF lens such as Voigtlander or Zeiss.
Anyway, all of this really only applies to me. Someone else's needs will be different - maybe a little, maybe a lot. And that's how it should be, I think - variety is good, no?