p.2 #1The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Not loving much from May but I'll participate anyway.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Camera body: A&R2
Lens: Samyang 85mm f/1.4
Aperture: f/1.4
Filters: n/a
Short note on PP: B&W Conversion in ACR, Slight Crop
Top vote (3p) + reason: RoamingScott - Just a cool shot of a cool bird.
Runner-up vote (2p): TNCasual - Cool shot and setup.
Last vote (1p): retrofocus - Always points for actual B&W film, plus great toning and geometry.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
p.2 #2The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Thank you for your votes last month, and congrats to FplStudio and Birdied.
Camera body: Sony A7RIII
Lens: FE 100-400GM 1.4TC
Aperture: f/8
Filters: None
Short note on PP: LR and PS
Top vote (3p) + reason: Birdied, excellent color and details of hummingbird and flowers. It's not easy to capture hummingbird in flight.
Runner-up vote (2p): BobbyTan, clear and good color rendering image of GG bridge.
Last vote (1p): TNCasual, inventive and excellent contrast.
I thought I would like to try out close up photography. Here is my submission:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Camera body: Sony A7 III
Lens: Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8
Aperture: f/14
Filters: Circular Polarizer
Short note on PP: Minor Color and contrast adjustments
Top vote (3p) + reason: fplstudio - simply stunning...wonderful color and calmness
Runner-up vote (2p): bobbytan
Last vote (1p): johnahill
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
p.2 #4The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
A question about rules I'd like to verify. It used to say Nikon lens on Nikon body, or Canon lens on Canon body weren't permitted. Now it stipulates DSLR. So to make sure I'm in line, is Nikon or Canon lens on Z or R body acceptable? Native Z/R mounts? What about F or EF on Z or R?
Specific example, my likely entry for June would be a Non AI 35/2 on a Z6. Permitted?
p.2 #5The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Mathieu18 wrote:
A question about rules I'd like to verify. It used to say Nikon lens on Nikon body, or Canon lens on Canon body weren't permitted. Now it stipulates DSLR. So to make sure I'm in line, is Nikon or Canon lens on Z or R body acceptable? Native Z/R mounts? What about F or EF on Z or R?
Specific example, my likely entry for June would be a Non AI 35/2 on a Z6. Permitted?
Hi Mathieu,
I didn't write the rules (copy/pasted below) but, as written, the 35/2 on a Z6 is definitely Alt as the Z6 is mirrorless, regardless of brand :
Canon DSLR using Canon EF mount lens is NOT alt.
Nikon DSLR using Nikon F mount lens is NOT alt.
Anything else IS alt, including all mirrorless systems.
Cheers
Kevin
Jul 01, 2019 at 12:41 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #6The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Frogfish wrote: Mathieu18 wroteA question about rules I'd like to verify. It used to say Nikon lens on Nikon body, or Canon lens on Canon body weren't permitted. Now it stipulates DSLR. So to make sure I'm in line, is Nikon or Canon lens on Z or R body acceptable? Native Z/R mounts? What about F or EF on Z or R?
Specific example, my likely entry for June would be a Non AI 35/2 on a Z6. Permitted?Hi Mathieu,
I didn't write the rules (copy/pasted below) but, as written, the 35/2 on a Z6 is definitely Alt as the Z6 is mirrorless, regardless of brand :
Canon DSLR using Canon EF mount lens is NOT alt.
Nikon DSLR using Nikon F mount lens is NOT alt.
Anything else IS alt, including all mirrorless systems.
Cheers
Kevin
I'm not here to be a party pooper, but Sony A7/A9 bodies with native Sony lenses is very far away from alt these days
p.2 #7The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
RoamingScott wrote: Frogfish wroteMathieu18 wroteA question about rules I'd like to verify. It used to say Nikon lens on Nikon body, or Canon lens on Canon body weren't permitted. Now it stipulates DSLR. So to make sure I'm in line, is Nikon or Canon lens on Z or R body acceptable? Native Z/R mounts? What about F or EF on Z or R?
Specific example, my likely entry for June would be a Non AI 35/2 on a Z6. Permitted?Hi Mathieu,
I didn't write the rules (copy/pasted below) but, as written, the 35/2 on a Z6 is definitely Alt as the Z6 is mirrorless, regardless of brand :
Canon DSLR using Canon EF mount lens is NOT alt.
Nikon DSLR using Nikon F mount lens is NOT alt.
Anything else IS alt, including all mirrorless systems.
Cheers
KevinI'm not here to be a party pooper, but Sony A7/A9 bodies with native Sony lenses is very far away from alt these days
I wonder if we might alter the rules at this point and say any shot from Canon, Nikon, or Sony with the same brand lens designed for that camera would be excluded. So a Sony E mount camera with a Sony A mount would still be alt, but a Sony E mount camera with a Sony E mount lens would not be. Similarly a Canon DSLR with EF mount would be excluded as would a Canon R camera with an RF mount lens, but not a Canon R camera with an EF lens. Same for Nikon as well. To me that would be more in keeping with the spirit of alt, but I don't really care all that much and would be very happy to bow to other's wishes.
Jul 01, 2019 at 09:30 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #8The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Steve Spencer wrote: RoamingScott wroteFrogfish wroteMathieu18 wroteA question about rules I'd like to verify. It used to say Nikon lens on Nikon body, or Canon lens on Canon body weren't permitted. Now it stipulates DSLR. So to make sure I'm in line, is Nikon or Canon lens on Z or R body acceptable? Native Z/R mounts? What about F or EF on Z or R?
Specific example, my likely entry for June would be a Non AI 35/2 on a Z6. Permitted?Hi Mathieu,
I didn't write the rules (copy/pasted below) but, as written, the 35/2 on a Z6 is definitely Alt as the Z6 is mirrorless, regardless of brand :
Canon DSLR using Canon EF mount lens is NOT alt.
Nikon DSLR using Nikon F mount lens is NOT alt.
Anything else IS alt, including all mirrorless systems.
Cheers
KevinI'm not here to be a party pooper, but Sony A7/A9 bodies with native Sony lenses is very far away from alt these days I wonder if we might alter the rules at this point and say any shot from Canon, Nikon, or Sony with the same brand lens designed for that camera would be excluded. So a Sony E mount camera with a Sony A mount would still be alt, but a Sony E mount camera with a Sony E mount lens would not be. Similarly a Canon DSLR with EF mount would be excluded as would a Canon R camera with an RF mount lens, but not a Canon R camera with an EF lens. Same for Nikon as well. To me that would be more in keeping with the spirit of alt, but I don't really care all that much and would be very happy to bow to other's wishes....Show more →
It would certainly eliminate 99% of my entries, but I think it's definitely more in the spirit of the original competition. Guess I'll have to start using my Helios more!
p.2 #9The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
So, a bit of history regarding this competition from one who used to operate it:
Originally, this competition was design for alt lenses...generally older manual focus lenses adapted to the traditional DSLRs.
When Micro 4/3 came around, it was viewed as an alternative system, as were the follow on mirrorless systems.
As things progressed, use of Alt lenses in day to day use declined rather strongly over time, and use of mirrorless systems increased. A large proportion of entries became from mirrorless systems.
However, because this was only posted in the Alt forum at the time, participation in the competition eventually dropped to extremely low rates, and made the competition nearly dead. If we had limited it at that point to only Alt lenses, there wouldn't be a competition any more.
So, about a year ago or so, I decided, with input from some regular contributes, to change the name of the competition to the "Alt and Mirrorless competition" from just the Alt competition. This would clear up any question regarding the rules, and make it more clear that submissions from all mirrorless systems would be welcome.
As a result, participation surged, and since then we've had an infusion of simply amazing photography every month.
I no longer run the competition, but in my opinion, I love what the change to be more inclusive has done.
If we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.
p.2 #10The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Steve Spencer wrote: RoamingScott wroteFrogfish wroteMathieu18 wroteA question about rules I'd like to verify. It used to say Nikon lens on Nikon body, or Canon lens on Canon body weren't permitted. Now it stipulates DSLR. So to make sure I'm in line, is Nikon or Canon lens on Z or R body acceptable? Native Z/R mounts? What about F or EF on Z or R?
Specific example, my likely entry for June would be a Non AI 35/2 on a Z6. Permitted?Hi Mathieu,
I didn't write the rules (copy/pasted below) but, as written, the 35/2 on a Z6 is definitely Alt as the Z6 is mirrorless, regardless of brand :
Canon DSLR using Canon EF mount lens is NOT alt.
Nikon DSLR using Nikon F mount lens is NOT alt.
Anything else IS alt, including all mirrorless systems.
Cheers
KevinI'm not here to be a party pooper, but Sony A7/A9 bodies with native Sony lenses is very far away from alt these days I wonder if we might alter the rules at this point and say any shot from Canon, Nikon, or Sony with the same brand lens designed for that camera would be excluded. So a Sony E mount camera with a Sony A mount would still be alt, but a Sony E mount camera with a Sony E mount lens would not be. Similarly a Canon DSLR with EF mount would be excluded as would a Canon R camera with an RF mount lens, but not a Canon R camera with an EF lens. Same for Nikon as well. To me that would be more in keeping with the spirit of alt, but I don't really care all that much and would be very happy to bow to other's wishes....Show more →
+1. Fully agree. Even I admit that Sony/Sony A-mount and Canon R/Canon EF-mount are borderline cases which are just okay because an adapter needs to be used (otherwise those would clearly better fit into the designated brand forums). Historically Sony only came into this competition when its market penetration was low compared to Canon and Nikon brands. This changed over the course of the last 6 years when Sony became very successful with its MLC systems and is on par with Canon and Nikon now in regard to market penetration. Fuji is another one which might be questionable at some point soon, too - their cameras find more and more attraction and I would less so consider them "Alt" anymore either. But being too restrictive would also lower the participation numbers. This fun competition is dominated by MLC gear - which is okay since it was changed this year to Alt and mirrorless. But I see less real "Alt" image participation than it was before.
p.2 #12The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
retrofocus wrote: Jman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.
I mean, in competition #69 we had six total entries. Six.
Other recent competitions around then typically had around 10 or 11 entries at most. It was slowly dying, and only a handful of people ever contributed each month. Of those that did at the time, only 4-5 would qualify under 'alt' removing the major mirrorless systems.
I mean, I don't run the competition any more, so it's not my call, but I always loved this informal competition because it brought out such amazing photographers....no limits on subject or themes, just what as a community have you shot lately that's great, and the change to formalize all mirrorless gear has really brought in phenomenal art.
Going back and looking at the discussion from when I changed the competition to the "Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition", you were one of the dissenting voices then as well, which I understand. However, we finished the discussion about the impending change with this following exchange:
I said: The rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.
And you replied: Okay - this is clearly a change in paradigm which I did not perceive as such. I simply saw the Sony camera - Sony lens allowance rooted in the history of the Alt forum when Sony was still (small) part of it and not separate. I am not against to have brands in separate forums but IMO Sony is now exactly like Canon or Nikon in size and usage and should be treated as such which would no longer be Alt. We can stick to the historical way and keep allowing Sony+Sony as it always was but then I agree, it should be renamed as you suggested. The other Alt gear will only be a small part of the competition if any I am afraid. Consequently, it should also be cross-posted into the Fuji and micro 4/3rd boards, too. ...Show more →
I will say that if the rules were to change to allow all adapted lenses, but not native mount lenses, we'd be in a bizarre situation where a Sony body with a Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (EF mount) with MC-11 would be allowed, but the Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (E-Mount) would not, despite them being literally the exact same lens.
p.2 #13The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
I just don't see how a modern mirrorless is any "less" so to speak than the DSLR counterpart. An EOS R/RF lens, or Z body/Z lens is just as capable as their DSLR cousins. Mirrorless is the mainstream going forward, not the fringe.
Frankly, I'd be more interested in just a "Your best shot of the month" competition open to all brand/lens combos, which would greatly increase the turnout each month if it were crossposted to the Sony/Canon/Nikon/Alt boards.
p.2 #14The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
retrofocus wrote: Jman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.
Here are the numbers for the last six months:
Competition #84 - 11 alt; 8 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #83 - 14 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #82 - 14 alt; 4 mirrorless with matching lens (first and second were alt; 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #81 - 13 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and tie for 3rd were alt; a tie for 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #80 - 16 alt; 1 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
Competition #79 - 16 alt; 6 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
So the competition is still primary alt, but perhaps is getting to include more mirrorless with a matching lens. Interestingly there are probably at least 12 people who have entered with a mirrorless with a matching lens at least once in the previous six months, but almost all of them sometimes enter an alt as well. Even Scott who thought 99% of his entries would be mirrorless with a matching lens entered 2 out of the last 6 with an alt lens. No question we have several very good contributors who have tended to enter mirrorless with a matching lens birdied (who I have voted for a couple of times and seems to have a strong entry every month), mitesh (who will get my first place vote for #84), Scott's entries have been consistently strong as well, and several others (hpfish, fpl2 --not sure I got those screen names right and I apologize for inevitably leaving a few names off. I would hate to lose those contributions, but I can see a time before long when the exclusion of DSLRs with matching lenses seems a bit of a weird rationale if it isn't weird already. Mirrorless cameras are selling more than DSLRs and before long it seems likely that DSLRs with matching lenses will be more alt than mirrorless with matching lenses.
p.2 #15The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Jman13 wrote: retrofocus wroteJman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.I mean, in competition #69 we had six total entries. Six.
Other recent competitions around then typically had around 10 or 11 entries at most. It was slowly dying, and only a handful of people ever contributed each month. Of those that did at the time, only 4-5 would qualify under 'alt' removing the major mirrorless systems.
I mean, I don't run the competition any more, so it's not my call, but I always loved this informal competition because it brought out such amazing photographers....no limits on subject or themes, just what as a community have you shot lately that's great, and the change to formalize all mirrorless gear has really brought in phenomenal art.
Going back and looking at the discussion from when I changed the competition to the "Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition", you were one of the dissenting voices then as well, which I understand. However, we finished the discussion about the impending change with this following exchange:
I said:
And you replied:
I will say that if the rules were to change to allow all adapted lenses, but not native mount lenses, we'd be in a bizarre situation where a Sony body with a Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (EF mount) with MC-11 would be allowed, but the Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (E-Mount) would not, despite them being literally the exact same lens. ...Show more →Earlier quoteThe rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.Earlier quoteOkay - this is clearly a change in paradigm which I did not perceive as such. I simply saw the Sony camera - Sony lens allowance rooted in the history of the Alt forum when Sony was still (small) part of it and not separate. I am not against to have brands in separate forums but IMO Sony is now exactly like Canon or Nikon in size and usage and should be treated as such which would no longer be Alt. We can stick to the historical way and keep allowing Sony+Sony as it always was but then I agree, it should be renamed as you suggested. The other Alt gear will only be a small part of the competition if any I am afraid. Consequently, it should also be cross-posted into the Fuji and micro 4/3rd boards, too.
Well Sigma on DSLRs were always allowed. So I see no way that Sigma either EF with the MC-11 or E mount would not be allowed.
p.2 #16The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
What makes something alternative rests entirely on one's perspective. When you are coming from the DSLR perspective, everything else is an alternative. In another few years, DSLRs will probably be alternative. In reality all ILC (mirrored or not) are alternative because most photography, by a huge margin, is done with mobile devices these days.
I don't see anything wrong with the way the contest is administered. It would be great if it had more participation, so limiting it further probably isn't the best idea.
All of that being said, I only ever submit images that fit within the initial restraints - old legacy glass on a mft sensor. I use the contest as motivation to experiment and be creative.
p.2 #17The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Jman13 wrote: retrofocus wroteJman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.I mean, in competition #69 we had six total entries. Six.
Other recent competitions around then typically had around 10 or 11 entries at most. It was slowly dying, and only a handful of people ever contributed each month. Of those that did at the time, only 4-5 would qualify under 'alt' removing the major mirrorless systems.
I mean, I don't run the competition any more, so it's not my call, but I always loved this informal competition because it brought out such amazing photographers....no limits on subject or themes, just what as a community have you shot lately that's great, and the change to formalize all mirrorless gear has really brought in phenomenal art.
Going back and looking at the discussion from when I changed the competition to the "Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition", you were one of the dissenting voices then as well, which I understand. However, we finished the discussion about the impending change with this following exchange:
I said:
And you replied:
I will say that if the rules were to change to allow all adapted lenses, but not native mount lenses, we'd be in a bizarre situation where a Sony body with a Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (EF mount) with MC-11 would be allowed, but the Sigma 35mm f/1.4 (E-Mount) would not, despite them being literally the exact same lens. ...Show more →Earlier quoteThe rules will remain the same. Sony+Sony has always been considered alt for the purposes of this competition, and it will continue to do so. If we limit this to only non system lenses, we will literally see fewer than 5 entries per month (this month has 4 entries that would qualify), which while perhaps in the original spirit when the competition was conceived 6 years ago, is kind of pointless. For the last 3-4 years at least, despite the name, this competition has been, defacto, the Alt and Mirrorless Monthly competition, and perhaps we should rename it as such.Earlier quoteOkay - this is clearly a change in paradigm which I did not perceive as such. I simply saw the Sony camera - Sony lens allowance rooted in the history of the Alt forum when Sony was still (small) part of it and not separate. I am not against to have brands in separate forums but IMO Sony is now exactly like Canon or Nikon in size and usage and should be treated as such which would no longer be Alt. We can stick to the historical way and keep allowing Sony+Sony as it always was but then I agree, it should be renamed as you suggested. The other Alt gear will only be a small part of the competition if any I am afraid. Consequently, it should also be cross-posted into the Fuji and micro 4/3rd boards, too.
I personally don't find six entries concerning - but this is my opinion. As you mentioned, I was never too intrigued by the change in the competition for reasons I mentioned today and the same reasons also earlier which you correctly cited. Regarding the rules and your example, yes, this would be the situation. It has become a big "grey zone" now with having extended the posting criteria. But I also admit that I asked a few months ago if there would be interest into a separate film-only based competition similar to the current "Alt and MLC" competition. The interest seemed very low - one reason for it is that this is predominantly a digital (new) gear focused forum place. So I guess it is best to leave this competition as is even I find it only minimally related to "Alt" how it was defined years ago. Just my 2 Cents.
p.2 #18The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Steve Spencer wrote: retrofocus wroteJman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.Here are the numbers for the last six months:
Competition #84 - 11 alt; 8 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #83 - 14 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #82 - 14 alt; 4 mirrorless with matching lens (first and second were alt; 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #81 - 13 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and tie for 3rd were alt; a tie for 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #80 - 16 alt; 1 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
Competition #79 - 16 alt; 6 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
So the competition is still primary alt, but perhaps is getting to include more mirrorless with a matching lens. Interestingly there are probably at least 12 people who have entered with a mirrorless with a matching lens at least once in the previous six months, but almost all of them sometimes enter an alt as well. Even Scott who thought 99% of his entries would be mirrorless with a matching lens entered 2 out of the last 6 with an alt lens. No question we have several very good contributors who have tended to enter mirrorless with a matching lens birdied (who I have voted for a couple of times and seems to have a strong entry every month), mitesh (who will get my first place vote for #84), Scott's entries have been consistently strong as well, and several others (hpfish, fpl2 --not sure I got those screen names right and I apologize for inevitably leaving a few names off. I would hate to lose those contributions, but I can see a time before long when the exclusion of DSLRs with matching lenses seems a bit of a weird rationale if it isn't weird already. Mirrorless cameras are selling more than DSLRs and before long it seems likely that DSLRs with matching lenses will be more alt than mirrorless with matching lenses....Show more →
Very good analysis! It's not a surprise after it was fully opened to MLC without change or further clarification of rules. Good point I didn't even think of in regard to DSLR with matching lenses with rising sales for MLC systems. This is becoming really complicate
p.2 #19The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
I guess it depends on how you're defining Alt. The winner of 82 used a Sony body with a native E mount Voigtländer lens (2nd place was the same, and third place was Sony/Sony). Sure, the first two are not a Sony lens, but it's not exactly "Alt" either given that it's made specifically for Sony cameras.
And if that's alt, is a Panasonic lens on am Olympus body alt, even though they are both m4/3 OEMs?
If we roll back to just being no sony/sony, canon/canon, fuji/fuji (which limits them a lot since there's so few third party makers for Fuji)....I guess I'd be fine on my Sony gear, as I use a lot of Voigtlander glass, adapted EF mount glass and the Tamron 28-75, but it would eliminate macro for me, which is a bummer.
Steve Spencer wrote: retrofocus wroteJman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.Here are the numbers for the last six months:
Competition #84 - 11 alt; 8 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #83 - 14 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #82 - 14 alt; 4 mirrorless with matching lens (first and second were alt; 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #81 - 13 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and tie for 3rd were alt; a tie for 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #80 - 16 alt; 1 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
Competition #79 - 16 alt; 6 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
So the competition is still primary alt, but perhaps is getting to include more mirrorless with a matching lens. Interestingly there are probably at least 12 people who have entered with a mirrorless with a matching lens at least once in the previous six months, but almost all of them sometimes enter an alt as well. Even Scott who thought 99% of his entries would be mirrorless with a matching lens entered 2 out of the last 6 with an alt lens. No question we have several very good contributors who have tended to enter mirrorless with a matching lens birdied (who I have voted for a couple of times and seems to have a strong entry every month), mitesh (who will get my first place vote for #84), Scott's entries have been consistently strong as well, and several others (hpfish, fpl2 --not sure I got those screen names right and I apologize for inevitably leaving a few names off. I would hate to lose those contributions, but I can see a time before long when the exclusion of DSLRs with matching lenses seems a bit of a weird rationale if it isn't weird already. Mirrorless cameras are selling more than DSLRs and before long it seems likely that DSLRs with matching lenses will be more alt than mirrorless with matching lenses....Show more →
p.2 #20The Alt and Mirrorless Monthly Competition #84
Jman13 wrote:
I guess it depends on how you're defining Alt. The winner of 84 used a Sony body with a native E mount Voigtländer lens. Sure, it's not a Sony lens, but it's not exactly "Alt" either given that it's made specifically for Sony cameras.
And if that's alt, is a Panasonic lens on am Olympus body alt, even though they are both m4/3 OEMs?
Steve Spencer wroteretrofocus wroteJman13 wroteIf we go back to limiting to only adapted lenses, you're going to see the competition start to die again, IMO, which would be a shame.I never saw that the monthly contest was close to "dying" even the participation was less than it is now.Here are the numbers for the last six months:
Competition #84 - 11 alt; 8 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #83 - 14 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (no winners yet)
Competition #82 - 14 alt; 4 mirrorless with matching lens (first and second were alt; 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #81 - 13 alt; 5 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and tie for 3rd were alt; a tie for 3rd was mirrorless with a matching lens)
Competition #80 - 16 alt; 1 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
Competition #79 - 16 alt; 6 mirrorless with matching lens (first, second, and third were alt)
So the competition is still primary alt, but perhaps is getting to include more mirrorless with a matching lens. Interestingly there are probably at least 12 people who have entered with a mirrorless with a matching lens at least once in the previous six months, but almost all of them sometimes enter an alt as well. Even Scott who thought 99% of his entries would be mirrorless with a matching lens entered 2 out of the last 6 with an alt lens. No question we have several very good contributors who have tended to enter mirrorless with a matching lens birdied (who I have voted for a couple of times and seems to have a strong entry every month), mitesh (who will get my first place vote for #84), Scott's entries have been consistently strong as well, and several others (hpfish, fpl2 --not sure I got those screen names right and I apologize for inevitably leaving a few names off. I would hate to lose those contributions, but I can see a time before long when the exclusion of DSLRs with matching lenses seems a bit of a weird rationale if it isn't weird already. Mirrorless cameras are selling more than DSLRs and before long it seems likely that DSLRs with matching lenses will be more alt than mirrorless with matching lenses.
There has always been three streams on the alt board. One stream is using adapted lenses. Another stream has always been using non-OEM lenses. A third stream has always been using a less popular system (e.g., Leica has always been considered Alt). I see no reason to alter from this three pronged definition. So yes, Panasonic and Olympics micr 4/3rds is definitely alt. For two reasons: 1) It is a less popular and commonly used system (all micro 4/3rds from this perspective would be alt); 2) It is using a non-OEM lens on a camera. And Zeiss and Voigtlander lenses on any camera have always been alt and have always made up a big part of the Alt board, so that win was definitely Alt. It seems you want to only call the first stream (adapted lenses) alt, but that is not the way the board has ever worked.