Looks really good at f/2 and f/2.8, as promised. However, in between those two, you can see the effect of straight blades. Somewhat concerning for what this may do to bokeh busy-ness in those interim apertures, though I'm sure it'll be sharp as can be.
Really interesting design- I'd love to see the shape of the blades. Looks perfectly round at f/2.8.
I'm much more in the "round blade / smooth bokeh" camp, not a fan of sun stars at all, but I'm stoked we may get the best of both worlds with this one.
lunar module wrote:
Quick summary of Japanese video showing bokeh ball findings at varying apertures:
At f4 it is very close to the 1130g Milvus 35mm f1.4 (14/11), but has better corners. At f2, it is in the technical class of the APO-Summicron-SL 50 f/2 Asph, a 740g 12/10 AF item, yet to be released. ($4500).
It will most definitely pair well with the 21/3.5, with only a great short tele portrait/general lens yet to appear, specific to E mount. A revised 75/1.5 VM (or a similar 90-100/2) would round out a great three lens kit weighing under a kilo.
People may try to paint it as a 'landscape lens', but it is more designed after Leica's better 50mm portrait/general lenses, and just happens to have the superb resolution of new lenses 2/3 times its weight/cost, with great versatility for much broader, real world usage.As far as resolution, it would probably pair better with the Loxia 21 and 85 lenses.
bjornthun wrote: Fred Miranda wrotephilip_pj wrote'The figures in the MTF diagram are actually measured by mass-produced products, not by design values.'
At f4 it is very close to the 1130g Milvus 35mm f1.4 (14/11), but has better corners. At f2, it is in the technical class of the APO-Summicron-SL 50 f/2 Asph, a 740g 12/10 AF item, yet to be released. ($4500).
It will most definitely pair well with the 21/3.5, with only a great short tele portrait/general lens yet to appear, specific to E mount. A revised 75/1.5 VM (or a similar 90-100/2) would round out a great three lens kit weighing under a kilo.
People may try to paint it as a 'landscape lens', but it is more designed after Leica's better 50mm portrait/general lenses, and just happens to have the superb resolution of new lenses 2/3 times its weight/cost, with great versatility for much broader, real world usage.As far as resolution, it would probably pair better with the Loxia 21 and 85 lenses.And the CV 21/1.4 ?
Yes, for an exclusive Voigtlander set and striving for high resolution/contrast, perhaps CV 21/1.4, CV 50/2 APO and CV 110/2.5 APO. Just missing that 28mm!
Fred Miranda wrote: bjornthun wroteFred Miranda wrotephilip_pj wrote'The figures in the MTF diagram are actually measured by mass-produced products, not by design values.'
At f4 it is very close to the 1130g Milvus 35mm f1.4 (14/11), but has better corners. At f2, it is in the technical class of the APO-Summicron-SL 50 f/2 Asph, a 740g 12/10 AF item, yet to be released. ($4500).
It will most definitely pair well with the 21/3.5, with only a great short tele portrait/general lens yet to appear, specific to E mount. A revised 75/1.5 VM (or a similar 90-100/2) would round out a great three lens kit weighing under a kilo.
People may try to paint it as a 'landscape lens', but it is more designed after Leica's better 50mm portrait/general lenses, and just happens to have the superb resolution of new lenses 2/3 times its weight/cost, with great versatility for much broader, real world usage.As far as resolution, it would probably pair better with the Loxia 21 and 85 lenses.And the CV 21/1.4 ?Yes, for an exclusive Voigtlander set and striving for high resolution/contrast, perhaps CV 21/1.4, CV 50/2 APO and CV 110/2.5 APO. Just missing that 28mm!
Wow, I just went to the website for that visualizer and it changes my perspective on things quite a bit. Thanks for posting it.
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteLooking at the samples from the video above, I think rendering is quite pleasant (smooth) even at mid-distance.
Definitely better than what I see from the Loxia 50/2.
Can't see axial / lateral CA either. Looking great!Nice almost free of sperochromatism!!
I also learn that that Japanese guys pronounces Apo Lanthar the German way, and almost (just a typical extra vowel sound in the middle) pronounces Voigtländer the German way! (he says Foacht-o-lender, whereas Foacht-lender is not a bad English way to represent the Germans sounds.
More exactly, the Japanese text on screen says フォクトレンダー. (My iPhone’s autocorrect suggested the complete word as soon as I’d typed the first three characters.) This transliterates as fokutorendaa but he pronounces it as foktorendaa which as you suggest, isn’t a bad way to represent the German sounds.
フォクトレンダー (fokutorendaa) is the Japanese katakana presentation of the original name, phonetically transcribed to closest sounding existing kana symbols. There is no 'v' in katakana so it becomes ’f' and there is no way to use a 'k' as standalone in katakana so it's combined with a vowel 'u'. By some luck it may sound close to German pronunciation
genji wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteLooking at the samples from the video above, I think rendering is quite pleasant (smooth) even at mid-distance.
Definitely better than what I see from the Loxia 50/2.
Can't see axial / lateral CA either. Looking great!Nice almost free of sperochromatism!!
I also learn that that Japanese guys pronounces Apo Lanthar the German way, and almost (just a typical extra vowel sound in the middle) pronounces Voigtländer the German way! (he says Foacht-o-lender, whereas Foacht-lender is not a bad English way to represent the Germans sounds.More exactly, the Japanese text on screen says フォクトレンダー. (My iPhone’s autocorrect suggested the complete word as soon as I’d typed the first three characters.) This transliterates as fokutorendaa but he pronounces it as foktorendaa which as you suggest, isn’t a bad way to represent the German sounds.
Really good/notable lens walk through! I really like the visual approach. Very thorough and practical and quick. Need to find his channel to see what other lenses he may have reviewed. Hope there are more.
What did he say at the end when comparing to the 1.2 ?
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wrotedavidmarinero wroteGreat video! Sunstars from 9:15. It’s crazy how wonderful the sunstars appear after f3.2 and then they become really bad at f16.Which video, David?
LBJ2 wrote:
Really good/notable lens walk through! I really like the visual approach. Very thorough and practical. Need to find his channel to see what other lenses he may have reviewed. Hope there are more.
What did he say at the end when comparing to the 1.2 ?
Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wrotedavidmarinero wroteGreat video! Sunstars from 9:15. It’s crazy how wonderful the sunstars appear after f3.2 and then they become really bad at f16.Which video, David?
~8:08m
He was thinking that the new 50/2 APO-Lanthar may be the "most powerful" lens made by Cosina up to now but personally he wants 50/1.2 even more. Then he mostly talked about how he has been borrowing the 50/1.2 from Cosina for a long time now and he should probably return it sometime soon... He didn't really talk about the differences between those 2 in the review so much but he seems to personally prefer a faster aperture for portraits and such.
He has reviewed a lot of stuff before too, not only Sony related but all kinds of cameras and gadgets so he's not specializing on lenses only. A few days ago there was a Tokina Firin 100/2.8 Macro lens review:
Juha Kannisto wrote:
フォクトレンダー (fokutorendaa) is the Japanese katakana presentation of the original name, phonetically transcribed to closest sounding existing kana symbols. There is no 'v' in katakana so it becomes ’f' and there is no way to use a 'k' as standalone in katakana so it's combined with a vowel 'u'. By some luck it may sound close to German pronunciation
genji wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteLooking at the samples from the video above, I think rendering is quite pleasant (smooth) even at mid-distance.
Definitely better than what I see from the Loxia 50/2.
Can't see axial / lateral CA either. Looking great!Nice almost free of sperochromatism!!
I also learn that that Japanese guys pronounces Apo Lanthar the German way, and almost (just a typical extra vowel sound in the middle) pronounces Voigtländer the German way! (he says Foacht-o-lender, whereas Foacht-lender is not a bad English way to represent the Germans sounds.More exactly, the Japanese text on screen says フォクトレンダー. (My iPhone’s autocorrect suggested the complete word as soon as I’d typed the first three characters.) This transliterates as fokutorendaa but he pronounces it as foktorendaa which as you suggest, isn’t a bad way to represent the German sounds.
Is R pronounced like an L in Japanese? The «ä» in Voigtländer is only approximately represented with an e, the «l» is not an «r» in German. The ending «er» is phonetically well represented with a dark «a». German and Swedish ä are very close.
bjornthun wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteフォクトレンダー (fokutorendaa) is the Japanese katakana presentation of the original name, phonetically transcribed to closest sounding existing kana symbols. There is no 'v' in katakana so it becomes ’f' and there is no way to use a 'k' as standalone in katakana so it's combined with a vowel 'u'. By some luck it may sound close to German pronunciation
genji wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteLooking at the samples from the video above, I think rendering is quite pleasant (smooth) even at mid-distance.
Definitely better than what I see from the Loxia 50/2.
Can't see axial / lateral CA either. Looking great!Nice almost free of sperochromatism!!
I also learn that that Japanese guys pronounces Apo Lanthar the German way, and almost (just a typical extra vowel sound in the middle) pronounces Voigtländer the German way! (he says Foacht-o-lender, whereas Foacht-lender is not a bad English way to represent the Germans sounds.More exactly, the Japanese text on screen says フォクトレンダー. (My iPhone’s autocorrect suggested the complete word as soon as I’d typed the first three characters.) This transliterates as fokutorendaa but he pronounces it as foktorendaa which as you suggest, isn’t a bad way to represent the German sounds.Is R pronounced like an L in Japanese? The «ä» in Voigtländer is only approximately represented with an e, the «l» is not an «r» in German. The ending «er» is phonetically well represented with a dark «a». German and Swedish ä are very close.
Yeah, there is no L in Japanese and R is prounounced as something that is in-between R and L so both R and L are represented by R in Japanese loanwords. Japanese people typically make mistakes between use of R and L when they use other languages as a result...
those two are the holly grial! even if resolution is excellent, it remains to see what about colors and contrast. i am skeptic about colors of voigtländer. whenever i use the lox 21 i do not want to remove it . if zeiss anounces the vm 35 f1.4 it is going to be a interesting choice, which one to get
Fred Miranda wrote: philip_pj wrote'The figures in the MTF diagram are actually measured by mass-produced products, not by design values.'
At f4 it is very close to the 1130g Milvus 35mm f1.4 (14/11), but has better corners. At f2, it is in the technical class of the APO-Summicron-SL 50 f/2 Asph, a 740g 12/10 AF item, yet to be released. ($4500).
It will most definitely pair well with the 21/3.5, with only a great short tele portrait/general lens yet to appear, specific to E mount. A revised 75/1.5 VM (or a similar 90-100/2) would round out a great three lens kit weighing under a kilo.
People may try to paint it as a 'landscape lens', but it is more designed after Leica's better 50mm portrait/general lenses, and just happens to have the superb resolution of new lenses 2/3 times its weight/cost, with great versatility for much broader, real world usage.As far as resolution, it would probably pair better with the Loxia 21 and 85 lenses.
Fred Miranda wrote: bjornthun wroteFred Miranda wrotephilip_pj wrote'The figures in the MTF diagram are actually measured by mass-produced products, not by design values.'
At f4 it is very close to the 1130g Milvus 35mm f1.4 (14/11), but has better corners. At f2, it is in the technical class of the APO-Summicron-SL 50 f/2 Asph, a 740g 12/10 AF item, yet to be released. ($4500).
It will most definitely pair well with the 21/3.5, with only a great short tele portrait/general lens yet to appear, specific to E mount. A revised 75/1.5 VM (or a similar 90-100/2) would round out a great three lens kit weighing under a kilo.
People may try to paint it as a 'landscape lens', but it is more designed after Leica's better 50mm portrait/general lenses, and just happens to have the superb resolution of new lenses 2/3 times its weight/cost, with great versatility for much broader, real world usage.As far as resolution, it would probably pair better with the Loxia 21 and 85 lenses.And the CV 21/1.4 ?Yes, for an exclusive Voigtlander set and striving for high resolution/contrast, perhaps CV 21/1.4, CV 50/2 APO and CV 110/2.5 APO. Just missing that 28mm!
A CV28mm APO would be awesome and probably sell really well, imo
Juha Kannisto wrote: bjornthun wroteJuha Kannisto wroteフォクトレンダー (fokutorendaa) is the Japanese katakana presentation of the original name, phonetically transcribed to closest sounding existing kana symbols. There is no 'v' in katakana so it becomes ’f' and there is no way to use a 'k' as standalone in katakana so it's combined with a vowel 'u'. By some luck it may sound close to German pronunciation
genji wroteDavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteLooking at the samples from the video above, I think rendering is quite pleasant (smooth) even at mid-distance.
Definitely better than what I see from the Loxia 50/2.
Can't see axial / lateral CA either. Looking great!Nice almost free of sperochromatism!!
I also learn that that Japanese guys pronounces Apo Lanthar the German way, and almost (just a typical extra vowel sound in the middle) pronounces Voigtländer the German way! (he says Foacht-o-lender, whereas Foacht-lender is not a bad English way to represent the Germans sounds.More exactly, the Japanese text on screen says フォクトレンダー. (My iPhone’s autocorrect suggested the complete word as soon as I’d typed the first three characters.) This transliterates as fokutorendaa but he pronounces it as foktorendaa which as you suggest, isn’t a bad way to represent the German sounds.Is R pronounced like an L in Japanese? The «ä» in Voigtländer is only approximately represented with an e, the «l» is not an «r» in German. The ending «er» is phonetically well represented with a dark «a». German and Swedish ä are very close.Yeah, there is no L in Japanese and R is prounounced as something that is in-between R and L so both R and L are represented by R in Japanese loanwords. Japanese people typically make mistakes between use of R and L when they use other languages as a result...
I recall that many years ago, when I was studying Japanese in Tokyo, I saw a humorous book on this subject in the Kinokuniya store in Shinjuku. It was titled Is That “R” as in London or “L” as in Paris.
genji wrote: Juha Kannisto wrotebjornthun wroteJuha Kannisto wroteフォクトレンダー (fokutorendaa) is the Japanese katakana presentation of the original name, phonetically transcribed to closest sounding existing kana symbols. There is no 'v' in katakana so it becomes ’f' and there is no way to use a 'k' as standalone in katakana so it's combined with a vowel 'u'. By some luck it may sound close to German pronunciation
genji wroteDavidBM wroteNice almost free of sperochromatism!!
I also learn that that Japanese guys pronounces Apo Lanthar the German way, and almost (just a typical extra vowel sound in the middle) pronounces Voigtländer the German way! (he says Foacht-o-lender, whereas Foacht-lender is not a bad English way to represent the Germans sounds.More exactly, the Japanese text on screen says フォクトレンダー. (My iPhone’s autocorrect suggested the complete word as soon as I’d typed the first three characters.) This transliterates as fokutorendaa but he pronounces it as foktorendaa which as you suggest, isn’t a bad way to represent the German sounds.Is R pronounced like an L in Japanese? The «ä» in Voigtländer is only approximately represented with an e, the «l» is not an «r» in German. The ending «er» is phonetically well represented with a dark «a». German and Swedish ä are very close.Yeah, there is no L in Japanese and R is prounounced as something that is in-between R and L so both R and L are represented by R in Japanese loanwords. Japanese people typically make mistakes between use of R and L when they use other languages as a result...I recall that many years ago, when I was studying Japanese in Tokyo, I saw a humorous book on this subject in the Kinokuniya store in Shinjuku. It was titled Is That “R” as in London or “L” as in Paris.
My name, Laurent or Lawrence depending upon which language spoken was translated in Japanese to me phonetically as Ro-rensu. While I was happy that someone took the time to translate my name...I always wondered what does Ro-rensu really mean Was the joke on me the Gaijin ? Ha Ha
I can easily imagine the CV 50mm APO besting the Loxia 50mm, but the Loxia 21mm seems to many people to still have the better rendering compared to the CV 21/1.4. Works against making a consistent set of the same brand/ergonomics. Or is that just my OCD speaking?
chiron wrote:
I can easily imagine the CV 50mm APO besting the Loxia 50mm, but the Loxia 21mm seems to many people to still have the better rendering compared to the CV 21/1.4. Works against making a consistent set of the same brand/ergonomics. Or is that just my OCD speaking?
I've owned both the Loxia 21 and (currently) the CV 21/1.4. IMO, they are equal in IQ, both excellent. The biggest differentiators are size (win: Loxia) and speed (win: Voigtlander). Some prefer the Loxia sunstars. I kept the CV 21 for the abilty to do astro (which I never do ). No wrong choice between the two.
smpetty wrote: chiron wroteI can easily imagine the CV 50mm APO besting the Loxia 50mm, but the Loxia 21mm seems to many people to still have the better rendering compared to the CV 21/1.4. Works against making a consistent set of the same brand/ergonomics. Or is that just my OCD speaking?I've owned both the Loxia 21 and (currently) the CV 21/1.4. IMO, they are equal in IQ, both excellent. The biggest differentiators are size (win: Loxia) and speed (win: Voigtlander). Some prefer the Loxia sunstars. I kept the CV 21 for the abilty to do astro (which I never do ). No wrong choice between the two.
They also differ in field curvature shape. The Voigtlander's is wavy (which affects the midfield) and the Loxia is inwards (which affect the extreme corners). Take your poison.
Fred Miranda wrote: smpetty wrotechiron wroteI can easily imagine the CV 50mm APO besting the Loxia 50mm, but the Loxia 21mm seems to many people to still have the better rendering compared to the CV 21/1.4. Works against making a consistent set of the same brand/ergonomics. Or is that just my OCD speaking?I've owned both the Loxia 21 and (currently) the CV 21/1.4. IMO, they are equal in IQ, both excellent. The biggest differentiators are size (win: Loxia) and speed (win: Voigtlander). Some prefer the Loxia sunstars. I kept the CV 21 for the abilty to do astro (which I never do ). No wrong choice between the two.They also differ in field curvature shape. The Voigtlander's is wavy and the Loxia is inwards.
Two other important differences for me after owning both:
1) I like the CV 21 f/1.4 better for up close performance. I think the floating element in the CV really helps provide very high level performance up close.
2) I much prefer the ergonomics of the CV especially the aperture ring at the front of the lens instead of back close to the mount on the Loxia. I also find the CV 21 f/1.4 a lot easier to get on and off the camera.
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wrotesmpetty wrotechiron wroteI can easily imagine the CV 50mm APO besting the Loxia 50mm, but the Loxia 21mm seems to many people to still have the better rendering compared to the CV 21/1.4. Works against making a consistent set of the same brand/ergonomics. Or is that just my OCD speaking?I've owned both the Loxia 21 and (currently) the CV 21/1.4. IMO, they are equal in IQ, both excellent. The biggest differentiators are size (win: Loxia) and speed (win: Voigtlander). Some prefer the Loxia sunstars. I kept the CV 21 for the abilty to do astro (which I never do ). No wrong choice between the two.They also differ in field curvature shape. The Voigtlander's is wavy and the Loxia is inwards.Two other important differences for me after owning both:
1) I like the CV 21 f/1.4 better for up close performance. I think the floating element in the CV really helps provide very high level performance up close.
2) I much prefer the ergonomics of the CV especially the aperture ring at the front of the lens instead of back close to the mount on the Loxia. I also find the CV 21 f/1.4 a lot easier to get on and off the camera.
Are you sure the Loxia 21/2.8 does not feature a floating system?
On Zeiss' official page, it shows the FLE icon: