fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR

  
 
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.14 #1Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
It also reflects the need for a high quality, compact standard prime.

If Sony comes out with a decent 50/1.8 II, it would help as well.


Ultraluminal wrote:
Wow! 14+ pages on a lens that is not yet for sale. Says worlds about how awesome Voigtlander has become (and for some of us has been for some time).


Oct 09, 2019 at 02:39 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.14 #2Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?


I'm hoping not. 7 Artisans have been experimenting with an iris which gives you a round aperture one stop down, and then the blades straighten (basically the blades have an odd shape, curved then straight, so that one stop down the curved part is making the aperture, and as you stop down it's the straight part)

So with luck the CV diaphragm is like that! Of course only time will tell..
Oct 09, 2019 at 03:31 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.14 #3Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
All very sweet, the special aperture deal and how about the size of it.

'But they have said the 2/50 is exclusive for E mount.'

This will cause more than a little consternation. How times change. See the excitement in the presenter's expression. Every system of course needs a great 50mm, see the new Canon and Nikon lenses with their very different direction for high end near-normals, a legacy of the DSLR days. We will do far better with the vision of Cosina.
Oct 09, 2019 at 03:48 PM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.14 #4Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
I'm just hoping they ship this before X-mas

Edited on Oct 09, 2019 at 04:15 PM · View previous versions
Oct 09, 2019 at 04:00 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.14 #5Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
DavidBM wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I'm hoping not. 7 Artisans have been experimenting with an iris which gives you a round aperture one stop down, and then the blades straighten (basically the blades have an odd shape, curved then straight, so that one stop down the curved part is making the aperture, and as you stop down it's the straight part)

So with luck the CV diaphragm is like that! Of course only time will tell..


I have a Canon nFD 55 f/1.2 Asph and it has similar aperture blades. The aperture is pretty round until f/2.8 and then gets straight at narrower apertures, so there is really nothing new about this approach.

In general, I think it is a great idea for a general purpose lens. For something like the CV 21 f/3.4 I think straight blades are the way to go. For primarily portrait lenses keeping the aperture as round as possible for as narrow of apertures as possible seems like the way to go. For a generalist lens, as this lens ought to be, this seems like just the right approach.
Oct 09, 2019 at 04:07 PM
lunar module
Offline
Details
p.14 #6Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?


I thought it was interesting that when the aperture was stopped down from f/2.0 to f/2.8 in the video (in what looked like 1/3 stop steps), the aperture was perfectly round at f/2.0 and f/2.8 but NOT round at the two intermediate steps in between.






f/2.0







f/2.2







f/2.5







f/2.8



Edited on Oct 09, 2019 at 05:19 PM · View previous versions
Oct 09, 2019 at 05:16 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.14 #7Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR

Sure, the partly curved profile has been around though imho underused for a while, just that 7A ate the first for a long time to experiment with it. But from the video this is unlike what Ive seen before. As you stop down it gets rough but then when it hits 2.8 its is closer to a circle than I think ivr seen from most curvd bladd before...
Steve Spencer wrote:
DavidBM wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I'm hoping not. 7 Artisans have been experimenting with an iris which gives you a round aperture one stop down, and then the blades straighten (basically the blades have an odd shape, curved then straight, so that one stop down the curved part is making the aperture, and as you stop down it's the straight part)

So with luck the CV diaphragm is like that! Of course only time will tell..
I have a Canon nFD 55 f/1.2 Asph and it has similar aperture blades. The aperture is pretty round until f/2.8 and then gets straight at narrower apertures, so there is really nothing new about this approach.

In general, I think it is a great idea for a general purpose lens. For something like the CV 21 f/3.4 I think straight blades are the way to go. For primarily portrait lenses keeping the aperture as round as possible for as narrow of apertures as possible seems like the way to go. For a generalist lens, as this lens ought to
...Show more →
Oct 09, 2019 at 05:16 PM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.14 #8Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR

Likely to show terrible sun stars before it hits f2.8.
lunar module wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I thought it was interesting that when the aperture was stopped down from f/2.0 to f/2.8 in the video (in what looked like 1/3 stop steps), the aperture was perfectly round at f/2.0 and f/2.8 but NOT round at the two intermediate steps in between.


Oct 09, 2019 at 05:27 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.14 #9Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
realVivek wrote:
Likely to show terrible sun stars before it hits f2.8.
lunar module wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I thought it was interesting that when the aperture was stopped down from f/2.0 to f/2.8 in the video (in what looked like 1/3 stop steps), the aperture was perfectly round at f/2.0 and f/2.8 but NOT round at the two intermediate steps in between.


Ha ha maybe it does something like this:

https://www.eoshd.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/cooke-bokeh.jpg
Oct 09, 2019 at 06:02 PM
Taylor Sherman
Offline
Details
p.14 #10Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
lunar module wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I thought it was interesting that when the aperture was stopped down from f/2.0 to f/2.8 in the video (in what looked like 1/3 stop steps), the aperture was perfectly round at f/2.0 and f/2.8 but NOT round at the two intermediate steps in between.


Makes sense - the different sections of each blade have different radius of curvature, so there's got to be an inflection point where they meet up, and that's exposed when it's between here and there.
Oct 09, 2019 at 06:15 PM
lunar module
Offline
Details
p.14 #11Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Taylor Sherman wrote:
Makes sense - the different sections of each blade have different radius of curvature, so there's got to be an inflection point where they meet up, and that's exposed when it's between here and there.


I know nothing about the engineering required to accomplish this, but I was imagining that the engineers could have designed a variable curvature at the tip of each blade which would produce a round aperture opening continuously up until a certain aperture value was reached. I guess it's more complicated than that.
Oct 09, 2019 at 06:32 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.14 #12Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
lunar module wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I thought it was interesting that when the aperture was stopped down from f/2.0 to f/2.8 in the video (in what looked like 1/3 stop steps), the aperture was perfectly round at f/2.0 and f/2.8 but NOT round at the two intermediate steps in between.


The question is, what happens to the aperture after f/2.8. I wish the reviewer would have stopped the lens down further to show us.
Oct 09, 2019 at 06:33 PM
Taylor Sherman
Offline
Details
p.14 #13Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
lunar module wrote:
Taylor Sherman wroteMakes sense - the different sections of each blade have different radius of curvature, so there's got to be an inflection point where they meet up, and that's exposed when it's between here and there.
I know nothing about the engineering required to accomplish this, but I was imagining that the engineers could have designed a variable curvature at the tip of each blade which would produce a round aperture opening continuously up until a certain aperture value was reached. I guess it's more complicated than that.


The gist of it is - you can't make part of one circle with part of another circle that's a different size.
Oct 09, 2019 at 06:59 PM
lunar module
Offline
Details
p.14 #14Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Fred Miranda wrote:
lunar module wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
GartenMoorriem wroteAnother one. Here we see the special aperture at 2.8. Go to minute 7.00

Wow! very nice feature indeed!

At f/2.8 it's just as circular as f/2. I'm wondering what happens after f/2.8...would that affect their famous well-defined sunstars at f/4?
I thought it was interesting that when the aperture was stopped down from f/2.0 to f/2.8 in the video (in what looked like 1/3 stop steps), the aperture was perfectly round at f/2.0 and f/2.8 but NOT round at the two intermediate steps in between.
The question is, what happens to the aperture after f/2.8. I wish the reviewer would have stopped the lens down further to show us.


Me too!
Oct 09, 2019 at 07:16 PM
lunar module
Offline
Details
p.14 #15Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Taylor Sherman wrote:
lunar module wrote
Taylor Sherman wroteMakes sense - the different sections of each blade have different radius of curvature, so there's got to be an inflection point where they meet up, and that's exposed when it's between here and there.
I know nothing about the engineering required to accomplish this, but I was imagining that the engineers could have designed a variable curvature at the tip of each blade which would produce a round aperture opening continuously up until a certain aperture value was reached. I guess it's more complicated than that.
The gist of it is - you can't make part of one circle with part of another circle that's a different size.


