fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR

  
 
fededuran
Offline
Details
p.27 #1Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Correction: we are all waiting for this lens.

GMPhotography wrote:
Yea buy a freaking umbrella already.

Just for the record I’m waiting on this lens.

Nov 11, 2019 at 04:31 PM
jhinkey
Offline
Details
p.27 #2Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Love my Lanthars (65/2, 110/2.5, 180/4), just wish this were a bit wider, like 45 or 40mm!
50mm is just a bit too narrow for me, especially with the 65/2 in hand.

Now they just need to release the 180/4 in E mount and we'd be all set.
Nov 11, 2019 at 05:14 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.27 #3Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
The makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Nov 11, 2019 at 06:08 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.27 #4Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
philip_pj wrote:
The makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro -
...Show more →

Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see a moderate speed high quality set built around this 50 APO Lanthar. If they could add a 25 f/2, 35 f/2, and an 90 f/2 APO that would be a wonderful set. Would love to see them add a remake of the 180 f/4 APO Lanthar to this set as well.

Finally, I think they are well on their way to a small aperture set with 10 f/5.6, 12 f/5.6, 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, 40 f/2.8, if they would just add to this 18 f/3.5, 25 f/3.5, 28 f/2.8, and an 85 f/2.8 all that are quite small they would have most of the bases covered. Bonus points if they added a 135 f/3.5 as well.
Nov 11, 2019 at 06:51 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.27 #5Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
philip_pj wrote:
The makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro -
...Show more →

---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote:
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see
...Show more →

Together you’ve laid out a superb, comprehensive roadmap for an enviable set of MF lenses. I would simply like to add a 45/2.8 pancake to Steve’s small aperture set.
Nov 11, 2019 at 07:27 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.27 #6Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
genji wrote:
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see a moderate speed high quality set built around this 50 APO Lanthar. If they could add a 25 f/2, 35 f/2, and an 90 f/2 APO that would be a wonderful set. Would love to see them add a remake of the 180 f/4 APO Lanthar to this set as well.

Finally, I think they are well on their way to a small aperture set with 10 f/5.6, 12 f/5.6, 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, 40 f/2.8, if they would just add to this 18 f/3.5, 25 f/3.5, 28 f/2.8, and an 85 f/2.8 all that are quite small they would have most of the bases covered. Bonus points if they added a 135 f/3.5 as well.
Together you’ve laid out a superb, comprehensive roadmap for an enviable set of MF lenses. I would simply like to add a 45/2.8 pancake to Steve’s small aperture set.


Well they do have the 40 f/2.8 Heliar that is a pretty much a pancake. It is a bit funky as it focusses with the M close focus adapter rather than having it's own helicoid, but it is a very nice performer and nicely small. It is as I understand made for the thickness of Sony sensor glass as well, even though it technically has an M mount--on a M, however, there would be no way to focus it.
Nov 11, 2019 at 07:31 PM
genji
Offline
Details
p.27 #7Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Steve Spencer wrote:
genji wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see a moderate speed high quality set built around this 50 APO Lanthar. If they could add a 25 f/2, 35 f/2, and an 90 f/2 APO that would be a wonderful set. Would love to see them add a remake of the 180 f/4 APO Lanthar to this set as well.

Finally, I think they are well on their way to a small aperture set with 10 f/5.6, 12 f/5.6, 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, 40 f/2.8, if they would just add to this 18 f/3.5, 25 f/3.5, 28 f/2.8, and an 85 f/2.8 all that are quite small they would have most of the bases covered. Bonus points if they added a 135 f/3.5 as well.
Together you’ve laid out a superb, comprehensive roadmap for an enviable set of MF lenses. I would simply like to add a 45/2.8 pancake to Steve’s small aperture set.
Well they do have the 40 f/2.8 Heliar that is a pretty much a pancake. It is a bit funky as it focusses with the M close focus adapter rather than having it's own helicoid, but it is a very nice performer and nicely small. It is as I understand made for the thickness of Sony sensor glass as well, even though it technically has an M mount--on a M, however, there would be no way to focus it.


I had the 40/2.8 Heliar for less than a week. Its terrible haptics led me to sell it as fast as I could. Happily the lens was in short supply at the time so I got back what I’d paid for it.
Nov 11, 2019 at 07:38 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.27 #8Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
genji wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
genji wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see a moderate speed high quality set built around this 50 APO Lanthar. If they could add a 25 f/2, 35 f/2, and an 90 f/2 APO that would be a wonderful set. Would love to see them add a remake of the 180 f/4 APO Lanthar to this set as well.

Finally, I think they are well on their way to a small aperture set with 10 f/5.6, 12 f/5.6, 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, 40 f/2.8, if they would just add to this 18 f/3.5, 25 f/3.5, 28 f/2.8, and an 85 f/2.8 all that are quite small they would have most of the bases covered. Bonus points if they added a 135 f/3.5 as well.
Together you’ve laid out a superb, comprehensive roadmap for an enviable set of MF lenses. I would simply like to add a 45/2.8 pancake to Steve’s small aperture set.
Well they do have the 40 f/2.8 Heliar that is a pretty much a pancake. It is a bit funky as it focusses with the M close focus adapter rather than having it's own helicoid, but it is a very nice performer and nicely small. It is as I understand made for the thickness of Sony sensor glass as well, even though it technically has an M mount--on a M, however, there would be no way to focus it.
I had the 40/2.8 Heliar for less than a week. Its terrible haptics led me to sell it as fast as I could. Happily the lens was in short supply at the time so I got back what I’d paid for it.


Good to know. I wondered how it would be to use. I guess not so good.
Nov 11, 2019 at 07:43 PM
imagesfromobjects
Offline
Details
p.27 #9Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Hahaha, totally. I keep thinking if the Sigma 45/2.8 had been manual focus it would have been even better.

genji wrote:
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see a moderate speed high quality set built around this 50 APO Lanthar. If they could add a 25 f/2, 35 f/2, and an 90 f/2 APO that would be a wonderful set. Would love to see them add a remake of the 180 f/4 APO Lanthar to this set as well.

Finally, I think they are well on their way to a small aperture set with 10 f/5.6, 12 f/5.6, 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, 40 f/2.8, if they would just add to this 18 f/3.5, 25 f/3.5, 28 f/2.8, and an 85 f/2.8 all that are quite small they would have most of the bases covered. Bonus points if they added a 135 f/3.5 as well.
Together you’ve laid out a superb, comprehensive roadmap for an enviable set of MF lenses. I would simply like to add a 45/2.8 pancake to Steve’s small aperture set.

Nov 11, 2019 at 08:21 PM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.27 #10Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
I'm personally most interested in a 28mm from them in the next year or so, e.g. that proposed 28/3.5 (similar to 21/3.5) would do nicely, but I'd also be happy with a new E-mount 28/2 Ultron or a 28/1.4 with similar style as 21/1.4. And an E-mount version of 75/1.5 is the next one after 28mm on my wanted list.

With the current E-mount lineup where I have all of the native e-mounts except 10mm and 12mm (+ I still have the 40/2.8 as well) I feel the main gaps are between 21mm and 35mm + lack of a lighter/smaller short tele.

They've been putting out 2 or 3 new ones for E-mount since they started that in 2016 (2016: 3, 2017: 2, 2018: 3, 2019: 3 once the 50/2 gets released) so hopefully we'll see 2 or 3 new ones next year again.
Nov 11, 2019 at 09:11 PM
NRKStudio
Offline
Details
p.27 #11Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
The 75/1.5 is so solid. They have an excellent series on their site detailing the “making of” the 75/1.5. The light path was described as “beautiful” by the optical designer. Edit: the Japanese site says the 50/2 APO was based on the macroplanar, but the 75/1.5 was one of their top 3 lenses for beautiful light ray path “Shimada-san sees, and this is the best 3 lens that you think the path of light is beautiful.“ (The other two are the 25/.95 micro 4/3 and the 50/2 APO).

Im sure this 50/2 APO will follows suit.

What Im waiting for though is the release of a solid 28/1.4, this line of 50/2, 75/1.5 and hopefully a 28/1.; would mimic the Otus series relatively closely.

Edited on Nov 17, 2019 at 06:59 AM · View previous versions
Nov 16, 2019 at 02:39 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.27 #12Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
NRKStudio wrote:
The 75/1.5 is so solid. I read it follows the same optical design as the Otus 85/1.4 ( which Cosina manufactures as well). They have an excellent series on their site detailing the “making of” the 75/1.5. The light path was described as “beautiful” by the optical designer.


I really like the CV 75/1.5's rendering and it's impressive how such compact lens can be so sharp at f/1.5. Unfortunately the M-mount does not perform optimally on the Sony sensor.

My wish list for what's next: CV 28/1.7, CV 35/1.7 and CV 75/1.5 E-mount lenses. All optimized for IQ with pleasant rendering while being as compact as possible.
Nov 16, 2019 at 05:55 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.27 #13Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
I have the 75 1.5. Really a sweet lens. Sure I'd like a E mount but it renders so nice. I'd kill for the 35 1.7 in E mount
Nov 16, 2019 at 06:45 PM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.27 #14Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR

At this point, I'd just be happy with a 50mm APO-Lanthar....

Patience is a virtue....that I lack.

-Tim
Nov 16, 2019 at 08:02 PM
NRKStudio
Offline
Details
p.27 #15Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
NRKStudio wroteThe 75/1.5 is so solid. I read it follows the same optical design as the Otus 85/1.4 ( which Cosina manufactures as well). They have an excellent series on their site detailing the “making of” the 75/1.5. The light path was described as “beautiful” by the optical designer.
I really like the CV 75/1.5's rendering and it's impressive how such compact lens can be so sharp at f/1.5. Unfortunately the M-mount does perform optimally on the Sony sensor with moderate induced field curvature.
My wish list for what's next: CV 28/1.7, CV 35/1.7 and CV 75/1.5 E-mount lenses. All optimized for IQ with pleasant rendering while being as compact as possible.


I do believe Cosina is following this Nokton line as a nod of the hat to the Otus line. The online series on the site does almost allude to it, aside from directly comparing the 75 to the 85 Otus. I’d say the reason we see a 75 instead of an 85mm is because CV is planning on releasing a 90mm Lanthar.

I’m with you on the 75’s rendering. I use it though mainly on my m10-p with awesome results, sparingly on the Sony admittedly. I wonder if a PCX filter would propel it even to another league? We will have to find a taker, one of the forum gurus I am sure will try!

I’m a 28mm shooter. though relatively new at photography, 28mm for me is perfect for family events and home on a Saturday with the kid(s). Match it to a 75, and that’s really all I need. Thus I’m with you on the necessity of a good 28mm Nokton. Leicas 28 Summilux is stellar but does have its fair share of issues. I really believe Cosina could best it.

With a one lens kit though, the 50 APO is a good compromise FOV. I bet we will see the 28 first as its most in need of a refresh, followed by the 35. Cosina is on a roll here really.
Nov 16, 2019 at 08:17 PM
theacguy71
Offline
Details
p.27 #16Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
NRKStudio wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
NRKStudio wroteThe 75/1.5 is so solid. I read it follows the same optical design as the Otus 85/1.4 ( which Cosina manufactures as well). They have an excellent series on their site detailing the “making of” the 75/1.5. The light path was described as “beautiful” by the optical designer.
I really like the CV 75/1.5's rendering and it's impressive how such compact lens can be so sharp at f/1.5. Unfortunately the M-mount does perform optimally on the Sony sensor with moderate induced field curvature.
My wish list for what's next: CV 28/1.7, CV 35/1.7 and CV 75/1.5 E-mount lenses. All optimized for IQ with pleasant rendering while being as compact as possible.
I do believe Cosina is following this Nokton line as a nod of the hat to the Otus line. The online series on the site does almost allude to it, aside from directly comparing the 75 to the 85 Otus. I’d say the reason we see a 75 instead of an 85mm is because CV is planning on releasing a 90mm Lanthar.

I’m with you on the 75’s rendering. I use it though mainly on my m10-p with awesome results, sparingly on the Sony admittedly. I wonder if a PCX filter would propel it even to another league? We will
...Show more →



CV 28,50 and 90mm APO’s would be a killer kit!!
Nov 16, 2019 at 08:34 PM
NRKStudio
Offline
Details
p.27 #17Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
theacguy71 wrote:
NRKStudio wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
NRKStudio wroteThe 75/1.5 is so solid. I read it follows the same optical design as the Otus 85/1.4 ( which Cosina manufactures as well). They have an excellent series on their site detailing the “making of” the 75/1.5. The light path was described as “beautiful” by the optical designer.
I really like the CV 75/1.5's rendering and it's impressive how such compact lens can be so sharp at f/1.5. Unfortunately the M-mount does perform optimally on the Sony sensor with moderate induced field curvature.
My wish list for what's next: CV 28/1.7, CV 35/1.7 and CV 75/1.5 E-mount lenses. All optimized for IQ with pleasant rendering while being as compact as possible.
I do believe Cosina is following this Nokton line as a nod of the hat to the Otus line. The online series on the site does almost allude to it, aside from directly comparing the 75 to the 85 Otus. I’d say the reason we see a 75 instead of an 85mm is because CV is planning on releasing a 90mm Lanthar.

I’m with you on the 75’s rendering. I use it though mainly on my m10-p with awesome results, sparingly on the Sony admittedly. I wonder if a PCX filter would propel it even to another league? We will have to find a taker, one of the forum gurus I am sure will try!

I’m a 28mm shooter. though relatively new at photography, 28mm for me is perfect for family events and home on a Saturday with the kid(s). Match it to a 75, and that’s really all I need. Thus I’m with you on the necessity of a good 28mm Nokton. Leicas 28 Summilux is stellar but does have its fair share of issues. I really believe Cosina could best it.

With a one lens kit though, the 50 APO is a good compromise FOV. I bet we will see the 28 first as its most in need of a refresh, followed by the 35. Cosina is on a roll here really.
CV 28,50 and 90mm APO’s would be a killer kit!!


I 100% agree. I hope Cosina reads FM Forum!

To Fred’s point (which just hit me): Fred is so right when he mentions that the compact size of the lens is a feat in itself. For a lens so small to behave so well, is really the achievement. Sure Leica does make incredible compact lenses, but Cosina is doing as well with much less cost to the buyer, less fanfare, and importantly: with very rapid speed to market.

Someone mentioned 3 lenses a year in M mount for each the last few years. This last year’s releases are all trophy products in their own right: 50/1.2, 75/1.5, 35/2, etc. Really crazy here these 3 were all within 8 months. The 50 APO will top off their year.

Would love to see Roger C. put these latest CV lenses on his optical bench. Aside from the OOF rendering and rich colors (especially with the 75), its sharp as a tack on the m10-p and will be even more so on the Leica SL2. Although Cosina doesn’t seem to mind (Thankfully for portraits) a soft wide open stop (like the 50/1.2 @ f1.2), stopped down just a little the 50/1.2 is a completely different lens.

If CV’s lenses, when they come to E mount, can compete with Sigma’s extremely high performing 15 element, 4 aspherical surface, 2 lb. giants, It’ll be a testament to their optical design. . As a side point: I know it’s not in their wheelhouse, but who doesn’t want to see some of these lenses with AF?
Nov 16, 2019 at 09:59 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.27 #18Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
65mm to 110mm leaves a big gap (and both are macros), and so does 21mm to 40mm (leaving aside the vintage 35/1.4). They are clear they want to release lenses that do justice to the a7rIV.

It might mean an end to using the M lenses as a springboard. Looking at their huge M range, the new (vintage, lol) 75/1.5 is all they have longer than 50mm - quite a surprise, even in a rangefinder range.

In M, they have *five 50mm* lenses there, and they have *five 35mm* lenses, plus a 28mm. It's like this: if you want wide, go 21mm or wider; otherwise it's 35-50mm for you. And that is all of 18 M lenses at 50mm or wider!

What might happen is: they do really well with the 50/2 - which many will buy as a collector's item - and a lot of new-to-CV people may buy their less-known great E lenses. The 50/2 might be a 'breakthrough lens' in market terms.

Surely, dedicated E mount 28-35-75-90 lenses must now come into consideration, and they should be high end from now on. They already have the formulas and know-how.
Nov 16, 2019 at 10:43 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.27 #19Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
NRKStudio wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
NRKStudio wroteThe 75/1.5 is so solid. I read it follows the same optical design as the Otus 85/1.4 ( which Cosina manufactures as well). They have an excellent series on their site detailing the “making of” the 75/1.5. The light path was described as “beautiful” by the optical designer.
I really like the CV 75/1.5's rendering and it's impressive how such compact lens can be so sharp at f/1.5. Unfortunately the M-mount does perform optimally on the Sony sensor with moderate induced field curvature.
My wish list for what's next: CV 28/1.7, CV 35/1.7 and CV 75/1.5 E-mount lenses. All optimized for IQ with pleasant rendering while being as compact as possible.
I do believe Cosina is following this Nokton line as a nod of the hat to the Otus line. The online series on the site does almost allude to it, aside from directly comparing the 75 to the 85 Otus. I’d say the reason we see a 75 instead of an 85mm is because CV is planning on releasing a 90mm Lanthar.

I’m with you on the 75’s rendering. I use it though mainly on my m10-p with awesome results, sparingly on the Sony admittedly. I wonder if a PCX filter would propel it even to another league? We will
...Show more →

I am pretty sure the reason we see a Leica M mount 75 instead of an 85 is because Leica M cameras have 75mm frame lines and no 85mm frame lines. My guess is the focal length will change when they make and E mount lens and aren't constrained by the frame lines of the camera. An 85 for Sony E mount makes a lot of sense. Not only is it a more common focal length on non-rangefinder cameras, but it fits quite nicely between the 65 and 110 APO Lanthar Macros. My best guess is that Cosina will make a 85 f/1.4 Nokton based on the 75 f/1.5 Nokton for M mount, but I would be just as happy if not more so with an 85 f/2 APO Lanthar.

I also think that while we are considering the Noktons, given that we have a 21, 40, and 50 Noktons it seems to me the obvious one to add is a 28. I would love to see such a lenses but even a 28 f/2 ultron would be a great addition in my book.

Edited on Nov 17, 2019 at 06:24 AM · View previous versions
Nov 16, 2019 at 11:52 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.27 #20Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
How terrible it is depends a lot on the quality of the helicoid adapter you use. Most are fine for occasionally getting closer but not a full time focus ring. Dont know what @genji used but i used it on a yeenon adapter with a nice brass helicoid with smooth movement and decent throw.

Having said that the lens has quite a nice look but not amazing, and is sharp but not very sharp, and I think there’s scope for a better pancake that this (or even the new Sigma, which likely is better)
Steve Spencer wrote:
genji wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
genji wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
---------------------------------------------

Steve Spencer wrote
philip_pj wroteThe makros isolate themselves due to weight and a sharper specification for their intended usage. The speed brigade of 21/1.4, 40/50/1.2 are their own class. The 'orphans' are the 21/3.5 and this new one, which is the first push into portrait-friendly, high end prime territory.

The market is there for more f3.5 lenses at 18mm and 28mm; and the portrait set needs a 75/90 to go with the 50/2. They may stretch/lighten the 65/2 if (as expected) pre-orders/sales are solid for the 50/2 APO-Lanthar.

With just four more lenses, they could have four distinct sub-ranges in two years: macro - 65/2 and 110/2.5 (tick); portrait - 35/2, 50/2 (tick) and 90/2; and landscape - 18/3.5, 21/3.5 (tick) and 28/3.5; and of course the already released fast character lenses: 21/1.4, 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 (tick). They could add an E version of the 75/1.5 there as well.
Very close to what I have been thinking.

Macros are set with the 65 f/2 and 110 f/2.5. These are so wonderful I don't think they need more unless they are going to get into longer lenses in a big way. If they do a 180 f/3.5 Macro would be lovely.

Fast set has a wonderful beginning with 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 if they would add to this a 28 f/1.4 and an 85 f/1.4 (perhaps by modifying the 75 f/1.5), then that would make a wonderful fast set of Noktons.

I would also love to see a moderate speed high quality set built around this 50 APO Lanthar. If they could add a 25 f/2, 35 f/2, and an 90 f/2 APO that would be a wonderful set. Would love to see them add a remake of the 180 f/4 APO Lanthar to this set as well.

Finally, I think they are well on their way to a small aperture set with 10 f/5.6, 12 f/5.6, 15 f/4.5, 21 f/3.5, 40 f/2.8, if they would just add to this 18 f/3.5, 25 f/3.5, 28 f/2.8, and an 85 f/2.8 all that are quite small they would have most of the bases covered. Bonus points if they added a 135 f/3.5 as well.
Together you’ve laid out a superb, comprehensive roadmap for an enviable set of MF lenses. I would simply like to add a 45/2.8 pancake to Steve’s small aperture set.
Well they do have the 40 f/2.8 Heliar that is a pretty much a pancake. It is a bit funky as it focusses with the M close focus adapter rather than having it's own helicoid, but it is a very nice performer and nicely small. It is as I understand made for the thickness of Sony sensor glass as well, even though it technically has an M mount--on a M, however, there would be no way to focus it.
I had the 40/2.8 Heliar for less than a week. Its terrible haptics led me to sell it as fast as I could. Happily the lens was in short supply at the time so I got back what I’d paid for it.
Good to know. I wondered how it would be to use. I guess not so good.



Edited on Nov 17, 2019 at 03:13 AM · View previous versions
Nov 17, 2019 at 12:10 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister