Without the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wrote: DavidBM wroteimagesfromobjects wroteNo word on an M version?Some of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.
dclark wrote: TheWonderer wroteI have reasonable knowledge of camera gear but can someone explain what the advantage of APO is?
I own the CV50 f1.2 and find it an amazing lens, so wondering how/why APO would better this.
Thanks!APO is an abbreviation for apochromat. One of the most difficult aberrations in lens design and manufacture is axial chromatic aberration, which means that different wavelengths of light focus at different distances. In other words the focal length of the lens is wavelength dependent (i.e. color dependent). In order to minimize the variation in focus with wavelength, lenses are designed with glasses that have different dispersion (wavelength dependence of index of refraction) and different curvature, so that a plot of focal length versus wavelength is "U" shaped, so it crosses the desired focal length twice. That is an "achromatic" lens. An apochromat has more different glass types so the the plot of focal length versus wavelength is shaped like an S on its side, so it crosses the desired focal length three times. Traditionally the glasses and surfaces needed to make apochromatic lenses are expensive and lens assembly tolerances are tight which also is expensive. The apochromat deviates from the desired focal length much less since is crosses three times rather that two times (or even one time as in cheap lenses). That means the lens has less chromatic aberration over a larger range of wavelength.
realVivek wrote:
Without the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteimagesfromobjects wroteNo word on an M version?Some of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.
I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.
freaklikeme wrote: realVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteimagesfromobjects wroteNo word on an M version?Some of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.
The RF coupler on a regular lens is just a curve on the mount end, since the entire lens block all moves together on a single helicoid. But a rangefinder coupled FLE design requires (at least) two separate helicoids, one for the FLE and one for the rangefinder, synced and calibrated together to work perfectly in tandem. It certainly isn't impossible, but it is definitely harder to do and definitely increases the cost of the mechanical part of the lens. And almost certainly why Cosina Voiigtlander has historically avoided FLE designs in their M-mount lenses.
All of those modern lenses are also extremely expensive compared to Cosina’s lenses. That is not just due to the brand commanding a higher price.
The mechanical construction of APO Summicron 75/2, for example, is delicate and more complex. Hence more expensive.
From the APO 75/2 brochure- about the floating elements:
“While the fundamental technology is common in SLR lenses, to achieve this in a compact M lens with its very limited space, the Leica designers had to develop a brand new, extremely precise adjusting mechanism.”
freaklikeme wrote: realVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteimagesfromobjects wroteNo word on an M version?Some of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.
MAubrey wrote:
The RF coupler on a regular lens is just a curve on the mount end, since the entire lens block all moves together on a single helicoid. But a rangefinder coupled FLE design requires (at least) two separate helicoids, one for the FLE and one for the rangefinder, synced and calibrated together to work perfectly in tandem. It certainly isn't impossible, but it is definitely harder to do and definitely increases the cost of the mechanical part of the lens. And almost certainly why Cosina Voiigtlander has historically avoided FLE designs in their M-mount lenses.
For instance, the LEICA 50mm f/1.4 ASPH SUMMILUX-M has FLE, and it has 2 helicoids. A lens on the expensive side. This is why, if using the Techart's TAP for AF in the Sony, it's better to manually focus to the ballpark and then use EyeAF to finish the fine adjustment.
MAubrey wrote: freaklikeme wroterealVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteimagesfromobjects wroteNo word on an M version?Some of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.The RF coupler on a regular lens is just a curve on the mount end, since the entire lens block all moves together on a single helicoid. But a rangefinder coupled FLE design requires (at least) two separate helicoids, one for the FLE and one for the rangefinder, synced and calibrated together to work perfectly in tandem. It certainly isn't impossible, but it is definitely harder to do and definitely increases the cost of the mechanical part of the lens. And almost certainly why Cosina Voiigtlander has historically avoided FLE designs in their M-mount lenses.
---------------------------------------------
realVivek wrote:
All of those modern lenses are also extremely expensive compared to Cosina’s lenses. That is not just due to the brand commanding a higher price.
The mechanical construction of APO Summicron 75/2, for example, is delicate and more complex. Hence more expensive.
From the APO 75/2 brochure- about the floating elements:
“While the fundamental technology is common in SLR lenses, to achieve this in a compact M lens with its very limited space, the Leica designers had to develop a brand new, extremely precise adjusting mechanism.”
freaklikeme wroterealVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteimagesfromobjects wroteNo word on an M version?Some of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.
I have the utmost respect for Leica's mechanical engineers, even if the marketing language makes them sound like they're elves working their magic on the lenses, and not people working with computers to calculate thread size. I agree it does add cost, but, assuming this is the APO-Summicron-like product they intended to make, then additional cost might not be the primary concern. Leica's giving them plenty of room to be the "cheap" alternative. And, I agree, in the past, Cosina has avoided FLEs, so much so that Zeiss had the ZM Sonnar 85 manufactured in Germany to accommodate the special need, but that changed with the ZM Distagon 35. Cosina took that on, so maybe, just maybe, they'd be willing to do it for a special lens of their own.
Also, their CEO shoots a film M-mount. They might want to please him.
Also, the distance encoder in the upcoming 50/2 APO has to report the distance accurately. The physical movement while focusing the lens has to be translated to electrical signals accurately.
freaklikeme wrote: MAubrey wrotefreaklikeme wroterealVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteSome of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.The RF coupler on a regular lens is just a curve on the mount end, since the entire lens block all moves together on a single helicoid. But a rangefinder coupled FLE design requires (at least) two separate helicoids, one for the FLE and one for the rangefinder, synced and calibrated together to work perfectly in tandem. It certainly isn't impossible, but it is definitely harder to do and definitely increases the cost of the mechanical part of the lens. And almost certainly why Cosina Voiigtlander has historically avoided FLE designs in their M-mount lenses.---------------------------------------------
realVivek wroteAll of those modern lenses are also extremely expensive compared to Cosina’s lenses. That is not just due to the brand commanding a higher price.
The mechanical construction of APO Summicron 75/2, for example, is delicate and more complex. Hence more expensive.
From the APO 75/2 brochure- about the floating elements:
“While the fundamental technology is common in SLR lenses, to achieve this in a compact M lens with its very limited space, the Leica designers had to develop a brand new, extremely precise adjusting mechanism.”
freaklikeme wroterealVivek wroteWithout the lens block diagram, it can already be admitted that this lens be very complex to be made in Leica M mount with range finder coupling because of the floating elements design.
freaklikeme wroteDavidBM wroteSome of the material said it is developed exclusively for E mount.
and there have been no M versions of any APO Lanthars. Although they are at focal lengths for which there are no frame lines on M.
Maybe they think that the extra resolution of the series only matters much on higher resolution bodies Li,e the A7r series? Odd if true. But it is true that the CV lenses developed initially for M tend to prioritise haptics and character over resolution contrast and colour correction.It's also possible that the design won't allow for M-mount. We'll know more about the possibilities when we see the block diagram.I'm not sure I follow. What about the RF makes using an FLE more difficult? Nearly all of Leica's modern lenses have them.I have the utmost respect for Leica's mechanical engineers, even if the marketing language makes them sound like they're elves working their magic on the lenses, and not people working with computers to calculate thread size. I agree it does add cost, but, assuming this is the APO-Summicron-like product they intended to make, then additional cost might not be the primary concern. Leica's giving them plenty of room to be the "cheap" alternative. And, I agree, in the past, Cosina has avoided FLEs, so much so that Zeiss had the ZM Sonnar 85 manufactured in Germany to accommodate the special need, but that changed with the ZM Distagon 35. Cosina took that on, so maybe, just maybe, they'd be willing to do it for a special lens of their own.
Also, their CEO shoots a film M-mount. They might want to please him....Show more →
I don't think there's any maybe here: they say the 2/50 Apo Lanthar has a floating mechanism (like the 65 and 110 macros do)
Unless perhaps you mean they might might be willing to do an M version with a rangefinder helicoid meshing with the focussing helicoid? But they have said the 2/50 is exclusive for E mount.
I first saw the announcement on SAR, that's why I doubted it 😂. I found it weird that the announcement was not posted by Cosina Voigtlander, but Fred said he received the news from Stephen Gandy, so it isn't fake news 😃.
Pixel Perfect wrote: ysultan wroteHopefully it’s not fake news 😭Was it SR5 on Sony Rumors?