fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)

  
 
chez
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
mudlake wrote:
chez wrote
mudlake wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
mudlake wroteSome may disagree (and I can respect that) but I think I already got my 35/2 GM in the Sony 24/1.4GM in crop mode on the R73. Yes, it’s only 18.5 megapixels, but 99.9999% of the time that’s plenty of resolution for my needs, even if I have to crop some. So for me, when Sony invented the 24GM, they threw in a 35/2 GM for free. Of course, others may have different needs.
Yes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.
All good points and I agree. But my primary point was that 99.999% of the time for me, that stuff won't matter in the least. One stop dynamic range and ISO capability may matter for someone taking scientific images or those getting paid a lot of money to deliver perfect images to a client, but I think you'll agree that those criteria apply to less than 1% of the people on this forum. For me, I'll be perfectly happy to have a dual lens in the 24 GM and not worry about the infinitesimal loss of a little ISO or dynamic range when taking vacation photos or images of my family, etc. For landscapes images, then yes, I'll never use the crop function. It's just a great solution for travel or family.
I’d be more concerned with the loss of pixels. There are many occasions when using the right lens I still need to crop to remove unwanted items from the image. Starting at 18mpix, this would be a challenge.

Personally i’d rather use the right lens for the situation rather than relying on crop mode.
Yes, I think since you make more large prints than I do, you would need to use all the pixels on the camera. I don't make a lot of large prints (and many people never print -which is a shame) and the images I do print large are landscapes where I'm on a tripod and crop mode would never be used. Eighteen megapixels is plenty to print the occasional 8x12 or 20x30.

By the way, Chez, would you rather have a 35/1.8 or the Batis 40/2? I know you were looking at it a while back.


Awaiting to see what the 35 1.8 delivers. I love Batis colours and contrast.
Jun 30, 2019 at 07:52 PM
WestTexas Sky
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)


DaveFP wrote:
WestTexas Sky wroteThere are a lot of 35mm options
Sony 35/2.8
Samyang 35/2.8
Sony 35/1.4
Samyang 35/1.4
Loxia 35/2
Sony 24-70/4
Sony 24-70/2.8
Sony 28-70 kit
Sony 24-105
Tamron 28-70/2.8
Sony 28/2 cropped slightly
Sony 24/1.8? In APS-C crop mode

I am sure there are more. I just find it humorous with all those choices to use at 35mm there is a lot of complaining here. So I don't think a 35/1.8 will stop the complaining. It will just shift slightly😀

Of course I hope it is the mythic lens everyone else wants but I just don't think it will satisfy the crowd here.

WestTexas Sky wroteIf this turns out to be a real lens, you know the complaining will start it's "too big" and should have been an f/2 or f/1.9 or something.

You know no one here will ever be happy with the the 35mm focal length despite all the options out there. 😀
wittyphrase wroteWhat are “all the options” for 1.8 max aperture 35mm native FE mount lens? There are 35mm options, but not at 1.8 and the appropriate price point people are hoping for.
I have five of the lenses on your list. None of them is the "Goldilocks" 35 we all want.


That's my whole point. There will never be a lens that meets the "just right" that people seem to want here for a 35mm. It's probably the most covered focal length yet most seem unhappy. I don't think they will ever be pleased. 😀
Jul 01, 2019 at 06:29 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #3Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
No we will never be pleased. We all want a 1.4 the size and weight of the 2.8 and at a low cost. NEVER will happen, so this debate the cows will come home and retire first.

I kinda given up on 35mm focal length. with the 40,45,50 out there they just seem to gap better for me. I have a 24 and 85 on either side. Right now the 45 is nice
Jul 01, 2019 at 06:40 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #4Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
mudlake wroteSome may disagree (and I can respect that) but I think I already got my 35/2 GM in the Sony 24/1.4GM in crop mode on the R73. Yes, it’s only 18.5 megapixels, but 99.9999% of the time that’s plenty of resolution for my needs, even if I have to crop some. So for me, when Sony invented the 24GM, they threw in a 35/2 GM for free. Of course, others may have different needs.
Yes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.


Obviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally
Jul 01, 2019 at 06:45 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #5Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
GMPhotography wrote:
No we will never be pleased. We all want a 1.4 the size and weight of the 2.8 and at a low cost. NEVER will happen, so this debate the cows will come home and retire first.

I kinda given up on 35mm focal length. with the 40,45,50 out there they just seem to gap better for me. I have a 24 and 85 on either side. Right now the 45 is nice


We need those rumored Zeiss Alon lenses to be announced
Jul 01, 2019 at 06:46 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
mudlake wroteSome may disagree (and I can respect that) but I think I already got my 35/2 GM in the Sony 24/1.4GM in crop mode on the R73. Yes, it’s only 18.5 megapixels, but 99.9999% of the time that’s plenty of resolution for my needs, even if I have to crop some. So for me, when Sony invented the 24GM, they threw in a 35/2 GM for free. Of course, others may have different needs.
Yes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.
Obviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally


Like I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that matters for their shooting. It does for mine and it will continue to do so even with the next higher MP sensors, but YMMV and it seems it likely does.
Jul 01, 2019 at 06:56 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
mudlake wroteSome may disagree (and I can respect that) but I think I already got my 35/2 GM in the Sony 24/1.4GM in crop mode on the R73. Yes, it’s only 18.5 megapixels, but 99.9999% of the time that’s plenty of resolution for my needs, even if I have to crop some. So for me, when Sony invented the 24GM, they threw in a 35/2 GM for free. Of course, others may have different needs.
Yes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.
Obviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally
Like I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that
...Show more →

I remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
Jul 01, 2019 at 07:12 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
mudlake wroteSome may disagree (and I can respect that) but I think I already got my 35/2 GM in the Sony 24/1.4GM in crop mode on the R73. Yes, it’s only 18.5 megapixels, but 99.9999% of the time that’s plenty of resolution for my needs, even if I have to crop some. So for me, when Sony invented the 24GM, they threw in a 35/2 GM for free. Of course, others may have different needs.
Yes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.
Obviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally
Like I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that matters for their shooting. It does for mine and it will continue to do so even with the next higher MP sensors, but YMMV and it seems it likely does.
I remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.


We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor sites (going to 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability. The A7r to the A7r II saw the introduction of a new technology the Aptina-DRX that allowed each pixel to function differently at base ISO and at higher ISOs. That change is what gave us the gain in high ISO performance in that development of sensors. Note that there was little increase in DR at base ISO from the A7r to A7r II. There doesn't appear to be anything on the horizon like the Aptina-DRX so I certainly do not expect much of an increase in high ISO performance in the new higher resolution sensors, but then one never knows for sure how a new sensor will perform.

Edited on Jul 01, 2019 at 07:24 AM · View previous versions
Jul 01, 2019 at 07:16 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #9Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
mudlake wroteSome may disagree (and I can respect that) but I think I already got my 35/2 GM in the Sony 24/1.4GM in crop mode on the R73. Yes, it’s only 18.5 megapixels, but 99.9999% of the time that’s plenty of resolution for my needs, even if I have to crop some. So for me, when Sony invented the 24GM, they threw in a 35/2 GM for free. Of course, others may have different needs.
Yes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.
Obviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally
Like I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that matters for their shooting. It does for mine and it will continue to do so even with the next higher MP sensors, but YMMV and it seems it likely does.
I remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.


Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.
Jul 01, 2019 at 07:21 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wroteYes, you get 18.5 megapixels, but you also get a stop less dynamic range at base ISO and importantly you lose a bit over a stop of high ISO capability when the light is low. So, you have a 37mm f/2.2 lens when you crop the 24 GM, and a little over a half stop less light than a 35 f/1.8, so if the 35 f/1.8 is pretty good wide open it should have a distinct advantage not only in resolution but in the ability to shoot in low light.
Obviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally
Like I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that matters for their shooting. It does for mine and it will continue to do so even with the next higher MP sensors, but YMMV and it seems it likely does.
I remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.
Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.


See my detailed comments above (I edited my original post), and it does matter to me as for exactly the type of shooting I want to use this lens for I could really use better high ISO capability. Shooting family stuff indoors (e.g., a birthday party with a cake illuminated with candles) I would really like better high ISO. That is why the better high ISO capability really matters to me and part of the reason I would definitely prefer a 35 f/1.8 to a cropped 24 f/1.4. YMMV, and probably does.
Jul 01, 2019 at 07:27 AM
nhsonyshooter
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wroteObviously we will see. But I'm not so sure it will have a "distinct" advantage in IQ since it appears it may not even be a G lens let alone GM. The 24GM will only get better for me with the next higher MP sensors. As others have mentioned 36mm at 18mp is actually pretty darn good already. I'm plenty happy to give up a half stop for the benefit of having 2 lenses in one personally
Like I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that matters for their shooting. It does for mine and it will continue to do so even with the next higher MP sensors, but YMMV and it seems it likely does.
I remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.
Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.
See my detailed comments above (I edited my original post), and it does matter to me as for exactly the type of shooting I want to use this lens for I could really use better high ISO capability. Shooting family stuff indoors (e.g., a birthday party with a cake illuminated with candles) I would really like better high ISO. That is why the better high ISO capability really matters to me and part of the reason I would definitely prefer a 35 f/1.8 to a cropped 24 f/1.4. YMMV, and probably does.


Just out of curiosity, how much difference do you "really" think there is going to be between this 35 f1.8 and say Batis 40mm? Obviously besides the focal length
Jul 01, 2019 at 07:33 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nhsonyshooter wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wroteLike I said above for me the issue is not resolution, it is the loss in dynamic range and particularly the loss in high ISO capability. That won't get better with the next higher MP sensors. We will of course see about the optical performance, but I would hope that this Sony 35 f/1.8 would at least compete with the Nikon 35 f/1.8S and the Canon RF 35 f/1.8 both of which are very nice lenses even though they are modestly priced. People will of course differ on whether that half stop loss in low light is something that matters for their shooting. It does for mine and it will continue to do so even with the next higher MP sensors, but YMMV and it seems it likely does.
I remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.
Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.
See my detailed comments above (I edited my original post), and it does matter to me as for exactly the type of shooting I want to use this lens for I could really use better high ISO capability. Shooting family stuff indoors (e.g., a birthday party with a cake illuminated with candles) I would really like better high ISO. That is why the better high ISO capability really matters to me and part of the reason I would definitely prefer a 35 f/1.8 to a cropped 24 f/1.4. YMMV, and probably does.
Just out of curiosity, how much difference do you "really" think there is going to be between this 35 f1.8 and say Batis 40mm? Obviously besides the focal length


A really good question. I expect the Batis to be better up close as that is a primary consideration in the design of that lens. The Batis will probably have a bit better contrast too, but the 35 f/1.8 will have that extra third of a stop wider aperture and will almost certainly be smaller if not lighter. I see the situation to be a bit like the FE 85 f/1.8 vs. Batis 85 f/1.8. I think on balance the Batis is a bit better lens, but it is bigger physically and costs a lot more than the FE 85 f/1.8. I expect a similar but not exactly the same situation between the FE 35 f/1.8 and the Batis 40 f/2. I do have pretty strong hopes that the FE 35 f/1.8 will be of similar quality to the FE 85 f/1.8 because mirrorless makes it easier to design a good 35 as Nikon and Canon have shown with their recent mirrorless 35s.
Jul 01, 2019 at 08:01 AM
hotel117
Offline
Details
p.7 #13Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
And ideally have AF/MF switches. I think the close focusing capabilities will be limited, but hopefully better than the 35 2.8. If the price/performance ratio is similar to the 85 1.8 I'd be happy. I'm holding off on getting a Batis 40 for that reason.
Jul 01, 2019 at 08:28 AM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
chez wrote:
Dave Sanders wroteYes, I don't understand why people are critical of this desire. I don't want a zoom. I don't want an off-brand lens. I don't want a large f/1.4 lens. I don't want a heavy lens. I don't want an f/2.8 lens. I don't want a manual focus lens, I already have those. I don't want a 40mm and I certainly don't want it at $1200. I want a 35//1.8 or 35/2, something I've been able to buy, affordably, in every single camera system I've used for 30 years, manual focus, autofocus, rangefinder, SLR or otherwise. It is also something that was delivered by every rival in every format within their first releases.
Have you tried the 35 2.8? I know it's not an f2, but it sure is light and delivers great image quality. I too would like a light 35 1.8...but the 35 2.8 has been a fabulous substitute for me...and I doubt I'd ever sell it as there is nothing out there that delivers the size, weight, AF and image quality in one package.