Damn you, geometry. Damn you!
Oct 09, 2019 at 07:18 PM
JohnJ
Offline
Details
Oct 09, 2019 at 11:04 PM
Seha
Offline
Details
p.14 #17Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Super interesting... I'm not too familiar with Voigtlander lenses. Will this lens be any good for portrait?
Oct 10, 2019 at 12:03 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #18Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
DavidBM wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
MAubrey wrote
freaklikeme wrote
realVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.

freaklikeme wroteIt's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.
I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.
The RF coupler on a regular lens is just a curve on the mount end, since the entire lens block all moves together on a single helicoid. But a rangefinder coupled FLE design requires (at least) two separate helicoids, one for the FLE and one for the rangefinder, synced and calibrated together to work perfectly in tandem. It certainly isn't impossible, but it is definitely harder to do and definitely increases the cost of the mechanical part of the lens. And almost certainly why Cosina Voiigtlander has historically avoided FLE designs in their M-mount lenses.
---------------------------------------------

realVivek wroteAll of those modern lenses are also extremely expensive compared to Cosina’s lenses. That is not just due to the brand commanding a higher price.

The mechanical construction of APO Summicron 75/2, for example, is delicate and more complex. Hence more expensive.

From the APO 75/2 brochure- about the floating elements:

“While the fundamental technology is common in SLR lenses, to achieve this in a compact M lens with its very limited space, the Leica designers had to develop a brand new, extremely precise adjusting mechanism.”

freaklikeme wrote
realVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.

freaklikeme wroteIt's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.
I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.
I have the utmost respect for Leica's mechanical engineers, even if the marketing language makes them sound like they're elves working their magic on the lenses, and not people working with computers to calculate thread size. I agree it does add cost, but, assuming this is the APO-Summicron-like product they intended to make, then additional cost might not be the primary concern. Leica's giving them plenty of room to be the "cheap" alternative. And, I agree, in the past, Cosina has avoided FLEs, so much so that Zeiss had the ZM Sonnar 85 manufactured in Germany to accommodate the special need, but that changed with the ZM Distagon 35. Cosina took that on, so maybe, just maybe, they'd be willing to do it for a special lens of their own.

Also, their CEO shoots a film M-mount. They might want to please him.
I don't think there's any maybe here: they say the 2/50 Apo Lanthar has a floating mechanism (like the 65 and 110 macros do)

Unless perhaps you mean they might might be willing to do an M version with a rangefinder helicoid meshing with the focussing helicoid? But they have said the 2/50 is exclusive for E mount.


Yes, my point was, since they're making an FLE lens with the Distagon 35, they might be willing to do it for one of their own.

As for the "exclusive development," exclusivity may or may not last. We'll see, but, if the design allows for an M-mount version, I'm betting we'll see it.
Oct 10, 2019 at 12:07 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.14 #19Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Taylor Sherman wrote:
lunar module wrote
Taylor Sherman wroteMakes sense - the different sections of each blade have different radius of curvature, so there's got to be an inflection point where they meet up, and that's exposed when it's between here and there.
I know nothing about the engineering required to accomplish this, but I was imagining that the engineers could have designed a variable curvature at the tip of each blade which would produce a round aperture opening continuously up until a certain aperture value was reached. I guess it's more complicated than that.
The gist of it is - you can't make part of one circle with part of another circle that's a different size.


That’s true, but if we remove the continuity requirement, we could make blades whose edges are a series of areas that form different size circle segments so we could have round apertures at a series of apertures, at the price of weirdness in between. Not a good idea, though, by my lights. I’d rather have a circle one stop down, then sharp dodecagons thereafter.
Oct 10, 2019 at 05:14 AM
MAubrey
Offline
Details
p.14 #20Pre-order: Voigtländer 50mm f/2 APO-LANTHAR
Taylor Sherman wrote:
lunar module wrote
Taylor Sherman wroteMakes sense - the different sections of each blade have different radius of curvature, so there's got to be an inflection point where they meet up, and that's exposed when it's between here and there.
I know nothing about the engineering required to accomplish this, but I was imagining that the engineers could have designed a variable curvature at the tip of each blade which would produce a round aperture opening continuously up until a certain aperture value was reached. I guess it's more complicated than that.
The gist of it is - you can't make part of one circle with part of another circle that's a different size.


I have a Schneider Xenar 240mm f/4.5 in a Compound 4 shutter with 20 blades that seems to do it pretty well!

Oct 10, 2019 at 06:17 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister