keepcoding wrote:
I've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??
I am not a huge fan of weather sealing as I don't know just how well it works. First, I don't like to shoot in the rain, so I don't very often. And second, when I do shoot in the rain I much prefer a rain cover than relying on an uncertain amount of weather sealing. If I bought the new Leica SL2 that actually meets an external standard I might do without the rain cover, but even that camera is only rated as splash proof, so I wouldn't use it in a steady rain. In a light drizzle, however, I would probably be fine coverless.
keepcoding wrote:
I've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??
Imho all the weather sealing for lenses is just a marketing gag.
No IP classes.
No coverage for water damage.
What is it worth?
Pretty sure any Voigtlander lens would withstand more water than any of the "weathersealed" Batis lenses.
BastianK wrote: keepcoding wroteI've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??Imho all the weather sealing for lenses is just a marketing gag.
No IP classes.
No coverage for water damage.
What is it worth?
Pretty sure any Voigtlander lens would withstand more water than any of the "weathersealed" Batis lenses.
Roger Cicala has pointed in the same direction, one should be cautious about any claims of weather sealing or weather resistance in photographic lenses. Plastic bags and rubber bands are still a goid idea (sic).
BastianK wrote: keepcoding wroteI've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??Imho all the weather sealing for lenses is just a marketing gag.
No IP classes.
No coverage for water damage.
What is it worth?
Pretty sure any Voigtlander lens would withstand more water than any of the "weathersealed" Batis lenses.
Well no rating yes, but it still gives a reasonable amount of weather resistance. I wouldn't call it marketing gag. Olympus cameras and lenses for instance are really good in this regard, I've had no worries rinsing my E-M1 under the faucet when it was dirty. Wouldn't do that with my Sony stuff.
But I do agree that one has to be careful about the claim of weather resistance.
Steve Spencer wrote: keepcoding wroteI've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??I am not a huge fan of weather sealing as I don't know just how well it works. First, I don't like to shoot in the rain, so I don't very often. And second, when I do shoot in the rain I much prefer a rain cover than relying on an uncertain amount of weather sealing. If I bought the new Leica SL2 that actually meets an external standard I might do without the rain cover, but even that camera is only rated as splash proof, so I wouldn't use it in a steady rain. In a light drizzle, however, I would probably be fine coverless....Show more →
Often times it is not rain I'm concerned about, but rather DUST. I've visited Namib Desert recently, and it was extremely dusty. All my lenses except for the Tamron 28-75mm now have small specks of dust inside.
keepcoding wrote:
I've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??
Seems like most MF primes with their greased helicoids and sometime unit focusing assemblies are already pretty resistant to the weather. Yes, a mount gasket seems like a good idea, but unless you dunk the lens+camera body it should be pretty resistant to light mist kind of weather or casual splashes.
BastianK wrote: keepcoding wroteI've wondered for a while now why Voigtlander does not add weathersealing to their lenses... I mean after all their products are in the premium segment, and I bet that most people would welcome added weather resistance.
Or are you all shooting in sunny weather only??Imho all the weather sealing for lenses is just a marketing gag.
No IP classes.
No coverage for water damage.
What is it worth?
Pretty sure any Voigtlander lens would withstand more water than any of the "weathersealed" Batis lenses.
One thing we all need to bear in mind is the question of how much weather sealing a lens *needs*.
A traditional MF lens with helicoids and mechanical grease is not bad at resisting moisture through the focussing system.
But the important thing is that a small amount of moisture anywhere else is not big deal; the worst that can happen is that a lot gets in and leaves a mark on an element: but that would need to be a lot (or perhaps get unlucky and mess up the exif electronics).
A modern AF lens though has it's main lens barrel hidden. Around that is wrapped lots of electronics and then a thin polycarbonate or aluminium shell. Any moisture getting through that shell can be disastrous: if the electronics die, the lens dies.
And there's electronics all around it.
So dedicated weather sealing—gaskets and the like—are very important on an AF lens, especially one with switches and buttons though which there might be water penetration. Lower end AF lenses with switches or function buttons I would never trust to extreme weather without some kind of housing or plastic bag system.
So back to Batis (for example) versus VC. The Batis lenses seem pretty well sealed for AF lenses. There's sealing around the focus ring and a lens gasket. There are also no switches or buttons, which for weather sealing is state of the art, though of course you may want them.
So there are two questions. Which lens better resists small amounts of water penetration? I obviously don't know - that requires serious testing - but it wouldn't surprise me if it's the Batis, even if it's only at the lens mount that there is much difference.
But which lens better survives wet conditions? It wouldn't surprise me if that's the CV, because small amounts of water penetration, if they happen, are less likely to be catastrophic.
I don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.
TakenWild wrote:
I don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.
Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.
keepcoding wrote: TakenWild wroteI don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.
I don't think that is really true. You could always use a waterproof housing if you really were concerned about dust or you can wrap in plastic with rubber bands for some level of protection. Further if you are so concerned about dust, then why would you really on a manufacturer's claim which is not supported by any third party standard? That claim means absolutely nothing. I am fine with rubber gaskets and such and think they are nice, but I would never pretend that is actually even a dust resistant sealing.
keepcoding wrote:
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.
Yes, there is a good way. I use when in dusty or wet environments whether the lens is weather sealed or not.
Just buy an elastic silicone "O" ring of the proper diameter so that it fits tightly around the joint between the lens and the body mount. Slip it over the lens from the back before mounting on the camera. After mounting just roll it into the joint. You will see that there is a small slot created between the lens and the body when a lense is mounted. Size the "O" ring so that it fills this gap. Cheap, easy to use, and does a really good job. It is cosmetically nice, You won't even know it is there when shooting.
A rubber band can be similarly used in a pinch, but I find the rounded shape of an "O" ring does a much better job of sealing because it drops into the gap.
Steve Spencer wrote: keepcoding wroteTakenWild wroteI don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.I don't think that is really true. You could always use a waterproof housing if you really were concerned about dust or you can wrap in plastic with rubber bands for some level of protection. Further if you are so concerned about dust, then why would you really on a manufacturer's claim which is not supported by any third party standard? That claim means absolutely nothing. I am fine with rubber gaskets and such and think they are nice, but I would never pretend that is actually even a dust resistant sealing.
I disagree. Wrapping the camera or lens with a plastic bag greatly reduces usability. It is just not practical for longer periods of time.
Same goes for waterproof housings. They are expensive, bulky, and take away the joy of using the camera in my opinion, and there is an impact on image quality due to added glass.
Why I rely on manufacturers claims? Because my experience shows that if it is done right, weather sealing can make a significant difference.
1bwana1 wrote: keepcoding wroteBut as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.Yes, there is a good way. I use when in dusty or wet environments whether the lens is weather sealed or not.
Just buy an elastic silicone "O" ring of the proper diameter so that it fits tightly around the joint between the lens and the body mount. Slip it over the lens from the back before mounting on the camera. After mounting just roll it into the joint. You will see that there is a small slot created between the lens and the body when a lense is mounted. Size the "O" ring so that it fills this gap. Cheap, easy to use, and does a really good job. It is cosmetically nice, You won't even know it is there when shooting.
A rubber band can be similarly used in a pinch, but I find the rounded shape of an "O" ring does a much better job of sealing because it drops into the gap.
keepcoding wrote: Steve Spencer wrotekeepcoding wroteTakenWild wroteI don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.I don't think that is really true. You could always use a waterproof housing if you really were concerned about dust or you can wrap in plastic with rubber bands for some level of protection. Further if you are so concerned about dust, then why would you really on a manufacturer's claim which is not supported by any third party standard? That claim means absolutely nothing. I am fine with rubber gaskets and such and think they are nice, but I would never pretend that is actually even a dust resistant sealing.I disagree. Wrapping the camera or lens with a plastic bag greatly reduces usability. It is just not practical for longer periods of time.
Same goes for waterproof housings. They are expensive, bulky, and take away the joy of using the camera in my opinion, and there is an impact on image quality due to added glass.
Why I rely on manufacturers claims? Because my experience shows that if it is done right, weather sealing can make a significant difference.
1bwana1 wrotekeepcoding wroteBut as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.Yes, there is a good way. I use when in dusty or wet environments whether the lens is weather sealed or not.
Just buy an elastic silicone "O" ring of the proper diameter so that it fits tightly around the joint between the lens and the body mount. Slip it over the lens from the back before mounting on the camera. After mounting just roll it into the joint. You will see that there is a small slot created between the lens and the body when a lense is mounted. Size the "O" ring so that it fills this gap. Cheap, easy to use, and does a really good job. It is cosmetically nice, You won't even know it is there when shooting.
A rubber band can be similarly used in a pinch, but I find the rounded shape of an "O" ring does a much better job of sealing because it drops into the gap.The rubber gasket at the mount is just half of the story. What about the focus mechanism?
Well, we will just have to agree to disagree. My perspective is that one person's experience cannot tell the story for protection from rare events, and I would not put a plastic bag over a camera and lens for dust protection. I would wrap the camera in plastic, which would not affect operation nearly as much. Anyway, it seems your mind is made up, so let's just agree to disagree.
Steve Spencer wrote: keepcoding wroteSteve Spencer wrotekeepcoding wroteTakenWild wroteI don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.I don't think that is really true. You could always use a waterproof housing if you really were concerned about dust or you can wrap in plastic with rubber bands for some level of protection. Further if you are so concerned about dust, then why would you really on a manufacturer's claim which is not supported by any third party standard? That claim means absolutely nothing. I am fine with rubber gaskets and such and think they are nice, but I would never pretend that is actually even a dust resistant sealing.I disagree. Wrapping the camera or lens with a plastic bag greatly reduces usability. It is just not practical for longer periods of time.
Same goes for waterproof housings. They are expensive, bulky, and take away the joy of using the camera in my opinion, and there is an impact on image quality due to added glass.
Why I rely on manufacturers claims? Because my experience shows that if it is done right, weather sealing can make a significant difference.
1bwana1 wrotekeepcoding wroteBut as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.Yes, there is a good way. I use when in dusty or wet environments whether the lens is weather sealed or not.
Just buy an elastic silicone "O" ring of the proper diameter so that it fits tightly around the joint between the lens and the body mount. Slip it over the lens from the back before mounting on the camera. After mounting just roll it into the joint. You will see that there is a small slot created between the lens and the body when a lense is mounted. Size the "O" ring so that it fills this gap. Cheap, easy to use, and does a really good job. It is cosmetically nice, You won't even know it is there when shooting.
A rubber band can be similarly used in a pinch, but I find the rounded shape of an "O" ring does a much better job of sealing because it drops into the gap.The rubber gasket at the mount is just half of the story. What about the focus mechanism?Well, we will just have to agree to disagree. My perspective is that one person's experience cannot tell the story for protection from rare events, and I would not put a plastic bag over a camera and lens for dust protection. I would wrap the camera in plastic, which would not affect operation nearly as much. Anyway, it seems your mind is made up, so let's just agree to disagree.
excellent idea, you keep using your plastic wrap and I keep buying weathersealed lenses
keepcoding wrote: Steve Spencer wrotekeepcoding wroteSteve Spencer wrotekeepcoding wroteTakenWild wroteI don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.I don't think that is really true. You could always use a waterproof housing if you really were concerned about dust or you can wrap in plastic with rubber bands for some level of protection. Further if you are so concerned about dust, then why would you really on a manufacturer's claim which is not supported by any third party standard? That claim means absolutely nothing. I am fine with rubber gaskets and such and think they are nice, but I would never pretend that is actually even a dust resistant sealing.I disagree. Wrapping the camera or lens with a plastic bag greatly reduces usability. It is just not practical for longer periods of time.
Same goes for waterproof housings. They are expensive, bulky, and take away the joy of using the camera in my opinion, and there is an impact on image quality due to added glass.
Why I rely on manufacturers claims? Because my experience shows that if it is done right, weather sealing can make a significant difference.
1bwana1 wrotekeepcoding wroteBut as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.Yes, there is a good way. I use when in dusty or wet environments whether the lens is weather sealed or not.
Just buy an elastic silicone "O" ring of the proper diameter so that it fits tightly around the joint between the lens and the body mount. Slip it over the lens from the back before mounting on the camera. After mounting just roll it into the joint. You will see that there is a small slot created between the lens and the body when a lense is mounted. Size the "O" ring so that it fills this gap. Cheap, easy to use, and does a really good job. It is cosmetically nice, You won't even know it is there when shooting.
A rubber band can be similarly used in a pinch, but I find the rounded shape of an "O" ring does a much better job of sealing because it drops into the gap.The rubber gasket at the mount is just half of the story. What about the focus mechanism?Well, we will just have to agree to disagree. My perspective is that one person's experience cannot tell the story for protection from rare events, and I would not put a plastic bag over a camera and lens for dust protection. I would wrap the camera in plastic, which would not affect operation nearly as much. Anyway, it seems your mind is made up, so let's just agree to disagree.excellent idea, you keep using your plastic wrap and I keep buying weathersealed lenses
No I'm not going to use a plastic wrap either, but I do think it probably is at least as much protection as manufacturer's the self-proclaimed weather-resistance (and never even weather sealing). You go ahead and trust the manufacturers. I will remain skeptical of their claims until they can verify them with third party standards.
keepcoding wrote:
The rubber gasket at the mount is just half of the story. What about the focus mechanism?
I agree that it is not a complete solution. It just helps with the most vulnerable point that threatens both the camera and the lens.
I would prefer to also buy only weather resistant lenses, and mostly do. However, some of my special use lenses like Voigtlander are not, so I do the best I can.
In severe conditions I carry a plastic cover setup that seems to work OK. So far, I have never lost a lens or body to water or dust damage. I have shot Africa plenty, and in some tough weather conditions in Iceland, Dolomites, Tetons, Sierras and the like.
I also have all of my equipment insured against all loss through my homeowners scheduled items policy. So, it all in all I am comfortable with my level of risk. I travel and shoot without much worry.
Would you guys consider starting a separate thread on water resistance, etc.?
I subscribed to this thread because I'm interested in information relating to the new CV 50/2 and it has devolved into a lengthy discussion on water resistance and equipment that does not specifically relate to this lens.
keepcoding wrote: Steve Spencer wrotekeepcoding wroteSteve Spencer wrotekeepcoding wroteTakenWild wroteI don’t understand people’s worries about weather sealing. Use protection. Protection on an unsealed lens or camera is better than on the most sealed camera or lens you can buy.
I’d feel concerned buying gear from people who are worried about sealing, their gear could be a ticking time bomb. Especially if they have that mentality around salt water.Yes of course, but even if you are careful with your gear, accidents can happen (e.g. someone spills a glass of water).
But as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.I don't think that is really true. You could always use a waterproof housing if you really were concerned about dust or you can wrap in plastic with rubber bands for some level of protection. Further if you are so concerned about dust, then why would you really on a manufacturer's claim which is not supported by any third party standard? That claim means absolutely nothing. I am fine with rubber gaskets and such and think they are nice, but I would never pretend that is actually even a dust resistant sealing.I disagree. Wrapping the camera or lens with a plastic bag greatly reduces usability. It is just not practical for longer periods of time.
Same goes for waterproof housings. They are expensive, bulky, and take away the joy of using the camera in my opinion, and there is an impact on image quality due to added glass.
Why I rely on manufacturers claims? Because my experience shows that if it is done right, weather sealing can make a significant difference.
1bwana1 wrotekeepcoding wroteBut as I already tried to explain (but I guess nobody has read that), protection against dust is more important. Either you don't use the lens in a dusty environment or you will get dust inside the lens if it is not weathersealed. There is simply no trivial way to protect the lens without seriously compromizing the usability.Yes, there is a good way. I use when in dusty or wet environments whether the lens is weather sealed or not.
Just buy an elastic silicone "O" ring of the proper diameter so that it fits tightly around the joint between the lens and the body mount. Slip it over the lens from the back before mounting on the camera. After mounting just roll it into the joint. You will see that there is a small slot created between the lens and the body when a lense is mounted. Size the "O" ring so that it fills this gap. Cheap, easy to use, and does a really good job. It is cosmetically nice, You won't even know it is there when shooting.
A rubber band can be similarly used in a pinch, but I find the rounded shape of an "O" ring does a much better job of sealing because it drops into the gap.The rubber gasket at the mount is just half of the story. What about the focus mechanism?Well, we will just have to agree to disagree. My perspective is that one person's experience cannot tell the story for protection from rare events, and I would not put a plastic bag over a camera and lens for dust protection. I would wrap the camera in plastic, which would not affect operation nearly as much. Anyway, it seems your mind is made up, so let's just agree to disagree.excellent idea, you keep using your plastic wrap and I keep buying weathersealed lenses
The sad truth is none of us know what "weather sealed" / "weather resistant" etc... really means. It's a moving target across brands. Look it's great in theory but as far as I know there is no one putting there money where there mouth is. So for me the motto is simple. "Don't do stupid things with your expensive equipment" and that starts with believing everything a manufacturer puts on the marketing brochure.
Perhaps, Fred could split this away from this thread?
(Weather resistance and Sony are not compatible but many here make it sound like weather resistance itself is nonsensical!)
Jeff Kott wrote:
Would you guys consider starting a separate thread on water resistance, etc.?
I subscribed to this thread because I'm interested in information relating to the new CV 50/2 and it has devolved into a lengthy discussion on water resistance and equipment that does not specifically relate to this lens.