p.3 #1The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Good thing I got some wins #66-70... though I guess it raises the question of validity...
Jman13 wrote: retrofocus wroteJman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.I mean, in competition #69 we had six total entries. Six.
Other recent competitions around then typically had around 10 or 11 entries at most. It was slowly dying, and only a handful of people ever contributed each month. Of those that did at the time, only 4-5 would qualify under 'alt' removing the major mirrorless systems.
I mean, I don't run the competition any more, so it's not my call, but I always loved this informal competition because it brought out such amazing photographers....no limits on subject or themes, just what as a community have you shot lately that's great, and the change to formalize all mirrorless gear has really brought in phenomenal art.
Going back and looking at the discussion from when I changed the competition to the "Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition", you were one of the dissenting voices then as well, which I understand. However, we finished the discussion about the impending change with this following exchange:
I said:
And you replied:
I will say that if the rules were to change to allow all adapted lenses, but not native mount lenses, we'd be in a bizarre situation where a Sony body with a Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (EF mount) with MC-11 would be allowed, but the Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (E-Mount) would not, despite them being literally the exact same lens. ...Show more →Earlier quoteThe rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.Earlier quoteOkay - this is clearly a change in paradigm which I did not perceive as such. I simply saw the Sony camera - Sony lens allowance rooted in the history of the Alt forum when Sony was still (small) part of it and not separate. I am not against to have brands in separate forums but IMO Sony is now exactly like Canon or Nikon in size and usage and should be treated as such which would no longer be Alt. We can stick to the historical way and keep allowing Sony+Sony as it always was but then I agree, it should be renamed as you suggested. The other Alt gear will only be a small part of the competition if any I am afraid. Consequently, it should also be cross-posted into the Fuji and micro 4/3rd boards, too.
p.3 #3The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
So was never my intent to start this discussion but some good points raised. I don’t think it’s a question we will escape though, as others have pointed out, in a few years it’s just as like DSLR use is far more Alt.
I’ll suggest one other form I think could be interesting... no native mount lens, any camera body. So if you adapt Contax N to EF you’re in. If you get anything to adapt to Nikon F you (should win automatically) but can enter at any rate. Might actually increase number of entries while keeping the Alt spirit. There are a couple cases like your EF/MC-11 example but I’ll argue they’ll be minimal. Just have to enter another shot.
Regardless, it’s still my favorite competition on FM, I’m honored to have won a few (regardless of field size) and I’ll keep playing by whatever rules are set.
p.3 #4The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Honestly, if we changed it it would be (imo) more fun to simply have it be for people using the alt board, generally. I don't think making it more restrictive is a good idea, especially since it's populated to a good extent by people like me who infrequently enter. Not that it matters much, DSLRs are still predominant even if mirrorless usage has surged.
p.3 #8The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
johnahill wrote:
Native does not necessarily mean non-alt. Back in the day and still now Zeiss ZE and ZF were native but Alt.
Yes, the current rules are anything but Canon EF mount camera with Canon EF mount lens or Nikon F mount camera with Nikon F mount lens are alt. So as always anything shot with a Zeiss, Voigtlander, Sigma, Tamron, Tokina, etc. are all Alt even if they are native mount. Likewise anything from Leica, Fuji, Panasonic, Olympus, Pentax, etc. is automatically Alt. Finally, anything that uses an adapted lens is automatically alt as well. These are the three streams of the Alt board that have always been considered Alt.
p.3 #9The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
RoamingScott wrote:
I just don't see how a modern mirrorless is any "less" so to speak than the DSLR counterpart. An EOS R/RF lens, or Z body/Z lens is just as capable as their DSLR cousins. Mirrorless is the mainstream going forward, not the fringe.
Frankly, I'd be more interested in just a "Your best shot of the month" competition open to all brand/lens combos, which would greatly increase the turnout each month if it were crossposted to the Sony/Canon/Nikon/Alt boards.
If you kept it the way you suggest, it would have lots of entries, if that is what the discussion is about, the drop in entries.
Maybe a "Your best shot of the month" competition open to all brand/lens combos, which would greatly increase the turnout each month if it were crossposted to the Sony/Canon/Nikon/Alt boards".should be created, I agree I bet the turnout would definitely increase the amount of images entered.