Ha, I have indeed tried the 35/2.8...3 times. I sold copy #3 about 6 months ago...with the expectation that copy #4 is a possibility in the future. It has, IMO, underrated image quality, sharp edge to edge from, essentially, f/2.8. It's very small and renders quite well. But, and this is the big but, I really miss the extra stop. I didn't think I would so I bought one with my original A7, a camera I financed by selling my RX1. I mean, there's a lot at work in the comparison of the two, but I realized that 35mm is one focal length where I really use the speed for subject isolation and I missed it. When I bought the Sigma 35A for my Nikon my Sony 35 almost never came out of the bag...despite the fact that the D810/35A combo was a monster. Sold. Then had a trip to visit the in-laws in Mexico and planned a photo stop for a week in Mexico City...rebought. Used it as my only lens, really enjoyed it, though still felt something was missing. Sold...then rebought...then sold to pick up a 24GM...which I also sold as the whole 'crop 24' didn't work for me. Argh.

So, yes, I have tried the 35/2.8, have alternately loved it and been frustrated by it...missing a stop that I actually use...I also find the 0.35m MFD too distant. But...it may join my kit once again now that I've sold all my Nikon stuff and I'm not splitting my time and dollars on two separate kits. It's a very useful tool and one that I'll appreciate more if it's not my only option in the range.
Jul 01, 2019 at 11:09 AM
SpecFoto
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wroteI remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.
Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.
See my detailed comments above (I edited my original post), and it does matter to me as for exactly the type of shooting I want to use this lens for I could really use better high ISO capability. Shooting family stuff indoors (e.g., a birthday party with a cake illuminated with candles) I would really like better high ISO. That is why the better high ISO capability really matters to me and part of the reason I would definitely prefer a 35 f/1.8 to a cropped 24 f/1.4. YMMV, and probably does.
Just out of curiosity, how much difference do you "really" think there is going to be between this 35 f1.8 and say Batis 40mm? Obviously besides the focal length
A really good question. I expect the Batis to be better up close as that is a primary consideration in the design of that lens. The Batis will probably have a bit better contrast too, but the 35 f/1.8 will have that extra third of a stop wider aperture and will almost certainly be smaller if not lighter. I see the situation to be a bit like the FE 85 f/1.8 vs. Batis 85 f/1.8. I think on balance the Batis is a bit better lens, but it is bigger physically and costs a lot more than the FE
...Show more →

I agree with you Steve. And that is why I returned my new Batis 40mm today, 8 days before the 30 day return period was up. I hope the new 35mm f1.8 has the IQ that my ZA55 f1.8 and FE85mm f1.8 lenses have and I will be very happy, plus most likely pocket $$$. The Batis 40 was very nice, no issues with it at all, but after trying the 40mm for a few weeks in an effort to replace my ZA35 f2.8 and 55, I decided that I want the 35 and 55mm option instead.

Jul 01, 2019 at 06:52 PM
Parariss
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
I just hope it's more like the 55/1.8 than the 50/1.8.

In other news, Sigma is rumored (SR5) to announce a 35/1.2. It won't be small, but hopefully it will compete nicely with the Sony 35/1.4.

Jul 01, 2019 at 08:03 PM
tuomkok
Offline
Details
p.7 #17Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wroteI remember people saying the same things about the 36mp R. And interestingly Sony gave us more MP and better performance. We will see though. Either way the performance of these sensors is so good now the splitting hair thing is getting silly. I'd still rather carry 1 lens vs 2.
We pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.
Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.
See my detailed comments above (I edited my original post), and it does matter to me as for exactly the type of shooting I want to use this lens for I could really use better high ISO capability. Shooting family stuff indoors (e.g., a birthday party with a cake illuminated with candles) I would really like better high ISO. That is why the better high ISO capability really matters to me and part of the reason I would definitely prefer a 35 f/1.8 to a cropped 24 f/1.4. YMMV, and probably does.
Just out of curiosity, how much difference do you "really" think there is going to be between this 35 f1.8 and say Batis 40mm? Obviously besides the focal length
A really good question. I expect the Batis to be better up close as that is a primary consideration in the design of that lens. The Batis will probably have a bit better contrast too, but the 35 f/1.8 will have that extra third of a stop wider aperture and will almost certainly be smaller if not lighter. I see the situation to be a bit like the FE 85 f/1.8 vs. Batis 85 f/1.8. I think on balance the Batis is a bit better lens, but it is bigger physically and costs a lot more than the FE
...Show more →

An educated guess: FE 35mm/1.8 will have different kind of rendering than Batis 40mm. FE 85mm/1.8 is sharp and technically good but Zeiss has always more character. Probably FE will also be smaller.
Jul 02, 2019 at 11:45 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.7 #18Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
tuomkok wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nhsonyshooter wrote
Steve Spencer wroteWe pretty much know how the next round of higher MP sensors from Sony will perform. It is likely to be based on 3.72 micron sensor (going 60 MP in FF 35mm) that we see in the 26 MP APS-C sensor from Sony and the 100 MP 44 X 33 sensor that Sony makes that recently came out in the Fuji GFX 100. We will get more resolution with this sensor and it should be a great sensor, but we shouldn't expect much improvement in high ISO capability. Increasing resolution typically does not lead to higher ISO capability.
Like I said. I remember hearing the same thing before In the end It doesn't matter, the high ISO capability is already great.
See my detailed comments above (I edited my original post), and it does matter to me as for exactly the type of shooting I want to use this lens for I could really use better high ISO capability. Shooting family stuff indoors (e.g., a birthday party with a cake illuminated with candles) I would really like better high ISO. That is why the better high ISO capability really matters to me and part of the reason I would definitely prefer a 35 f/1.8 to a cropped 24 f/1.4. YMMV, and probably does.
Just out of curiosity, how much difference do you "really" think there is going to be between this 35 f1.8 and say Batis 40mm? Obviously besides the focal length
A really good question. I expect the Batis to be better up close as that is a primary consideration in the design of that lens. The Batis will probably have a bit better contrast too, but the 35 f/1.8 will have that extra third of a stop wider aperture and will almost certainly be smaller if not lighter. I see the situation to be a bit like the FE 85 f/1.8 vs. Batis 85 f/1.8. I think on balance the Batis is a bit better lens, but it is bigger physically and costs a lot more than the FE 85 f/1.8. I expect a similar but not exactly the same situation between the FE 35 f/1.8 and the Batis 40 f/2. I do have pretty strong hopes that the FE 35 f/1.8 will be of similar quality to the FE 85 f/1.8 because mirrorless makes it easier to design a good 35 as Nikon and Canon have shown with their recent mirrorless 35s.
An educated guess: FE 35mm/1.8 will have different kind of rendering than Batis 40mm. FE 85mm/1.8 is sharp and technically good but Zeiss has always more character. Probably FE will also be smaller.


I hope the new 35/1.8 won't have the Batis 40/2's rendering harshness when shooting at mid-distance.
Jul 02, 2019 at 11:54 AM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.7 #19Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
I hope the new 35/1.8 won't have the Batis 40/2's rendering harshness when shooting at mid-distance.


The 40's rendering is probably inimitable

Now in all seriousness, I doubt that bokeh would be a priority for a 35mm f/1.8 design. Most likely it will be a "great for infinity shots at f/8" affair. Which is fine with me at this focal length.

For bokeh I think we have to wait for the Sigma 35/1.2.
Jul 02, 2019 at 01:27 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Your all going to laugh but until all this shakes out. I’m returning my Rokinon 45 when I get to Adorama and one of my Profoto A1x units and grab a B10 unit more power but in the meantime I said screw it grabbed the Sigma 35 1.4 Sony mount for like 649 on sale. I need a 3 shooter kit next week so why not the Sigma . At that price it’s worth trying again. Than will see what everyone’s got but until than to me it’s the same old bullshit. Hurry up and wait than get disappointed again. I’ll play with my lights for awhile and sit this whole thing out. Seriously it’s Horton really boring waiting for someone to actually make a high quality 35.

Btw this is still a rumor so are the Sigma announcement. I make no money off rumors

Edited on Jul 02, 2019 at 01:50 PM · View previous versions
Jul 02, 2019 at 01:47 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister